Super fun and ez way to make your own yougurt!
Replies
-
Skyr would cost double. As for storing, I repurposed an old candy tub.
Okay, you save a little more with the time you put in. If I get a 32 ounce Dannon light and fit it's $3.29 (896 grams). But then again, I don't have to make or store it, so I'd forego the savings personally for the convenience.ActivatedAlm0nds wrote: »
Seriously
1 150 gram tub is Siggi's is 1.50- I get four initial starters
The rennet tablets I bought were 1.97 and gives me 32 batches
Half a gallon of milk is 1.47 here
I end up with 700+ grams of home made skyr for less than two bucks. You can save some of what you made for next time! I'll do this up to 5 times (someone on the IP forums recommended this to prevent a runny batch) per initial starter.
It's fun and hands off enough for me to continue doing. I completely understand just buying a tub though. Personally, I love salads but loath the idea of making one at home.
1 -
All my attempts to strain my home made yogurt have been a huge fail. What sort of strainer do you use, how do you set it up, and how long does it take?
I want some liquid whey to try in a recipe.0 -
Cheesecloth folded so there's about four layers in my regular colander (like I use for pasta). I put the cheesecloth in, put all the yogurt in (my colander will *just barely* hold a gallon), put that back on top of a large bowl or the instant pot insert, and put it back in the fridge for 4-6 hours. When I use skim milk, it ends up about 8 cups greek yogurt/8 cups whey. Higher fat milk yields more yogurt and less whey.All my attempts to strain my home made yogurt have been a huge fail. What sort of strainer do you use, how do you set it up, and how long does it take?
I want some liquid whey to try in a recipe.1 -
I found something that looks like this at the dollar store. Some people use coffee filters.All my attempts to strain my home made yogurt have been a huge fail. What sort of strainer do you use, how do you set it up, and how long does it take?
I want some liquid whey to try in a recipe.
You can buy something like this too.0 -
3rdof7sisters wrote: »Question about boiling the milk, how do you keep it from scorching?
I am really interested in trying this, thanks for posting.
i stir mine. there may be more new-school solutions, but i've worked out a nice little routine where my saturday morning is a nice peaceful period of making yogurt and bread, so i'm in the neighbourhood anyway. every 10 minutes or so, though the more aggressive you are with bringing it up to that heat, the more often it probably needs to be stirred.
0 -
All my attempts to strain my home made yogurt have been a huge fail. What sort of strainer do you use, how do you set it up, and how long does it take?
I want some liquid whey to try in a recipe.
i had this old laundry bag that tore through, some kind of air-breathing weave that's pretty tight. i used that the one time i did it, but it's not something i do a lot of.
0 -
annacole94 wrote: »
Cheesecloth folded so there's about four layers in my regular colander (like I use for pasta). I put the cheesecloth in, put all the yogurt in (my colander will *just barely* hold a gallon), put that back on top of a large bowl or the instant pot insert, and put it back in the fridge for 4-6 hours. When I use skim milk, it ends up about 8 cups greek yogurt/8 cups whey. Higher fat milk yields more yogurt and less whey.All my attempts to strain my home made yogurt have been a huge fail. What sort of strainer do you use, how do you set it up, and how long does it take?
I want some liquid whey to try in a recipe.
I use flour sack towels, like these https://www.towelsandhome.com/flour-sacks/what-are-flour-sack-towels.html.0 -
Hi all, I have been making cashew milk yogurt. It is not thick but does turn out with a yogurt flavor so hopefully the probiotics are alive in there. I'll try boiling it longer and also use the tapioca flour thickener next time and see if that helps. It's unsweetened cashew milk so I add touch if sugar so the culture can grow. A half gallon fits in two large mason jars in a small yogurt making warm plate. I use it over cereal and have had great success improving my digestion with it:) ! Cool idea to open a probiotic capsule into it. I'll try that too!1
-
leahkathleen13 wrote: »Hi all, I have been making cashew milk yogurt. It is not thick but does turn out with a yogurt flavor so hopefully the probiotics are alive in there. I'll try boiling it longer and also use the tapioca flour thickener next time and see if that helps. It's unsweetened cashew milk so I add touch if sugar so the culture can grow. A half gallon fits in two large mason jars in a small yogurt making warm plate. I use it over cereal and have had great success improving my digestion with it:) ! Cool idea to open a probiotic capsule into it. I'll try that too!
thanks for posting I was wondering if this would work with cashew milk!!! What brand of yogurt do you add to make it grow?0 -
Thank you all for explaining the filters. If I recall the thickened yogurt clogged up my cheesecloth and it was a bear trying to scrape it all out. Plus there was still liquid unstrained yogurt in the center. Thanks for the strainer ideas.
I think I will try a milk with more fat next time.0 -
Wow - never expected this much engagement and feedback - pretty cool!
Thanks for all the ideas - awesome stuff!
Alex0 -
TheAlexMarkov wrote: »Hi,
yes you can use raw milk - even better as it has more nutrients;
When you say strength I presume flavour and not thickness - IME the flavour of the final product depends on the starter culture - I used FAGE full fat as a starter; you can experiment with different brands
You can controll the thickness by varying the time you simmer the milk - the longer the thicker the yougurt will be.
Use plastic or jar bottle but not metal to avoid contaminating the bacteria.
Once you get going you can make yougurt forever and ever by using your previous batch as a starter:)
Hope you like it,
Alex
Homemade butter is very hard to eat on bread because it is so strong. It smells rotten. But is amazing in cooking.0 -
Sorry, but I think you're doing it wrong. When I make butter it is very mild-tasting. Are you rinsing all the whey out thoroughly? If not, that can cause it to go off fairly quickly.wellthenwhat wrote: »TheAlexMarkov wrote: »Hi,
yes you can use raw milk - even better as it has more nutrients;
When you say strength I presume flavour and not thickness - IME the flavour of the final product depends on the starter culture - I used FAGE full fat as a starter; you can experiment with different brands
You can controll the thickness by varying the time you simmer the milk - the longer the thicker the yougurt will be.
Use plastic or jar bottle but not metal to avoid contaminating the bacteria.
Once you get going you can make yougurt forever and ever by using your previous batch as a starter:)
Hope you like it,
Alex
Homemade butter is very hard to eat on bread because it is so strong. It smells rotten. But is amazing in cooking.
0 -
Sorry, but I think you're doing it wrong. When I make butter it is very mild-tasting. Are you rinsing all the whey out thoroughly? If not, that can cause it to go off fairly quickly.wellthenwhat wrote: »TheAlexMarkov wrote: »Hi,
yes you can use raw milk - even better as it has more nutrients;
When you say strength I presume flavour and not thickness - IME the flavour of the final product depends on the starter culture - I used FAGE full fat as a starter; you can experiment with different brands
You can controll the thickness by varying the time you simmer the milk - the longer the thicker the yougurt will be.
Use plastic or jar bottle but not metal to avoid contaminating the bacteria.
Once you get going you can make yougurt forever and ever by using your previous batch as a starter:)
Hope you like it,
Alex
Homemade butter is very hard to eat on bread because it is so strong. It smells rotten. But is amazing in cooking.
Our butter is made with sour milk. It can take a month on a family farm to collect the amount of cream needed to make a good batch of butter. My family is old order Mennonite, and have been making butter since they came over from Europe hundreds of years ago.1 -
I also use the Instant Pot method which is SO easy. I strain through a colander lined with a muslin cloth left from when my kids were babies. I strain overnight on the counter, for a super-thick yogurt which peels off the cloth easily. It's cream cheese really - Middle Eastern Labneh. Really delicious with a little bit of honey.annacole94 wrote: »
Cheesecloth folded so there's about four layers in my regular colander (like I use for pasta). I put the cheesecloth in, put all the yogurt in (my colander will *just barely* hold a gallon), put that back on top of a large bowl or the instant pot insert, and put it back in the fridge for 4-6 hours. When I use skim milk, it ends up about 8 cups greek yogurt/8 cups whey. Higher fat milk yields more yogurt and less whey.All my attempts to strain my home made yogurt have been a huge fail. What sort of strainer do you use, how do you set it up, and how long does it take?
I want some liquid whey to try in a recipe.
I use flour sack towels, like these https://www.towelsandhome.com/flour-sacks/what-are-flour-sack-towels.html.
1 -
And yes, the butter is thoroughly washed multiple times.0
-
Ok, interesting. I haven't heard of that. Do you also make sweet butter for bread?wellthenwhat wrote: »
Sorry, but I think you're doing it wrong. When I make butter it is very mild-tasting. Are you rinsing all the whey out thoroughly? If not, that can cause it to go off fairly quickly.wellthenwhat wrote: »TheAlexMarkov wrote: »Hi,
yes you can use raw milk - even better as it has more nutrients;
When you say strength I presume flavour and not thickness - IME the flavour of the final product depends on the starter culture - I used FAGE full fat as a starter; you can experiment with different brands
You can controll the thickness by varying the time you simmer the milk - the longer the thicker the yougurt will be.
Use plastic or jar bottle but not metal to avoid contaminating the bacteria.
Once you get going you can make yougurt forever and ever by using your previous batch as a starter:)
Hope you like it,
Alex
Homemade butter is very hard to eat on bread because it is so strong. It smells rotten. But is amazing in cooking.
Our butter is made with sour milk. It can take a month on a family farm to collect the amount of cream needed to make a good batch of butter. My family is old order Mennonite, and have been making butter since they came over from Europe hundreds of years ago.
0 -
Ok, interesting. I haven't heard of that. Do you also make sweet butter for bread?wellthenwhat wrote: »
Sorry, but I think you're doing it wrong. When I make butter it is very mild-tasting. Are you rinsing all the whey out thoroughly? If not, that can cause it to go off fairly quickly.wellthenwhat wrote: »TheAlexMarkov wrote: »Hi,
yes you can use raw milk - even better as it has more nutrients;
When you say strength I presume flavour and not thickness - IME the flavour of the final product depends on the starter culture - I used FAGE full fat as a starter; you can experiment with different brands
You can controll the thickness by varying the time you simmer the milk - the longer the thicker the yougurt will be.
Use plastic or jar bottle but not metal to avoid contaminating the bacteria.
Once you get going you can make yougurt forever and ever by using your previous batch as a starter:)
Hope you like it,
Alex
Homemade butter is very hard to eat on bread because it is so strong. It smells rotten. But is amazing in cooking.
Our butter is made with sour milk. It can take a month on a family farm to collect the amount of cream needed to make a good batch of butter. My family is old order Mennonite, and have been making butter since they came over from Europe hundreds of years ago.
No. It was not practical for them to make a tiny batch of butter, so the cream is simply collected and stored until there is enough for a large batch. My mom always used margarine for bread and corn on the cob. My brother's family, on the other hand, use it for table eating, too. Once you get past the smell, it doesn't taste too bad, but man, what a smell!0 -
We had a small butter churn back home on the farm. We made sweet butter, but only in the spring when milk has loads of cream on it.
It might not be customary in some places, but it's not impractical necessarily.
I also made yogurt a few times, just in the oven with the light on and no heat.0 -
annacole94 wrote: »We had a small butter churn back home on the farm. We made sweet butter, but only in the spring when milk has loads of cream on it. It might not be customary in some places, but it's not impractical necessarily.
I also made yogurt a few times, just in the oven with the light on and no heat.
Well, they did do everything by hand with no electricity and didn't have an extra minute it the day, lol. It's a lot of work raising 14 kids and running a farm with horses. I'm sure in some places it was a higher priority. I love the idea of homemade yogurt. I get my milk free, and don't like buying anything I don't have to.
I went back and looked at my post, and I meant to say it wasn't practical in their situation. I made it sound like it is never practical, didn't mean that.0 -
Okay, you save a little more with the time you put in. If I get a 32 ounce Dannon light and fit it's $3.29 (896 grams). But then again, I don't have to make or store it, so I'd forego the savings personally for the convenience.
Yeah, sure, but then you're stuck eating Dannon light...
Seriously though, it's certainly not for everyone (and it may not be for me...I haven't made any yet) but once I tried Siggi's skyr yogurt, I'll never go back to the mass brands. It's like beer from a local brewery vs. beer from BudMillerCoors. No comparison.
I'm like @annacole94 and like to make my own when it make sense. I make my own kombucha, I cure my own bacon and I think I'd really like to make my own skyr.
2 -
Has anyone tried making quark? My first attempt was a failure. Thinking about trying quark again with some of the tips in this thread. Or maybe I'll do Skyr instead.
And does anyone know how to figure out the macros, or do you just use the standard USDA macros?0 -
for greek yogurt, I just use the Fage entry that matches my milk input. it's not worth the marginal change in accuracy to figure out the inputs and things removed (whey).
Home cured bacon is amazing. I like stuff like this, but fully know it's a hobby. It's not magically healthier or anything, just sometimes more delicious.1 -
Okay, you save a little more with the time you put in. If I get a 32 ounce Dannon light and fit it's $3.29 (896 grams). But then again, I don't have to make or store it, so I'd forego the savings personally for the convenience.
Yeah, sure, but then you're stuck eating Dannon light...
Seriously though, it's certainly not for everyone (and it may not be for me...I haven't made any yet) but once I tried Siggi's skyr yogurt, I'll never go back to the mass brands. It's like beer from a local brewery vs. beer from BudMillerCoors. No comparison.
I'm like @annacole94 and like to make my own when it make sense. I make my own kombucha, I cure my own bacon and I think I'd really like to make my own skyr.
I make my own kombucha too! I like your analogy. It really is a different flavor in yogurts and you can adjust the tartness to your taste depending on how long you let it ferment.
It doesn't take much work to heat up milk and let it chill. I'm usually doing other kitchen stuff like chopping vegetables or cleaning at the time anyway.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions