Food for acid reflux?
Replies
-
stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »
Are you?
Just because you give smart a** comments doesn’t mean everyone does.
I was sicerely asking because it is not one of those cancers that’s covered as much. Steve Jobs’ death brought some light on it, but it’s not like googling breast cancer. My mother died of it. That’s why I’m interested in it. Alerting someone to be an advocate for their health is not hunting unicorns. I hope whatever has made you so cynical gets better.
Hunting unicorns is hunting unicorns.
I'm sorry about for your loss, but that doesn't change the fact that pancreatic cancer is a unicorn. Especially when compared with breast cancer.
Hunting unicorns makes great TV(Thanks House), but it's not advisable as a lifestyle choice.
I’ve never seen House.
I’m not going to stop encouraging people to be strong advocates for their health.
Again I’m sorry for whatever is troubling you.
I thought I was pretty clear. It's troubling that you're fearmongering. It's troubling that you're clouding the issue of reflux with a highly improbable distraction by bringing unicorns(pancreatic cancer) into the discussion.
Fearmongering is not advocating for health it's advocating for fear and paranoia.
It’s troubling that you don’t want others to take the best care of themselves they can.
4 -
Cutemesoon wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »PLEASE please please Anyone who suffers from chronic GERD Please get your PANCREAS checked for cancer.
It is a deadly cancer because it’s rarely noticed before it has spread to other organs. It most often presents as acid reflux first. Please. Insist on testing.
This is very true. This happened to someone I know.
I have a friend with pancreatic cancer...it wasn't so much that it presented as GERD but that it was diagnosed as such by the doctor because it was much more likely to be GERD than pancreatic cancer. They gave him some medication and it persisted so he went back a week later which is when they found the cancer.
The likelihood that someone suffering from GERD has pancreatic cancer is pretty low...and really, at that point if it is pancreatic cancer, it's far too late. That pain is one of the first physical symptoms, but by the time you have that pain, the cancer has been around awhile and has typically already spread to the liver and/or other organs.
In most cases, someone suffering from that pain who actually has pancreatic cancer will be dead in a matter of weeks...maybe a month or two tops. My friend has the kind that Steve Jobs had which is more rare and they give him 3-5 years, but it's incurable.
I do think this is all a bit scare monger...it's highly unlikely that someone with GERD has pancreatic cancer...not impossible, but really, really, really unlikely.
As to the OP...I used to get acid reflux all the time...really didn't seem to matter the foods. I think it was a combination of serving sizes that were too large and being overweight. The only time I ever get it since I've lost 40 Lbs is if I have a very large meal.3 -
@cwolfman13 don't be all reasonable now.
0 -
This is turning into a WebMd search...1
-
I guess I have a different level for labeling fear-mongering. If I’d said, “Oh my god you belched after eating! Start chemo now! You’re dying.” That would be fear mongering to me. This was just suggesting someone resquest an extra test to be on the safe side.1
-
HestiaMoon1 wrote: »I guess I have a different level for labeling fear-mongering. If I’d said, “Oh my god you belched after eating! Start chemo now! You’re dying.” That would be fear mongering to me. This was just suggesting someone resquest an extra test to be on the safe side.
Getting extra and unnecessary tests is what pushes up everyone's healthcare costs.
The Placebo effect is powerful as is the WebMD effect . Seeing cancer behind every door and pursuing cancer tests for every toothache and rumble in your gut is the exact definition of fearmongering. Encouraging people to suspect the improbable instead of the mundane is fearmongering. I choose to not live that way. Emotional and Mental health is part of whole wellness and advocating for your own health. Chasing waterfalls and rainbows and unicorns doesn't benefit anyone.3 -
stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »I guess I have a different level for labeling fear-mongering. If I’d said, “Oh my god you belched after eating! Start chemo now! You’re dying.” That would be fear mongering to me. This was just suggesting someone resquest an extra test to be on the safe side.
Getting extra and unnecessary tests is what pushes up everyone's healthcare costs.
The Placebo effect is powerful as is the WebMD effect . Seeing cancer behind every door and pursuing cancer tests for every toothache and rumble in your gut is the exact definition of fearmongering. Encouraging people to suspect the improbable instead of the mundane is fearmongering. I choose to not live that way. Emotional and Mental health is part of whole wellness and advocating for your own health. Chasing waterfalls and rainbows and unicorns doesn't benefit anyone.
I am sorry you are so anxious. I do hope your life gets better.5 -
HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »I guess I have a different level for labeling fear-mongering. If I’d said, “Oh my god you belched after eating! Start chemo now! You’re dying.” That would be fear mongering to me. This was just suggesting someone resquest an extra test to be on the safe side.
Getting extra and unnecessary tests is what pushes up everyone's healthcare costs.
The Placebo effect is powerful as is the WebMD effect . Seeing cancer behind every door and pursuing cancer tests for every toothache and rumble in your gut is the exact definition of fearmongering. Encouraging people to suspect the improbable instead of the mundane is fearmongering. I choose to not live that way. Emotional and Mental health is part of whole wellness and advocating for your own health. Chasing waterfalls and rainbows and unicorns doesn't benefit anyone.
I am sorry you are so anxious. I do hope your life gets better.
I'm not the one who sees cancer behind every door.
LOL
You're confused.
2 -
stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »I guess I have a different level for labeling fear-mongering. If I’d said, “Oh my god you belched after eating! Start chemo now! You’re dying.” That would be fear mongering to me. This was just suggesting someone resquest an extra test to be on the safe side.
Getting extra and unnecessary tests is what pushes up everyone's healthcare costs.
The Placebo effect is powerful as is the WebMD effect . Seeing cancer behind every door and pursuing cancer tests for every toothache and rumble in your gut is the exact definition of fearmongering. Encouraging people to suspect the improbable instead of the mundane is fearmongering. I choose to not live that way. Emotional and Mental health is part of whole wellness and advocating for your own health. Chasing waterfalls and rainbows and unicorns doesn't benefit anyone.
I am sorry you are so anxious. I do hope your life gets better.
I'm not the one who sees cancer behind every door.
LOL
You're confused.
You can project your worries onto me if that makes you feel better, but I’m not the one using the word “every.”
3 -
I had heartburn for a very short while. When I cut my evening snack the problem went away. So mess around with food timing and see if that helps.2
-
Apple cider vinegar helps my heartburn. I was on a daily dose of ranitidine (sp?) years ago, but started taking ACV. Now, I'm off all meds and only experience the heartburn MAYBE 2-3 times a year. I just take the ACV when I feel the burn, and it goes away within a few hours. I don't *think* I have changed my diet all too much, as I am a creature of habit, but there may be other factors that have supported this change as well.
Note: I am not a medical professional, this may be "woo," and I do not promote it over seeking medical advice 1 -
Apple cider vinegar helps my heartburn. I was on a daily dose of ranitidine (sp?) years ago, but started taking ACV. Now, I'm off all meds and only experience the heartburn MAYBE 2-3 times a year. I just take the ACV when I feel the burn, and it goes away within a few hours. I don't *think* I have changed my diet all too much, as I am a creature of habit, but there may be other factors that have supported this change as well.
Note: I am not a medical professional, this may be "woo," and I do not promote it over seeking medical advice
Nope. Woo is a claim that is universal or dogmatic.
Yours is an interesting anecdote clearly caveated with an implied YMMV0 -
I had reflux when I was fat - I had an upper endoscopy done. They prescribed some Rx stuff (can't remember what...I want to say Prilosec?) I never took it. I lost weight and the reflux went away. In that time during weight loss I tried to eat a light last meal, and no carbonated drinks in the afternoon or evening. That helped a lot.0
-
HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »
Are you?
Just because you give smart a** comments doesn’t mean everyone does.
I was sicerely asking because it is not one of those cancers that’s covered as much. Steve Jobs’ death brought some light on it, but it’s not like googling breast cancer. My mother died of it. That’s why I’m interested in it. Alerting someone to be an advocate for their health is not hunting unicorns. I hope whatever has made you so cynical gets better.
Hunting unicorns is hunting unicorns.
I'm sorry about for your loss, but that doesn't change the fact that pancreatic cancer is a unicorn. Especially when compared with breast cancer.
Hunting unicorns makes great TV(Thanks House), but it's not advisable as a lifestyle choice.
I’ve never seen House.
I’m not going to stop encouraging people to be strong advocates for their health.
Again I’m sorry for whatever is troubling you.
My husband has had GERD since he was a child, as has his mom and his uncle. None of them have ever had pancreatic cancer (although that scares anyone!!!). It's a genetic condition. I'm not sure there is any link between inherited GERD and acid reflux and this cancer.. husband has always been a very healthy weight up until recently he's only 10 lbs overweight or so. And his uncle and mom are in good shape.1 -
obi1cannoli wrote: »Does anyone here suffer from acid reflux, and if so, what do you eat? I'm a very picky eater as it is, and this is limiting my food options even more, so I'm at a loss as to what I can actually eat without making it worse.
For me, high fat meals are a trigger. I eat chocolate sparingly....not a bad thing. Lower acid (higher PH) apples are Fuji & gala. I'm fine with bananas (some people aren't). Oatmeal (which should be a good thing) gives me terrible heartburn. I love it, but I always pay. Eating before bed has to be something very light. Diet A&W root beer is so much better than Diet Coke.
There are books .....Dropping Acid is one. I've read it, but it still comes down to trial and error.0 -
I have chronic gastritis for going on 5 months and it is AWFUL. I completely avoid soft drinks, fast food, and anything fried. I also cut out 90% of processed foods. Basically fresh fruits and veggies, lean protein(chicken and ground turkey for me), as well as brown rice and quinoa. It can get boring, but it’s better than being in pain.
0 -
stanmann571 wrote: »Apple cider vinegar helps my heartburn. I was on a daily dose of ranitidine (sp?) years ago, but started taking ACV. Now, I'm off all meds and only experience the heartburn MAYBE 2-3 times a year. I just take the ACV when I feel the burn, and it goes away within a few hours. I don't *think* I have changed my diet all too much, as I am a creature of habit, but there may be other factors that have supported this change as well.
Note: I am not a medical professional, this may be "woo," and I do not promote it over seeking medical advice
Nope. Woo is a claim that is universal or dogmatic.
Yours is an interesting anecdote clearly caveated with an implied YMMV
Half the people on here use “woo” as a positive. Just thought you might like to know.0 -
You might want to try betaine HCL or try mineral drops with chloride to boost stomach acid production if your stomach acid is too weak.0
-
obi1cannoli wrote: »Does anyone here suffer from acid reflux, and if so, what do you eat? I'm a very picky eater as it is, and this is limiting my food options even more, so I'm at a loss as to what I can actually eat without making it worse.
I do, but mine is triggered by not eating enough, rather than by any given food. I had to stop intermittent fasting because of it.0 -
stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »PLEASE please please Anyone who suffers from chronic GERD Please get your PANCREAS checked for cancer.
It is a deadly cancer because it’s rarely noticed before it has spread to other organs. It most often presents as acid reflux first. Please. Insist on testing.
Unicorns, zebras or horses?
Zebra. If medication doesn't help within 30days, it's not going to hurt you to know you don't have cancer.
No, I am not an oncologist, but my bosses are (I work for a health system, but mostly for the cancer docs.) and it is a sign that people often ignore too long. It's also a sign of esophageal cancer.
For the poster who asked what if your family has always had it: My dad always had heart burn. His sister did too. He's had several polyps removed from his esophagus. She had liver cancer. Her son died of esophageal cancer. I can control mine by eating smaller meals more often, but next year, my doc will have me scoped because family history is a huge clue.1 -
stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »stanmann571 wrote: »HestiaMoon1 wrote: »
Are you?
Just because you give smart a** comments doesn’t mean everyone does.
I was sicerely asking because it is not one of those cancers that’s covered as much. Steve Jobs’ death brought some light on it, but it’s not like googling breast cancer. My mother died of it. That’s why I’m interested in it. Alerting someone to be an advocate for their health is not hunting unicorns. I hope whatever has made you so cynical gets better.
Hunting unicorns is hunting unicorns.
I'm sorry about for your loss, but that doesn't change the fact that pancreatic cancer is a unicorn. Especially when compared with breast cancer.
Hunting unicorns makes great TV(Thanks House), but it's not advisable as a lifestyle choice.
Pancreatic cancer is not a unicorn, unfortunately; it's a zebra. A deadly zebra because people check every other GI disease first.
Breast cancer is a horse, though. Actually, it's lots of different breeds of horses, and because so much money has been poured into research we can cure most of them with relative ease now. Even the dreaded triple negative breast cancer with no hormone receptors is more treatable than pancreatic cancer.2 -
barnettskylar15 wrote: »I have chronic gastritis for going on 5 months and it is AWFUL. I completely avoid soft drinks, fast food, and anything fried. I also cut out 90% of processed foods. Basically fresh fruits and veggies, lean protein(chicken and ground turkey for me), as well as brown rice and quinoa. It can get boring, but it’s better than being in pain.
I had the same. I spent about four months on a PPI until the gastritis cleared up, slowly weened myself off it, then another three months popping tums to combat the lingering reflux issues. Tomato-based foods and coffee were a big trigger for me. I couldn't give up the coffee, but I stopped drinking it on an empty stomach and I cut way back tomato-y things. I'm mostly back to normal now.
OP: I found that bananas and almonds were good snacks to soothe my stomach.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions