46 Yr. Old Guy / 1500 Calories / 15 Lbs fat loss 6 Weeks?
livelarge303
Posts: 5 Member
Ok... I think I'm on track but wanted to get some opinions. I did 45 days of P90X and got some amazing muscle gains on my upper body. I lost about 3.5" around the belly, but I need to lose another 6" in the next 45 days. Why? I'm in a competition with an old competitor/friend, and I'm not going to lose. It is a "1" measurement competition, measured by % loss around the belly button. He is winning as of now, but I bet on muscle gains to help me burn calories hard on the final stretch.
If I eat 1,500 calories, 600 Calories / Day exercises, and maintain 100-150g protein, less than 50g of fat and carbs, will this get to my goal and not sacrifice too much muscle? I can't afford to make a mistake.
JohnnyX
If I eat 1,500 calories, 600 Calories / Day exercises, and maintain 100-150g protein, less than 50g of fat and carbs, will this get to my goal and not sacrifice too much muscle? I can't afford to make a mistake.
JohnnyX
1
Replies
-
I would have investigated the odds before entering the competition, but anyway, 1% of your weight is the most you can expect to lose per week, if you're obese, and on point with calorie intake every day. 1500 calories is the lowest MFP will give a guy, and it's only suitable for the lean, short, sedentary and elderly. And your macro split makes me sad.10
-
Are you fairly active? I think 1500 calories is pretty low for a guy. i eat 1500-1700 a day and I'm a 5'2 female3
-
You don't say your current weight, but unless you are over 300 lbs, if you succeed in losing 15 lbs in 6 weeks you will for sure be losing muscle. Especially considering you probably already lost whatever water weight you had to lose in the first 6 weeks.
There is nothing realistic about the numbers you are throwing around. And there is no way to know where any weight you continue to lose will come from, it could come from everywhere except your stomach for the next 6 weeks.
Whether or not you "win" will come down to luck, as the body doesn't lose weight in any specific pattern, and weight loss/muscle gain doesn't happen in a straight line directly proportional to your effort. Whether or not you will sacrifice too much muscle depends mostly on your current weight, and eating only 1500 calories for 3 months while exercising doesn't help. Heck, I was 5'4 140 lb barely lightly active woman and I struggled to limit myself to 1500 cals when I was losing.6 -
Can't you just suck your gut in during the final measurement to gain another inch or two? .... seems impossible to fairly measure. I admire your grit though.6
-
Hmm... I'm currently 170lbs., 5'8". I've been on 1500-1650 cal/day for about 3 days and don't feel bad, but some less energy in the workouts. I'm spreading it out across 5 meals. Most of my activity is targeted at my p90X/P90X+ workout and lightly active. 0 Calorie vitamin waters getting me through the hunger times.
You make a good point, it seems like my stomach is not losing as expected, but I've definitely lost fat in in other areas. Maybe I just have to sacrifice the gains to get to my target and I can do a bulk up the month in July.
Tough decisions.0 -
livelarge303 wrote: »Hmm... I'm currently 170lbs., 5'8". I've been on 1500-1650 cal/day for about 3 days and don't feel bad, but some less energy in the workouts. I'm spreading it out across 5 meals. Most of my activity is targeted at my p90X/P90X+ workout and lightly active. 0 Calorie vitamin waters getting me through the hunger times.
You make a good point, it seems like my stomach is not losing as expected, but I've definitely lost fat in in other areas. Maybe I just have to sacrifice the gains to get to my target and I can do a bulk up the month in July.
Tough decisions.
How much muscle do you think you can gain in one month?6 -
Not as much as I would like, but I'm guessing about 4-5lbs/mo. I say this because I lost 3.5" in my belly and did not lose a single lb in 45 days. Actually, I went up 2-3 lbs. Also, my comparison picture show the gains on the upper body.0
-
Kommodevaran... I'll research what a macro split is, thanks for the heads up! Johnny0
-
It is difficult to gain appreciable muscle. Stressing your body to lose weight super fast and burn through some of your muscle mass is short sighted. And again, there would still be no guarantee that you would lose waist circumference in the process. What you are doing and planning to do is essentially a recipe for how to end up more overweight six months from now than you were when you started.
I would really suggest you get more educated on how weight loss and muscle building work before making any future bets.
Guys who work with professional trainers and dietitians and eat in a surplus are lucky if they gain 1 lb of muscle per week. A guy eating at a deficit doing a BB workout isn't gaining a lb of muscle per week. Body composition changes are long term endeavors, measuring them in the short term is inaccurate due to normal body fluctuations that have nothing to do with body comp. I love BB workouts, but I hate that they sell them by convincing people that normal short term, temporary fluctuations are actually long term gains and losses. Lose 7 lbs in your first week! Lose 10" in a month! It's all woo-woo leveraging off of all the weird water weight fluctuations and stress related hormone surges your body goes through when it is newly stressed and underfed.
You seem set on what you are doing, so best of luck. I hope it works out for you.7 -
Ok.. ran an IIFYM calculator on the aggressive setting. It is saying 2076 Calories, 147 protein, 219 Carbs, and 68 Fats. I'm guessing I need to up my calories and carbs from 50. Wonder why the carbs are so high on the macro tracking diet.1
-
livelarge303 wrote: »Ok.. ran an IIFYM calculator on the aggressive setting. It is saying 2076 Calories, 147 protein, 219 Carbs, and 68 Fats. I'm guessing I need to up my calories and carbs from 50. Wonder why the carbs are so high on the macro tracking diet.
50% isn't 'so high'?5 -
livelarge303 wrote: »Ok.. ran an IIFYM calculator on the aggressive setting. It is saying 2076 Calories, 147 protein, 219 Carbs, and 68 Fats. I'm guessing I need to up my calories and carbs from 50. Wonder why the carbs are so high on the macro tracking diet.
2000 calories sounds more reasonable at least.1 -
livelarge303 wrote: »Ok... I think I'm on track but wanted to get some opinions. I did 45 days of P90X and got some amazing muscle gains on my upper body. I lost about 3.5" around the belly, but I need to lose another 6" in the next 45 days. Why? I'm in a competition with an old competitor/friend, and I'm not going to lose. It is a "1" measurement competition, measured by % loss around the belly button. He is winning as of now, but I bet on muscle gains to help me burn calories hard on the final stretch.
If I eat 1,500 calories, 600 Calories / Day exercises, and maintain 100-150g protein, less than 50g of fat and carbs, will this get to my goal and not sacrifice too much muscle? I can't afford to make a mistake.
JohnnyX
If you can brave the storm? Why not for the next 44 days run a P90X Doubles routine?
Or, if you can wait, get your hands on P90X2 and really pump up the results?4 -
sounds to me you're under eating and over excercising.. it slows weight loss for me. i'd eat more..exercise less..and you'll lose faster... and that belly will go down.6
-
elisa123gal wrote: »sounds to me you're under eating and over excercising.. it slows weight loss for me. i'd eat more..exercise less..and you'll lose faster... and that belly will go down.
Except that's not how weight loss works.6 -
- Don't go under 100 carbs or you will screw with your thyroid.
- Make sure that you eat healthy fats (like grass fed butter) and ditch the fruit, sugar, diet drinks.
- Carbs should include things like sweet potatoes, butternut squash, pumpkin, beans...
- No nuts or grains AT ALL... that will definitely cause you to lose water weight.
- Research Resistant starch -- a type of starch that isn't fully broken down and absorbed, but rather turned into short-chain fatty acids by intestinal bacteria -- that helps your metabolism.
- Get on a good probiotic -- see www.gutsense.org If you are pooping multiple times a day that can haelp you be 5-10 lbs lighter due to water content and solid waste.
Good luck.18 -
- Don't go under 100 carbs or you will screw with your thyroid.
- Make sure that you eat healthy fats (like grass fed butter) and ditch the fruit, sugar, diet drinks.
- Carbs should include things like sweet potatoes, butternut squash, pumpkin, beans...
- No nuts or grains AT ALL... that will definitely cause you to lose water weight.
- Research Resistant starch -- a type of starch that isn't fully broken down and absorbed, but rather turned into short-chain fatty acids by intestinal bacteria -- that helps your metabolism.
- Get on a good probiotic -- see www.gutsense.org If you are pooping multiple times a day that can haelp you be 5-10 lbs lighter due to water content and solid waste.
Good luck.
You're back!
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
cyberberry wrote: »@TT: is that a good thing or a bad thing?
depends on how much you like using the woo button I guess3 -
livelarge303 wrote: »Not as much as I would like, but I'm guessing about 4-5lbs/mo. I say this because I lost 3.5" in my belly and did not lose a single lb in 45 days. Actually, I went up 2-3 lbs. Also, my comparison picture show the gains on the upper body.
I admire your optimism LL but assuming you are natty (not on steroids) , you can expect to gain a maximum of 2-3 pounds of muscle per month as a true beginner, 1-2 pounds of muscle per month as an intermediate, and 0-.5 of a pound per month as you get more advanced. And that would be if you are eating more than you use.
Water weight and fat will add a few more pounds, but it takes a lot of time to build lean muscle, even if you're doing everything right.
1 -
cyberberry wrote: »@TT: is that a good thing or a bad thing?
read their post, and then decide!!! :laugh:1 -
In no way am I an expert on nutrition and I don't want to give advice on calorie counting, but I would think a keto diet and maybe even combined with intermittent fasting, would get you to your goals MUCH faster. Try a one or two meal a day goal with macros in the 10% carb, 65% fat, 25% protein range. Be prepared to feel like crap for a couple days though.3
-
I would imagine low carb would be the most useful of this sort of contest. It has no fat loss advantage, but the lower carbs will result in lower water retention on average, so the diet will be a bit more deterministic in my view. However, I do think these sorts of contests encourage unhealthy weight loss which may reduce lean body mass.
Muscle burns more calories than fat, but you're not going to build enough muscle for that to be a factor imo.0 -
livelarge303 wrote: »Not as much as I would like, but I'm guessing about 4-5lbs/mo. I say this because I lost 3.5" in my belly and did not lose a single lb in 45 days. Actually, I went up 2-3 lbs. Also, my comparison picture show the gains on the upper body.
OP, are you taking steroids for those gains?
If not, this is a realistic expectation: https://bodyrecomposition.com/muscle-gain/muscle-gain-math.html/1 -
livelarge303 wrote: »Ok... I think I'm on track but wanted to get some opinions. I did 45 days of P90X and got some amazing muscle gains on my upper body. I lost about 3.5" around the belly, but I need to lose another 6" in the next 45 days. Why? I'm in a competition with an old competitor/friend, and I'm not going to lose. It is a "1" measurement competition, measured by % loss around the belly button. He is winning as of now, but I bet on muscle gains to help me burn calories hard on the final stretch.
If I eat 1,500 calories, 600 Calories / Day exercises, and maintain 100-150g protein, less than 50g of fat and carbs, will this get to my goal and not sacrifice too much muscle? I can't afford to make a mistake.
JohnnyX
Men generally lose fat around the belly LAST when in a deficit. So no matter how hard you try, you will probably experience the LEAST amount of fat loss from this area.
I don't see any realistic or healthy way in which you could try to gain muscle while losing weight and drop 6" of belly fat in 45 days. Just try to do it in a safe and healthy way and let the chips fall where they may!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions