Squats and discomfort in shoulder area?
jtcedinburgh
Posts: 117 Member
Hi folks.
Just started SL5x5 last week, taking it from empty bar and up. It's going well (even though I know I can manage quite a bit higher weight, but I'm forcing myself to be a 'by-the-book' student on this).
One thing: when I do squats, I'm finding some discomfort where the bar rests across my shoulder/neck area. It's not major and there's no bruising, but then the weights are still <30Kg total and I worry that as these increase I'm going to start making a mess of my shoulder/neck.
I'm guessing it's either a technique thing OR a question of just getting used to it. If it's the former, what might I be doing wrong. And the latter, any tips to offset the discomfort?
Just started SL5x5 last week, taking it from empty bar and up. It's going well (even though I know I can manage quite a bit higher weight, but I'm forcing myself to be a 'by-the-book' student on this).
One thing: when I do squats, I'm finding some discomfort where the bar rests across my shoulder/neck area. It's not major and there's no bruising, but then the weights are still <30Kg total and I worry that as these increase I'm going to start making a mess of my shoulder/neck.
I'm guessing it's either a technique thing OR a question of just getting used to it. If it's the former, what might I be doing wrong. And the latter, any tips to offset the discomfort?
0
Replies
-
Try squeezing your shoulder blades together to form a better pad for the bar to sit on. Don't have the bar too high. Is there a coach to check your form?2
-
You can get a foam pad that wraps around the bar (if you're in a gym they should provide them) but I find them too thick so I wrap a small gym towel around it2
-
-
Or perhaps (I could be wrong but it could be some of the factors below);
You need to strengthen your upper body (shoulders/chest)
your upper form is wrong, you might be slouching somewhat to make the bar abit more comfortable. Are you as upright and hold your shoulders down and back as much as possible?
0 -
Do not use a foam pad. Your traps are a naturally built in pad. Try positioning the bar in a different area, there's both high and low bar squats. Also, make sure you're not actually pulling the bar down into your back during the movement. Also work on developing your traps and rhomboids in order to increase muscle mass in the area.3
-
If you've never done barbell squats, the honest answer is you just have to suck it up. Even if your bar position is correct, it will feel uncomfortable when you first start. Eventually it feels natural even when you have 300+ lbs.1
-
There are actually a lot of things that could be causing the issue. Could be hand positioning, bar position, bar path, or just general form. I had trouble when starting out too and still don't feel like I have it perfect yet, but it's getting there.
I recommend checking out omarisuf on YouTube because he has a very descriptive squatting video. It's like 2 hours long though.1 -
Just keep doing them. You get used to it.
Don't use a pad!!!
Srs though as posted above, Layne Norton does 1 good video.1 -
Squeeze your shoulder blades / traps together, and rest the bar on that. Do not rest the bar on your bone / spine!!
Look at this olympic gold medalist rest 550lbs on his traps, not spine. Obviously his are bigger than yours, but the idea is the same.1 -
Thers a pad you can get to wrap the bar,it should get better as you build muscle thatll pad tjat area0
-
What's wrong with using a foam pad? Is it any different for men vs women? I can't imagine doing squats without it. I have a big thick one and I find when I do squats at the gym (where there is a pad but it's thin) I'm miserable. How is this different than, say, bike shorts? I can't cycle for long without the extra padding in my bike shorts either.0
-
Or don't do squats. There are many exercises that work legs also.0
-
goldthistime wrote: »What's wrong with using a foam pad?
It puts the bar in a different position - which makes you alter your form and makes the bar less stable. With the pad, you probably won't realize if the bar is in a particularly bad spot until the weight gets much heavier.
1 -
goldthistime wrote: »What's wrong with using a foam pad? Is it any different for men vs women? I can't imagine doing squats without it. I have a big thick one and I find when I do squats at the gym (where there is a pad but it's thin) I'm miserable. How is this different than, say, bike shorts? I can't cycle for long without the extra padding in my bike shorts either.
Because it's 100% unnecessary and you really don't want another layer of material between your body and the bar at higher weights.2 -
goldthistime wrote: »What's wrong with using a foam pad? Is it any different for men vs women? I can't imagine doing squats without it. I have a big thick one and I find when I do squats at the gym (where there is a pad but it's thin) I'm miserable. How is this different than, say, bike shorts? I can't cycle for long without the extra padding in my bike shorts either.
Honestly, I find the pad to be unstable. I feel like I have to work harder to make sure the bar doesn't roll down my back. Suck it up for a while, and eventually your traps will toughen up.0 -
Sounds from the description that the bar may be higher on your back, close to your neck. SL5x5 calls for low bar squats. What you want to do is get your hands as close to together as possible and push your elbows back. This creates a shelf between the scapula and traps for the bar to rest on. There are many videos on youtube that will show good squat form. Check out Mark Rippetoe and Allan Thral.2
-
Sounds from the description that the bar may be higher on your back, close to your neck. SL5x5 calls for low bar squats. What you want to do is get your hands as close to together as possible and push your elbows back. This creates a shelf between the scapula and traps for the bar to rest on. There are many videos on youtube that will show good squat form. Check out Mark Rippetoe and Allan Thral.
I second this. He's awesome...
eta-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bs_Ej32IYgo 2 -
FWIW, doing squats w/a bar plus heavy weights across your back is simply uncomfortable. All the "adjustment" in bar, arm and/or shoulder position in the world will NOT make it much better, especially when you're squatting over 200 lbs (90kg).
There are only 3 things that can make it "feel" better:
1) a thick dense foam pad which cushions the bar but also raises the center of gravity
which in turn may cause balance problems and does not change the point of pressure on the neck/shoulders;
2) the Manta Ray, which is a hard plastic accessory that provides a stable platform on which the bar can rest on your shoulders and that distributes the pressure of the weight of the bar more widely across the shoulders; and
3) a fully padded safety squat yoke bar which transfers the weight slightly forward but makes lifting really heavy weight about as comfortable as possible.
I've got all 3.
The foam pad is the cheapest and will deform and degrade quickly under heavy weight. All of them except the thickest and most expensive are junk and if you get a really thick one you run into center of gravity and balance issues.
The safety squat yoke bar is the BEST but it costs around $400 plus shipping and tax, where applicable. I've got the one made by eliteFTS that I got for only $240 off of Craigslist. I do all off my squatting w/it, unless I'm too lazy to lift the 60# 8 ft long monster out of the bar rack.
In that case, I just use the Manta Ray which only costs about $45. Forget about the foam pads which cost as much or more. It's absolutely the best and most affordable thing you can buy to make your squatting more comfortable and it small and light enough to throw into your bag when you go to the gym. No need to use the scuzzy gross beat up pads often found there.
BUT don't be decieved!!! DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT, buy any of the cheap, soft foam knock offs of the Manta Ray sold on eBay, Amazon and elsewhete on the Net.
Only buy the TM'd blue hard plastic Manta Ray. It's the hard plastic that distributes the weight better across the shoulders and makes the product so durable.
Happy squatting!
0 -
I also found this info on squaters shoulder helpful.
https://www.t-nation.com/training/squatters-shoulder-the-cause-amp-the-cure0 -
What someone already stated...alan thrall and/or mark rippetoe for form. If something is hurting, something is wrong and it usually comes back to user error.
Good luck!!1 -
IILikeToMoveItMoveIt wrote: »Sounds from the description that the bar may be higher on your back, close to your neck. SL5x5 calls for low bar squats. What you want to do is get your hands as close to together as possible and push your elbows back. This creates a shelf between the scapula and traps for the bar to rest on. There are many videos on youtube that will show good squat form. Check out Mark Rippetoe and Allan Thral.
I second this. He's awesome...
eta-https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bs_Ej32IYgo
This is an awesome video. My only question is about locking the knees at the top of the move. I was always under the impression that this was a big no no. People who know more than me please educate me.0 -
i actually like how the bar feels on my back. take a few minutes to get into squat position and get your upper body tight, and flex up those muscles to hold it the bar in place.1
-
If you've never done barbell squats, the honest answer is you just have to suck it up. Even if your bar position is correct, it will feel uncomfortable when you first start. Eventually it feels natural even when you have 300+ lbs.
Agreed. Also, play around with your hand positioning. For me, I'm not super comfortable with a super narrow grip, but I know a wide grip can compromise stability; so I work to put my arms in a position that's a nice in between and I've become used to it. Also, paying attention to how you set up to unrack can be helpful to. Ex: is the bar at a proper height? Also, pay attention to if you set up with an evenly on the bar.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtPN-ftmxG8
This video also helped me develop a strong setup. It may help you too :].0 -
FWIW, doing squats w/a bar plus heavy weights across your back is simply uncomfortable. All the "adjustment" in bar, arm and/or shoulder position in the world will NOT make it much better, especially when you're squatting over 200 lbs (90kg).
There are only 3 things that can make it "feel" better:
1) a thick dense foam pad which cushions the bar but also raises the center of gravity
which in turn may cause balance problems and does not change the point of pressure on the neck/shoulders;
2) the Manta Ray, which is a hard plastic accessory that provides a stable platform on which the bar can rest on your shoulders and that distributes the pressure of the weight of the bar more widely across the shoulders; and
3) a fully padded safety squat yoke bar which transfers the weight slightly forward but makes lifting really heavy weight about as comfortable as possible.
I've got all 3.
The foam pad is the cheapest and will deform and degrade quickly under heavy weight. All of them except the thickest and most expensive are junk and if you get a really thick one you run into center of gravity and balance issues.
The safety squat yoke bar is the BEST but it costs around $400 plus shipping and tax, where applicable. I've got the one made by eliteFTS that I got for only $240 off of Craigslist. I do all off my squatting w/it, unless I'm too lazy to lift the 60# 8 ft long monster out of the bar rack.
In that case, I just use the Manta Ray which only costs about $45. Forget about the foam pads which cost as much or more. It's absolutely the best and most affordable thing you can buy to make your squatting more comfortable and it small and light enough to throw into your bag when you go to the gym. No need to use the scuzzy gross beat up pads often found there.
BUT don't be decieved!!! DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT, buy any of the cheap, soft foam knock offs of the Manta Ray sold on eBay, Amazon and elsewhete on the Net.
Only buy the TM'd blue hard plastic Manta Ray. It's the hard plastic that distributes the weight better across the shoulders and makes the product so durable.
Happy squatting!
I squat in the mid 200s for sets with absolutely nothing but the bar on my back and feel absolutely zero discomfort, I've never used a pad and never will. Draw your arms back and squeeze your shoulder blades together and rest the bar on your traps. Which EVERYONE has just a varying levels of development. You do not want that bar to have the ability to roll inside of a pad with over 200lbs on your back with your hands hooked into it.
2 -
I squat in the mid 200s for sets with absolutely nothing but the bar on my back and feel absolutely zero discomfort, I've never used a pad and never will.
Congratulations, Jesse. You're blessed.
FWIW, I've used a bare bar doing squats over 200# and, regardless of how/where I place the bar, it's NOT comfortable to me. So, if there are "aids" that can make it feel more comfortable, why not use them?
There's this theme in weight lifting that denigrates the use of anything that "helps" you to lift, like straps, gloves, knee wraps, belts, etc. The message is that you're not considered a "man" unless you can lift the weight entirely unaided.
I personally think this POV is pure BS. However, the accessories I've mentioned DO NOT help anyone to squat more weight, they just make it more comfortable to do so and IMO there's no reason why anyone who wants to feel more comfortable doing squats shouldn't use them if they help.
0 -
I squat in the mid 200s for sets with absolutely nothing but the bar on my back and feel absolutely zero discomfort, I've never used a pad and never will.
Congratulations, Jesse. You're blessed.
FWIW, I've used a bare bar doing squats over 200# and, regardless of how/where I place the bar, it's NOT comfortable to me. So, if there are "aids" that can make it feel more comfortable, why not use them?
There's this theme in weight lifting that denigrates the use of anything that "helps" you to lift, like straps, gloves, knee wraps, belts, etc. The message is that you're not considered a "man" unless you can lift the weight entirely unaided.
I personally think this POV is pure BS. However, the accessories I've mentioned DO NOT help anyone to squat more weight, they just make it more comfortable to do so and IMO there's no reason why anyone who wants to feel more comfortable doing squats shouldn't use them if they help.
I wholeheartedly support belts and knee wraps which provide support and stability. I just know out of every powerlifter/body builder I've trained with not a single one of them finds discomfort when squatting especially at the higher weights, purely because they refined their form.
0 -
And fyi. I was merely trying to provide and example so there's no need for talking down.0
-
I agree with the traps - squeeze 'em together and rest the bar there. My lifting coach busted me on that after my first session - I had a nice little bruise from the bar. Also, check the hands. Make sure they're even on the bar, and really squeeze the bar.
Any chance there's a safety bar at your gym? We've been working with the safety bar on stability squats for the last couple of weeks and its really helped me improve form.0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t2b8UdqmlFs
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions