To meet 200 grams protein per day can a man eat only whey protien?
MassarDv
Posts: 76 Member
To meet 200 grams protein per day can a man eat only whey protien?
Say I scoop in breakfast , then lunch and then before and after workout then before bed.
Is this harmful ?
Say I scoop in breakfast , then lunch and then before and after workout then before bed.
Is this harmful ?
0
Replies
-
Do you mean literally only whey as in 200g (6-8 scoops) of whey a day? If so I can't imagine that's too good for you.
Other protein sources contain nutrients that whey might/does not, such as iron, zinc, magnesium, vitamin a, b12, etc (+ many other minerals and vitamins), that's why it's suggested to get your macros from whole foods. I don't know if something bad will happen to you if you eat that much whey - but I can't really understand why you'd want to?2 -
To meet 200 grams protein per day can a man eat only whey protien?
Say I scoop in breakfast , then lunch and then before and after workout then before bed.
Is this harmful ?
How would you then get your fats and micros to fit?
There is nothing wrong with supplementing with whey but that is excluding all other sources.
Why wouldn't you want a steak or prawns etc?0 -
In theory, yes. In practise it's a terrible idea5
-
trigden1991 wrote: »In theory, yes. In practise it's a terrible idea
Pretty much... but also, do you need 200g of protein?2 -
and why only whey protein?0
-
Yeah, don't do this.0
-
I have a 200g daily protein "goal" which I have difficulty meeting w/o supplementing w/protein powder, drinks and/or bars.
I do not rely solely on these supplements but they can make up as much as 50% or 100g toward my goal. I get the rest of my protein from normal food sources - meat, poultry, eggs, seafood, etc.
I have had no notable dietary or digestive problems doing this for over a year during which time I have lost almost 40# and reduced my BF to just 10%.3 -
What is your daily calorie goal? I feel like there's a much better solution to getting to the amount of protein you want, even though the amount seems a bit excessive..0
-
but why?4
-
but why?
Yeah, why is there such a prejudice against so-called "HIGH PROTEIN" diets on MFP?
Fact is, a high protein diet can be effective if your objective is to lose weight and increase or maintain strength and LBM.
200G of protein for an averaged size man like me at 160#, which is equal to 1.25g/#BW on a 2000 cal/day diet, is not excessive by any means and the heavier & bigger you are, the lower that ratio becomes.
Protein is digested just like carbs and fat but only it can be used to increase or maintain muscle development. Protein also requires more energy to digest than carbs and fat and tends to reduce hunger and appetite, which contributes to weight loss.5 -
but why?
Yeah, why is there such a prejudice against so-called "HIGH PROTEIN" diets on MFP?
Fact is, a high protein diet can be effective if your objective is to lose weight and increase or maintain strength and LBM.
200G of protein for an averaged size man like me at 160#, which is equal to 1.25g/#BW on a 2000 cal/day diet, is not excessive by any means and the heavier & bigger you are, the lower that ratio becomes.
Protein is digested just like carbs and fat but only it can be used to increase or maintain muscle development. Protein also requires more energy to digest than carbs and fat and tends to reduce hunger and appetite, which contributes to weight loss.
I don't think it's a dig on high protein diets, it's a dig on only ingesting protein via a supplement.1 -
ocrXfitter wrote: »I don't think it's a dig on high protein diets, it's a dig on only ingesting protein via a supplement.
You apparently haven't seen and read all of the "you don't need THAT much protein" comments on MFP that I've seen and read.
Such comments are not just limited to protein via supplements; they are opposed to the idea of what the commenters consider "excessive protein" (however they define it) from whatever source -- natural or otherwise.
4 -
trigden1991 wrote: »In theory, yes. In practise it's a terrible idea
Because the whey protien is the purest form and has the highest biological absorption capacity .
Steak , chicken breast and egg are always 20 to 30 percent behind .
Also I believe the whey gets into blood much easily than the meats .
I m not a Doctor but I also believe that a lot of what we eat in meat goes to waste and also contributes to fat .
Yeah we build muscle eating meat but eating pure form only builds lean muscle .
May be you guys might differ but this is what I think right now !
0 -
GoldenEye_ wrote: »What is your daily calorie goal? I feel like there's a much better solution to getting to the amount of protein you want, even though the amount seems a bit excessive..
Calorie goal -2000 as I work out every day and my goal is to get rid of body fat from 14 percent to 12 percent .
Body weight :150 pounds height :5 11
I m trying to figure out a very effective eating plan which ensures I cut body fat very fast .
I m seeing top abs appearing slightly but at 14 percent the lower are still hidden .
A slight increase in carbs by mistake destroys all my hard work .I have noticed even a orange juice or wheat bread slice destroys all my hard work .
0 -
I think it would first hurt your wallet :-) Out of curiosity, would you plan be to go that route to meet a short-term objective or would this be a long term plan? One thing I could think of is developing some kind of digestive intolerance to it but this is not backed-up by anything. Other thing is getting bored of the taste of it. Good luck in your journey.0
-
Last year (2016) I reviewed some research that concluded muscle protein synthesis was maximised on only 40g of protein daily, provided 4 grams of leucine were included in the diet. While the other 160g would be harmless it is also expensive. I suspect the figure of 200g is usually recommended because that dosage would contain about 4 g of leucine (MOL). I'll try to dig out the paper and list the reference for it here.2
-
Professor_Fate wrote: »Last year (2016) I reviewed some research that concluded muscle protein synthesis was maximised on only 40g of protein daily, provided 4 grams of leucine were included in the diet. While the other 160g would be harmless it is also expensive. I suspect the figure of 200g is usually recommended because that dosage would contain about 4 g of leucine (MOL). I'll try to dig out the paper and list the reference for it here.
I'm curious to see that link. I've seen an article by Layne Norton PhD talking about approximately 40g of protein being sufficient to reach the leucine threshold for maximal stimulation, but that was for a given meal, not per day.5 -
Professor_Fate wrote: »Last year (2016) I reviewed some research that concluded muscle protein synthesis was maximised on only 40g of protein daily, provided 4 grams of leucine were included in the diet. While the other 160g would be harmless it is also expensive. I suspect the figure of 200g is usually recommended because that dosage would contain about 4 g of leucine (MOL). I'll try to dig out the paper and list the reference for it here.
This research review from JISSN addresses both protein and leucine requirements: https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1550-2783-9-542 -
I think OP is asking if the only way to hit 200g daily is through supplementation. Which simply is "no". I don't need 200g for my height and weight but I can easily hit 170g through dairy and meat products eating at a calorie deficit. One meal alone I have 85g of protein through 12 oz of chicken. Another 50g+ with greek yogurt and egg whites. And that's maybe only half my calories for the day. Easy enough to see you could go light on protein the rest of the day and still make your goals.2
-
I m not a Doctor but I also believe that a lot of what we eat in meat goes to waste and also contributes to fat
I beg to differ.
I'm not a doctor either but one thing that I've learned and have been taught about the human body is that nothing of nutritional or metabolic value in what you eat ever goes to waste.
Everything you eat, except for excess water that passes thru the kidneys and is expelled thru the urinary tract and those things that are undigestable in the GI tract and expelled thru the rectum, is used in some way.
Excess protein not used for muscle maintenance and/or growth (or for other protein related functions) is converted to sugar which is used by the body for energy and other metabolic and nutritional needs and will NOT be converted to fat (together w/excess carbs and fat) unless you are eating at a caloric surplus.
The fact that the body stores excess cals as fat is proof that nothing of value eaten, including excess protein in meat, ever goes to waste.
4 -
0
-
There are lots of very vocal and nonetheless well-intentioned people on MPF who will happily give nutritional advice that is sadly not backed up by scientific fact, Hearsay, myth and pseudoscience prevail in the face of logic and fact.
People who quote facts in forum topics are often shouted down by those same well-intentioned people, if those facts don't happen to be in line with what they believe.
Protein consumption is one subject where there is a lot of difference of opinion.
However, no matter what individuals believe and how unique each person is, we are all governed by the same biology and metabolism works the same way for everyone.
Eating a diet (by diet I mean "what you eat and drink" rather than "a weight-loss plan") that is high in protein is not detrimental in any way and is in fact beneficial in many ways.
The key thing is that protein provides the body with the materials needed for daily repair as well as enhancing muscle mass. You need that regular supply of fresh protein to maintain your body as it cannot be stored for future use.
Maintaining the body is critical to anyone restricting their calorie intake, as it's fat you want to lose, not lean muscle.
Cutting calories means consuming less food. Consuming less food means less nutrients are going in, so it's even more important to ensure that what you consume contains enough nutrition of the right kind.
Many people on a weight-loss programme also include exercise in their routine. It burns more calories which of course is excellent if you're already in deficit from reduced food intake because those extra calories will be produced from burning fat supplies in the body.
However, exercise comes at a cost to the body, wear-and-tear if you like. After exercise your body needs extra maintenance, muscles need repairing and upgrading, your organs need an overhaul from getting worked harder.
Protein provides the building materials needed for all of that.
In addition, protein-rich foods keep you feeling fuller for longer, making it ideal for anyone on a restricted calorie diet where you're eating less and therefore prone to feeling hungry.
Does any of it actually work in practice?
Yes.
In my own example I lost 9 stone during 2016 on a high-protein but calorie-restricted diet.
I went from being a morbidly obese fat man to a normal healthy weight.
A whole year to achieve it might sound like a lot, but it averages at close to 2.5lb weight loss per week, which most people would be pretty happy with.
The OP of this topic wants 200g of protein a day, that sounds about right to me.
It was 180g for me (and it still is now that I'm in maintenance).
I supplemented a lot with whey protein (and still do), with up to 75% of my daily protein intake being of whey origin.
The rest would be mainly from fish, chicken, beef and pork.
I now maintain at a healthy weight that I last saw when I was in my early twenties (I'm 48 now) and enjoy a fit and active lifestyle that I'd forgotten existed.
I attribute a lot of the success in achieving this to adopting a protein-rich diet.
0 -
Jockamo319 wrote: »Professor_Fate wrote: »Last year (2016) I reviewed some research that concluded muscle protein synthesis was maximised on only 40g of protein daily, provided 4 grams of leucine were included in the diet. While the other 160g would be harmless it is also expensive. I suspect the figure of 200g is usually recommended because that dosage would contain about 4 g of leucine (MOL). I'll try to dig out the paper and list the reference for it here.
I'm curious to see that link. I've seen an article by Layne Norton PhD talking about approximately 40g of protein being sufficient to reach the leucine threshold for maximal stimulation, but that was for a given meal, not per day.
It's going to vary by source of protein; 25-30g for Whey, 30-40g for beef/egg protein, 50g for plant based sources. Layne Norton has a video on this and I will see if I can find it. Might be the one on how much a body can absorb.1 -
ocrXfitter wrote: »I don't think it's a dig on high protein diets, it's a dig on only ingesting protein via a supplement.
You apparently haven't seen and read all of the "you don't need THAT much protein" comments on MFP that I've seen and read.
Such comments are not just limited to protein via supplements; they are opposed to the idea of what the commenters consider "excessive protein" (however they define it) from whatever source -- natural or otherwise.
IMO, I am not sure if people hate on high protein or look to define the difference between need and want. I can't recall many, if any studies that demonstrate a benefit from consuming more than 1g per lb (and more often showing a range from 1.5g -2.2g/kg - ~.68g-1g/lb)... but if someone find does it for preference or compliance, it's a different study. Personally, I aim for 150g+ (175lb around 15%), but there are days I get over 200.
I do think, if there is any hate, it's related to the bro-stigma tat you must eat 1.5-2g per lb of your bw or that one must follow 40/40/20. This is part of the reason we have so many threads about worrying about getting all of this protein.
Whether or not the OP needs that much protein is going to depend on a lot of factors of which he has not told us anything.2 -
I think OP is asking if the only way to hit 200g daily is through supplementation. Which simply is "no". I don't need 200g for my height and weight but I can easily hit 170g through dairy and meat products eating at a calorie deficit. One meal alone I have 85g of protein through 12 oz of chicken. Another 50g+ with greek yogurt and egg whites. And that's maybe only half my calories for the day. Easy enough to see you could go light on protein the rest of the day and still make your goals.
not how I read it - since the OP said - can a man eat only whey protien1 -
ocrXfitter wrote: »but why?
Yeah, why is there such a prejudice against so-called "HIGH PROTEIN" diets on MFP?
Fact is, a high protein diet can be effective if your objective is to lose weight and increase or maintain strength and LBM.
200G of protein for an averaged size man like me at 160#, which is equal to 1.25g/#BW on a 2000 cal/day diet, is not excessive by any means and the heavier & bigger you are, the lower that ratio becomes.
Protein is digested just like carbs and fat but only it can be used to increase or maintain muscle development. Protein also requires more energy to digest than carbs and fat and tends to reduce hunger and appetite, which contributes to weight loss.
I don't think it's a dig on high protein diets, it's a dig on only ingesting protein via a supplement.
This was my original question- and not really even a dig- just curious.ocrXfitter wrote: »I don't think it's a dig on high protein diets, it's a dig on only ingesting protein via a supplement.
You apparently haven't seen and read all of the "you don't need THAT much protein" comments on MFP that I've seen and read.
Such comments are not just limited to protein via supplements; they are opposed to the idea of what the commenters consider "excessive protein" (however they define it) from whatever source -- natural or otherwise.
I fall somewhere in the middle.
I have nothing against high protein diets. I am for high protein (well "higher"- I'm generally woefully short)- but I was actually really curious as to "why" consuming only protein from whey- that seems highly unsatisfactory- and expensive- and not efficient.
I mean- I really like eating my protein- but I have to be honest- I'm a steak/meat junkie- so the more the merrier. The idea of consuming THAT much protein ONLY in the form of whey just seems odd.
In a more global world- I think people get really hung up on the minutia and miss the forest because of the trees.
150 grams of protein means nothing if the rest of your diet/world isn't balanced. Which is what @SideSteel says in this "guide to sexy pants" thread- and I think it's spot on.
The "quick" down and dirty advice I typically get is "aim for anything over 100"- (this is typically directed at women)why 100? because most people have to go a LITTLE out of their way to hit it- and gets them more than they normally eat... and brings attention to it- w/o feeling like they are constantly failing for not reaching 150.
And if you slice it 1 gram per lean mass- or 0.8 per pound- it is almost always very close- within 20-30 grams.
So if you aim for over 100- it puts you in a good ball park. Most people can get away with that- the longer you trainer -and the more specific/specified you get- the more important dialing that in becomes. But for the vast majority of people just trying to live a better life- over 100 is a damn good start.4 -
Yes you can do it. Your body will still use whey protein just like any other protein source.
Should you do it? I would never dare. Variety of foods is always advised in any healthy lifestyle plus a large percent of your food will be from suppliments. Personally I have had 3 to 5 scoops of protein on a desperate day, but it's not my fav. Protein suppliments don't make me as full as real food and some people have tummy trouble from drinking too much protein.
I would also advise getting the most natural brand of protein you can if you are going to be doing multiple scoops a day. Try Isopure or Naked brand. Also you can have more variety at night by drinking Casein before bed. I prefer the casein at night beacause it makes me so full and I don't ever feel ravenous in the mornings. ALSO KEEP IN MIND THAT YOUR BODY CAN ONLY ABSORB APPR. 44 GRAMS OF PROTEIN AT A TIME....I'm no expert, but I have been gievn this advice multiple times. I generally don't drink more than 1.75 scoops in a sitting for this reason.
If you really want at least 200 of protein a day it is super doable with real food. I do it almost daily. I consume about 1700 to 2000 cal a day with a goal of 25c/40p/35f and I am a WOMAN....GASP(noticed you specified "man" in post
I would advise you to add friends and creep on people's diaries that consume a high protein diet or balance macros. Also hunt Pinterest,Bodybuilding.com, Instagram, etc. for ideas.This is what I did until I could get enough ideas for sneaking in protein throughout the day.
My protein staples in random order are:
-Eggs (whole & lots of whites) I eat them every day for breakfast. Buy them bulk like 5dz.
-Cheese (low fat and reg) I use sliced cheese and grated feta often. I prefer sliced because it is already measured.
-Triple 0 yogurt from Chiobani and plain Greek yogurt.
-Luncheon meat as snacks or in salad.
-Lean meat at every meal. My fav are fish, shrimp, steak, and ground meat (I use a mix of 97 lean beef cooked with 98 lean turkey in stir fry, spaghetti sauce, taco meat, dirty rice).
-Sneak in protein every chance. If you eat carbs buy Protein Up Wraps, Joseph Bread Wraps, protein added sandwhich bread, and protein powder pancake and waffles. Also keep things like protein bars(20g at least) as staples.
-Drink Protein Suppliments after working out and be sure to space out scoops. My favorite is Isopure in Natural Vanilla. Consider Casein at night.
-If I am going to eat a dessert or junk food I try to keep foods in the house that still have a touch of protein like Halo Top ice crean and Lenny & Larry's Cookies.
-Weigh and track EVERYTHING! You will be suprised how many carbs and fats help you achieve your protein goal. Milk, cheese, yogurt, and nuts round out protein goals nicely.
Good luck.1 -
MrsChasteen wrote: »Yes you can do it. Your body will still use whey protein just like any other protein source.
Should you do it? I would never dare. Variety of foods is always advised in any healthy lifestyle plus a large percent of your food will be from suppliments. Personally I have had 3 to 5 scoops of protein on a desperate day, but it's not my fav. Protein suppliments don't make me as full as real food and some people have tummy trouble from drinking too much protein.
I would also advise getting the most natural brand of protein you can if you are going to be doing multiple scoops a day. Try Isopure or Naked brand. Also you can have more variety at night by drinking Casein before bed. I prefer the casein at night beacause it makes me so full and I don't ever feel ravenous in the mornings. ALSO KEEP IN MIND THAT YOUR BODY CAN ONLY ABSORB APPR. 44 GRAMS OF PROTEIN AT A TIME....I'm no expert, but I have been gievn this advice multiple times. I generally don't drink more than 1.75 scoops in a sitting for this reason.
If you really want at least 200 of protein a day it is super doable with real food. I do it almost daily. I consume about 1700 to 2000 cal a day with a goal of 25c/40p/35f and I am a WOMAN....GASP(noticed you specified "man" in post I would advise you to add friends and creep on people's diaries that consume a high protein diet or balance macros. Also hunt Pinterest,Bodybuilding.com, Instagram, etc. for ideas.This is what I did until I could get enough ideas for sneaking in protein throughout the day.
My protein staples in random order are:
-Eggs (whole & lots of whites) I eat them every day for breakfast. Buy them bulk like 5dz.
-Cheese (low fat and reg) I use sliced cheese and grated feta often. I prefer sliced because it is already measured.
-Triple 0 yogurt from Chiobani and plain Greek yogurt.
-Luncheon meat as snacks or in salad.
-Lean meat at every meal. My fav are fish, shrimp, steak, and ground meat (I use a mix of 97 lean beef cooked with 98 lean turkey in stir fry, spaghetti sauce, taco meat, dirty rice).
-Sneak in protein every chance. If you eat carbs buy Protein Up Wraps, Joseph Bread Wraps, protein added sandwhich bread, and protein powder pancake and waffles. Also keep things like protein bars(20g at least) as staples.
-Drink Protein Suppliments after working out and be sure to space out scoops. My favorite is Isopure in Natural Vanilla. Consider Casein at night.
-If I am going to eat a dessert or junk food I try to keep foods in the house that still have a touch of protein like Halo Top ice crean and Lenny & Larry's Cookies.
-Weigh and track EVERYTHING! You will be suprised how many carbs and fats help you achieve your protein goal. Milk, cheese, yogurt, and nuts round out protein goals nicely.
Good luck.
Your body can absorb any amount of protein that you consume, but what it does is delay the digestion. Also, whey is whey, regardless of the marketing hype by companies. So there wouldn't be a difference (excluding flavoring and potential fillers) between brands like Naked vs ON vs Pure Protein, etc.. But you can make the distinction.
Below is Dr. Layne Norton's explanation on protein.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CTF9YR6BU9k 4
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions