BCAA (branch chain amino acids)

For me, personally, I think they are a waste of money. The documented effects are minor at best and are not worth the investment for me since I don't care if I last a few seconds longer while running.

I got a free bottle with my protein powder. I ended up throwing them away. I felt bad and wasteful for doing it, but i could find zero benefits for me to take them. I didn't want to pop pills for the hell of it.

I tried them but felt zero benefit.

ronjsteele1 wrote: »

trigden1991 wrote: »

If you are getting sufficient protein they are surplus to requirement. I only ever use them if I will be fasted and doing strenuous exercise.

So are they helpful if you're NOT getting enough protein? I am lifting progressively 2-3 days a week with cardio those days also and I'm having the hardest time hitting my protein by quite a lot. I have my macros set at 20% protein and after checking last night, I'm averaging 13% over the last 60 days. I'm also struggling with getting any more weight down and keep wondering if it's because I'm lacking the protein while lifting as much as I am. Would adding BCAA's for someone like me be helpful???

Maybe. I personally would buy a whey protein supplement rather than BCAA's if that is the case.

If you really haven't lost any weight for 60 days then you're eating too much and not to do with your protein intake.

trigden1991 wrote: »

ronjsteele1 wrote: »

trigden1991 wrote: »

If you are getting sufficient protein they are surplus to requirement. I only ever use them if I will be fasted and doing strenuous exercise.

So are they helpful if you're NOT getting enough protein? I am lifting progressively 2-3 days a week with cardio those days also and I'm having the hardest time hitting my protein by quite a lot. I have my macros set at 20% protein and after checking last night, I'm averaging 13% over the last 60 days. I'm also struggling with getting any more weight down and keep wondering if it's because I'm lacking the protein while lifting as much as I am. Would adding BCAA's for someone like me be helpful???

Maybe. I personally would buy a whey protein supplement rather than BCAA's if that is the case.

If you really haven't lost any weight for 60 days then you're eating too much and not to do with your protein intake.

I can't have any dairy. I have egg protein and pea protein that I can use. The problem I have with them is I have to make a protein drink out of them and when I do that (especially to hit my protein macro) it ends up being almost 400 calories (one is 110 cals and the other 130 cals). I'd have to mix it with water to keep it at 240 cals. Trying to fit that into 1200 cals (even 1350 if I eat back half my exercise cals) is really hard. It literally means doing a shake for a full meal. Which, I guess I could do. I've not lost pounds so much this past 60 days but I'm losing clothing sizes (and getting loose skin on top of it) so I figure something is still moving - just not the scale right now???? Okay, it's moving, just REALLY slooooowwwww.....like a 1/4 lb at a time some weeks. I just moved my target calories from 1550 to 1200 the other day so I'll see what that does for actual numbers. I probably shouldn't complain if my clothes are getting loose but I do worry about the protein thing.

I use BCAAS for 3 reasons

A) To drink during heavy lifting sessions to of course replenish and keep my muscles less fatigued and my recovery time very quick (of course muscle soreness is normal but I won't be limping after a 2 hr leg sesh like most lol)

B)To curb my cravings for sweets during the day and or evening

C)To ensure I keep my lean muscle mass and help the anabolic process of the protein to maximize growth and minimize muscle loss (although some muscle loss is inevitable if training fasted)

amusedmonkey wrote: »

For me, personally, I think they are a waste of money. The documented effects are minor at best and are not worth the investment for me since I don't care if I last a few seconds longer while running.

I wonder what about this post moved someone to flag it? #harsh

Summary of BCAA with links to relevant studies

https://examine.com/supplements/branched-chain-amino-acids/

"BCAA supplementation, for people with low dietary protein intake, can promote muscle protein synthesis and increase muscle growth over time. It can also be used to prevent fatigue in novice athletes."

emphasis - mine

^^Yep. And, if you look at the studies they link on exercise fatigue - they were working with untrained individuals. I mention this because some people may interpret the "novice athletes" term they use as someone much more advanced than an untrained individual.

JeromeBarry1 wrote: »

From the examine link above: "Supplementing BCAAs prevents a serum decline in BCAAs, which occurs during exercise. A serum decline would normally cause a tryptophan influx into the brain, followed by serotonin production, which causes fatigue. " That means BCAA's may prevent workout fatigue.


"BCAAs are important to ingest on a daily basis, but many protein sources, such as meat and eggs, already provide BCAAS. Supplementation is unnecessary for people with a sufficiently high protein intake (1-1.5g/kg a day or more)."

That math means that I, at 183.2 lb today, get sufficient BCAA from my food if my protein is above 83 g on my food diary. Today it's over 140.

I keep finding conflicting information on protein levels. Do you know what this equates to per pound? I keep seeing people posting 1-1.5 per POUND, when I believe it is actually per KG, as your post states.

all in all BCAAs arn't DETRIMENTAL or an OMG YOU NEED THIS kind of thing for weight loss and or fitness, they help, but nothing helps better than a balanced nutrition.