Weight Gain on 1200cal and 5 Miles a day?
Options
newmanc0299
Posts: 16 Member
Okay...
I am 5'5 and 20. I began at 135lbs and I weighed in this morning (before breakfast, after bathroom, etc) at 142lbs. For the last two and a half weeks, I have been running 5 miles 6 times a week and eating 1200 calories...someone please explain this. I am so confused.
I have no idea what is going on--- I was 110lbs in August. I eat completely clean with one dessert a week. I weigh and measure everything, and I watch my sodium intake....help meeeee!!!!
I am 5'5 and 20. I began at 135lbs and I weighed in this morning (before breakfast, after bathroom, etc) at 142lbs. For the last two and a half weeks, I have been running 5 miles 6 times a week and eating 1200 calories...someone please explain this. I am so confused.
I have no idea what is going on--- I was 110lbs in August. I eat completely clean with one dessert a week. I weigh and measure everything, and I watch my sodium intake....help meeeee!!!!
10
Replies
-
could be a couple things...holding onto water for repair of muscle with new running regimen...and if you're eating very low calories and then doing all of that running and not fueling that activity, you're putting a major stress on your body and raising cortisol levels which will inhibit and slow weight loss...my guess would be a combo of both things.
Are you eating some of your exercise calories back to account for your running activity? 1200 calories assumes sedentary...if you're running 5 miles per day, you're not sedentary.13 -
When you say you're eating 1200 calories, is that net or supposed to be gross?0
-
What does myfitnesspal tell you your calories should be per day? Possibly you are way under that and your body is fighting back storing calories due to a deficit.35
-
-
cwolfman13 wrote: »could be a couple things...holding onto water for repair of muscle with new running regimen...and if you're eating very low calories and then doing all of that running and not fueling that activity, you're putting a major stress on your body and raising cortisol levels which will inhibit and slow weight loss...my guess would be a combo of both things.
Are you eating some of your exercise calories back to account for your running activity? 1200 calories assumes sedentary...if you're running 5 miles per day, you're not sedentary.
I really just stick to the 1200 and don't really eat anything back...fitbit has a tracking part for daily calorie expenditure (so it creates a 1000cal deficit), and it tells me I'm in the target zone when I eat 1200 and burn off 2250 cal a day, which I seem to only be able to do with exercise.0 -
newmanc0299 wrote: »
1200 gross, sorry but please see @cwolfman13 's post. If that's true, you'd be under eating and putting a massive stress on your body. It's a real recipe for burnout, or worse, especially at a normal BMI. Odds are, if your logging is correct, you've probably gained some water weight. Eventually it will come off, but cutting as severely as you are at the weight you're at, you'll end up sacrificing muscle as well as fat(and water) when the weight starts coming down. This means that you may lose weight, but your BF% may not change much (if at all) so you probably won't get what you're aesthetically looking for.
With your stats, I'd recommend researching a recomp.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10177803/recomposition-maintaining-weight-while-losing-fat/p17 -
Period weight gain?0
-
Not only losing muscle but heading for a hospital visit inducing collapse.
I expect not only are you retaining from the sudden increase in exercise but also from cortisol due to the amount of stress you're putting your body under.17 -
cwolfman has a very good point. If your body is not used to the idea of doing so much exercise, it will take some time to settle down and to become happy with all you are expecting of it. Not eating back calories earned or part is adding stresses to your systems and may impeded your recovery from these runs. It is possible one rest day is insufficient for yourself.
I question how over weight you are because if you are close to a good weight for your height it is going to be more difficult to loose 1 or even 1/2 a lb a week. You are taller than myself and at less than my goal, (if this makes sense to you). I would be inclined to change my activity level from sedentary to active, and loss to half or one lb a week. Then out of interest, see what calorific level would enable you to maintain to achieve a good all round view, so you can define your actual goals.
Possibly running is not the exercise you need, some find resistance helps, low weights and that sort of thing helping achieve a more sculpted look.
Also if you are female, the dreaded event can have a dramatic impact on those scales.2 -
1200 calories isn't nearly enough for a 20-year-old woman who's 5'5 and runs 5 miles almost every day. It's not even close to enough. And when you try to eat so much less than your body needs, your brain does everything it can think of to force you to eat more.
What you "think" 1/4 cup of something looks like when you're starving, hungry, or sated actually changes--by a lot. When you're underfed you forget things and overlook things and underestimate things, and you also wind up moving more sluggishly and cutting out more activity, often without even realizing it. Your brain's job is to keep you alive, and it doesn't really care what you think you look like in a bikini. It will lie to you all day long if it has to.
So, you know...stop fighting with it. Put your real, actual stats into MFP, and set a reasonable weight-loss target, like 1lb/week. Then weigh and measure all of your food and eat as much as you're supposed to. Eat more on days you move more. You can't beat your subconscious; you have to work with it.14 -
Cortisol and water weight. Not eating enough and stressing your system with exercise on top of it. No mystery.12
-
Why are you eating so little?17
-
I'm 5'5" and 135 (but not 20 lol). I find the water weight I retain from exercise at this weight is a lot more significant than when I was heavier (aka I had more fat). That said though, I would agree that it would seem you are probably drastically undereating if you are only eating 1200 (and you are sure you are eating 1200 because you are appropriately weighing and measuring your food intake) and doing that much exercise, you risk loss of muscle along with the fat that will eventually come off.
It would probably help if you opened up your diary for others to take a look. Often the answers are found in the logging.4 -
I would suggest a fancy scale that measures BMI, Fat percentage, water percentage and muscle percentage. That way you can see if it is muscle gain or water25
-
RuNaRoUnDaFiEld wrote: »Period weight gain?
nope, I don't have one (active pill) so that is definitely not the case0 -
VintageFeline wrote: »Not only losing muscle but heading for a hospital visit inducing collapse.
I expect not only are you retaining from the sudden increase in exercise but also from cortisol due to the amount of stress you're putting your body under.
oh wow, thank you so much...I had no idea I was eating so much under what I should be...4 -
cwolfman has a very good point. If your body is not used to the idea of doing so much exercise, it will take some time to settle down and to become happy with all you are expecting of it. Not eating back calories earned or part is adding stresses to your systems and may impeded your recovery from these runs. It is possible one rest day is insufficient for yourself.
I question how over weight you are because if you are close to a good weight for your height it is going to be more difficult to loose 1 or even 1/2 a lb a week. You are taller than myself and at less than my goal, (if this makes sense to you). I would be inclined to change my activity level from sedentary to active, and loss to half or one lb a week. Then out of interest, see what calorific level would enable you to maintain to achieve a good all round view, so you can define your actual goals.
Possibly running is not the exercise you need, some find resistance helps, low weights and that sort of thing helping achieve a more sculpted look.
Also if you are female, the dreaded event can have a dramatic impact on those scales.
thank you I used to be a ballet dancer, but I stopped recently, so maybe I will reincorporate some of those activities.0 -
FlyingMolly wrote: »1200 calories isn't nearly enough for a 20-year-old woman who's 5'5 and runs 5 miles almost every day. It's not even close to enough. And when you try to eat so much less than your body needs, your brain does everything it can think of to force you to eat more.
What you "think" 1/4 cup of something looks like when you're starving, hungry, or sated actually changes--by a lot. When you're underfed you forget things and overlook things and underestimate things, and you also wind up moving more sluggishly and cutting out more activity, often without even realizing it. Your brain's job is to keep you alive, and it doesn't really care what you think you look like in a bikini. It will lie to you all day long if it has to.
So, you know...stop fighting with it. Put your real, actual stats into MFP, and set a reasonable weight-loss target, like 1lb/week. Then weigh and measure all of your food and eat as much as you're supposed to. Eat more on days you move more. You can't beat your subconscious; you have to work with it.
thank you! I do put everything into a measuring cup before I eat it, especially with soups and what not, so I really am very exact on what I eat, but with that still in mind, I'll definitely take into account that this is too little...I just originally thought that I was basing it on the 1000 calorie deficit. Thank you4 -
TavistockToad wrote: »Why are you eating so little?
I didn't realize it wasn't enough! Even my nutritionist told me to stay around 1200 because we don't really realize how little we burn.1 -
gorditalindaz wrote: »I would suggest a fancy scale that measures BMI, Fat percentage, water percentage and muscle percentage. That way you can see if it is muscle gain or water
Those scales are hugely inaccurate for measuring BF%. Consumer Reports won't even test or make recommendations for them anymore due to being so wildly inaccurate.7
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 393 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 934 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions