Taking a week break from logging food - What results have YOU had from a logging break?
Options
Replies
-
I rarely log food intake anymore. As long as I eat my protein and fruits and veggies, and get my exercise, I stay on track. Occasionally I let other things take priority and I gain a little weight, but with a bit of focus (but still no logging), it comes right back off again. A few times I have really struggled and started logging again in hopes of getting back to my good habits, and so far, it has always worked.2
-
Three years ago, I left MFP for almost 6 months and kept the weight within the normal +/-2lbs range that I set for myself. However, I was very “aware” of the kind of foods and the amount that I was eating and I also kept exercising. I came back because I wanted to keep better track of my macros.
In general, I don’t log while on vacation, and except for water weight due to travel, I also keep my weight in check. Sometimes I even lose weight while on vacation because I am more conscious of portion control since I don’t have the logging part of the equation helping me to track the calories.
There are many people in the forums that are already on maintenance, just like I am, and keep their weight in check. In my opinion, a lot depends on how much you learned while losing, your relationship with food, motivation, and control.
6 -
I lost 125 lbs then been maintaining 1 year after I stopped logging. I logged only for my first 3 months, 25 lbs. I eat consistently (same things) and learned to manage eating out. So the things I learned while logging stayed with me.2
-
Depends how long it's for but generally maintenance or a small (3-4lb) gain followed by maintenance.0
-
In July I went to Europe for 2 weeks and took a break. Mentally it was great for me! I didn’t log, didn’t wear my Fitbit, and swapped my regular intense 2hr weights/boxing workouts for 15 min morning yoga.
I did come back a few lbs heavier but it was water weight and within a little over a week I was back to normal. I was plateaued for a few months before the trip and am now down 5lb from pre-vacation weight with 5lb more to go to goal.0 -
6.51bs on and so not *kitten* worth it. Thar was my wight in after not logging last week.0
-
I just had a week off due to going overseas for a holiday. I set my goal to loose .25 kilos and I was able to eat an extra 1800kj per day. It made a difference eating more. I also walked alot and ate some of those kj's back. I ended up loosing 700 grams and came back slightly lighter.0
-
I would like to throw something in here... A lot of people say they instantly gained weight when not logging a week. But this observation might be biased. Many of us take a break from logging because other things take over. Vacation, depression, stress at work, having a baby, you name it. That already sets you up to be thrown out of your rhythm and is connected to having fewer choices of food/ choice to prepare it yourself / choice of portions served to you. That does not mean that the break from logging alone made you gain weight, it was the break from your structure in total. That can be different if you just take a random break but keep everything else on track.12
-
skymningen wrote: »I would like to throw something in here... A lot of people say they instantly gained weight when not logging a week. But this observation might be biased. Many of us take a break from logging because other things take over. Vacation, depression, stress at work, having a baby, you name it. That already sets you up to be thrown out of your rhythm and is connected to having fewer choices of food/ choice to prepare it yourself / choice of portions served to you. That does not mean that the break from logging alone made you gain weight, it was the break from your structure in total. That can be different if you just take a random break but keep everything else on track.
That would be correct, and for one week it's likely not going to make that much of a difference if you're careful with your choices. "IDGAF" kind of logging break is potentially more likely to lead to weight gain. My experience, however, with longer periods of not logging is that it's harder for me to diet because I tend to want to undereat "just in case" and it's more stressful because I'm not sure if I can "afford" that piece of high calorie something I want, which leads to food blowouts that make it harder for me to lose weight. For maintenance, I find not logging much easier. I notice a calorie creep the longer I'm not logging and I find myself needing to take corrective "fast days" more often (when weight goes above my set maximum allowed). I also personally feel logging puts me in a better mental state for calorie control and I'm happier on it.3 -
For me it equaled weight gain. I wasn’t ready to not be tracking & quickly fell right back into old eating habits0
-
Water weight gain. Was eating more carbs and enjoying two weeks' holiday. It was ace! Came back no problems logging and hitting calorie targets for deficit. Still losing now. I like the slow and steady approach. I like being flexible. I like the practice and the confidence eating at maintenance and slightly over has given me. Not logging did not stress me out either.0
-
For me, a logging break is a diet break - I don't find it difficult to log so if i'm not logging, it's generally because I'm overeating and don't care what the macros/calories are. I have found a week off after 4-5 months can be a great mental break, with minimal setbacks - however, you do need to be very aware of how to 'get back on the horse' - which I know i'm fine at. If you are someone who struggles to start, I wouldn't recommend it.3
-
Stopped logging. Started gaining. Went back to logging.1
-
Just started back today after a 2 week stay-cation. I do not log or worry about what I eat during vacations...the result...4 lb gain. It's hard as hell to lose 4 lbs in 2 weeks but easy as pie (and brownies and homemade bread, etc) to gain it.0
-
If it is ONLY a week, Maintenance.
If more than a week I can go up by 5-7 lbs due to my love of carbs some will be fat some will be water.
Taking a tracking break for 1 week does wonders for recommitting to tracking. I'd rather stop tracking completely than become lax in tracking.0 -
Taking a break from logging leads to a longer break from logging. I think of logging as being a good habit and see a 'break' from logging as being a 'break' from my other good habits.
I learned from previous laxness in logging that I cannot rely on how I feel about what I'm eating to control my intake. I've also learned that I'm not entirely honest with myself about how much I am eating. Logging has been an excellent counterbalance to my shortcomings, as well as the most effective thing I do for my health.1 -
Its second nature for me to login every day and track food and exercise. It does not take much time for me to do it, but I have not met my need to take a break from it.0
-
I needed a logging break over a year ago....I'm still on that break and have maintained my weight fairly effortlessly. I do weigh regularly though so if I saw myself going to higher end of goal range I would just cut out a snack to get back to my happy weight.3
-
Weight gain. I'm up a lb and a half. Not loving it.0
-
A week turned into 2 weeks, then 3 weeks, then 3 months and I undid 4 months of hard work3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 389 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 919 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions