Does anybody have one "eat as many calories as you want" day a week & lose weight?
newstart1988
Posts: 154 Member
Have you lost weight doing that?
0
Replies
-
If I were to do that, I think I would undo much of the work I'd already done. I'm not willing to do that.
You may hear differently from others, but I don't find 'cheat' days like that to be worth it.18 -
I could easily blow my entire weeks deficit in a day like that.20
-
In my case, that would lead me eating a lot of calories and I've found me eating a lot of calories one day makes me want to continually eat a lot of calories. It's a slippery slope and one I'd rather avoid.
There have been days I have slipped up and gone over my calories, but I don't ever intentionally plan to do so.11 -
That would completely destroy my deficit. As many calories as I want is far more than my body needs, that's why I'm having to lose weight.
Tbh I don't ever feel inclined to do that, I just make sure I eat the goods I like within my calorie budget. I've yet to come up against a special occasion that I haven't managed to make fit.8 -
Depends on if you have a reasonable deficit or not.
Reasonable, and eating a reasonable amount over normal deficit amount - would not undo a whole week's worth of doing it right - and would likely be beneficial.
Unless it caused you totally lose it.
Even there though, if you had a 500 cal daily deficit, and went over on a weekend day, you'd have to hit goal, eat 500 more, and then eat 3000 more to wipe out what the week caused.
That would be like purposeful pigging out for many.
But if you just had a planned splurge meal, ate smaller or no breakfast, and little lunch, and good long workout - then it's unlikely dinner would cause any more harm than increased sodium intake causing water retention for a few days.
But that's not like real fat weight gained anyway - obviously don't weigh on Sun or Mon unless you can totally separate your emotional response from purely data numbers for curiosity's sake.
Plenty of people do similar.
But just like anything - planning is needed. If you don't plan to succeed, you plan to fail.4 -
If you are going to do that type of free day, you are still going to have to plan it if you want to lose weight. You will have to see what your weekly deficit is vs your goals and decide how many calories you want to eat in that single day.
If you are trying to lose, i think a more balanced approach might be to have a maintenance day instead of a binge day. That way you dont lose any progress from the week but you get to eat a bit more on that one day.6 -
I've always had a "Comfort Food" day and it's generally a Sunday because I weigh myself first thing on Sunday morning and then have a day of eating more relaxed ... I started my weight loss in November 2012 at 145.6kg (321lb), by November 2014 I got down to 71.1kg (156.7lb) and I have been maintaining since then.
Just because you're having a "Comfort Food" doesn't mean you have to go mad and your entire weeks allowance, it simply means you can eat the things you've been fancying all week - my usual treat is alcohol, custard and some sort of cake; my average calorie intake is 2100 a day Monday to Saturday, but on a Sunday it can be up to 2500 and I have lost weight and continue to maintain my weight on that - admittedly I do about 6 hours exercise a week, but then again I have done that for almost 4 years now, so it's a habit not a necessity.6 -
I'm in maintenance, but I believe the question is interesting for both losers and maintainers.
Back in 2013 when I joined MFP, I was obese, but I decided to immediately start eating, moving and thinking like a normal weight person. This has transformed my habits, attitudes, environment and preferences. "As many calories as I want" does no longer equal "as much food as I can possibly get into my body in one sitting/day", but "an amount of food that makes me happy and healthy, including, but not limited to, keeping a normal weight for my height", adjusted for the food's awesomeness an the occasion's specialness. So instead of aiming to eat a lot, I aim to eat what I like best. My quality of life has improved immeasurably.15 -
Nope. Because a day like that could easily destroy my calorie deficit for the entire week.3
-
a cheat day could undo all the work you put in to the past week , but 1 cheat meal , like on fri. , or sat , on your off day( if you keep it reasonable) is recommended . you can easily work it in to your calories for the day, you just have to plan ahead . my cheat meal is always mediterranean food !1
-
A lot of people do this I believe, where they follow a plan for the week and usually on Sunday they'll have a feast. I know one girl who makes sure she doesnt binge by listing her cravings through out thee week and choosing three on sunday for her meals, along with a nice water/tea and a brisk walk.1
-
As for me, if I were to do that, I would douse what I could in hot sauce to speed my metabolism up.11
-
-
No but if I know I'm going to a birthday party or special event once in a while I will give give up the counting and eat what I want for that event - trying to make good decisions if I can. I am fully aware that if I do that I can give up on losing anything that week, and possibly the week after.4
-
It really does depend on how many calories you can put away. I would struggle to eat enough in one day to completely wipe out a whole weeks deficit.4
-
Nah. I can easily put away 5000 calories at a buffet. I wouldn't want to disappoint myself seeing the scale jump up several pounds the next day. I wouldn't want to induce a dopamine rush from food ever again, because in my experience it is hard to jump back into the swing of things. My goal is to learn to eat for the weight I want to be.4
-
Food is one of life's pleasures and it's a shame when people say they have an 'all or nothing' approach to eating. I think when people deny themselves it's likely they'll end up (in their minds) 'failing' at some point and going back to old habits when they see certain foods as 'cheats' or 'no go areas'.
For me, I've stopped using this sort of language and have changed my lifestyle to incorporate a wider range of foods. My husband and I both work full time in education so I plan our lunches/dinners in the week and shop to ensure that I have plenty of healthy options to snack on.
I like experimenting with food and have found that this has been one of the ways to success. Spicing up meals in the week with a range of different grains, vegetables and herbs make all meals enjoyable and not something 'you have to eat'. because it's good for you. I have an ever growing range of recipe books from Persian to Cantonese: you'll find that often these foods are naturally healthier, but utterly delicious.
On Friday evening, after a long week, we go to the supermarket and choose what we fancy for an easy tea: perhaps Pizza or a shank; a selection of cheeses and definitely a desert, or a bar of chocolate each. We also choose a bottle of wine to enjoy over the Friday and Saturday evenings. He plays football and I go to gym and then it's 'flop' down on the sofa and chill. On Saturday mornings we usually have a tea cake or a bacon sandwich and then we have an 'ordinary' weekend - balanced but not strict, (so, if we want butter on our toast we'll have it). The difference is that as we have trained ourselves to eat better over a period of time, we're more aware of our appetite and so where once we'd keep going back to the cheese board until our stomachs hurt, we now cut a reasonable amount and put the rest away before sitting down and relaxing.
The real change for me has been exercise. I know people don't want to hear it, but you'll never maintain weight loss if you don't do the two together. I exercise three to five times a week - three at the gym and one to two following a DVD at home. Not only have I lost weight but more importantly, I've seen a change in the shape of my body and my state of mind. Again, I switch things around; try different equipment and DVD routines to ensure that it stays fresh and enjoyable. There's nothing better than an hour in the gym; head phones in, dance music on, to work out the stresses of teaching college students I can tell you!
I'm fifty but I look and feel better than I did fifteen years ago. I would urge others not to exclude things; if you feel they are 'denying' yourself, you are more likely to all out 'binge' at some stage and then feel awful. The key question is are you 'enjoying' your food? If the answer is 'no' then, even if you do lose weight, you're likely to ditch the 'healthy' side and revert to old habits when you hit your goal: thereby ensuring the cycle starts again.
'Everything in moderation' is the key: food is there to be enjoyed! Hope you all find a happy medium.
Sorry about the essay - force of habit!4 -
No - I can easily eat 10k+ calories in a day.
But I do often have days or weekends that I eat significantly over maintenance requirements, but do ok without compensating- overall of course it slows weight loss, but happy to mix up my metabolism a bit.1 -
Apparently, Dolly Parton eats no carbs during the week and eats what she wants at the weekend. Not sure I could totally shun carbs for five days straight, though.0
-
Honestly, I don't think I *ever* eat "as much as I want". Nor do I sleep as much as I want, or slack off as much as want, or spend as much money as I want...
But I eat well, live well, buy fun stuff...10
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.7K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.8K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 415 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.6K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions