mini meals or 3 square meals??

jslmom1
jslmom1 Posts: 21 Member
edited October 1 in Health and Weight Loss
Just wondering if I could get some input on what works best for all the MFP buddies out there. Let me know what works better for you- do you prefer "snacking" all day with 5-6 mini meals or does 3 square meals a day and maybe 1 snack work better for you?

Replies

  • I personally feel that it doesn't matter - 1200 calories is 1200 calories.
    Therefore, I usually go with what works best for me (4 medium meals usually!)
    However, I have often heard that it is "healthier" to eat 5-6 smaller meals per day...
  • smitchell37
    smitchell37 Posts: 121 Member
    I have to do 5-6 small meals. That way I feel full all day and Im not looking for everything and anything to eat
  • Kelly_Wilson1990
    Kelly_Wilson1990 Posts: 3,245 Member
    I do six small meals a day. It seams to keep me from over snacking.
  • getsveltEagain
    getsveltEagain Posts: 1,063 Member
    I was eating 3 meals a day with little snacking since January. But then a month or two ago I started getting a quesy stomach every 2 - 3 hours. My body is telling me to eat the 5 - 6 small meals through the day. I am working on getting this right since for lunch I tend to still eat a "meal" that I shouldn't. No matter the size of the lunch I am hungry two hours later :grumble:
  • mikegohl
    mikegohl Posts: 68 Member
    Everyone is different. I have to eat between meals or I would die!
  • jennieodwyer
    jennieodwyer Posts: 1,036 Member
    Unless I am crazy busy, I like to have more frequent smaller meals. I like to graze :smile:
  • SophRW
    SophRW Posts: 93 Member
    I find it easier to eat 3 solid meals per day. Planning 6 mini meals takes forever, and I find myself obsessing over MFP too much when I'm eating all the time!
  • WifeMomDVM
    WifeMomDVM Posts: 1,025 Member
    Some days I eat 3 larger meals, somedays I eat 4-6 smaller meals and/or snacks. It just depends on the day and how I feel. In general though, I prefer or try to eat 4-6 smaller meals rather than 3 larger ones, but sometimes it just doesn't work out!
  • mamashatzie
    mamashatzie Posts: 238 Member
    I just eat when I'm hungry. I have a smoothie when I leave for work in the morning (8am) and then I'm usually hungry and have a snack around 10am. I have lunch around 1pm and, if I'm hungry, I'll have a snack around 4. Dinner between 5:30-6 and then a glass of milk and a small snack if I need it around 9pm.

    I plan my meals and try to leave plenty of room for snacks if I need them.
  • AlsDonkBoxSquat
    AlsDonkBoxSquat Posts: 6,128 Member
    I mini meal, it's just my preference.
  • I really think it's a personally preference thing. For me, I found that eating 3 meals (not huge) a day with smaller snacks worked best. I wasn't hungry all the time. I'm so used to 3 meals, that I could never get the 5-6 small meals plan to work.
  • Nomomush
    Nomomush Posts: 582 Member
    I eat 6x a day. It works for me because I don't like feeling hungry with the big gaps of time with only 3 meals a day.
  • jemko
    jemko Posts: 91 Member
    I do 3 meals and 3 small snacks. Not because of any 'myth' or anything, but just because I'd be starving if I didn't, and I'm hypoglycemic and this helps to prevent my blood sugar from dropping and making me ill. I think it's all up to the individual and what works best for them. :)
  • shellyrulz
    shellyrulz Posts: 148 Member
    I usually eat 3 meals a day and have a protein and a fruit or veggie as a snack 2 times a day. It helps me not eat after 7:00 at night.
  • jfinnivan
    jfinnivan Posts: 360 Member
    I eat something every few hours. Only because I like to eat...
  • Nomomush
    Nomomush Posts: 582 Member
    I personally feel that it doesn't matter - 1200 calories is 1200 calories.
    Therefore, I usually go with what works best for me (4 medium meals usually!)
    However, I have often heard that it is "healthier" to eat 5-6 smaller meals per day...

    I would have to disagree that 1200 calories is 1200 calories. All calories is NOT created equal. How your body metabolizes and breaks down all those calories is very important. too.

    However, I do agree with eating schedule that works for each person. My trainer and dietitian have guided me to 6 meals a day to keep my metabolism fired up.
  • Sheeshy
    Sheeshy Posts: 133
    I do 3 meals and maybe one snack. I've tried small meals throughout the day, and I feel like I'm just constantly eating, never satisfied. I like to eat a nice meal, feel full, and brush my teeth :). I think it's whatever works best for your body.
  • sandislim
    sandislim Posts: 264
    It doesn't matter which way you do it. Science has proven it doesn't have much effect on your metabolism - but for some people its better to space meals out especially those with insulin resistance. So it just depends on what works for you.

    If you like to eat often and hate feeling hungry but not mind not feeling full up - have lots of smaller meals.

    If you don't like eating often or your too busy and you don't mind going hungry for a short time and like bigger meals - have bigger meals less often.

    Its what works for you that counts. Don't struggle to do what other people do just because they say its better. It might be better for them - but you need to work out whats best for you.
  • I eat three small meals and 2-3 snacks a day. I've tried just three bigger meals but I just get hungry in-between and find myself snacking anyway!
  • silvergurl518
    silvergurl518 Posts: 4,123 Member
    i like a good bfast and a good lunch. dinner i can do with our without, depending on the day. and i'm definitely a snacker so i don't get cranky when my blood sugar dives. do what works for you!!! :)
  • rileysowner
    rileysowner Posts: 8,331 Member
    Three large meals with an evening snack if I have the calories left. I fit those meals in between 12 or 1PM to about 8 or 9PM, sometimes later. I tried the many small meals, and was hungry all the time. Then I did some research on meal frequency and weight loss and found meal frequency made no difference.
  • Michelle_M2002
    Michelle_M2002 Posts: 301 Member
    Different people have different needs. For ME.. my need is to eat about every 3 hours. So I have 4-5 smaller meals throughout the day.

    When I don't have small well balanced snacks between meals, I get hungry, shaky and irritable. Because for ME, it causes my blood sugar to dip. Then I'm fighting off carb cravings and I'm also hungrier so am more likely to over eat.

    When I eat every 3 hours or so... my blood sugar stays stable, I don't have carb cravings, and I'm eating right about the time I'm just STARTING to get hungry, so it takes less to satisfy me.

    A typical day for me:

    9am, breakfast: 2 to 3 units of protein, 1 unit of carb
    12pm, lunch: 4 units of protein, 1 unit of carb, 2 units of healthy fat
    3pm, snack: 2 units of protein, 1 unit of carb
    6pm, dinner: 5 units of protein, 1 unit of carb, 2 units of healthy fat
    Evening snack (time varies): this is usually a "treat" that fits into my calorie plan for the day, but I still try to keep it balanced.

    Note: 1 unit of protein = 1 oz of meat, fish, or poultry, 1/2 oz of nuts, 1 tablespoon of nut butter, 1 egg, 2oz greek yogurt
    1 carb = 1 piece of fruit, 1 piece of swg bread, 1/2 swg bagel, 1 cup of vegetables, 1 cup of berries, 1 cup whole fat milk, 2oz regular yogurt
    1 healthy fat = 1 oz of cheese from grass fed beef, 1 tsp butter from grass fed beef, 1tsp olive oil or coconut oil

    That is the type of meal plan that works for me. And also, that is an "average" day for me. Some days I need a bit more, some days a bit less. Some days I need an extra serving of carbs, while other days I need a bit extra protein.

    Also very important ESPECIALLY for women, any time you have sugar, you need to temper it with a decent amount of healthy fat. So for instance, if you put sugar in your coffee... you should put full fat milk, half and half, or cream in your coffee to slow the sugar absorption so you don't cause your blood sugar to go up and start the cycle of the blood sugar roller coaster.

    Again.. I realize that not everything works for everyone. My nutrition is based off of the Diet Solution Program for protein types who need 1600 calories a day, and it's what works for ME.

    God bless!
  • jslmom1
    jslmom1 Posts: 21 Member
    Different people have different needs. For ME.. my need is to eat about every 3 hours. So I have 4-5 smaller meals throughout the day.

    When I don't have small well balanced snacks between meals, I get hungry, shaky and irritable. Because for ME, it causes my blood sugar to dip. Then I'm fighting off carb cravings and I'm also hungrier so am more likely to over eat.

    When I eat every 3 hours or so... my blood sugar stays stable, I don't have carb cravings, and I'm eating right about the time I'm just STARTING to get hungry, so it takes less to satisfy me.

    A typical day for me:

    9am, breakfast: 2 to 3 units of protein, 1 unit of carb
    12pm, lunch: 4 units of protein, 1 unit of carb, 2 units of healthy fat
    3pm, snack: 2 units of protein, 1 unit of carb
    6pm, dinner: 5 units of protein, 1 unit of carb, 2 units of healthy fat
    Evening snack (time varies): this is usually a "treat" that fits into my calorie plan for the day, but I still try to keep it balanced.

    Note: 1 unit of protein = 1 oz of meat, fish, or poultry, 1/2 oz of nuts, 1 tablespoon of nut butter, 1 egg, 2oz greek yogurt
    1 carb = 1 piece of fruit, 1 piece of swg bread, 1/2 swg bagel, 1 cup of vegetables, 1 cup of berries, 1 cup whole fat milk, 2oz regular yogurt
    1 healthy fat = 1 oz of cheese from grass fed beef, 1 tsp butter from grass fed beef, 1tsp olive oil or coconut oil

    That is the type of meal plan that works for me. And also, that is an "average" day for me. Some days I need a bit more, some days a bit less. Some days I need an extra serving of carbs, while other days I need a bit extra protein.

    Also very important ESPECIALLY for women, any time you have sugar, you need to temper it with a decent amount of healthy fat. So for instance, if you put sugar in your coffee... you should put full fat milk, half and half, or cream in your coffee to slow the sugar absorption so you don't cause your blood sugar to go up and start the cycle of the blood sugar roller coaster.

    Again.. I realize that not everything works for everyone. My nutrition is based off of the Diet Solution Program for protein types who need 1600 calories a day, and it's what works for ME.

    God bless!
  • jslmom1
    jslmom1 Posts: 21 Member
    Thank you...just what I was looking for
  • bcattoes
    bcattoes Posts: 17,299 Member
    I snack all day, then have one "meal" in the evening. I may have 3 snacks or I may have 5 or even more. Basically, I start the day with a cup of soy milk and then just grab something when I'm hungry. I nearly always eat something at noon when I'm at work because that's my lunch time. My diary is open if you want to look. With this I had a 1 lb a week weight loss for about the first 20 lbs then about half that (.5 a week) for the next 6. Now I'm losing at a slightly lower pace (1-2 a month). I met my goal which wasn't really weight related, so now I'm just sticking with this plan that is working for me and I figure I'll stop losing when I'm at my ideal weight.
  • I graze. Works best for me......
  • PantalaNagaPampa
    PantalaNagaPampa Posts: 1,031 Member
    mini meals work best for me, although on the weekends I tend to graze more than anything.. just little bits of this and that as the day goes on.
  • rileysowner
    rileysowner Posts: 8,331 Member
    The key thing to remember is when it comes down to it, meal frequency does not affect your metabolism at all, so eat the number of meals that works for you whether that is 1 or 9 or something in between. As long as it is good quality vitamin rich food and you stay within your calorie budget.
This discussion has been closed.