Losing more muscle than fat!
sbalzer
Posts: 18 Member
Ok my fellow fitnesspal’s I need your help. I got my second DEXA scan yesterday, three months after my initial scan. The results show I lost 2.9kg of LEAN + BMC and 1.34kg of fat, showing my BF went from 23.8 to 23.3%. I’m trying to do the impossible I know of losing BF while maintaining muscle mass. However losing muscle to fat at a ratio of 2 to 1 is concerning. I would prefer it the ratio was reversed! I should add BF around my waist decline by 20% whereas overall BF declined by 7%.
Here is some background information to help;
I started a 20% calorie deficit (counting calories with MFP app) in June last year just as we got out of the first lockdown in Australia. As gyms were closed I bought a spin bike and was doing two 30 minute bike rides of low cardio intensity per day plus 10k steps daily. I know this is not optimal for maintaining muscle mass. I was able to decrease my weight from 90.6kg to 81kg. Once restrictions were lifted in November I commenced weight training again, I took a diet break for two weeks over the Christmas and New Year period before getting my first DEXA scan in early January.
In terms of weight training, I have been lifting on and off since I was 24, but not consistent enough in my diet or training to make any significant gains. Prior to re-commencing training in November, I hadn’t weight trained for 12 months. I would class myself as somewhere between novice to intermediate. I follow a structured hypertrophy training program hitting all muscle groups twice a week over five days with a two day rest period, plus 30 minute bike ride at low cardio intensity. Since November I have been gaining strength increasing weight steadily by approximately 20% on major exercises such as squats, deadlifts, bench press etc..
My current 1RM is as follows:
Squats – 136kg
Deadlift – 136kg
Bench Press – 76kg
I haven't been taking measurements except for my stomach, which has reduced by two inches since I started measuring in January. Have started taking measurements of arm legs, neck, chest and waist now as well.
Ok, now diet. I’ following IIFYM with the following macro ratio’s. I found through trailing, my TDEE to be 2250 calories, originally thought it was more like 2500 but found I was gaining at this maintenance level. I eat 2000 calories per day plus exercise to achieve my 20% calorie deficit. I have been consistently losing 0.5kg per week since November except the break over Christmas, New Year. Alcohol once a week at most some weeks no alcohol at all, when I do have a drink it's approximately 2 - 3 glasses of red wine. Protein comes from a range of sources, various meats, dairy and WPI pre and post workouts.
Protein – 171g min.
Fat – 62g min.
Carbs – what ever is left over approx 130g
My aim is to get to somewhere between 68kg – 70kg then assess BF and physique and determine whether to start a re-comp or continue cutting.
My questions
1. Should I take a diet break? And eat a maintenance for one month?
2. What should I reasonably expect my muscle to fat loss ratio to be?
3. I’m thinking the latest DEXA scan result could have been erroneous, i.e dehydrated throwing out my lean mass reading???
Any advise would be greatly appreciated. I don’t want to go to my next DEXA scan losing another 3kg of muscle!!!
Here is some background information to help;
I started a 20% calorie deficit (counting calories with MFP app) in June last year just as we got out of the first lockdown in Australia. As gyms were closed I bought a spin bike and was doing two 30 minute bike rides of low cardio intensity per day plus 10k steps daily. I know this is not optimal for maintaining muscle mass. I was able to decrease my weight from 90.6kg to 81kg. Once restrictions were lifted in November I commenced weight training again, I took a diet break for two weeks over the Christmas and New Year period before getting my first DEXA scan in early January.
In terms of weight training, I have been lifting on and off since I was 24, but not consistent enough in my diet or training to make any significant gains. Prior to re-commencing training in November, I hadn’t weight trained for 12 months. I would class myself as somewhere between novice to intermediate. I follow a structured hypertrophy training program hitting all muscle groups twice a week over five days with a two day rest period, plus 30 minute bike ride at low cardio intensity. Since November I have been gaining strength increasing weight steadily by approximately 20% on major exercises such as squats, deadlifts, bench press etc..
My current 1RM is as follows:
Squats – 136kg
Deadlift – 136kg
Bench Press – 76kg
I haven't been taking measurements except for my stomach, which has reduced by two inches since I started measuring in January. Have started taking measurements of arm legs, neck, chest and waist now as well.
Ok, now diet. I’ following IIFYM with the following macro ratio’s. I found through trailing, my TDEE to be 2250 calories, originally thought it was more like 2500 but found I was gaining at this maintenance level. I eat 2000 calories per day plus exercise to achieve my 20% calorie deficit. I have been consistently losing 0.5kg per week since November except the break over Christmas, New Year. Alcohol once a week at most some weeks no alcohol at all, when I do have a drink it's approximately 2 - 3 glasses of red wine. Protein comes from a range of sources, various meats, dairy and WPI pre and post workouts.
Protein – 171g min.
Fat – 62g min.
Carbs – what ever is left over approx 130g
My aim is to get to somewhere between 68kg – 70kg then assess BF and physique and determine whether to start a re-comp or continue cutting.
My questions
1. Should I take a diet break? And eat a maintenance for one month?
2. What should I reasonably expect my muscle to fat loss ratio to be?
3. I’m thinking the latest DEXA scan result could have been erroneous, i.e dehydrated throwing out my lean mass reading???
Any advise would be greatly appreciated. I don’t want to go to my next DEXA scan losing another 3kg of muscle!!!
0
Replies
-
Sorry despite all the information above I forgot to add my current weight is 76.4kg.0
-
I'm having trouble understanding the math here: Can you provide some additional information, specifically how tall you are, and what your exercise calories tend to be (and how you estimate those)?
However much you're eating, your actual deficit seems to average around 550 calories daily?0 -
Tracking with a Garmin watch, weight training calories burned between 200 - 300 calories per workout depeding on the type of workout, i.e legs greater intensity closer to 300. Bike average about 200 calories for 30mins. Height 172cm.0
-
I agree with you deficit estimate, I'm aiming for about a 500cal deficit.0
-
What is your actual lifting regimen? 5x5? High volume? Split routine? If you're losing muscle STILL, it's because the lifting routine you're doing ISN'T taxing the muscle enough to retain it.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
Program I’m doing is Strong lifts 5x50
-
Would you suggest another program?0
-
Did you lose 4.24kg between your two scans, or some other amount? If a different amount... where is that accounted on your scan?
Were the scans at the same time during the day? Had you eaten/consumed similar amounts? Had you used the bathroom in a similar manner? Same machine? Same operator (especially the guy clicking on the screen and choosing the areas)?
Did you exercise differently or consumed significantly different amounts of carbs before the two measurements.
Glycogen changes also show as a lean mass change and they are much more likely to occur with relatively low carbs and exercise...
Your numbers seem impressive to me... but then again I don't lift so I have no clue Niner may be able to suggest a more appropriate program for someone who is not really a beginner...?
If you're concerned about lean mass lost the two things you can control are training impetus... and deficit size.0 -
@pav8888 thanks for your reply. In answer to your questions
Test was done at the same time 10am, by the same person on the same machine. I had been to the toilet on both occasions had nothing to eat or drink. I can’t recall what training I had completed the morning before on both occasions, but it is highly like it wasn’t the same training day. This is why I’m perplexed by the results. I’m thinking my best approach is to continue what I have been doing until my next test in 8 weeks and see if it was / is glycogen changes that have affected the results.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy with the weight loss, this has been my aim, but not the loss of muscle.
As for deficit, I think I have this right as I’m losing at a steady pace and wouldn’t want to cut anymore for fear that this could increase my muscle loss.
@niner, thanks for your feedback. I think I’m my training is taxing but this only my perspective. Are there signs or indications that I should be looking out for to determine if I’m taxing my muscles sufficiently?0 -
My hint was towards smaller not larger deficit as protection to lean mass1
-
Oops thanks for the clarification0
-
Did the DEXA report estimate how much of the lean mass loss was msucle as it's not clear to me if you are reading all the lean mass loss as muscle? (Which it isn't - it's everything that isn't fat.)
e.g. drink a pint of water and you just added a 1lb of lean mass. Donate a pint of blood you just lost 1lb of lean mass.0 -
Hello,
Just to note that your macros appear lower in protein and higher in fat than the recommended 40/40/20 (carbs/protein/fat) that I’ve seen. I’m sure there are many recommended ways but I’m on 248g of protein and 58g fat for a roughly 20% deficit (at 2500 calories). Touch wood, but I’m reasonably happy that I’m losing predominately fat.
Dave0 -
Hello,
Just to note that your macros appear lower in protein and higher in fat than the recommended 40/40/20 (carbs/protein/fat) that I’ve seen. I’m sure there are many recommended ways but I’m on 248g of protein and 58g fat for a roughly 20% deficit (at 2500 calories). Touch wood, but I’m reasonably happy that I’m losing predominately fat.
Dave
He's getting 171g protein for 76.4 kg (168lb) bodyweight, at 172 cm (5'8"ish). That's over a gram per pound bodyweight, should be
adequate protein.8 -
Would you suggest another program?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
2 -
Just a side note, you reference losing fat while maintaining, or even gaining, muscle as an "impossible task". It's not. If you eat sufficient protein, keep the calorie deficit small such that you're only losing around 0.5% of your body weight per week, and you are consistent with a well designed, progressive, lifting program you can absolutely gain muscle mass while in a deficit.
The conventional wisdom that it's not possible to gain while in a deficit really only applies to men who are going into single digit body fat ranges. Generally you won't gain as much muscle mass as you would in a calorie surplus, but at 23% BF your body has sufficient resources to draw on to build muscle while in a deficit, assuming the aforementioned conditions are met.
I agree with others in your case though. It's time to move on from the 5x5.5 -
@ninerbuff thanks for the suggestion.0
-
In the list have a look at the AllPro programme. It is a 3x8-12 programme that may be a good transition from the 5x5.
Cheers, h.2 -
This content has been removed.
-
I tried for over a YEAR to "recomp" by lifting HEAVY 3x's a week and eating a very HIGH PROTEIN diet (up to 200g/#/day (from regular food and supplements) and by measuring my BF/muscle mass every quarter w/DEXA.
The results were VERY disappointing and I gave it up.
Long story short, I gained most of the muscle mass that I currently (and still) have from bulking and cutting. When I bulked to 200 and back to 160 (which is my current max wt) while doing the same things (lifting heavy and eating a high protein diet). It did it TWICE and each time I gained a significant amount of muscle mass and "musculature" which became more defined w/some dieting and regular (but not extraordinary) exercise, which in my case, is rowing.
There's a history to this method which many competitive body builders still use and the reason they still continue to do it is because it "works."
Recomp is good in theory but near impossible to achieve in practice.
That's my experience and you have no basis to "disagree" with it (as many have to my prior posts on this issue) unless you've actually tried to do it yourself and have properly measured your results w/DEXA or hydro. Absent such data, any "objection" is pure BS.
Just my 20 cents on the topic. LOL!
1 -
In contrast to the experience above I've never struggled to recomp, even before I knew what I regard as normal had a name!
Even now in my 60's with my gym closing/opening/closing/opening during the pandemic I've achieved easily visible and measurable increases in muscle mass and reduction in body fat when I can resume training.
Different people have different responses to training stimulus so "impossible" needs to be seen as personal rather than universal. For the entirety of four decades of training I've always expected and achieved quicker results than my peer group when I can train consistently. I've also seemingly tolerated a greater training volume than most of my peers which is no doubt a factor. Apart from the guesswork of good genetics I do have unusually high natural T levels.
Never tried the cut and bulk method, never felt the need TBH. My results have always been training driven and diet frankly wasn't / isn't a big factor at all. I neither feel a detriment from a small deficit or a boost from a surplus unlike others seem to.
With the caveat I've never been into bodybuilding or very low levels of bodyfat, just not my thing. Strength gains and sporting performance have been my drivers.
1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions