Weight not shifting?
xarra
Posts: 128 Member
I've been eating around my calorie goal (1200 for 1kg loss) every day - never more than the .5kg loss amount, been going for brisk walks to get fitter, and while there's been a few dips, I've lost nothing in 21 days. It's really disheartening that I don't appear to have lost even water weight (having swapped from coke zero to squash and drinking over 2l a day)
Any support? Because I'm feeling like throwing in the towel ATM...
Any support? Because I'm feeling like throwing in the towel ATM...
2
Replies
-
there is a fabulous infographic I've seen a few people post, hopefully someone who has it will jump on and add it. It's a lovely troubleshooting flow chart.
Generally the answer will be that you probably eat more than you think, and you should look at how accurately you measure your food.
Do you use a food scale?0 -
No - I go by what's on the packet generally... It's worked for me before, so I don't know why it isn't now! Even if I was eating slightly more, I would still be at a deficit...
And yes, I'm eating the exercise calories back...0 -
Ok, I found that I can buy a packet that says there are 220g in the pack, but when I weigh the contents it's actually more. So give that a try and see how it works out.0
-
No - I go by what's on the packet generally... It's worked for me before, so I don't know why it isn't now! Even if I was eating slightly more, I would still be at a deficit...
And yes, I'm eating the exercise calories back...
i would highly recommend weighing everything you eat.
how are you calculating your exercise cals?2 -
MapMyWalk for the exercise calories.
I'll look into getting a food scale, but I have done MFP before and it's worked just going off the packets...
0 -
How long have you been dieting? - Your body would normally adjust after a time, and weight loss would get progressively smaller.
I think a good solution for you would be to up your activity throughout the week (e.g. active dancing/aerobics/cardio in one day, something more strength-oriented in the next).
I have certainly seen improvement with increased physical activity: over time my calorie intake went up, but my weight stayed down.0 -
MapMyWalk for the exercise calories.
I'll look into getting a food scale, but I have done MFP before and it's worked just going off the packets...
but if its not working now, then you need to change something...
are you sure that your exercise calories aren't being overestimated using MapMyWalk3 -
MapMyWalk for the exercise calories.
I'll look into getting a food scale, but I have done MFP before and it's worked just going off the packets...
MyMapWalk seems to give dreadfully high estimates for walking. Your counts are very, very high for short durations.
Suggest you switch to using the formula for net calorie burn from walking.....
Bodyweight in pounds X 0.3 X miles walked.2 -
MapMyWalk for the exercise calories.
I'll look into getting a food scale, but I have done MFP before and it's worked just going off the packets...
I don't really understand that, unless you only eat ready meals, how could you just work off a packet? For example cereal if you portion that, how do you portion that? Or a bag of potatoes, how do you portion that, sure you don't eat the full bag in one go.
I would highly recommend the foodscale. Also wouldn't rely on apps to estimate calorie burn.3 -
are you including the calories in your squash? You may be drinking more calories than you are expecting1
-
sytchequeen wrote: »are you including the calories in your squash? You may be drinking more calories than you are expecting
yep, squash is probably more calories than coke zero.6 -
you only eat food in individually portioned packages? no fruit or veggies or even just meat? or things from larger containers like cereal?0
-
-
TavistockToad wrote: »sytchequeen wrote: »are you including the calories in your squash? You may be drinking more calories than you are expecting
yep, squash is probably more calories than coke zero.
It is more calories 200grams is around 45 to 50 cals raw.0 -
A scale is essential especially if you see you are not loosing much.
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10634517/you-dont-use-a-food-scale/p1
Honestly, i've gone thru this a few years ago and lost 100lbs. I have again lost 20 or so pounds since April and I STILL find I've miscalculated some things. Recently i realized I was not accurately weighting my chicken breast and salmon. And that my tiny bonus chocolate treat was actually 80 calories. I've maintained the loss as I wasn't eating my "exercise calories" back but as I am trying to eat those back to slow my loss to something healthier, I need to tighten up my logging.
Or I was using incorrect entries in MFP.
0 -
psychod787 wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »sytchequeen wrote: »are you including the calories in your squash? You may be drinking more calories than you are expecting
yep, squash is probably more calories than coke zero.
It is more calories 200grams is around 45 to 50 cals raw.
not that sort of squash... :laugh:
cordial? juice? the flavoured stuff you mix with water!3 -
Well there's not much to do other than to double-check what goes in, double-check what goes out, and acknowledge that sometimes it's not just math.
1. Start logging ridiculously accurate in what concerns intake (to the gram, everything weighed and measured).
2. Look more critically at your MMW calorie burn output. Compare it with the formula sijomial provided above. But honestly, this is of secondary importance to point 1 if your planned intake is as low as 1200 cals... lower than your BMR, you should lose basically sitting anyway.
3. Don't despair. Sometimes it takes a while. A big while. I always envy those who start off dropping a whooping amount in the first days. For me it doesn't work like that. Measuring everything with a food scale, on an aggressive 1,200 cal/day plan I have refused to scrap, I have lost zip between 4/01 and 3/02 this year. After that, everything started moving fast all of a sudden
Good luck!1 -
Weight loss is a long term project and requires constant adjusting. Try to keep an attitude of experimentation.
Seems like what the folks on your thread are gingerly trying to suggest is, you aren’t eating in a deficit. Likely our tendency to undercount intake and over count exercise. I could give you specifics, but I was making big under count errors when not weighing everything.
Plus all these calculators and gadgets give the impression that they a spit out the exactly right numbers. They don’t. The calculators are based on averages. The only way to get a specific calorie target is hooked up in a lab.
But the reason I’m posting is to suggest that if you’re just maintaining where you are, you only need some modest changes to get on a downward trajectory. Don’t fall into the pit of “it’s all wrong” weight loss despair. Get a scale and check some things. Maybe recalculate your walking.
If you’re in for the long term, really looking for a new lifestyle, the tinkering and tweaking never stops. Good luck.4 -
shift yourself..weight will automatically shift0
-
TavistockToad wrote: »psychod787 wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »sytchequeen wrote: »are you including the calories in your squash? You may be drinking more calories than you are expecting
yep, squash is probably more calories than coke zero.
It is more calories 200grams is around 45 to 50 cals raw.
not that sort of squash... :laugh:
cordial? juice? the flavoured stuff you mix with water!
Probably American and never heard of squash.
I'm American too, but have a few British friends so I've heard of it. At first I had no idea what they were talking about but then I realized it was like a version of Kool-Aid.0 -
@xarra
21 days is normal for a plateau. Also, if you happened to weigh yourself at the bottom end of your normal fluctuations, weight not dropping for well over a month can be very normal.
Food scales are important. So many food packages are off, sometimes rather substantially if it's a calorie dense food. The more dense in calories a food is, the more important it is to weigh it. Example: peanut butter, a small amount off - 100 calories easily. Spinach leaves - off by a lot, not as big of a deal, 10 calories. No need to spend $100's on a food scale, the $20 digital one is perfectly fine.
Why would you switch from a zero calorie drink, to a drink with calories? Other than the acidity on your teeth, there's nothing bad about having a few diet sodas.
Go to the success stories, read the stories from people that have lost a lot of weight. Everyone there has 2 things in common: patience, and never quitting. People that have lost 100, 200 (a few over 300lbs) measure the time it took in years! It takes a lot of time to lose weight. Also, never quitting. No matter how long a plateau was, having bad days, weeks, even bad months was never a reason to quit.
As long as you keep moving forward, you will get there. Be patient and give yourself time. You didn't gain the weight in a month, it's not coming off in a month.
0 -
You have a lot of convenience foods which have a lot of carbs/sugar. Your body may do better with whole foods, rather than pre-packaged items. I'm the same way. If it's a quick thing - I'll grab a protein bar but I want to try to get better about that.
Also, I truly agree about weighing EVERYTHING. You can't go by what the items say in MFP diary - even if you scan it in. Some people are not careful about their entries. And the weight could be wrong. For example, I love canned chicken and the can says there are 4 serving sizes for the whole thing. When in fact it's only 2.5 when you weigh it out! So it's less calories, which is a bonus but that isn't always the case. 2 -
Water weight constantly fluctuates; the initial water weight drop happens, well, just once.
You seem to be hung up on It's worked for me before, so I don't know why it isn't now! - let's try to explain. When you're heavier, you can lose easy and fast with little effort, because you have plenty of fat on your body. At a lower weight, with less fat, you can't lose as fast, and to keep losing, you have to be more vigilant so you still are in a calorie deficit. Hence the scale, so you stop the overestimating. If you eat back exercise calories too, you might be double-dipping, and switching from zero calorie drink to sugary(?) squash - presumably not accunted for - you're in reality triple- or quadruple-dipping calories.
Well that is an attitude you have to work on if weightloss is your goal.Any support? Because I'm feeling like throwing in the towel ATM...0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.5K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions