Losing weight but not fat
estelle_baptiste
Posts: 7 Member
I’m trying to lose the fat around my stomach. I have weighed myself a couple of times and see that i am slowly losing weight, obviously I have my days when I overeat but I’ve noticed that even though I am losing weight I havent lost any fat from my stomach.
I don’t understand why I’m losing it from other places but not where I actually want.
Also I have a bad habit of wanting to snack. Not because I’m hungry, I just have the urge to nibble all the time. It’s especially bad at night time after dinner. I find myself wanting to nibble on snacks. But I never fancy fruit, I always crave crunchy snacks that I can just put in my mouth one after another.
I tried nuts but I can overeat on nuts really easily and have no filter and they also contain a lot of fat which doesn’t help. I know air-popped popcorn is a good healthy snack at night. But I’ve been told it is bad to eat carbs at night and you should eat protein.
But all the protein foods I see are high in calories or they contain lots of carbs, fat or sugar too. I’ve tried yoghurt but it’s not satisfying and when I eat it with granola, I end up eating way too much granola than is necessary.
Any suggestions on late night snacks. That are healthy and low in carbs, fat and sugar and calories. I’ve currently gave up meat for lent but open to the suggestions for after I have finished lent. Although I do not eat pork and I am not really a fan of beef.
Also are there any sports or workouts that help lose fat from your stomach. I have heard weight training helps but I wouldn’t know where to start and I’m a bit to embarrassed to do it on my own in the gym.
I don’t understand why I’m losing it from other places but not where I actually want.
Also I have a bad habit of wanting to snack. Not because I’m hungry, I just have the urge to nibble all the time. It’s especially bad at night time after dinner. I find myself wanting to nibble on snacks. But I never fancy fruit, I always crave crunchy snacks that I can just put in my mouth one after another.
I tried nuts but I can overeat on nuts really easily and have no filter and they also contain a lot of fat which doesn’t help. I know air-popped popcorn is a good healthy snack at night. But I’ve been told it is bad to eat carbs at night and you should eat protein.
But all the protein foods I see are high in calories or they contain lots of carbs, fat or sugar too. I’ve tried yoghurt but it’s not satisfying and when I eat it with granola, I end up eating way too much granola than is necessary.
Any suggestions on late night snacks. That are healthy and low in carbs, fat and sugar and calories. I’ve currently gave up meat for lent but open to the suggestions for after I have finished lent. Although I do not eat pork and I am not really a fan of beef.
Also are there any sports or workouts that help lose fat from your stomach. I have heard weight training helps but I wouldn’t know where to start and I’m a bit to embarrassed to do it on my own in the gym.
2
Replies
-
Fat usually is last to go from the stomach. As you continue to lose it will eventually come off that area too.
The main thing is not what you eat but having a calorie deficit. So eat whatever snacks you fancy as long as they fit into your allotted calories.
We can't spot reduce but weight training does help. I do all my strength training from home using dumb bells and youtube workouts such as Fitness Blender/Jessica Smith TV.2 -
It's all down to genetics, nothing you can do about it, low carb/low fat/low sugar won't really make any difference. You just have to keep going with your calorie deficit and consider starting some strength training, you don't need to do it at the gym, you can do some bodyweight exercises at home.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1161603/so-you-want-a-nice-stomach/p1
Also worth noting that all of this below is a load of woo, there is nothing wrong with fat (fat doesn't make you fat, too many calories do) there is nothing wrong with eating carbs at night (unless it causes you digestive issues that might stop you from sleeping) and popcorn is no more healthy than any other snack, it's just a low calorie snack. Eat foods you enjoy, ensure you get your minimum daily recommended amounts of Protein and Fat, moderate higher calorie, low nutrient foods and stick to your calories allowance.estelle_baptiste wrote: »I tried nuts but I can overeat on nuts really easily and have no filter and they also contain a lot of fat which doesn’t help. I know air-popped popcorn is a good healthy snack at night. But I’ve been told it is bad to eat carbs at night and you should eat protein.
But all the protein foods I see are high in calories or they contain lots of carbs, fat or sugar too. I’ve tried yoghurt but it’s not satisfying and when I eat it with granola, I end up eating way too much granola than is necessary.
10 -
You can't spot lose fat it will come off from all over the place we want it is usually the hardest to lose it from as that's usually where the most fat is located just keep at it
4 -
Rice cakes and a smidge peanut butter or jam. A nice crunch and sweet flavour for not many calories.
Popcorn as you say
plain cereal like bran flakes. not as calorific as granola
Have you tried Intermittent fasting where you stop eating at x time? That may help you combat the cravings.
I also have to fight the evening munchies as it can be so easy to sit and nibble on everything. Brushing my teeth helps.0 -
You can't spot lose fat it will come off from all over the place we want it is usually the hardest to lose it from as that's usually where the most fat is located just keep at it
^ This is absolutely true, but there are things you can do to tone the area and improve the appearance. If you're working on your stomach specifically, try crunches, planks, leg lifts, bicycle lifts, scissor kicks, etc. These are all things you can do from the comfort of your own bedroom - this is what I do to help with my belly fat. But ultimately, the above comments are correct, be consistent with your diet and don't give up!12 -
I have a theory.
Fat is a mean SOB. It know you are trying to get rid of it so, in a fit of spite, it figures out where you want to lose it (gut) and where you don't (boobs) and purposefully does the exact opposite. Guy want to lose your moobs? Last to go. Ladies, boobs go first so they look deflated and saggy. And the gut stays on as long as it possibly can.
Nothing you can do about it. But if you need the encouragement, then take measurements from all over you body. Calf, thigh, hips, waist, chest, neck, biceps, forearms and wrist are mine. Take them every couple of weeks just to see where you are in fact losing.9 -
My stomach was the very last place on my body that had visible fat loss. Even when I got to goal I wasn't completely happy with how it looked. I kept at it with resistance training and I finally got the results I want.
4 -
You can't choose where it comes and goes from. Some people find it comes off evenly while others find certain areas are difficult and are the last place it disappears from. Nothing you can do, just have to keep at it.0
-
You can't spot reduce, but you can spot strengthen. Stronger abdominal muscles may help the look. And even if they don't, I can give you two things that happened specifically to me. 1) Most of my TOM cramps and bloating have vanished and I seldom need medication to deal with the rest of it. 2) I was able to sit up unaided in the recovery room after surgery. The nurse in attendance complimented me on my trunk muscles. Also, I think my posture's improved.
Your body can't tell whether it's day or night, so eat what you want within your calories. (I personally find eating more protein helps me feel fuller longer, but that's more protein overall, not restricting my snacks to protein after a certain hour.) Similarly, eating higher fat isn't a problem if that makes you feel fuller, so long as you're within your calories. In other words, nothing wrong with nuts in moderation. As to HOW to eat them in moderation... pre-weighing and measuring helps. Try topping a salad or stirfry with an ounce of chopped nuts instead of eating them out of hand as a snack. Or, if you want to snack, figure out the calories before hand, weigh out that amount, and then put the container/bag away.
I've been strength training at home for a year. While a lot of exercises have a core-strengthening component—plus I rest on a stability ball between sets in addition to using the ball during the workout—my ab workout involves bicycle crunches, dead-bugs, deep abs ball transfers, and planks with knee bends. Still got a muffin top, but I'm also about 14 lbs overweight and about 24 lbs from goal. And, like you, the fat is leaving my stomach last. But it'll come. Meanwhile? I'm liking the looks of my arms, shoulders, and legs...3 -
Fat burning seems to follow a "Last on, First off" or "First on, Last off" pattern. If you gained fat first on your belly, it may be the last to burn off. Just keep at it. You may want to try a 'fat-burning' diet approach like keto or the 'slow carb diet". Personally, my goal is 70% calories good fats, 10% good carbs, 20% good protein. Works for me.2
-
Patience. Keep going.3
-
estelle_baptiste wrote: »I don’t understand why I’m losing it from other places but not where I actually want.
In my experience, the first place you put it on is the last place you take it off...
1 -
If only it worked that way!!
I started losing weight to get rid of my love handles and front pooch.....
15 lbs later, my boobs have shrunk, my face doesn't look as fat and I have less thigh fat, BUT I still have only lost a very little bit from my hips and stomach. I can see improvement and that keeps me motivated though!!
Keep eating at a deficit, be patient and don't give up!!!
**edit: my profile pic is what i'm trying to get back too, not me now2 -
There’s no telling which fat goes first, just stick with it!
You can help things along by doing more core exercises as that’ll help tone things up.1 -
It doesn't matter if you eat carbs or protein at night, just what you eat the whole day. Low cal snacks: crisp raw veggies and fruit, 0% Greek yogurt, jerky, low cal popcorn, Kay's naturals protein snacks...
You also can't spot reduce. Calorie deficit and strength training...4 -
You lose weight, that's great, but as mentioned before you can't choose where you lose it first. The best thing you can do is to keep on working on it and check what you eat.
Work all the muscle groups and don't fear to get bulky, women don't get bulky.
Good luck.0 -
We r in the same shoes...I found a solution which works well with me..it is to stop eating after 6 pm and try to sleep as early as u can to avoid any night bad eating habits4
-
0
-
Do you somehow think that willing the fat off a spot will cause your body to burn it from there?3
-
borrowingmoonlight wrote: »You can't spot lose fat it will come off from all over the place we want it is usually the hardest to lose it from as that's usually where the most fat is located just keep at it
^ This is absolutely true, but there are things you can do to tone the area and improve the appearance. If you're working on your stomach specifically, try crunches, planks, leg lifts, bicycle lifts, scissor kicks, etc. These are all things you can do from the comfort of your own bedroom - this is what I do to help with my belly fat. But ultimately, the above comments are correct, be consistent with your diet and don't give up!
None of those things will "help with your belly fat". Fat is inert and can't be exercised, and spot reduction is not possible. You can do ab exercises all day long and you may develop a bangin' set of ab muscles, but they won't be visible until you lose the fat covering them. That's done by calorie deficit (consuming less calories than you expend).
Your fat distribution patterns are determined by your genetics and there's no diet, exercise or supplement which will change that.7 -
borrowingmoonlight wrote: »You can't spot lose fat it will come off from all over the place we want it is usually the hardest to lose it from as that's usually where the most fat is located just keep at it
^ This is absolutely true, but there are things you can do to tone the area and improve the appearance. If you're working on your stomach specifically, try crunches, planks, leg lifts, bicycle lifts, scissor kicks, etc. These are all things you can do from the comfort of your own bedroom - this is what I do to help with my belly fat. But ultimately, the above comments are correct, be consistent with your diet and don't give up!
No offense, but I train my A S S off in the gym. 5-6 days a week a few hours per session. If I knew all it took was some scissor kicks to have a great stomach, I'd have it.14 -
estelle_baptiste wrote: »I’m trying to lose the fat around my stomach. I have weighed myself a couple of times and see that i am slowly losing weight, obviously I have my days when I overeat but I’ve noticed that even though I am losing weight I havent lost any fat from my stomach.
I don’t understand why I’m losing it from other places but not where I actually want.
Also I have a bad habit of wanting to snack. Not because I’m hungry, I just have the urge to nibble all the time. It’s especially bad at night time after dinner. I find myself wanting to nibble on snacks. But I never fancy fruit, I always crave crunchy snacks that I can just put in my mouth one after another.
I tried nuts but I can overeat on nuts really easily and have no filter and they also contain a lot of fat which doesn’t help. I know air-popped popcorn is a good healthy snack at night. But I’ve been told it is bad to eat carbs at night and you should eat protein.
But all the protein foods I see are high in calories or they contain lots of carbs, fat or sugar too. I’ve tried yoghurt but it’s not satisfying and when I eat it with granola, I end up eating way too much granola than is necessary.
Any suggestions on late night snacks. That are healthy and low in carbs, fat and sugar and calories. I’ve currently gave up meat for lent but open to the suggestions for after I have finished lent. Although I do not eat pork and I am not really a fan of beef.
Also are there any sports or workouts that help lose fat from your stomach. I have heard weight training helps but I wouldn’t know where to start and I’m a bit to embarrassed to do it on my own in the gym.
I buy 100 calorie microwave popcorn. They are mini bags so they are already portioned out and does the trick when I’m craving salty crunchy goodness.0 -
As everyone has already pointed out you can't spot reduce.... as for snacks If want something sweet I really like greek crunch yogurts, 130 cals. Angies Light Kettle Corn cals depend on how much I pour, and cheesesticks.0
-
Don't worry, it takes some time... when I started with the diet, I lost 20 lbs and nothing happened with my belly. Then, from one week to the other, I lost more then 3 inches. There's no linear connection with weight and girth (at least in my case): I drop weight and nothing happens, I'm in a plateau, my weight stays the same or even increases slightly but girth is shrinking... so just stay the course and you'll succeed in the end. Regarding snacks: a good alternative are vegetables like carrots, bell pepper, kohlrabi with a dip of sour cream with a little seasoning and herbs... believe me, I used to be not very keen on greenstuff but after I tried, it was quite tasty. Good luck on your journey!0
-
Don't worry, it takes some time... when I started with the diet, I lost 20 lbs and nothing happened with my belly. Then, from one week to the other, I lost more then 3 inches. There's no linear connection with weight and girth (at least in my case): I drop weight and nothing happens, I'm in a plateau, my weight stays the same or even increases slightly but girth is shrinking... so just stay the course and you'll succeed in the end.
This makes no sense.
But is exactly what happens to me as well.
I really don't get it.
1 -
Have you tried chewing gum to occupy your mouth? Or brushing your teeth ready for bed earlier in the night so that you then don’t fancy the taste of other foods? It sounds like your evening snacking is habitual so the best thing would be to try to break that munching habit so that you’re then only snacking when you’re actually hungry as opposed to mindlessness or boredom. Easier said than done, I know!2
-
Try beef or chicken broth. You can have a mug or two and still be at 50 calories max. Caution: check the sodium content, usually on the high side. If your blood pressure is under control maybe you can tolerate it for a couple of weeks or thereabouts...maybe...0
-
There’s no telling which fat goes first, just stick with it!
You can help things along by doing more core exercises as that’ll help tone things up.
Core exercises may help strengthen the muscles beneath the fat, but they'll do absolutely nothing to preferentially reduce the fat in that region. Spot reduction is not possible and there's no exercise, diet or supplement which will make it happen.0 -
I would love to lose fat on my thighs and calves. I really wished for it. Instead, my breasts got smaller (great) and my stomach got even flatter and now pants are still too tight on the legs and too wide at the top. It's genetics. You can't decide where you lose weight. Chances are though that it takes longest where you have most fat as your body sees that area as a priority in fat storage.2
-
Don't worry, it takes some time... when I started with the diet, I lost 20 lbs and nothing happened with my belly. Then, from one week to the other, I lost more then 3 inches. There's no linear connection with weight and girth (at least in my case): I drop weight and nothing happens, I'm in a plateau, my weight stays the same or even increases slightly but girth is shrinking... so just stay the course and you'll succeed in the end. Regarding snacks: a good alternative are vegetables like carrots, bell pepper, kohlrabi with a dip of sour cream with a little seasoning and herbs... believe me, I used to be not very keen on greenstuff but after I tried, it was quite tasty. Good luck on your journey!
You're the opposite of a whoosher? That's really fascinating
Maybe you're holding air in your cells, which then deflates all of a sudden 
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions