Not Sure I'm Doing The Calorie Intake Correctly
Narivsa
Posts: 19 Member
Hello Everyone,
I'm confused to exactly how much calories I should intake daily. As per My Fitness Pal it is saying 1200 while other sites say 1500.
I started with 220 Lbs (The highest I have ever been)
I started by cutting out what I love to eat which is Pastas and Potatoes. I started to eat healthier and I started to count my calories, which I think for starters I lost the 1st 24lbs because of this and some light exercise.
I am now down to 196lbs but it seems I have plateaued. I either stay the same 1-3 weeks or go up 1-3 lbs and then back down to 196 lbs. Now here's the thing, I have started to go to the gym and doing full body workouts for 45-60mins.
I am not sure since I have started to do more exercises if I should bring up my calorie intake or keep it at 1200. The only thing is, sometimes I find it even difficult to reach my 1200, cause I'm not hungry. I feel like I am doing something wrong.
If someone can please help me here I would greatly appreciate it. If you need more information, please feel free to ask.
Quick info about myself:
Height: 5'1
Current Weight 196lbs
Weight Goal: 130lbs (I am aiming 1st for 150lbs, but my main goal will be 130lbs)
Workouts: 3-5 Days full body workouts at gym and others brisk walking.
My main struggle is: Drink enough water and meet my calorie intake.
NOTE: I am doing 16:8 intermittent fasting
I'm confused to exactly how much calories I should intake daily. As per My Fitness Pal it is saying 1200 while other sites say 1500.
I started with 220 Lbs (The highest I have ever been)
I started by cutting out what I love to eat which is Pastas and Potatoes. I started to eat healthier and I started to count my calories, which I think for starters I lost the 1st 24lbs because of this and some light exercise.
I am now down to 196lbs but it seems I have plateaued. I either stay the same 1-3 weeks or go up 1-3 lbs and then back down to 196 lbs. Now here's the thing, I have started to go to the gym and doing full body workouts for 45-60mins.
I am not sure since I have started to do more exercises if I should bring up my calorie intake or keep it at 1200. The only thing is, sometimes I find it even difficult to reach my 1200, cause I'm not hungry. I feel like I am doing something wrong.
If someone can please help me here I would greatly appreciate it. If you need more information, please feel free to ask.
Quick info about myself:
Height: 5'1
Current Weight 196lbs
Weight Goal: 130lbs (I am aiming 1st for 150lbs, but my main goal will be 130lbs)
Workouts: 3-5 Days full body workouts at gym and others brisk walking.
My main struggle is: Drink enough water and meet my calorie intake.
NOTE: I am doing 16:8 intermittent fasting
2
Replies
-
What did you put as your 'rate of loss'?
edit: also there is nothing wrong with eating pasta and potatoes! Don't make losing weight harder by cutting out your favorite foods13 -
Go_Deskercise wrote: »What did you put as your 'rate of loss'?
edit: also there is nothing wrong with eating pasta and potatoes! Don't make losing weight harder by cutting out your favorite foods
Thank you for replying
I want to hold back a bit in eating those, until I lose a few more lbs hehe. Now regarding my "rate of loss" I put to lose 2lbs per week. Which at 1st I was loosing 1 - 1.5lbs a week and now 0, which is frustrating.1 -
2lbs per week is very aggressive and that is why MFP is giving you 1200 calories. This is the bare minimum that a female should be eating. I would adjust this to 1lb per week. Eat back 50-75% of your exercise calories.
Make sure you are logging accurately and consistently - I pre-log my food so I can adjust accordingly to make sure I am going to have enough calories for the rest of the day.
Lots of food entries are wrong in the database, so makes sure you double check.
Weighing your food is more accurate than tsp., tbsp., cups, etc... so it might help you to get a scale. Doesn't have to be long term, just until correct portion sizes are learned. Eyeballing portions can be VERY off!8 -
How are you measuring your food intake? Are you using a food scale?
How long have you been stalled? If you just started a new exercise routine, that can cause water retention that may be masking weight loss, also.4 -
I'm 5'1" and was 220 at my heaviest. I would have been chewing my arm off at 1200 calories.
How are you measuring how many calories you're consuming? Are using a digital food scale for solids? Are you measuring all liquids? Cooking oils? Beverages? Any cheat meals?
Accuracy and consistency are key to making this work.5 -
Thank you all for replying. OK lets see...
- I have a measuring scale at home for solid foods. For the most part I am using that.
- I also go by tbs, tbsp and cups
- For beverages I have been drinking plain water and sometimes (not very often) Clear Ice Sparkling Water.
- For cooking oils I use Coconut Oil or Olive Oil.
- No Cheat food yet. I've been strict about it.
- I will say I have been stuck for about 3 weeks around the same weight. (More or less around the same time I started to walk more/workout more)
- I have started a "new workout"...I started the gym sessions a week ago.
4 -
Thank you all for replying. OK lets see...
- I have a measuring scale at home for solid foods. For the most part I am using that.
- I also go by tbs, tbsp and cups
- For beverages I have been drinking plain water and sometimes (not very often) Clear Ice Sparkling Water.
- For cooking oils I use Coconut Oil or Olive Oil.
- No Cheat food yet. I've been strict about it.
- I will say I have been stuck for about 3 weeks around the same weight. (More or less around the same time I started to walk more/workout more)
- I have started a "new workout"...I started the gym sessions a week ago.
See the bolded. Can you make your food diary public and post a link so we can check for common logging errors?1 -
Just an FYI, you're not really supposed to heat olive oil to high temps so I wouldn't recommend actually frying anything in it. Be aware too (although you probably already are) that it has loads of calories. When I first started out I was pretty shocked when I first noticed that.
Anyway, I'll get out of the way now and let everyone else get to preaching the weird of Weigh Everything, it seems to be a favorite pass time here.
I started off at 220 as my wake up call for the heaviest I've ever been and I'm pretty close to your height. Plateauing was a huge frustration for me and led to my giving up a couple times so I definitely feel your pain. Best of luck to you and all I can advise is stick to it and follow the advice of the veterans here about your counting methods, if you're doing it accurately the weight will have to start coming off soon no matter how stubborn it's being.10 -
There is no possible way - ZERO - that you are not losing weight at 1500 cals, regardless of exercise. Your logging is off somewhere.17
-
And using measuring cups and spoons “for the most part,” which probably means Eye-balling other times isn’t the most accurate way to estimate calorie intake. Most of us have a really hard time Eye-balling accurately because our expectations of portions are so off by the huge servings everywhere.
A food scale is the the best way for solid foods, weighing everything before cooking. The scales have a “tare” function and you put one thing in, Press tare to reset to zero and add the next and “tare” and so in.
Here’s an example from a month or so ago about the importance of food scales. I bought a bag of frozen crinkle cut fries ( I love my potatoes, too!). When I brought them home, the serving size was something like 115 grams or about 22 fries. The pre-MFP me would have counted out the pieces and called it good. But the MFP me got out the food scale and put fries on it until I hit 115 grams (also made for a fun game of Jenga!). You know how many fries made up the serving? Six. SIX!!!!!! Six stinking fries (yes, I am still bitter about The Great Potato Deception of 2018). But if I had just counted, I would have eaten almost four servings when I thought I was eating one. Each of the fries was roughly the same size, so the labeling was off in that regard. The bag still had the approximate number of servings going by grams. Pieces? About two servings instead of nine.
Anyway, you’ll be largely horrified by how small the measured servings are (and be prepared to cry if you like peanut butter). But you will be pleasantly surprised sometimes, too. A serving of the black beans I like when weighed is more than the half cup measure. Cherish those times.10 -
I think it is most probably coz of your new work out . I have just introduced strength training in addition to cardio and my weight loss has stalled even though my eating habits haven't changed . My scale has not moved for last 10 days. Maybe it is coz of the water that body is storing.1
-
A couple of things could be at play here.
First, if you just started a new fitness routine, then that could temporarily mask any loss. Your muscles hold on to water to repair themselves. This should go away eventually.
Second, how carefully are you measuring your food? It's really, really easy to eat many more calories than you think. Even prepackaged foods can be inaccurate as to portion size. I suggest you get a food scale and weigh everything, at least until you feel like you have an excellent grasp of portion sizes. Also measure any liquid that has calories (milk, soda, etc.)2 -
There is no possible way - ZERO - that you are not losing weight at 1500 cals, regardless of exercise. Your logging is off somewhere.
I haven't tried the 1500. I was going by My Fitness Pal and doing 1200. Reason I asked since I started strength training and cardio workout if I should switch it to 1500. Then again I find it hard to even complete the 1200 many days I am off (lower) by 200-300 calories cause I'm not hungry. This could also be a problem I am not eating enough?I think it is most probably coz of your new work out . I have just introduced strength training in addition to cardio and my weight loss has stalled even though my eating habits haven't changed . My scale has not moved for last 10 days. Maybe it is coz of the water that body is storing.
Yes this could be a possibility too.DomesticKat wrote: »See the bolded. Can you make your food diary public and post a link so we can check for common logging errors?
Sure, I'll check out how to do this.2 -
There is no possible way - ZERO - that you are not losing weight at 1500 cals, regardless of exercise. Your logging is off somewhere.
I haven't tried the 1500. I was going by My Fitness Pal and doing 1200. Reason I asked since I started strength training and cardio workout if I should switch it to 1500. Then again I find it hard to even complete the 1200 many days I am off (lower) by 200-300 calories cause I'm not hungry. This could also be a problem I am not eating enough?I think it is most probably coz of your new work out . I have just introduced strength training in addition to cardio and my weight loss has stalled even though my eating habits haven't changed . My scale has not moved for last 10 days. Maybe it is coz of the water that body is storing.
Yes this could be a possibility too.DomesticKat wrote: »See the bolded. Can you make your food diary public and post a link so we can check for common logging errors?
Sure, I'll check out how to do this.
My Home > Settings > Diary Settings > Diary Sharing (at bottom). Set to public.0 -
-
You're eating more than you think. You don't appear to be really weighing any of your foods. Foods should be weighed in grams. Weigh the foods accurately and log the calories accurately. 1 medium piece of fruit could be any weight - you don't really know the calories unless you weigh it.7
-
musicfan68 wrote: »You're eating more than you think. You don't appear to be really weighing any of your foods. Foods should be weighed in grams. Weigh the foods accurately and log the calories accurately. 1 medium piece of fruit could be any weight - you don't really know the calories unless you weigh it.
OK, this is something I need to start doing (as in weighing exactly everything).6 -
Here's what jumps out just glancing over the last two weeks or so: I see several things not weighed, including calorie dense items like peanut butter and mayonnaise. I see some generic entries for items and also some "home made" items. If you make a recipe yourself, use the recipe builder instead of searching the database for a similar item. The database is user-generated, so you really have no way of knowing how their recipe really compares to yours and the calories will almost certainly be off. I see a few days missing any logging, so that indicates some consistently issues. I see some restaurant entries, so you should just assume those are calorie estimates since those can be off.
With consistency and accuracy, the weight would literally be falling off regardless of the exercise at 1200 calories. I just need to be honest. I lost consistently at 220 by eating about 600 calories more than you. Tighten up your logging for 4-6 weeks and see where you are.6 -
DomesticKat wrote: »Here's what jumps out just glancing over the last two weeks or so: I see several things not weighed, including calorie dense items like peanut butter and mayonnaise. I see some generic entries for items and also some "home made" items. If you make a recipe yourself, use the recipe builder instead of searching the database for a similar item. The database is user-generated, so you really have no way of knowing how their recipe really compares to yours and the calories will almost certainly be off. I see a few days missing any logging, so that indicates some consistently issues. I see some restaurant entries, so you should just assume those are calorie estimates since those can be off.
With consistency and accuracy, the weight would literally be falling off regardless of the exercise at 1200 calories. I just need to be honest. I lost consistently at 220 by eating about 600 calories more than you. Tighten up your logging for 4-6 weeks and see where you are.
Thank you for your advice, I will for sure work on it.5 -
I lose at 1200 cal but I’m 63 and 5’2”. I’m also at goal weight, so you must be off in your counting. When I started a new exercise regime I plateaued for 3 weeks. Also, be careful about allocating too many calories if you’re lifting weights. For cardio I only eat half the calories back that mfp gives me.0
-
Thank you everyone for replying and for advice. I have much to learn and you all have helped.2
-
You have a great attitude already. Problem solving with this is pretty easy. If you're not losing weight you are not in a caloric deficit.
Start here are read all the "stickied" threads. There's gold within:
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10300319/most-helpful-posts-general-health-fitness-and-diet-must-reads#latest1
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions