Best way to burn fat?

Cardio or weight training?

Replies

  • sijomial
    sijomial Posts: 19,809 Member
    Are you looking to lose weight or looking to improve your body composition while maintaining at your current weight?

    Giving more information about yourself and your goals would be helpful rather than the false dichotomy of one type of exercise versus the other.
  • CarolF11
    CarolF11 Posts: 67 Member
    sijomial wrote: »
    Are you looking to lose weight or looking to improve your body composition while maintaining at your current weight?

    Giving more information about yourself and your goals would be helpful rather than the false dichotomy of one type of exercise versus the other.

    Im looking to lose weight and get toned. I’ve gained some weight the past few months so I’m also on a calorie deficit doing low carb(not keto)I’m 39yrs old and had two babies. My problem is my mid section/thighs. Endomorph i believe.
    I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio.
    Im 135lbs and 5’1
  • CarolF11
    CarolF11 Posts: 67 Member
    Why not do both?
    I’ve heard doing both each time at the gym isn’t the best. I’ve been watching a lot of YouTube videos on what is best to help burn fat and seems like it’s 50/50 so I’m confused
  • AnnPT77
    AnnPT77 Posts: 34,225 Member
    CarolF11 wrote: »
    sijomial wrote: »
    Are you looking to lose weight or looking to improve your body composition while maintaining at your current weight?

    Giving more information about yourself and your goals would be helpful rather than the false dichotomy of one type of exercise versus the other.

    Im looking to lose weight and get toned. I’ve gained some weight the past few months so I’m also on a calorie deficit doing low carb(not keto)I’m 39yrs old and had two babies. My problem is my mid section/thighs. Endomorph i believe.
    I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio.
    Im 135lbs and 5’1

    Losing weight requires a calorie deficit, and most people find that easier to accomplish mostly on the eating side of the equation. (It takes me a long time to burn 300 calories by exercising; not eating a Snickers candy bar, for about the same calorie benefit, takes no time at all. ;) ).

    "Toning" is kind of a vague term, without a standard definition. Most women seem to mean looking a little bit more fit or muscular, but not "bulky" (also a poorly-defined term). The good news is, most women would have to work like demons over a very long time, to get even a tiny bit "bulky". So, looking "toned" is really about creating some fit-looking muscles, and losing enough of the overlying fat layer that they become nicely visible.

    To do that most efficiently, strength training will help. Most people won't gain much muscle while in a calorie deficit, but people new to strength training can gain a little. But strength training will help us keep as much existing muscle as possible while losing fat (a very good thing, since muscle is slow/difficult to regain, especially for women). It will also increase strength, even before it increases muscle, by better recruiting and using existing muscle to do things. Strength is helpful in itself, in everyday life.

    This is a good thread to learn about strength training: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10332083/which-lifting-program-is-the-best-for-you

    Following a formal program (like the ones in that thread) is more effective than just doing random exercises at the gym.

    Cardiovascular exercise is good for your heart and overall health, so also worth doing. It also burns more calories than weight training, minute for minute, so can help you eat more and be happier while maintaining a calorie deficit. The best idea is to find an activity you enjoy, and do that. For most people, the highest total calorie burn comes from doing that activity at a continuous intensity you can sustain for the time you want to devote to it, without feeling exhausted for the rest of your day.

    How much you sweat has nothing to do with how much fat you're burning. (Neither does the so-called "fat burning zone".) Some people sweat a lot (I do). Some don't. If they both do the same amount of work, they burn pretty much the same number of calories, all other things being equal, sweat or no.

    I'd suggest doing both strength training and cardio, for best health, fitness, and appearance results. Most beginner strength programs are 3 times a week. If you don't want to do both strength and cardio on the same day, you can work up to alternate days. Most mainstream health authorities suggest a minimum of 150 minutess of moderate cardio weekly (or 75 minutes intense), plus a minimum of 2 days of strength training. That, too, could be a reasonable goal.

    Somatotypes (endomorph, ectomorph, whatever) have been pretty much debunked, by the way.

    Best wishes!
  • Running2Fit
    Running2Fit Posts: 702 Member
    I do both.

    Cardio (running) 3 days a week. Then 2 days of light cardio and strength training. I'm training for a half-marathon so cardio is my main focus but I'm also working on losing weight and want to maintain as much of my muscle as possible so I make sure to get my strength training days in too. You don't have to chose one or the other they both have a place in increasing your fitness in different ways.
  • MikePTY
    MikePTY Posts: 3,814 Member
    The only way to burn fat is to take less calories in that you are burning. Most of that comes down to the food you eat. Plenty of people burn fat with doing no exercise. However exercise can assist with weight loss, and is important for overall physical health.

    A lot of cardio vs. weight training comes down to which you like more. If you are more likely to keep up with one vs. the other, focus mostly on that. Doing at least a little bit of both is the best overall though.
  • CarolF11
    CarolF11 Posts: 67 Member
    I'm 5'1" and maintain in a range between 123-126. I started at 195 pounds almost 2 years ago after having my fifth baby, got to my goal weight maybe 6 months ago? I'd have to look at a calendar. I've been doing recomp since then. Following a well-structured strength program with progressive overload made the biggest difference for me while I was losing in order to maintain muscle while reducing fat. I do some cardio for cardiovascular health but it doesn't really have anything to do with maintaining or losing weight. Reducing body fat and maintaining/building muscle via strength training and doing it *consistently* has been a game changer. My midsection and thighs are no longer problem areas for me. This is a year between photos.

    3t3fmpl24cmu.jpg

    Wow! Congrats! I was 122 once upon a time
  • CarolF11
    CarolF11 Posts: 67 Member
    AnnPT77 wrote: »
    CarolF11 wrote: »
    sijomial wrote: »
    Are you looking to lose weight or looking to improve your body composition while maintaining at your current weight?

    Giving more information about yourself and your goals would be helpful rather than the false dichotomy of one type of exercise versus the other.

    Im looking to lose weight and get toned. I’ve gained some weight the past few months so I’m also on a calorie deficit doing low carb(not keto)I’m 39yrs old and had two babies. My problem is my mid section/thighs. Endomorph i believe.
    I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio.
    Im 135lbs and 5’1

    Losing weight requires a calorie deficit, and most people find that easier to accomplish mostly on the eating side of the equation. (It takes me a long time to burn 300 calories by exercising; not eating a Snickers candy bar, for about the same calorie benefit, takes no time at all. ;) ).

    "Toning" is kind of a vague term, without a standard definition. Most women seem to mean looking a little bit more fit or muscular, but not "bulky" (also a poorly-defined term). The good news is, most women would have to work like demons over a very long time, to get even a tiny bit "bulky". So, looking "toned" is really about creating some fit-looking muscles, and losing enough of the overlying fat layer that they become nicely visible.

    To do that most efficiently, strength training will help. Most people won't gain much muscle while in a calorie deficit, but people new to strength training can gain a little. But strength training will help us keep as much existing muscle as possible while losing fat (a very good thing, since muscle is slow/difficult to regain, especially for women). It will also increase strength, even before it increases muscle, by better recruiting and using existing muscle to do things. Strength is helpful in itself, in everyday life.

    This is a good thread to learn about strength training: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10332083/which-lifting-program-is-the-best-for-you

    Following a formal program (like the ones in that thread) is more effective than just doing random exercises at the gym.

    Cardiovascular exercise is good for your heart and overall health, so also worth doing. It also burns more calories than weight training, minute for minute, so can help you eat more and be happier while maintaining a calorie deficit. The best idea is to find an activity you enjoy, and do that. For most people, the highest total calorie burn comes from doing that activity at a continuous intensity you can sustain for the time you want to devote to it, without feeling exhausted for the rest of your day.

    How much you sweat has nothing to do with how much fat you're burning. (Neither does the so-called "fat burning zone".) Some people sweat a lot (I do). Some don't. If they both do the same amount of work, they burn pretty much the same number of calories, all other things being equal, sweat or no.

    I'd suggest doing both strength training and cardio, for best health, fitness, and appearance results. Most beginner strength programs are 3 times a week. If you don't want to do both strength and cardio on the same day, you can work up to alternate days. Most mainstream health authorities suggest a minimum of 150 minutess of moderate cardio weekly (or 75 minutes intense), plus a minimum of 2 days of strength training. That, too, could be a reasonable goal.

    Somatotypes (endomorph, ectomorph, whatever) have been pretty much debunked, by the way.

    Best wishes!

    I pretty much do eat healthy most of the time and I’m always in a calorie deficit. Three years ago I weighed 165 and went down to 122 doing low carb low fat. But I know with working out I need to add healthy carbs to my diet so I won’t feel weak. I started going to the gym last April but struggled cause I didn’t know exactly what to eat. I stopped in September and now I started again with a diet that gives me energy.

    I didn’t know about the sweat thing

    Yes I’ll continue to do both and add more time to cardio

    Thanks
  • CarolF11
    CarolF11 Posts: 67 Member
    I do both.

    Cardio (running) 3 days a week. Then 2 days of light cardio and strength training. I'm training for a half-marathon so cardio is my main focus but I'm also working on losing weight and want to maintain as much of my muscle as possible so I make sure to get my strength training days in too. You don't have to chose one or the other they both have a place in increasing your fitness in different ways.

    Thanks!
  • sijomial
    sijomial Posts: 19,809 Member
    CarolF11 wrote: »
    sijomial wrote: »
    Are you looking to lose weight or looking to improve your body composition while maintaining at your current weight?

    Giving more information about yourself and your goals would be helpful rather than the false dichotomy of one type of exercise versus the other.

    Im looking to lose weight and get toned. I’ve gained some weight the past few months so I’m also on a calorie deficit doing low carb(not keto)I’m 39yrs old and had two babies. My problem is my mid section/thighs. Endomorph i believe.
    I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio.
    Im 135lbs and 5’1

    "My problem is my mid section/thighs."
    You do realise you don't target fat in those areas by exercising those body parts I hope?

    "Endomorph i believe."
    No you are just a human being.

    "I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. "
    Why don't you train your whole body?

    "I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat"
    Sweating is an irrelevance. If you are moving you are burning calories. If you are living you are burning calories...
    I can burn more calories when I keep (relatively) cool during an long and intense indoor cycling because I'm not getting exhausted from overheating and go longer and harder.

    "but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio. "
    Neither is better - they are different. Cardio has much higher potential for big calorie burns and is great for fitness and cardiovascular health, weight training is obviously better for muscle growth/retention and strength but is a low calorie burner.

    To be honest your routine isn't going to achieve much in the way of calorie burns from just 30mins of cardio (ignoring that you should be eating back exercise calories anyway) and your strength training seems incredibly limited. You could train much more effectively than that.

    Have a real think about your fitness goals and design your workouts appropriately.

  • CarolF11
    CarolF11 Posts: 67 Member
    sijomial wrote: »
    CarolF11 wrote: »
    sijomial wrote: »
    Are you looking to lose weight or looking to improve your body composition while maintaining at your current weight?

    Giving more information about yourself and your goals would be helpful rather than the false dichotomy of one type of exercise versus the other.

    Im looking to lose weight and get toned. I’ve gained some weight the past few months so I’m also on a calorie deficit doing low carb(not keto)I’m 39yrs old and had two babies. My problem is my mid section/thighs. Endomorph i believe.
    I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio.
    Im 135lbs and 5’1

    "My problem is my mid section/thighs."
    You do realise you don't target fat in those areas by exercising those body parts I hope?

    "Endomorph i believe."
    No you are just a human being.

    "I go to the gym 4xweek and do both cardio 30 min and do hip/thigh exercises on machines. "
    Why don't you train your whole body?

    "I feel i don’t sweat easily and I like to cause makes me feel like I’m burning fat"
    Sweating is an irrelevance. If you are moving you are burning calories. If you are living you are burning calories...
    I can burn more calories when I keep (relatively) cool during an long and intense indoor cycling because I'm not getting exhausted from overheating and go longer and harder.

    "but I’ve also heard weight training is better than cardio. "
    Neither is better - they are different. Cardio has much higher potential for big calorie burns and is great for fitness and cardiovascular health, weight training is obviously better for muscle growth/retention and strength but is a low calorie burner.

    To be honest your routine isn't going to achieve much in the way of calorie burns from just 30mins of cardio (ignoring that you should be eating back exercise calories anyway) and your strength training seems incredibly limited. You could train much more effectively than that.

    Have a real think about your fitness goals and design your workouts appropriately.

    No. That’s why I’m here asking questions.

    Good to know I’m human. I was wondering about that

    I do arms about 2x week. I was doing abs but will start up again

    Yes I prefer exercising in a gym for that reason. It’s cooler indoors than being out in the sun. Just my preference

    Im understanding both is best. I’ll focus on both equally

    Im going to also add more time to both

    Thanks for all the tips
  • AnnPT77
    AnnPT77 Posts: 34,225 Member
    If you want to make steady progress on the strength training front, do a well-designed program, not some combination of "do abs", "do arms", etc.

    There are many sound options in this thread, including some bodyweight programs as well as weights/machines:

    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10332083/which-lifting-program-is-the-best-for-you

    One of those will give you a better return on your time investment.