How should I portion my calories throughout the day?
limeysss
Posts: 28 Member
I'm a 23 year old female at 5'7, 160lbs, eating ~1380 calories a day. Is there an ideal calorie breakdown by meal/time of day? Like how much should I eat per meal, what time, and how often? I know breakfast is the most important, but other than that I'm not sure the best order to eat my calories
0
Replies
-
nope, totally doesn't matter. it is all personal preference. weight loss has nothing to do with the time of day you eat - it is all about the calorie deficit.4
-
Muscleflex79 wrote: »nope, totally doesn't matter. it is all personal preference. weight loss has nothing to do with the time of day you eat - it is all about the calorie deficit.
Currently because of my work schedule, I skip breakfast (I feel sick every morning until about 11 my entire life) eat a small lunch around ~200 calories between 11 and 1, and consume the rest of my calories after 4 and with dinner. Is this ok?0 -
Whichever way makes it sustainable and easy for you.0
-
however way you wish0
-
Try not to eat after about 7:300
-
-
mrsnattybulking wrote: »
some people might have digestive issues when they eat too close to bedtime, but that would be the only reason not to eat after a certain time of the day.0 -
True. OP if you have digestive issues preventing you from sleep/being uncomfortable at night because of late eating then definitely eat earlier but if you're asking for any perceived benefit to weight loss; there is absolutely none.0
-
-
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!1 -
I changed the name of my meals to time periods (6-10am, 10-12, 2-6 and 6-10). I have a specific amount of calories assigned to each 4 hour window. It's better for me to have 4 goal periods each day and try to meet my calorie goal for that time period. It took some trial and error to figure out what time periods and calories totals and what ratios of carbs protein and fats were right for me. It might work for you.3
-
mrsnattybulking wrote: »True. OP if you have digestive issues preventing you from sleep/being uncomfortable at night because of late eating then definitely eat earlier but if you're asking for any perceived benefit to weight loss; there is absolutely none.
0 -
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
Sorry but this isn't true.
On skipping breakfast: https://examine.com/nutrition/is-it-really-that-bad-to-skip-breakfast/
On meal frequency: https://examine.com/nutrition/do-i-need-to-eat-six-times-a-day-to-keep-my-metabolism-high/9 -
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
nope science doesn't support this (hint, I can also find a study that says not eating in the morning is good for me) - your metabolism is a continuous burn during the day, you don't need to accelerate it
I find eating in the am actually causes me to having more cravings later in the day and I tend to have an early morning slump - which counters pretty much everything you said6 -
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
no - most of this is not true. tons of people skip breakfast and lose weight. eating breakfast does not "accelerate your metabolism" (if only it were that easy!) the 30 minute window to eat after a workout has also been debunked. so many myths in one post!6 -
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
You have no idea what you're talking about, literally everything you've posted here is wrong.4 -
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
Nope. I never eat breakfast. I save my calories for later in the day and evening when I actually *am* hungry. Meal timing is irrelevant to weight loss. Eating breakfast does not accelerate your metabolism. It's working 24/7 or you'd be dead.
I've lost 75 lbs over a year ago, reached my goal weight and have been in maintenance ever since without ever eating breakfast.
For some people, eating breakfast makes sense. For others, (like me) not so much. There is no one-size-fits-all method for weight loss, other than finding the way that works best for you to eat less calories in a day than you burn.5 -
mrsnattybulking wrote: »True. OP if you have digestive issues preventing you from sleep/being uncomfortable at night because of late eating then definitely eat earlier but if you're asking for any perceived benefit to weight loss; there is absolutely none.
That's because it's hooey.4 -
Muscleflex79 wrote: »nope, totally doesn't matter. it is all personal preference. weight loss has nothing to do with the time of day you eat - it is all about the calorie deficit.
Currently because of my work schedule, I skip breakfast (I feel sick every morning until about 11 my entire life) eat a small lunch around ~200 calories between 11 and 1, and consume the rest of my calories after 4 and with dinner. Is this ok?
Yes, this is okay.0 -
Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
Another nope. None of this is true. There whole protocol of Intermittent Fasting is in direct contradiction to this.1 -
snickerscharlie wrote: »mrsnattybulking wrote: »True. OP if you have digestive issues preventing you from sleep/being uncomfortable at night because of late eating then definitely eat earlier but if you're asking for any perceived benefit to weight loss; there is absolutely none.
That's because it's hooey.
+10 -
Its best to apportion your calories the way it suits you best. This is an individual thing. Sorry your mornings can start badly were you to have breakfast. As in all things, do what is right for you.0
-
I normally eat approx 250 for breakfast, 350 lunch and 500 dinner. Absolute approx, no real plan just what tends to happen the rest of my calories come from snacks/milk in a couole coffees. Today, randomly, I skipped breakfast altogether but ate 200-300 snacks/meals every couple of hours from 1100 onwards and feel like I've eaten tons but actually feel more hungry this evening (I don't normally feel hungry at all).
I don't really make any plans, especially being on mat leave there's less structure to my days so less food routine. Find what works best for you but just remember the bottom line is the total calories is what's important. When, what or how they're consumed is of far less value to weigtloss.
One thing i do do though is bunch a couple days together if I know i have a social event.. so one day may look over and one under but I know overall I've stayed within my goals.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
deannalfisher wrote: »Actually I somewhat disagree. Yes it's all about the calorie deficit but how and what you eat can help or hurt you.
For instance - don't skip breakfast! Make sure you get protein and fats and not just carbs. Eating in the morning will accelerate your metabolism (ie help you burn more calories) AND reduce cravings and give you more energy.
There are studies that say eating smaller meals throughout the day also help keep your metabolism high and at the same time keep your cravings down. Also eating within 30 minutes of working out has shown to help you repair / rebuild your body after a tough workout.
But my best learning has been to eat breakfast even when I'm not hungry. It helps me stay to the plan for the entire day.
Best of luck!
nope science doesn't support this (hint, I can also find a study that says not eating in the morning is good for me) - your metabolism is a continuous burn during the day, you don't need to accelerate it
I find eating in the am actually causes me to having more cravings later in the day and I tend to have an early morning slump - which counters pretty much everything you said
100% agree and avoid eating too early for this very reason. I am in way better control if my first meal comes later than earlier after waking. I too, tend to have less cravings and desire to mindlessly eat if calorie consumption starts later. Ive never quite been sure if its reliable information when it comes to 'speeding up' metabolism, in any way.0 -
I eat about 300 calories every 3 hours because I always enjoy always having a meal right around the corner.0
-
Agree with others that timing is utterly irrelevant.
I tend to start my day with black coffee but otherwise skip breakfast entirely. If I know I'm going to struggle to fit my calories in for the day (like on a day I have a big cardio session planned or a class at the gym) I'll eat at break time. Otherwise most of my calories for the day are consumed in one big block at lunch.
I tend to save 1-200 calories for treat things in the evening. Today it was gin.1 -
-
Whenever you want. Just ensure it is a timeframe that is sustainable for you. If you are happy with your current timing don't change it. Eat within your calorie goal and profit.0
-
OP - you'll need to figure this one out yourself. It's totally based on what keeps you satisfied throughout the day. Start with 3 meals and 2 snacks, or 4 meals -- or 3 larger meals and test it out. Good luck.1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions