Weight Loss 1200 cal, little to no exercise
summyd01
Posts: 8 Member
So I've heard that a 500 calorie deficit per day will equal about 1 lb of weight loss per week. Is that right? My question is this.... if I focus on my diet only and do the minimum of 1200 calories recommended by MFP, can I still lose weight? My resting metabolic rate was estimated to be about 1400-1450. I'm about 170 lbs, 5' 4" and work in an office. I've been having back issues and costochronditis (inflammation of the cartilidge in the rib case) so I haven't been wanting to exercise much or cause more pain. I know I could do some low impact exercises in my apartment or walk..
Anyways, I'm wondering if I need to be at a deficit to lose weight or does MFP calculate this already? Am I technically at approx 200-250 calorie deficit by only consuming 1200 calories? Any advice would be appreciated. I'm looking to lose some weight through portion control and calorie counting and then plan to work out more once I have less weight to carry around. I do use a standing desk now, yay!
Anyways, I'm wondering if I need to be at a deficit to lose weight or does MFP calculate this already? Am I technically at approx 200-250 calorie deficit by only consuming 1200 calories? Any advice would be appreciated. I'm looking to lose some weight through portion control and calorie counting and then plan to work out more once I have less weight to carry around. I do use a standing desk now, yay!
5
Replies
-
I lost 50lbs with little to no exercise. A calorie deficit is all that's required to lose weight. It isn't the ideal way to do it, but it is possible. This time (Yes, I gained 30lbs back), I'm adding some mild exercise, walking mainly. It allows me to eat a bit more and is helping tone up some muscles. I plan to start doing more as I get some of the weight off.5
-
MFP calculates your deficit - so whatever it gives you as a goal is the amount you should eat to lose weight. 1200 is the absolute minimum calories for women. Most people can lose weight eating more than that. If you do any exercise you can eat those calories too (and should since you're eating so little already).4
-
I'm 5'4" and when I joined MFP I weighed 172lbs. MFP gave me a calorie allowance of 1350. In the beginning It was pretty common for me to lose 2-3lbs a week just sticking to that and without exercising. I lost 50lbs in 7 months. Stick with the app and your calorie allowance. Remember, weight loss is about losing the weight and keeping it off - so eating way under what you are allowed isn't setting you up for success long term. Good luck!12
-
Ooh that's awesome, kerstenk141. I need to just stick with it then! I am not actually weighing myself but doing measurements and going by how my clothes fit. Your success is very inspiring. Thanks for sharing!2
-
So I've heard that a 500 calorie deficit per day will equal about 1 lb of weight loss per week. Is that right? My question is this.... if I focus on my diet only and do the minimum of 1200 calories recommended by MFP, can I still lose weight? My resting metabolic rate was estimated to be about 1400-1450. I'm about 170 lbs, 5' 4" and work in an office. I've been having back issues and costochronditis (inflammation of the cartilidge in the rib case) so I haven't been wanting to exercise much or cause more pain. I know I could do some low impact exercises in my apartment or walk..
Anyways, I'm wondering if I need to be at a deficit to lose weight or does MFP calculate this already? Am I technically at approx 200-250 calorie deficit by only consuming 1200 calories? Any advice would be appreciated. I'm looking to lose some weight through portion control and calorie counting and then plan to work out more once I have less weight to carry around. I do use a standing desk now, yay!
If you're resting metabolic rate is estimated to be 1400-1450, you should at least be eating that much each day, regardless of whether you're exercising or not. That number is the amount you need just to fuel your body to function properly. Yes, 1200 is the minimum calories recommended, but realistically I don't think that it's a very healthy number. I think you can still lose weight if you eat the BMR amount of 1400. What will help is making healthy choices and making those calories count with nutritious food vs. junk food..and you'll see a difference soon enough. You can do it!!4 -
When you put in your stats (height, weight, etc.) and activity level, and indicate you want to lose weight: The goal that MFP gives you is what you should eat at, and has a deficit built in.
BUT if it gives you 1200, you've hit the minimum. So putting in 1 pound per week and getting 1200 does not mean that 1200 will lead to a 1 pound loss. It could be less. If MFP expects you to use less than 1700 per day (living and any movement uses calories, not just exercise) then it won't tell you to eat less than 1200.
Put it at maintenance just to see what goal MFP gives you for calories. If its 1650, for example, then you can know eating 1200 is a 450/day deficit rather than 500/day.
To be satisfied on 1200 calories you may need to be creative. Including mixed greens w/ light dressing at lunch/dinner can help add bulk without using many calories. Helps get your veggie count up also. Aim for lean protein, but be careful not to cut fat too low. Our bodies need it.7 -
Thank you for your tips and suggestions. I think I definitely need to add more veggies into my lunch and snacks. We have packaged protein/granola bars at the office and string cheese which I've been using as snacks. Ive also just been having turkey sandwiches for lunch which don't really fill me up. I don't want anything heavy for lunch but I don't want to be real hungry either. I eat good for dinner because my husband makes delicious and filling dinners like mushroom curry....which is mostly veggies and brown rice. I just don't like something that heavy for lunch.1
-
So I changed my goals to maintain and it listed 1880 as my calorie intake. So if I select lose 1 lb a week it will do 1380. I had it set to lose 1.5 lbs a week, that's why it went down to 1200. I like to keep the low number so in case I go a little bit over, it won't lead to weight gain.2
-
So set you goal a min 1200 but allow yourself up to while your trying to lose 1400 based one the numbers you just posted, my min is 1200 max 1600 based on a combination of my MFP goal and my fitbit goal (fitbit usually give you more than MFP) . I do recomend adding 10mins yoga to your day to help keep your body healthy i work in an office too and sitting all the time is really bad for us1
-
I am fairly inactive though I am trying to improve. I am at an office job too. I am eating 1200 calories a day and have lost 6 lbs in 2 weeks. I eat a lot of veggies and drink at least 100 ounces a water a day. I had a salad for lunch today, greens with a little dressing and topped with cooked egg whites, ham, cheese and apple. It was low cal but had enough substance to keep me full. If you find yourself starving you are definitely doing something wrong and need to adjust your food or up your intake. No lifestyle change will stick if you are miserable.1
-
Just stumbled across this thread but I'm glad I did. Lots of good info here!1
-
I use my cals like a check book. I'm set to eat 1550, and usually do well with this number...but if I know I have a night out coming up on Saturday I will build in an additional deficit (usually 100 cals per day - so Monday thru Friday allows me to build up 500 additional cals that I can use at my event). Like wise.. if I end up off track early on in the week, I will cut myself down as needed through the remainder of the week in order to reach and end of the week average of 1550 per day. Hope that makes sense! and good luck!!3
-
I DID IT 101 LBS IN 8 MONTHS 1000-1200 CALORIES PER DAY PORTION CONTROL AND CUTTING OUT SWEETS AND DRINKING ONLY WATER AND MILK NO EXTRA EX
ERCISE EITHER .
14 -
I'm so happy people are commenting on this thread! I am going to stick with the 1200 cals and not fret too much if I go a little over. I'm actually not weighing myself becase my scale needs a new battery plus it was really bad about giving inconsistent figures within minutes of each other. I'm going by how my clothes fit. Hoping to notice some real change within a couple months0
-
I am set to eat 1200 calories. I use a good scale and try to be accurate. I also work out everyday and eat back majority of exercise clarifies which I get that estimate from my HRM. I like it this way because I usually end up eating about 1500 calories. I concentrate more on weekly calories.0
-
I'm 5'4". I started this app when I was 163. I'm slightly more active than you so I ate a little more but yeah, people poo poo 1200 calories but some of us have to dip a little lower. Even now, I eat 1200 calories a couple days out of the week because I sure as hell can't make it through the weekend on 1500. I need a couple maintenance days.0
-
I DID IT 101 LBS IN 8 MONTHS 1000-1200 CALORIES PER DAY PORTION CONTROL AND CUTTING OUT SWEETS AND DRINKING ONLY WATER AND MILK NO EXTRA EX
ERCISE EITHER .
why did you eat so little? were you under a doctors care? a male is not supposed to eat so little calories. recommended male calories is 1500 and thats the bare minimum.0 -
My resting metabolic rate was estimated to be about 1400-1450.
Anyways, I'm wondering if I need to be at a deficit to lose weight or does MFP calculate this already? Am I technically at approx 200-250 calorie deficit by only consuming 1200 calories? Any advice would be appreciated. I'm looking to lose some weight through portion control and calorie counting and then plan to work out more once I have less weight to carry around. I do use a standing desk now, yay!
Mfp already calculates the deficit, but not from your RMR/BMR, but from your TDEE minus exercise or NEAT. Mfp is designed so that you add your exercise calories and eat a portion (1/3 to 1/2) of your cardio calories back.
1 -
So I changed my goals to maintain and it listed 1880 as my calorie intake. So if I select lose 1 lb a week it will do 1380. I had it set to lose 1.5 lbs a week, that's why it went down to 1200. I like to keep the low number so in case I go a little bit over, it won't lead to weight gain.
you wont gain unless you go over your maintenance calories. and if you do gain it could be water weight from that time of the month,excess sodium,waste still in your body,etc. weight loss is not linear.if you see your weight trending up for a period of time or your clothes stop fitting,then it can be an error in logging(using generic or wrong entries in mfp) youre over estimating any exercise calories and eating them back,or you are overestimating your calories if you dont use a food scale.If you do all those things and it goes up then its time to see a dr.0 -
I keep seeing i cant exercise, but i can walk on various posts on the forum. Just an FYI, walking IS exercise! You dont need to slog it out in the gym for hours everyday, I haven't set foot in a gym since i started trying to lose weight. All i do is walk, you'd be surprised how many calories you can burn everyday by simply walking more.
If you have a look in my diary, all the extra exercise calories (fitbit synced) are from "just" walking.5 -
CharlieBeansmomTracey wrote: »I DID IT 101 LBS IN 8 MONTHS 1000-1200 CALORIES PER DAY PORTION CONTROL AND CUTTING OUT SWEETS AND DRINKING ONLY WATER AND MILK NO EXTRA EX
ERCISE EITHER .
why did you eat so little? were you under a doctors care? a male is not supposed to eat so little calories. recommended male calories is 1500 and thats the bare minimum.
I wasnt under Dr. orders and really didn't plan on it to work out that way. When I cut out the crap and cut my portions that is just what I ended up at.0 -
Christine_72 wrote: »I keep seeing i cant exercise, but i can walk on various posts on the forum. Just an FYI, walking IS exercise! You dont need to slog it out in the gym for hours everyday, I haven't set foot in a gym since i started trying to lose weight. All i do is walk, you'd be surprised how many calories you can burn everyday by simply walking more.
If you have a look in my diary, all the extra exercise calories (fitbit synced) are from "just" walking.
Very true! I do a lot of different workouts, but I still love to go for a quick power walk - I did 30 minutes this morning and burned about 250 calories. Easy on the knees and still does the job!2 -
I came from calorie counter (which is closing - that is why I am here). That site has wonderful ideas for counting calories, starting with counting your BMR. (It's still functioning if you want to poke around to see what I am talking about). They also recommend counting every step you take, every stair you climb, every activity that involves standing (like cooking dinner, showering), every activity that involves pushing a grocery cart, baby stroller; activities carrying groceries, babies, laundry. (That adds up to about 116 to 200 calories an hour). This site, once you figure that out, will allow you to copy those activities while you do them (once you record them here). I copy my BMR over every day as my exercise. The downside is that if you do that, then this site adds those as your allowable calories, unless you turn off the adjust my daily calorie goal button. If you pay for the premium, then you can also track calories eaten / remaining for either your allotted meal or for the day. Also, unless there is a specific event / piece of clothing that you are trying to fit into by a specific date, I would encourage you to not necessarily look for 1 whole pound a week. I just try to stay under a specific calorie limit per meal by recording my calories, adjusting my recipes / meals to more or less meet those limits, relax and put away the scale and bring it out on a specific day (generally following the end of your cycle) so that you can see how well you are progressing. Your skin will sag less due to "rapid weight loss" and you will soon become in tune with this new way of living your life. Hope that this helps.1
-
I eat between 1200-1300. I am exercising more because I want to, but some days I don't, and that's OK. My life is crazy busy and that's just the way it is. I started in Sept and I am down 50lbs so far, with 50 to go. I plan on sticking with this calorie range until I reach maintenance. Some days 1200 seems really hard and other days I have to work to reach it. When it's that time of month, I seem especially hungry, so I'll inch toward the 1300 or eat fattier foods to fill more full.
I actually have my calories set to 1310 because when I was set at 1250 I was losing 3ish lbs per week and sometimes wasn't getting to the 1250 mark. For some reason with the 1310 setting, I'm consistently hitting 1200-1250 and keeping my weight loss around 2lbs.1 -
I came from calorie counter (which is closing - that is why I am here). That site has wonderful ideas for counting calories, starting with counting your BMR. (It's still functioning if you want to poke around to see what I am talking about). They also recommend counting every step you take, every stair you climb, every activity that involves standing (like cooking dinner, showering), every activity that involves pushing a grocery cart, baby stroller; activities carrying groceries, babies, laundry. (That adds up to about 116 to 200 calories an hour). This site, once you figure that out, will allow you to copy those activities while you do them (once you record them here). I copy my BMR over every day as my exercise. The downside is that if you do that, then this site adds those as your allowable calories, unless you turn off the adjust my daily calorie goal button. If you pay for the premium, then you can also track calories eaten / remaining for either your allotted meal or for the day. Also, unless there is a specific event / piece of clothing that you are trying to fit into by a specific date, I would encourage you to not necessarily look for 1 whole pound a week. I just try to stay under a specific calorie limit per meal by recording my calories, adjusting my recipes / meals to more or less meet those limits, relax and put away the scale and bring it out on a specific day (generally following the end of your cycle) so that you can see how well you are progressing. Your skin will sag less due to "rapid weight loss" and you will soon become in tune with this new way of living your life. Hope that this helps.
your BMR is what you burn by being alive so why would you use it as exercise? its not exercise its what your body burns even if you were in a coma.the only thing you should be counting is your actual exercise(not counting your daily activities such as work and so on).
1 -
I lost 13 lbs on a 1200 calorie diet and then after a few months i started working out and just plateaued. Dunno what happened there?
Hopefully it works out better for you.0 -
I've lost 19.4 pounds since Nov 1st just by counting calories I don't exercise at all I do have a fitbit and that does give me extra calories just from my daily normal activities but I don't eat them back everyday and when I do eat them back I only eat 50-75% I basically use them as my buffer in case my husband says hey lets go out to eat
I forgot to mention I'm at 1250 calories a day with 37lbs left to lose and I also have a desk job0 -
I tried the 1200 calorie thing once, and lasted a whole 3 days, 3 long miserable days :sad:
I don't know if a few extra inches makes a big difference.... I'm talking height here boys and girls
But I'm 5"8 and was around 155lbs iirc when did it. 1 -
This thread is really inspiring. I've also been given a 1200 calorie plan and although i am trying to stick to it my work schedule doesn't really allow me to get home until 8pm which i've heard is not the best time to eat dinner after 8? any recomendations? has anyone still lost weight even eating at later hours??0
-
Dar_Line86 wrote: »I lost 13 lbs on a 1200 calorie diet and then after a few months i started working out and just plateaued. Dunno what happened there?
Hopefully it works out better for you.
Are you taking measurements or noticing changes in the mirror and/or how your clothes fit? If you started working out and plateaued you may have just gained muscle.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions