What to do after overeating
geiznekcm
Posts: 1,357 Member
Hello, All. I pray everyone is well!!
I am usually not one to expose myself like this nor resort to media to seek advice, but, nonetheless, here I am. Let me say now that I appreciate any genuine, realistic advice and knowledge from any of your personal experience you are willing to share. Please forgive me if I fail to be brief with my concerns (I am also not one to be concise!!).
Anyway,
I do not need to lose weight, but my goal is to not gain any -- specifically fat. I am disgusted and ashamed to admit that this week I overate -- I mean, I consumed at least twice my caloric needs on multiple days. Not that this makes it any less bad, but I overate very few processed foods; the bulk were whole foods. To no surprise, I feel not only physically gross, but emotionally and mentally. I really do not want to experience any "rebound" weight gain, but I feel as if I've set myself up for just that, and I am at a loss as to what to do now.
So, I suppose my question is if there is anything I could possibly do to mitigate or counteract all the overeating for the week to NOT gain any weight. What do you think the maximum "rebound" will be from my poor decisions? Do you recommend I fast at all, eat significantly less to try to compensate? What would likely happen if I just forgive myself, act as if my slate is clean, then pick up my usual routine tomorrow, without trying to compensate for overdoing it all this week?
Again, I apologize for being a burden. I ask anyone who reads all of this to please be kind in sharing any advice they have. I sincerely appreciate it.
God bless you All!!
I am usually not one to expose myself like this nor resort to media to seek advice, but, nonetheless, here I am. Let me say now that I appreciate any genuine, realistic advice and knowledge from any of your personal experience you are willing to share. Please forgive me if I fail to be brief with my concerns (I am also not one to be concise!!).
Anyway,
I do not need to lose weight, but my goal is to not gain any -- specifically fat. I am disgusted and ashamed to admit that this week I overate -- I mean, I consumed at least twice my caloric needs on multiple days. Not that this makes it any less bad, but I overate very few processed foods; the bulk were whole foods. To no surprise, I feel not only physically gross, but emotionally and mentally. I really do not want to experience any "rebound" weight gain, but I feel as if I've set myself up for just that, and I am at a loss as to what to do now.
So, I suppose my question is if there is anything I could possibly do to mitigate or counteract all the overeating for the week to NOT gain any weight. What do you think the maximum "rebound" will be from my poor decisions? Do you recommend I fast at all, eat significantly less to try to compensate? What would likely happen if I just forgive myself, act as if my slate is clean, then pick up my usual routine tomorrow, without trying to compensate for overdoing it all this week?
Again, I apologize for being a burden. I ask anyone who reads all of this to please be kind in sharing any advice they have. I sincerely appreciate it.
God bless you All!!
9
Replies
-
Honestly, go with forgiving yourself and picking up your usual routine tomorrow. Extremes such as fasting or eating significantly less may well backfire, setting you up for further overeating. In all likelihood, you may not be as hungry as normal the next day or two anyway, so if you end up eating a little less than normal, that's fine, just don't try to do it deliberately.
I would also avoid the scale for several days. There will be a scale weight spike, but most of it is going to be fluid retention, glycogen replenishment, and extra food in your system. It will be gone soon enough.19 -
Be kind to yourself. Crap like that happens, it's not the end of the world. Get up, dust yourself off and carry on with your normal regime.17
-
What they said ^^^
I had a shocking day on Saturday - and suffered a morning of self recrimination the day after. But I didn't do anything other than eat how I "normally should", and there is no harm done. It's difficult to forgive yourself sometimes, but punishing yourself will not fix anything.4 -
Nony_Mouse wrote: »Honestly, go with forgiving yourself and picking up your usual routine tomorrow. Extremes such as fasting or eating significantly less may well backfire, setting you up for further overeating. In all likelihood, you may not be as hungry as normal the next day or two anyway, so if you end up eating a little less than normal, that's fine, just don't try to do it deliberately.
I would also avoid the scale for several days. There will be a scale weight spike, but most of it is going to be fluid retention, glycogen replenishment, and extra food in your system. It will be gone soon enough.
This 100%
If your goal is to maintain weight you've got to accept that overeating happens occasionally. It's only if it is common when it could be a problem.
Remember 3500kcals is 1lb of fat. So unless you've consumed A LOT LOT extra calories, you've almost certainly not gain barely anything fat wise. I highly doubt that your daily weight stays exactly the same eat day and I easily get fluctuations of 1-2lbs daily, so chances are if you do see some movement on the scale, it's unlikely to be actual fat movement, more because of fluid retention/physically having more food in your body at the time.
5 -
What happened was not "gross" or "bad" and you have no reason at all to be ashamed. You just ate food. There is no morality attached to eating food. You have nothing to forgive yourself for.
Do you know why you felt the need to overeat? Anxious? Stressed? Sad? Over tired? Food can be comforting to the brain, everybody knows that and although its obviously not a healthy thing to rely on food-as-comfort in the long term, you'd be better off looking for the underlying issue rather than focusing on the symptom (overeating). Punishing yourself for eating "too much" is a small step on the rocky road to Eating Disorder Town.15 -
That was a lot of reading and I didn't do it, so I'm responding to the headline... If you overeat one day spread the difference over the next week or so and eat fewer calories (maybe 50-100 calories a day) for the week, or just workout more to burn it off faster. It happens when ppl are working on bettering themselves. Worst thing to do is stress out and get your cortisol level up over it. Once in a while is no big deal, it's easy to fix.10
-
What you need to do, is to stop thinking about "mitigating" overeating. Trying to fix overeating with undereating, sets you up for more overeating. Overeating happens occasionally, everybody overeats now and then, it's perfectly normal. We don't have to "think"; a pound of fat equals 3500 calories. But a pound of fat is easily hidden within normal weight fluctuations. It's consistent overeating over time that leads to weight gain, and guilt for eating sets you up for comfort eating, paradoxically. So you are not to forgive yourself, because you haven't done anything wrong, and there is no reason to "confess" what you have eaten. You are also to stop thinking of yourself as a burden. People reply or decline based on interest in the topic. And this is a topic that interests me greatly, I have struggled with bad relationship with food myself, and MFP has been a lifesaver; I hope you will find success too!
It's important that you stop dividing foods into good/bad, healthy/unhealthy, processed/clean (or whatever). A diet is more or less healthy, and you can eat anything in moderation, The key is moderation, and when you're relaxed and informed, and trusting yourself to decide what to eat, and what moderation is, in each individual situation, you can eat in moderation.17 -
People who naturally maintain a healthy weight without counting eat more on some days and less on others. I wouldn't think much of what you did last week. I'd just go on a deficit for several days.3
-
What to do after overeating?
Log it all honestly and completely, learn from it and move on.6 -
You'll be fine. Just get back to your 'normal'.1
-
Just go back to normal, you'll be fine. It's not like you're going to gain 10lbs in a week from overeating.0
-
Have to echo, forgive yourself and move on.0
-
Yup forgive, and move on. To add though, if this is a chronic problem for you, instead of beating yourself up, ask yourself why? Figuring out the root cause of why you overate can be helpful to reduce occurrences in the future. Were you stressed? Bored? Was the food just too tasty to step away from? Super hungry?
Stress or boredom- find something else you enjoy to channel your energy to.
Food too good?- If it's a trigger food (food you have a hard time moderating) Limit your access to it. Or serve yourself, and immediately put away leftovers so it's more inconvenient to go back for seconds.
Were you too hungry and inhaled your food? You may look into your calories and nutrition to get a handle on your appetite.
There are other things that can cause overeating of course, it's different for everyone. But the number one thing to do, is to accept it happened, and move on.1 -
I'll add to all the excellent responses you've got - Stop thinking of eating in terms of a morality play. There is no reason to feel gross or ashamed by eating too much once :huh: It's just food - it's fuel for your body and yummy as a bonus. I'm sure there are plenty of times you ate less than you needed without realizing it. This time you ate more. That's life. Fearing food or moralizing eating can easily lead to unhealthy habits and a disordered relationship with food.
If it happens often, look for the reasons why it happens and work on improving them. If it happens once in a blue moon, congrats! You're human!
6 -
I always go to the gym. when I am done there I feel great and forgive myself and forget it.8
-
I agree with the suggestion to forgive yourself and just move forward from here. I see a lot of emotionally charged words in your post and I worry that adding in fasts or very restrictive eating, is just punishment for doing "bad" things. This mindset can set you on years of hateful thinking towards yourself. We ALL need to learn self-forgiveness and self-compassion. Go with the forgiveness and work on improving your emotional well-being.1
-
You move on...a couple of days of overeating isn't going to make you gain weight (fat)...the human body is very adept at maintaining homeostasis...to override your body's ability to maintain homeostasis you must consistently be in a calorie surplus for an extended period of time or in a calorie deficit for an extended period of time. The human body is very good at utilizing excess energy in the short term.2
-
Grab a heating pad an try an do better the following day0
-
Lots of us here have behaviors and feelings to overcome. If you have a history of under-eating, then you might put on your analytical hat and think about where your concern is coming from.
[edited by MFP Mods]5 -
Move on. Nothing happened. Everyone, even the thinnest people, have days where they eat more than their usual. It's completely normal and nothing you need to feel gross about or even need to forgive yourself for. There's nothing to forgive.
Fixating on it will only make things worse, pushing you to restrict, which results in more frequent overeating. That's one cycle you don't want in your life. Don't act like it's a clean slate, just act like it's part of life, which it is.
You won't rebound to your weight unless you overeat consistently without catching it early. Don't focus on this one day, but if your weight starts creeping up over time, just re-lose the small bit you gained.3 -
Ugh,I feel you cuz I've had one of those days today where I just can't get full! Not craving anything in particular just have the munchies and I'll admit it's stressing me out a bit but I'll listen to the advice given to you2
-
Don't beat yourself up over it. Just don't do it again the following day.0
-
just workout, it's good for you and it'll ease your mind knowing you burnt those extra calories.4
-
I’m right there with you... I have been up and down the scale so much since starting on here and I really wish I would have listened to all this advice being given how to you. Keep calm and move on... no harm done. Life is balance and the more guilty we feel, the worse the whole situation can be.1
-
I don't worry about it, I'm not on a crash diet, if I go out and have a few beers and a massive curry once in a blue moon, the socializing will do me more good mentally than a weeks hard dieting will physically.
Just try not to let it happen too often. It's a lot easier to overeat by 2KKcal than to exercise it off or to diet it back1 -
Move on, but first log it! Logging isn't just for feeling good when we're on track, it's also for keeping us accountable when we're not!3
-
Accept it and move on. If I overeat one day there's nothing I can do to change it, so I don't let it get to me. Also, just like one day of eating at a deficit isn't going to magically make me achieve my goals, one day of overeating isn't going to ruin all my progress.1
-
jdubois5351 wrote: »Be kind to yourself. Crap like that happens, it's not the end of the world. Get up, dust yourself off and carry on with your normal regime.
I love how someone clicked WOO to this advice. Lol some people..3 -
Exercise. Even if it's just walking.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
I try to look at things as meal to meal now, as opposed to my diet starting on "Mondays" or the next day when I have overeaten. What I mean is that if I mess up, I get right back on the plan for my next meal, including sticking to any scheduled exercise. In the past, for example, if I were to mess up at lunch I would see the whole day as "ruined" anyway and would continue the feast until night and skip any scheduled workouts. Now if I do that I get back on track for dinner and will still go to the gym. I don't claw back calories though to make up for the overeating....I am just back on track on the next meal. This is one of the ways that I have done away with the all or nothing thinking. It's more of looking at weight loss over a longer time period instead of day to day. I think of how the calories burned on those workouts that I still go to even if I have messed up with my eating will add up over a year.3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions