Protein Powder
marygraci999
Posts: 1,917 Member
Whats the down low on Protein powders?? Are they really required or is it a cash grab?? And who exactly should use it?? I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts.. But I dony use any protein powders
0
Replies
-
Do you get sufficient protein without it? It's only really needed if you can't get enough protein in your normal meals
I personally like it in yoghurt (to add more protein, along with flavour and sweetness to natural yogurt - I don't need it if I buy one of the higher protein yoghurts though)
I also make protein pancakes - they'd take up too many carbs if I made "normal" ones.2 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders?? Are they really required or is it a cash grab?? And who exactly should use it?? I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts.. But I dony use any protein powders
I use it maybe once a week on days I don't hit my protein goal.
It's nothing magic, it's just protein in powder form.0 -
Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.5 -
Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??0 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders?? Are they really required or is it a cash grab?? And who exactly should use it?? I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts.. But I dony use any protein powders
Good for meal replacement and convenience but no magic powers.
1 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??
Protein intake is way over-emphasized.
Check your macros on MFP which default to 20% protein.
If you get close to this you will be fine.
No need for the crazy protein numbers espoused by supplement shills like 1g/lb. etc.
Nonsense.
We all get suckered into this scam unfortunately. Same BS with BCAAs.4 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??
How much do you get?
Aiming to exceed MFPs target is probably emough.
I aim for around 0.8g per pound of bodyweight.2 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??
There's quite a range of recommendations but the factors that would normally be seen as reasons to increase above sedentary RDAs or general minimums would be:
Calorie deficit.
Training hard.
Endurance cardio.
My personal preference when I was food logging was for 1g of protein per pound of estimated lean body mass. A rough estimate is fine, accuracy not required but I did tend to regard it as a minimum goal. That also suited my dietary preferences.
These days I'm just mindful of both calories and protein and don't track either.1 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??
If you're trying to build muscle and strength quickly, the general consensus is to eat about 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight assuming you aren't obese or 1 g per pound of lean body mass if you are obese. For most men that ends up at around 150-200 g of protein per day and yes, I know that's much higher than the recommended minimum of 0.8 g per kg but that is what tends to get the best results if you're goal is to build size and strength quickly.
If that isn't your goal, or if it is but you're not in a hurry to get big and strong, then don't worry about it. It's pretty hard to not get the minimum amount of protein your body needs to be healthy so you won't have any health issues if your protein intake isn't high.
To go back to your question of whether or not you need protein powder, the answer is no, not really even if you have a high protein goal. My goal is to eat about 190 g of protein per day and I almost always do that with normal food. I still have some powder in my kitchen in case it's getting late and I'm way below my goal, but it's not something I rely on for my day to day nutrition.2 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??
If you're trying to build muscle and strength quickly, the general consensus is to eat about 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight assuming you aren't obese or 1 g per pound of lean body mass if you are obese. For most men that ends up at around 150-200 g of protein per day and yes, I know that's much higher than the recommended minimum of 0.8 g per kg but that is what tends to get the best results if you're goal is to build size and strength quickly.
If that isn't your goal, or if it is but you're not in a hurry to get big and strong, then don't worry about it. It's pretty hard to not get the minimum amount of protein your body needs to be healthy so you won't have any health issues if your protein intake isn't high.
To go back to your question of whether or not you need protein powder, the answer is no, not really even if you have a high protein goal. My goal is to eat about 190 g of protein per day and I almost always do that with normal food. I still have some powder in my kitchen in case it's getting late and I'm way below my goal, but it's not something I rely on for my day to day nutrition.
Deff not obese Im at 130 right now..0 -
This content has been removed.
-
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders??
Just a protein rich dietary supplement.
Scores on convenience.
Scores on calorie efficiency.
Some people think they confer bonus "bro points" if consumed in a gym.
Are they really required.
Nope. No more required than chicken any other individual source of protein.
or is it a cash grab??
Not really - pretty inexpensive.
Hyped - yes.
Overused or used inappropriately - probably.
And who exactly should use it??
People who like to drink some of their protein to help reach a suitable protein goal.
I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts..
Makes you a candidate for a higher protein goal than a sedentary person who isn't training/exercising. Protein shakes might help hit that goal but that's just a preference.
How do I know if I am getting enough protein??
Protein intake is way over-emphasized.
Check your macros on MFP which default to 20% protein.
If you get close to this you will be fine.
No need for the crazy protein numbers espoused by supplement shills like 1g/lb. etc.
Nonsense.
We all get suckered into this scam unfortunately. Same BS with BCAAs.
There is loads of research that does not agree with your assessment.
https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12970-017-0177-8
One example.
OP, protein powder can be useful in hitting your goal for the day. sjomial summed it up rather nicely.1 -
I supplement with protein powder because I seem to be unable to get all my protein grams otherwise. It's sad, really. Kinda like my inability to do math....I'm unable to consume the required amount of protein daily. The powder is my way of cheating the system, yo1
-
I struggle reaching my protein goals so a protein shake after a workout helps me reach my goal.0
-
I find it is an easy breakfast after swim, before work that I don't need to think about.
Also just got a lemon cheesecake powder that is going to be my pudding for a while! tres yummy.
Average 19g protein for 100cals (with water - more with milk obvs). I like those numbers
0 -
Protein powder is just a source of protein. I like a min amount of protein at all meals (I find it filling and it helps me meet my protein goal), so if my breakfast would normally be lower protein I include it. More often than not (as when I'm regularly having vegetable omelets for breakfast), I don't.
Good protein goal if you are trying to lose weight or gain muscle (or both) is about .65-.85 g per lb of a healthy goal weight (as you are a healthy weight, just using your weight is fine). I tend to aim for the higher end (.8) when at a deficit as I'm a woman in my 40s so can use some help retaining or building muscle (obviously work out matters more).0 -
marygraci999 wrote: »Whats the down low on Protein powders?? Are they really required or is it a cash grab?? And who exactly should use it?? I myself am very active I lift and do full body workouts.. But I dony use any protein powders
No, but it helps me manage my chocolate cravings. I use protein powder to make yummy homemade chocolate protein bars that fulfill my craving for a sweet treat but are low sugar, carbs and high protein. In the long run, I wouldn't feel happy eating a bunch of cookies and brownies every day, but I'm good with a protein bar every single day.0 -
I personally love protein powder I don't drink one every day but it helps on days that my protein levels from food sources are on the low side. Most of them are also pretty low in calories. I'm weight training in a deficit so thats a huge plus! It's also quick and convenient 0
-
Mint chocolate chip with water is great. Trying to bulk so it's quick and easy for inbetween meals.0
-
I find it is an easy breakfast after swim, before work that I don't need to think about.
Also just got a lemon cheesecake powder that is going to be my pudding for a while! tres yummy.
Average 19g protein for 100cals (with water - more with milk obvs). I like those numbers
OOO Sounds delicious.. Have you had it before0 -
liftorgohome wrote: »Mint chocolate chip with water is great. Trying to bulk so it's quick and easy for inbetween meals.
I will have to try it..0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions