Not losing - don't know why
MsWax
Posts: 32 Member
So for the past month I've been tracking ALL my food, and eating what I consider to be pretty well. I'm certainly not perfect, but with all my hard work I'm only down 1.6 lbs! My diary is open if anyone wants to take a look and give suggestions. I'm open to them all (even if I choose not to follow them).
A few things to note:
A few things to note:
- I have desk job but usually do 3-6000 steps during the work day, even though I've input my lifestyle as sedentary.
- I changed my diary last week to include more detail, so the meals that food is listed under from before that aren't correct (but all the food is still there)
- I exercise multiple times/week and eat some or all of my exercise calories (depending on how hungry I am
- I've got a good 20lbs to lose, but would feel much better if I was even 10 lbs lighter.
1
Replies
-
4 weeks, 1.6 lbs. So your calorie deficit isn't as big as you think it is. Do you use a food scale to weigh everything?
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10634517/you-dont-use-a-food-scale
13 -
Likely culprits are:
* Calories creeping in with things like cooking oil, sauces, dips, drinks, etc. Be sure to log everything.
* Misjudging portions - especially with things like nuts, nut butters, and other high calorie foods. Do you have a food scale? I've got one for $20 off Amazon that's reasonably accurate.
* Using overestimations of calories burned during exercise - try not eating back your exercise calories.
On a more subtle note - how much water are you drinking daily? Biologically we need a sufficient amount of water to metabolize fat - whether that be dietary or body fat. The 8 glasses isn't really sufficient for our purposes - try to aim for an ounce for each pound of body weight, spread out throughout the day.50 -
If there is only 20 pounds or so to lose, you are pretty much right on track - or at least what you should be targeting.
That said, if you set a target for a quicker rate (which would be a mistake IMO), you probably have some logging errors or you just haven't analyzed results for a long enough time period.10 -
So with 20lbs to lose a good rate would be 0.5lb a week. In 4 weeks that should be 2lb and you're at 1.6lb so you're only 0.4lb shy. That could easily be hidden in natural weight fluctuations due to salt or water retention or time of month (if applicable). I'd give it a couple more weeks at least. Maybe use a weight trending app to help see past the fluctuations.16
-
Likely culprits are:
* Calories creeping in with things like cooking oil, sauces, dips, drinks, etc. Be sure to log everything.
* Misjudging portions - especially with things like nuts, nut butters, and other high calorie foods. Do you have a food scale? I've got one for $20 off Amazon that's reasonably accurate.
* Using overestimations of calories burned during exercise - try not eating back your exercise calories.
On a more subtle note - how much water are you drinking daily? Biologically we need a sufficient amount of water to metabolize fat - whether that be dietary or body fat. The 8 glasses isn't really sufficient for our purposes - try to aim for an ounce for each pound of body weight, spread out throughout the day.
you were doing good up until all the woo about water.36 -
Likely culprits are:
* Calories creeping in with things like cooking oil, sauces, dips, drinks, etc. Be sure to log everything.
* Misjudging portions - especially with things like nuts, nut butters, and other high calorie foods. Do you have a food scale? I've got one for $20 off Amazon that's reasonably accurate.
* Using overestimations of calories burned during exercise - try not eating back your exercise calories.
On a more subtle note - how much water are you drinking daily? Biologically we need a sufficient amount of water to metabolize fat - whether that be dietary or body fat. The 8 glasses isn't really sufficient for our purposes - try to aim for an ounce for each pound of body weight, spread out throughout the day.
I measure (but don't weigh) portions, only drink water or alcohol (don't judge) and that's pre-packaged, and I feel like the calories are close to accurate, and I usually don't eat them all. I drink between 100-150 oz of water daily, so no shortage there.
4 -
Silentpadna wrote: »If there is only 20 pounds or so to lose, you are pretty much right on track - or at least what you should be targeting.
That said, if you set a target for a quicker rate (which would be a mistake IMO), you probably have some logging errors or you just haven't analyzed results for a long enough time period.
If I netted my calorie goals spot on I should be losing 1lb/week, and I'm losing less than half that. The really frustrating part is I can usually lose more during the first week or 2 of being back "on-track," but this time around my body is fighting me every step of the way!
1 -
Likely culprits are:
* Calories creeping in with things like cooking oil, sauces, dips, drinks, etc. Be sure to log everything.
* Misjudging portions - especially with things like nuts, nut butters, and other high calorie foods. Do you have a food scale? I've got one for $20 off Amazon that's reasonably accurate.
* Using overestimations of calories burned during exercise - try not eating back your exercise calories.
On a more subtle note - how much water are you drinking daily? Biologically we need a sufficient amount of water to metabolize fat - whether that be dietary or body fat. The 8 glasses isn't really sufficient for our purposes - try to aim for an ounce for each pound of body weight, spread out throughout the day.
I measure (but don't weigh) portions, only drink water or alcohol (don't judge) and that's pre-packaged, and I feel like the calories are close to accurate, and I usually don't eat them all. I drink between 100-150 oz of water daily, so no shortage there.
This is where the problem is, I'd guess. Read the thread titled, "So you don't use a food scale?". Very enlightening. Also, I didn't see your diary open.19 -
Silentpadna wrote: »If there is only 20 pounds or so to lose, you are pretty much right on track - or at least what you should be targeting.
That said, if you set a target for a quicker rate (which would be a mistake IMO), you probably have some logging errors or you just haven't analyzed results for a long enough time period.
If I netted my calorie goals spot on I should be losing 1lb/week, and I'm losing less than half that. The really frustrating part is I can usually lose more during the first week or 2 of being back "on-track," but this time around my body is fighting me every step of the way!
If you should be losing a pound a week but are only hitting half of that, you're eating more than you think. Invest in a food scale and start weighing everything.13 -
Likely culprits are:
* Calories creeping in with things like cooking oil, sauces, dips, drinks, etc. Be sure to log everything.
* Misjudging portions - especially with things like nuts, nut butters, and other high calorie foods. Do you have a food scale? I've got one for $20 off Amazon that's reasonably accurate.
* Using overestimations of calories burned during exercise - try not eating back your exercise calories.
On a more subtle note - how much water are you drinking daily? Biologically we need a sufficient amount of water to metabolize fat - whether that be dietary or body fat. The 8 glasses isn't really sufficient for our purposes - try to aim for an ounce for each pound of body weight, spread out throughout the day.
While true about logging and weighing what's eaten - 3rd point ....
While there may be inaccuracy potential on some database exercises (low calorie burn items done for a long time - while accurate estimate probably, application by MFP causes problems actually) - there is 1 number that is absolutely wrong ....
Your suggestion of not counting them at all, meaning giving a value of 0 to the exercise.
Not a good idea.
Especially since it was explained Sedentary was selected, but by steps is above sedentary - so already underestimated there.
And the water aspect - where is this science that such a great quantity of water is needed to metabolize fat?8 -
Likely culprits are:
* Calories creeping in with things like cooking oil, sauces, dips, drinks, etc. Be sure to log everything.
* Misjudging portions - especially with things like nuts, nut butters, and other high calorie foods. Do you have a food scale? I've got one for $20 off Amazon that's reasonably accurate.
* Using overestimations of calories burned during exercise - try not eating back your exercise calories.
On a more subtle note - how much water are you drinking daily? Biologically we need a sufficient amount of water to metabolize fat - whether that be dietary or body fat. The 8 glasses isn't really sufficient for our purposes - try to aim for an ounce for each pound of body weight, spread out throughout the day.
I measure (but don't weigh) portions, only drink water or alcohol (don't judge) and that's pre-packaged, and I feel like the calories are close to accurate, and I usually don't eat them all. I drink between 100-150 oz of water daily, so no shortage there.
Start weighing. You'll be surprised at what you find.9 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »
I'll move it down here. Maybe then OP will check it out?8 -
Silentpadna wrote: »If there is only 20 pounds or so to lose, you are pretty much right on track - or at least what you should be targeting.
That said, if you set a target for a quicker rate (which would be a mistake IMO), you probably have some logging errors or you just haven't analyzed results for a long enough time period.
If I netted my calorie goals spot on I should be losing 1lb/week, and I'm losing less than half that. The really frustrating part is I can usually lose more during the first week or 2 of being back "on-track," but this time around my body is fighting me every step of the way!
Your body is going to fight it because if have only 20 lbs. to lose--1 lb. per week is agressive if you are already close to the goal weight. Some people on MFP say it takes them a year to lose that last 10-20 lbs.14 -
Silentpadna wrote: »If there is only 20 pounds or so to lose, you are pretty much right on track - or at least what you should be targeting.
That said, if you set a target for a quicker rate (which would be a mistake IMO), you probably have some logging errors or you just haven't analyzed results for a long enough time period.
If I netted my calorie goals spot on I should be losing 1lb/week, and I'm losing less than half that. The really frustrating part is I can usually lose more during the first week or 2 of being back "on-track," but this time around my body is fighting me every step of the way!
Your body doesn't "fight you". It behaves according to the laws of nature.
It also does a multitude of different things - all at varying rates. This makes it almost impossible to measure in the short term. You cannot weigh in identical conditions because of those variables. Being "on track" doesn't show up on the scale day to day or even week to week.
There is no such thing as being "spot on" with respect to calorie goals because we deal in estimates both on the intake side and the burn side of the energy balance. With the magnitude of fluctuations that most people have daily, even a 1lb/week goal can be easily hidden (or exaggerated) in a 4-6 week window.
I would again say that if you have 20 pounds to lose, even a pound a week might be too aggressive. In any case, you may have already lost a pound (of fat) per week over your short (so far) time window. It still seems to me that you have nothing to worry about. If your rate (after about 8 weeks using a trending scale app) isn't where you want it to be then look at tightening up logging or making an adjustment.8 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »quiksylver296 wrote: »
I'll move it down here. Maybe then OP will check it out?
In the meantime, check out quiksylver's link. Should be the first thing out of your drawer before every meal or meal prep.3 -
You said you eat all or most of your exercise calories. How are you measuring your calories burned during workouts?
If I were betting I’d say you are eating a little more than you think because you aren’t weighing, and also you’re likely eating back a little more than you e actually burned through workouts too. Most people I see who are successful eating exercise calories given through MFP recommend eating back only half because the site over estimates burns.8 -
One perhaps mistake I made - I started using a protein powder (Elevation by Millville - Whey Protein Chocolate Powder Blend) to get me more protein during the day to not get that peckish feeling while on a 1600 calorie diet. Before i started using it, every day / week I was losing weight. However the last two days since I started using that powder, while remaining on the same food intake pattern for other foodstuffs, i gained 4 lbs. Creatine seems to be doing that to me, since it makes the body retain water?
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC155510/
Maybe something you are eating in something as well?
(i know, anecdotal. But i will stop using this powder, and see after a week or so if the downward trend resumes. i guess that's why you want to log everything as precise as possible :-) )12 -
If you're not losing as you expect to lose AND you're not using a food scale, then you're almost certainly eating more than you think you're eating.
Depending on how you calculate your exercise calories, you may be overestimating how many calories you burned.
If this level of exercise is new for you, then you're likely retaining water as your muscles repair themselves.
The rate of weight loss you've seen so far is perfectly reasonable for your goals. With 20 pounds to lose, a 0.5 lb/week rate of loss is recommended, and that's close to what you've actually seen.11 -
Is the exercise new? My scale went up 7 pounds when I started weight lifting again. Took a few weeks to come off.
If applicable, are you at the point in your cycle when you are ovulating or premenstrual?
If neither of these applies, get a food scale - you are probably eating more than you think. Scales have the added benefit of being quicker than using measuring cups, and there's less to wash.3 -
I weigh I log daily and have since May 2016 but I quit losing months ago.. just stuck and in fact gained 5 pounds the past two months!! My menu choices have been the same for two years but something must have changed for sure as I totally quit my swift weight loss trajectory I WAS on. I keep at it but fear my Celebrex is the culprit. If I continue to gain I will stop taking it and just suffer the painful, debilitating arthritis as I will not be fatter again, so be it.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 388 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 910 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.2K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions