Eating after 6:00pm
Karri_Bryant
Posts: 10 Member
Does anyone have an opinion about eating dinner after 6:00pm.
I set down with a nutritionist at the end of February. I have taken off 63 pounds but in recent I am slowing down on the weight loss. I have gone back over my notes and I keep re-reading where she says to eat before 6:00pm and if I can't then I should just eat a protein bar and count that as my dinner. If I did this I would never eat dinner, most evenings I am just getting dinner started by 6:00pm. Even food prepping and crock-pot cooking, with my work schedule we can't get dinner consumed before 6:pm.
I set down with a nutritionist at the end of February. I have taken off 63 pounds but in recent I am slowing down on the weight loss. I have gone back over my notes and I keep re-reading where she says to eat before 6:00pm and if I can't then I should just eat a protein bar and count that as my dinner. If I did this I would never eat dinner, most evenings I am just getting dinner started by 6:00pm. Even food prepping and crock-pot cooking, with my work schedule we can't get dinner consumed before 6:pm.
6
Replies
-
Calories are the only thing that matter in terms of weight loss.
Meal timing can help with compliance/satiety but will not have any effect on weight loss. Your nutritionist is using 'bro science' from the 80's/90's with that recommendation.36 -
Calories are the only thing that matter in terms of weight loss.
Meal timing can help with compliance/satiety but will not have any effect on weight loss. Your nutritionist is using 'bro science' from the 80's/90's with that recommendation.
^^^This
See a registered dietician instead of a nutritionist.21 -
that's pretty silly advice, what if you work the night shift, 6 is breakfast
17 -
Meal timing has nothing to do with weight loss - I lost my weight while often eating dinner past 9:00 PM.
The one thing to keep in mind, however, is that eating later in the evening may impact the number you see on the scale in the next morning (you'll still be digesting dinner) - so while it can impact a weigh-in, it doesn't impact weight loss.18 -
i don't typically eat dinner until 8-9pm at night - so i call hooey on that advice...
IIRC the origination of that advice came from Oprah...and it had to do with the fact that people tended to mindlessly snack at night - so by saying don't eat after 7 they reduced calories and lost weight - which turned into eating after 7 is bad because you'll gain weight18 -
I don't get off work until 6:00. I usually have dinner around 7:00-ish. Then I sit down with my book and have a glass of wine (or two) and a bedtime snack around 10:00. I've gone from a size 12 to a size 2.13
-
I generally eat dinner between 7:30 and 9:00 pm, both while losing and in maintenance. I lost about 60 pounds, 4 sizes and have maintained that for nearly 3 years now.6
-
Fire that nutritionist, if possible find a registered dietician if you need help with a meal plan.13
-
Calories are the only thing that matter in terms of weight loss.
Meal timing can help with compliance/satiety but will not have any effect on weight loss. Your nutritionist is using 'bro science' from the 80's/90's with that recommendation.
Well a bit this but it isn't necessarily bro science to make the recommendation. It depends on their reasoning. @Karri_Bryant is your nutritionist an actual registered dietitian?
It would be more so to eat some carbs, but there is a practical recommendation to eat a dinner near a few hours before bed to promote healthy sleep. Sleep will impact decision making the next day for future food choices. Plus, when a person gets less sleep, weight loss tends to come more from lean tissue instead of fat in comparison to weight loss by people getting more sleep.14 -
-
Like you, I'd basically never get to eat dinner with that advice, or would be forgoing my fun cooking and eating routine with eating at my desk or a protein bar (and while nothing wrong with protein bars, they are actually not worth the cals for me). Pretty much the whole time I was losing I got home around 8 (sometimes later, as I sometimes worked out after work) and then cooked and ate dinner around 9.
Unless you have a problem eating that close to bed (6 would not be close to bed for me), it sounds rather like non science based advice or a one-size-fits-all prescription that fails to take into account your particular circumstances. Especially if she claimed that going to bed without working off dinner would mean it turned right into fat, I'd think about whether her advice was really making sense overall.6 -
I've just recently started having dinner no earlier than 6 pm, in an attempt to eliminate mid-evening snack. So far, so good.9
-
Karri_Bryant wrote: »Does anyone have an opinion about eating dinner after 6:00pm.
I set down with a nutritionist at the end of February. I have taken off 63 pounds but in recent I am slowing down on the weight loss. I have gone back over my notes and I keep re-reading where she says to eat before 6:00pm and if I can't then I should just eat a protein bar and count that as my dinner. If I did this I would never eat dinner, most evenings I am just getting dinner started by 6:00pm. Even food prepping and crock-pot cooking, with my work schedule we can't get dinner consumed before 6:pm.
From a logic standpoint, how would or could this even matter?
I'm rarely home by 6PM from the office and my wife and I usually eat dinner around 8:30PM...lost 40 Lbs pretty easily.3 -
I'm hoping you don't pay this nutritionist. The only thing that matters in weight management is calories. Meal timing is irrelevant and completely variable on your personal schedule.
I ingest >75% of my calories after 6 pm and lost 60 lbs - been in maintenance for 4 years now.7 -
There are some interesting perspectives on circadian rhythms and feeding timing in the works and writings of Satchidananda Panda.
https://www.salk.edu/scientist/satchidananda-panda/15 -
I go to bed around 12 pm. If I eat dinner before 6 pm, you better believe I am gonna eat again before bedtime!
5 -
-
corinasue1143 wrote: »I go to bed around 12 pm. If I eat dinner before 6 pm, you better believe I am gonna eat again before bedtime!
Same. I don’t event eat lunch until 2ish most days and I’m not even hungry again before 7 or 8.0 -
Karri_Bryant wrote: »Does anyone have an opinion about eating dinner after 6:00pm.
I set down with a nutritionist at the end of February. I have taken off 63 pounds but in recent I am slowing down on the weight loss. I have gone back over my notes and I keep re-reading where she says to eat before 6:00pm and if I can't then I should just eat a protein bar and count that as my dinner. If I did this I would never eat dinner, most evenings I am just getting dinner started by 6:00pm. Even food prepping and crock-pot cooking, with my work schedule we can't get dinner consumed before 6:pm.
How in the heck could anyone that works a 9-5 job, get home from work, prepare dinner and eat dinner before 6 pm? What is meant to happen to your body after 6 pm that will prevent it from digesting food as it did at 5:59?
The only reason meal timing is at all relevant to weight loss is in how it affects your satiety, mindless snacking, and how well you sleep.
This is why you should avoid seeing a nutritionist and see a registered dietician instead. You can call yourself a nutritionist with a short online course only.11 -
Karri_Bryant wrote: »Does anyone have an opinion about eating dinner after 6:00pm.
I set down with a nutritionist at the end of February. I have taken off 63 pounds but in recent I am slowing down on the weight loss. I have gone back over my notes and I keep re-reading where she says to eat before 6:00pm and if I can't then I should just eat a protein bar and count that as my dinner. If I did this I would never eat dinner, most evenings I am just getting dinner started by 6:00pm. Even food prepping and crock-pot cooking, with my work schedule we can't get dinner consumed before 6:pm.
My opinion is that this rule is silly.
My experience is that losing weight does not rely on eating dinner before 6 pm.
I very very rarely eat dinner before 6 - most days I'm not even home from work till about then - and I never eat protein bars.
Lost to goal weight in 2013 and kept it off since.
I can see that for some people , not eating after x time is a helpful strategy - generally not eating after dinner, not the time in particular - because it helps them avoid mindless high calorie evening snacking in front of TV.
I do usually have a small snack after dinner as well, often about 9 or 10 pm - so not eating after dinner wasnt a neccesary rule for me.
But can see the logic for some people.
The thing is to recognise it as a strategy and then decide if it is useful to you, , rather than see it as a magic or compulsory rule
3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 388 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 909 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.2K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions