Cocoa Powder vs Dark Chocolate
Replies
-
Well if you are not going to be serious I will assume that you are taking food "medicine" for no good reason. You have likely been on too many websites that talk about super foods and what this food can do for you. It is causing you to overthink eating.
Too many websites... Maybe but probably way less then the average bear. Super foods...negative on that. I can show you my diary from the last month to prove that one. Plain chicken is probably my only super food and whey protein. But I am engineer and I for sure over think somethings...very guilty on that one. If there is a readily available cheap food that I can try, I am all onboard. As far as asking a simple question and getting woo-ed I love it! Wished woo-ing had more protein. BTW...never liked chocolate a day in my life. But if I can throw cocoa powder in my protein shake and down it real quick I will try it. Haven't done it yet but there is always tomorrow. Oh I do have a herb garden and I love cooking. So I am a little geeky there. Don't forget to woo me.....pleaseeeeeeee!
I don't woo people.
You still didn't answer the question. What illness are you trying to cure with this cocoa powder you are adding to your shake? If none, get the nutrients you would get there somewhere more enjoyable.3 -
So you don't believe in superfoods, but you think it's worthwhile to put a nutritionally negligible amount of cocoa, which you dislike, in your coffee or shake.
OK. Thrive on.
Here's a woo-collection tip, since that seems to be what you crave, for some reason. Tick off some evangelist for some particular strongly-held point of view, and make sure it's someone persistent but neurotically, obsessively passive-aggressive. Pathetically, they'll find it a good use of their time to seek out and woo every single post you make, no matter how innocuous.
Good luck in your comp, sincerely.14 -
Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.3 -
anthocyanina wrote: »Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.
So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?8 -
anthocyanina wrote: »Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.
So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?
You and me, @NovusDies. But imagine all the money we're saving, eating that nasty cheap chocolate.
5 -
So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?
Heavens no! That's not what I meant at all. Hershey's makes candy, they're good at what they do. It is what it is, no judgement.
A 100% chocolate bar is most definitely not candy, as any kid who's ever taken a bite of baking chocolate can attest.
A little like comparing a frappuccino to black coffee or coffee with a splash of cream. They're both made with coffee, but are wildly different products.1 -
anthocyanina wrote: »Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.
So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?
anthocyanina not the one who made it a class thing. Just sayin'.
signed, former trailer park resident3 -
quiksylver296 wrote: »anthocyanina wrote: »Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.
So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?
You and me, @NovusDies. But imagine all the money we're saving, eating that nasty cheap chocolate.
I find the best way to enjoy a square of Hershey's is to smell it first and take in the subtle floral notes of the Hershey factory. Then place it gently on my tongue and let it melt slightly in my mouth before chewing it.
I like to have a few squares with my coffee on the weekends. I am not a big sweets eater and I like a classic.
With that said I do like the Lindt DC Sea Salt too. I have no idea what percentage it is because none of that means anything to me. I just care about taste.3 -
anthocyanina wrote: »So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?
Heavens no! That's not what I meant at all. Hershey's makes candy, they're good at what they do. It is what it is, no judgement.
A 100% chocolate bar is most definitely not candy, as any kid who's ever taken a bite of baking chocolate can attest.
A little like comparing a frappuccino to black coffee or coffee with a splash of cream. They're both made with coffee, but are wildly different products.
I was just giving you a hard time and trying to be slightly funny at the same time. It is kind of what I do.4 -
anthocyanina wrote: »Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.
I have tried the 90%+ eating chocolates, and man, I just can't do it. But then I don't like even really fresh, good quality coffee black (needs some cream!) so I guess it's just a flavor profile I'm not into
The 60-70% dark chocolate though does for me what the more serious stuff does for you - one or two squares with a cup of tea and I'm good. And then I have the M&Ms for when I need sweeter!
OP, the problem with chasing individual foods for their "benefits" is that nutritional studies are tough to pin down causality. You can't lock people in a lab for 5 years controlling every aspect of their diet so that you know the only real difference between group A and Group B is cocoa powder, or chia seeds, or blueberries. All it can tell you is that people who tend to have more of this food in their diet (assuming those people are accurately reporting their diet which is a big assumption) tend to have a lower risk of this or that. So your best bet is to enjoy a varied diet with lots of nutritious foods and don't sweat the small stuff.
And I think you might have misjudged the amount of powerlifters and bodybuilders around here present company excluded though - I'm neither. 6 -
anthocyanina wrote: »
Not trying to pile on, just an FYI which I found surprising... America's Test Kitchen likes Hershey's natural cocoa powder quite a bit...By far our favorite natural cocoa powder, this product had “mild” yet pleasant chocolate flavor that “tasted familiar.
(Droste was their overall favorite)
3 -
anthocyanina wrote: »Here's the difference nutritionally:
Cocoa powder has had the cocoa butter removed. As a result, the fat that remains is negligible.
100% pure chocolate has both cocoa butter & solids. It has substantially more fat than cocoa powder.
You want a bar made for eating, not baking. Montezuma's Absolute Black is a 100% chocolate bar, made with only cocoa solids, butter, and nibs (broken up bits of cocoa bean). Trader Joe's carries them and they're amazing.
If you appreciate really dark chocolate and black coffee, you might like it. Sugar and milk tends to mask the various flavors in chocolate (as well as in coffee). With low quality beans, you need that. Good beans need little to no embellishment.
I've found that when I crave chocolate, it takes only a square or two of good 90-100% chocolate to satisfy the craving, whereas with milk chocolate or even regular dark chocolate (~60% range) I have to eat a LOT more before the craving stops.
So am I white trash for liking Hershey's?
If white is the marshmallow and the brown paper trash is the graham cracker, then white trash me up.4 -
@NovusDies good to know! So hard to tell online sometimes.
@kimny72 You're right. It is a flavor profile thing. I love that you can taste differences depending on the varieties and where they were grown. I must have a fairly high tolerance for bitter flavors
@Kalex1975 actually I really like Hershey's cocoa powder, Gharadelli's too. Interestingly enough, I can't stand either of their chocolate bars.2 -
Enjoy the powdered cocoa.
In your honor I'm putting 2g in my black coffee. And 1g of cinnamon.
You worry about your macros and let poor @quiksylver296 muddle through with her stupid calories and ice cream. It makes you a better man, right?
<sorry @quiksylver296, couldn't resist that last one since you're no longer turning your back to us!>8 -
Thanks, @PAV8888. The funny thing is, I hit my macros pretty consistently. With ice cream and without cocoa powder.6
-
quiksylver296 wrote: »Thanks, @PAV8888. The funny thing is, I hit my macros pretty consistently. With ice cream and without cocoa powder.
Hitting macros or not you're strong as all get out @quiksylver296 I always get a kick out of seeing the gains you post, all while eating what you enjoy. Awesome. Keep it up.4 -
4
-
There was quite a bit of "honest to goodness informative dialogue" before that. You, however, dismissed a lot of it.BTW...never liked chocolate a day in my life. But if I can throw cocoa powder in my protein shake and down it real quick I will try it. Haven't done it yet but there is always tomorrow.
Why would you do this? It seems like a waste of calories vs. adding something to the protein shake you will enjoy (assuming you don't like it when you do try it). What amazing effect do you think cocoa powder will have?
(For the record, I use it in cooking from time to time but not in smoothies other than one time when it happened to go with my ingredients. I usually choose ingredients that would not go well with chocolate in my smoothies, IMO, and I want tasty (in addition to healthy) smoothies. Obviously YMMV, but I'm just trying to understand what you believe you are accomplishing.)
Thanks lemurcat and jgnatca....Finally an honest to goodness informative dialogue. I am going to try adding cocoa powder to my coffee. I realized that I shouldn't be asking questions on MFP. I am a powerlifter trying to lose weight for competition. I have to make every macro calorie count while being in a calorie deficit. Most of MFP have different goals than I, which is awesome! But don't be a smart a$? about it. I will use MFP for tracking calories and macros...and try to stay away from chats. Just want to see how many more woo's I can get then leaving this community. Again thank you!
4
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions