Is it necessary to eat every 2 or 3 hours?
Options
Replies
-
It is not necessary, but I think it really depends on your own hunger cues. I eat frequently, smaller meals, because I like it that way and it keeps me from being overly hungry.2
-
poonamsonii21 wrote: »Is it necessary to eat every 2 or 3 hours for weighg loss..my nuyritionist say if u dont eat every 2 or 3 hours...body forms gas and bloating...is it true
For weight loss you just need a calorie deficit. Meal timing is personal preference and has little to do with gas and bloating I think.
Eating too fast can contribute to gas and bloating as you swallow air.
http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/gas-and-gas-pains/in-depth/gas-and-gas-pains/ART-20044739?pg=1
1 -
I don't think that sounds right, why eat every 2/3 hours if you aren't hungry?0
-
I've lost over 130lbs only eating, usually, twice a day. I wouldn't be taking advice from them anymore if I was you. Their information is completely inaccurate.4
-
Nope. 35 lbs lost and maintained for 1.5 years while fasting for about 16 hours every day and eating 2 meals a day.1
-
For some with sugar absorption issues or a need to control blood sugar levels may find eating at 2 to 3 hour intervals helpful but if you are like the majority on here, fit and healthy, there is no definite benefit. I would consider the production of gas to be down to inadequate digestion, the stomach not emptying fully between meals, in some of us insufficient digestive microbes to breakdown foods, slow transit could also encourage gas in some subjects too, this can lead to reduced digestive enzymes, this would be much less common cause.
Need2exercise raises a good point, some of us will benefit from a daily fast. Generally our bodies do benefit from our taking breaks from eating particularly if one has a grazing habit, so the elimination of the by-products of life can happen easily giving the liver and other organs the opportunity to recover between days. Most of us will easily manage 10 possibly 12 hours fast a day having breakfast and supper, our start and end to the day well spaced. Many will consider this idea woo.
It is often said our lives are very different to those of our ancestors. I raise this here because with the advent of electricity we are able to rise earlier on our dark winter days and stay up much later too providing more opportunity for us to eat. We as a species are so very far removed from our and the worlds natural cycles. The study of tribal cultures who have maintained their historic dietary patters is showing none of our modern readily accepted health issues.8 -
I eat and snack whenever I am hungry I just keep it within my calories for the day that is all you need to do to lose weight.3
-
poonamsonii21 wrote: »
This may be from your own knowledge, or perhaps someone with some equally bad qualifications as your nutritionist....
Exercise is NOT for weight loss, it is for heart health and body transformation.
Reread that several times if needed. Weight gain is usually it's side effect.
Diet is for weight loss - done right hopefully just fat loss, done wrong you can include some muscle loss in there - and that will suck sooner and later.
The sooner you get that right, the sooner you won't make bad decisions based on a wrong premise.
And your 1200 diet goal, probably is for average sedentary woman.
You sedentary with exercise? - then eat more.
You want to be average? - then eat more.
Have better workouts - transform the body more.9 -
This is the kind of thing that makes me a little embarrassed to tell people that I eat every 2-3 hours. It has nothing to do with optimizing digestion or extra calorie burn or whatever, it's just what keeps me full and under calories for the day. The human digestive system is actually pretty awesome - sure, it can get thrown off by all sorts of things, but it can also adapt to all sorts of things.9
-
MegaMooseEsq wrote: »This is the kind of thing that makes me a little embarrassed to tell people that I eat every 2-3 hours. It has nothing to do with optimizing digestion or extra calorie burn or whatever, it's just what keeps me full and under calories for the day. The human digestive system is actually pretty awesome - sure, it can get thrown off by all sorts of things, but it can also adapt to all sorts of things.
Don't be embarrassed - it's what works for you.
Now - you come out spouting advice that it's required for weight loss, with no comment or background as to why it actually works for you better - then prepared to be slammed by many.8 -
MegaMooseEsq wrote: »This is the kind of thing that makes me a little embarrassed to tell people that I eat every 2-3 hours. It has nothing to do with optimizing digestion or extra calorie burn or whatever, it's just what keeps me full and under calories for the day. The human digestive system is actually pretty awesome - sure, it can get thrown off by all sorts of things, but it can also adapt to all sorts of things.
Don't be embarrassed - it's what works for you.
Now - you come out spouting advice that it's required for weight loss, with no comment or background as to why it actually works for you better - then prepared to be slammed by many.
Oh for sure, I would never suggest anyone do anything other than what works best for them to keep a deficit. It more comes up when people ask how I've lost weight, which has been happening increasingly often now that I'm down 25+ lbs. If I mention eating frequently I've often gotten this knowing sort of "Ah yes, I heard that boosts the metabolism blah blah" and then I have to make the awkward choice of either addressing the misconception or letting it slide.2 -
poonamsonii21 wrote: »Not at all.
Purely personal preference.
Perhaps she is talking about you specifically getting that problem, because that's not true at all in general.
I don't eat all day until 8-11 pm after exercise - no gas or bloating for me.
Unless I eat a carb heavy or only meal or snack. Then yes.
I do have a little problem with carbs, or rather my insulin response does - eating every 2-3 hrs would be a great way for me to be in a tired state all day long, I'll say that.
You might look up the degrees they have, and if recent.
Ok thnks...each every nutritionist says to eat every 2 hours.
Um. No.
I see one of the top sports med dietitians in the U.S., and that "advice" has never come out of her mouth.
So maybe you're seeing quacks, but that's certainly not "every" nutritionist.
Protip: Stick to the dietitians and not the nutritionists. Anyone can call himself/herself a nutritionist.2 -
If exercise can be equal to increased mobility then there can be advantages because you are improving circulation posture and other functions particularly if weight loss is not your only goal, if you are wanting a more healthy life style for example.
The essential thing for us all to take into consideration, doing what is right and works for you to achieve your personal goal. Listening to others hearing what they have to say then adopting something you like because you think it may work for you is good, changing what you do is also good if it fails to make a difference over time.0 -
poonamsonii21 wrote: »Is it necessary to eat every 2 or 3 hours for weighg loss..my nuyritionist say if u dont eat every 2 or 3 hours...body forms gas and bloating...is it true
How do YOU feel if you eat fewer times a day? That's all that counts. Everyone needs to find their sweet spot for how often they eat and what their diet consists of. Beware of anyone telling you universal truths about what or when to eat - there are no universal truths.8 -
I personally eat every 2-3 hours all day just because that's the best way to keep myself full throughout the day and not over eat during more spread out mealtimes.0
-
poonamsonii21 wrote: »Is it necessary to eat every 2 or 3 hours for weighg loss..my nuyritionist say if u dont eat every 2 or 3 hours...body forms gas and bloating...is it true
Nope.
I do, but only because I am diabetic and that helps keep my blood sugar more level. I also am more likely to binge if I get too hungry.4 -
poonamsonii21 wrote: »
Losing weight isn't about doing this workout or that workout...losing weight is about consuming fewer calories than you are expending regardless of exercise. Regular exercise has the added benefit of increasing your expenditure to some degree, but unless you're training like an athlete, it's rather negligible relative to the calories you burn existing and then going about your day to day...7 -
I tend to eat every 3 hours or so because I am hungry and because it keeps my blood sugar levels on an even keel. Everyone is different, talk to a nutritionist.2
-
-
@poonamsonii21
Is this "nutritionist" part of a weight loss clinic/program you have entered?
My spidey sense is tingling...3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.8K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 395 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 960 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions