Premier Protein Shakes? Alternatives?
AquaPunk87
Posts: 13 Member
Hi all! I'm wondering how people feel about premier protein shakes. I'm not a big breakfast person at all and have very little time in the mornings. Lately I've been drinking the chocolate shake, but am wondering how healthy they really are. What are your thoughts? Any suggestions for a better alternative? Doesn't have to be a shake, just easy.
1
Replies
-
I don't know about premier protein. If you're looking for other options I'd like to recommend Driven Whey Protein as well as Chike Protein (especially if you like coffee), and Ascent protein options.
If you'd prefer a protein bar to grab and go, I highly recommend Barebells.
Good Luck!!!1 -
Why not just skip breakfast? It doesn't sound like you enjoy that meal very much.2
-
Do you crash by mid-morning if you don't eat/drink anything at breakfast time? If not, then yeah, maybe just skip breakfast and don't eat until lunchtime. Plenty of folks on IF (intermittent fasting) plans don't eat until 11 AM or even later during the day, like 2 or 3 PM. Three meals a day in the morning, at noon, and at night is just one possible way of eating, and if it doesn't work for you, you don't have to follow it. There aren't any Breakfast Police that will come and shove bacon and eggs down your throat at 7 AM if you don't.4
-
zombieblondie wrote: »I don't know about premier protein. If you're looking for other options I'd like to recommend Driven Whey Protein as well as Chike Protein (especially if you like coffee), and Ascent protein options.
If you'd prefer a protein bar to grab and go, I highly recommend Barebells.
Good Luck!!!
Thanks! I'll check those out. I love coffee!1 -
joyanna2016 wrote: »Why not just skip breakfast? It doesn't sound like you enjoy that meal very much.
My days at work get crazy and 9 times out of 10 I end up skipping lunch. I didn't used to eat breakfast, but just snacking or waiting until dinner doesn't work for me. So while I'm not a natural breakfast person, I definitely feel better and have more energy if I have something.3 -
goal06082021 wrote: »Do you crash by mid-morning if you don't eat/drink anything at breakfast time? If not, then yeah, maybe just skip breakfast and don't eat until lunchtime. Plenty of folks on IF (intermittent fasting) plans don't eat until 11 AM or even later during the day, like 2 or 3 PM. Three meals a day in the morning, at noon, and at night is just one possible way of eating, and if it doesn't work for you, you don't have to follow it. There aren't any Breakfast Police that will come and shove bacon and eggs down your throat at 7 AM if you don't.
I do crash by mid-morning, plus I end up skipping lunch most days (my job tends to get crazy fast!). I started with the shakes about a month ago and I definitely feel better/have more energy by having something to hold me over. I'm just not a huge breakfast person and don't have much time since I'm up 4:30-5:00am. Cooking in the morning, or even scarfing down oatmeal is a no go. To top it off, I've never met a breakfast/protein bar I like 🤣1 -
Ready to drink I recommend OWYN , and powdered to make I use plant based- Sunwarrior or Garden of Life, Vega Sport and True Athlete Plant Protein from Vitamin Shoppe
Whey I would recommend Ascend also, True Athlete, Biochem and Kaged Muscle1 -
With 30g of protein for 160 calories, plus caffeine in the cafe latte flavor, I'm a big fan. I usually have a shake for breakfast.
8 -
i love them i use drink them everyday for my breakfast6
-
What about adding some fresh fruit or even vegetables on the side. If you have time to add them in to your smoothie to make your own, I'd also add some healthy fats like nuts or avocado.3
-
AquaPunk87 wrote: »am wondering how healthy they really are. What are your thoughts? Any suggestions for a better alternative? Doesn't have to be a shake, just easy.
They are as healthy as whatever the calories/ingredients/nutrition say on the box...not sure what you're trying to get at there as "healthy" is a subjective term.
Nature Valley has nut-based protein chewy bars that are good - the blueberry is a great morning bar, and if you want a mouth-full of peanut butter the crunch bars will hit the spot:
https://www.naturevalley.com/products/protein-bars
Premier itself has a decent nut-based bar:
https://www.premierprotein.com/products/12g-chocolate-peanut-butter-protein-bar3 -
-
Thanks everyone! I guess as long as there's no one screaming "OMG those are complete poison!" I'll call it a win 🤣
I don't eat/drink a whole lot of pre-packaged foods and wanted to make sure I wasn't accidentally sabotaging myself. I think I'll take speakeasy's advice and try to eat an apple with it. Not sure why I never thought of that 🤦♀️2 -
Possibly pre-make a pitcher of your own concoction that suits you - nutritionally and flavor/etc. - that lasts a couple of days?1
-
There's nothing inherently unhealthy about a Premiere Protein shake...but it's just a protein supplement. My bigger concern, particularly as you are also skipping on lunch most days is that you aren't really getting adequate nutrition in regards to essential micro-nutrients. Protein supplements are just protein supplements...they don't have the requisite nutrition to replace a meal.
If I were going this route I'd pick up an actual meal replacement shake that would also supplement a lot of the other nutrition you need or I would go the smoothie route.4 -
goal06082021 wrote: »There aren't any Breakfast Police that will come and shove bacon and eggs down your throat at 7 AM if you don't.
How can I arrange a visit from these Breakfast Police peeps? lol
I second the idea of meal replacement shakes rather than protein shakes to serve as breakfast, along with Special K protein bars. 12g of protein plus 5g fiber, and it tastes like a granola bar, not chalky as a lot of protein bars tend to do.1 -
Thanks guys! I Knew there were meal replacement shakes, I just never really thought about it lol. I'll check some out, along with the special k bars nossmf recommended.0
-
Aquapunk....I have been drinking Premier protein shakes daily for a while. I love them! I am a vegetarian (no meat but dairy)and realized after using MFP app and logging my food how much i was lacking in protein. I tried few different protein shakes and these are my favorite. Since upping my protein (I am fairly active and run 5 mile a day) I feel soooooo much better and have cut down on my binge eating. You know I go with how my body feels. If I feel good after eating something and have more energy that is my body speaking to me (is that corny...i don't know?). When I eat junk I get tired and have no desire to exercise. I have one or two of these daily. I was buying the prepared drinks but that got pricey so now I do the powder and make my own. My favorite is a smoothie with a frozen banana; chocolate protein powder, peanut butter powder(no fat just dehydrated ), ground flax seed and almond milk. OMG....it is like a dessert and keeps me full!3
-
Aquapunk....I have been drinking Premier protein shakes daily for a while. I love them! I am a vegetarian (no meat but dairy)and realized after using MFP app and logging my food how much i was lacking in protein. I tried few different protein shakes and these are my favorite. Since upping my protein (I am fairly active and run 5 mile a day) I feel soooooo much better and have cut down on my binge eating. You know I go with how my body feels. If I feel good after eating something and have more energy that is my body speaking to me (is that corny...i don't know?). When I eat junk I get tired and have no desire to exercise. I have one or two of these daily. I was buying the prepared drinks but that got pricey so now I do the powder and make my own. My favorite is a smoothie with a frozen banana; chocolate protein powder, peanut butter powder(no fat just dehydrated ), ground flax seed and almond milk. OMG....it is like a dessert and keeps me full!
Wow, you all are are giving me some great ideas! That recipe sounds super amazing. It probably won't work for me on a weekday, but I'm definitely trying it this weekend! 🤩0 -
cwolfman13 wrote: »There's nothing inherently unhealthy about a Premiere Protein shake...but it's just a protein supplement. My bigger concern, particularly as you are also skipping on lunch most days is that you aren't really getting adequate nutrition in regards to essential micro-nutrients. Protein supplements are just protein supplements...they don't have the requisite nutrition to replace a meal.
If I were going this route I'd pick up an actual meal replacement shake that would also supplement a lot of the other nutrition you need or I would go the smoothie route.
I admit I am not a nutritionist, but the label on the Premier brand, anyhow, which is the brand OP is asks about, looks pretty good.
2 -
If oatmeal isn’t an option due to cooking times, you could try refrigerator oatmeal.
Just put a quarter cup regular oatmeal in a travel container - mason jars work great.
Add some milk, yogurt, fruit, nuts if you like, and let it sit in the fridge overnight. These keep a week refrigerated, so you can make them ahead of time and just grab them as you zoom out the door.
Then you can have the protein shake for lunch.2 -
I’ve been using dry peanut powder with cacao. Those packaged shakes have so much sugar and additives you might as well have a milkshake.1
-
krjohnson1292 wrote: »I’ve been using dry peanut powder with cacao. Those packaged shakes have so much sugar and additives you might as well have a milkshake.
Premier protein has no added sugar and 30 grams of protein. The peanut butter I use has added sugar though (2grams).
4 -
krjohnson1292 wrote: »I’ve been using dry peanut powder with cacao. Those packaged shakes have so much sugar and additives you might as well have a milkshake.
Different packaged shakes have different nutritional goals. It may be that the ones you’re familiar with are the ones like Ensure, which was designed as a meal replacement for seriously ill people. The amount of carbs in those is very useful in that circumstance.
There are many other brands that cater to different dietary goals. Premier, the brand OP mentioned, is relatively low on carbs. It’s not keto, but it absolutely has a place in a diabetic diet, for example.
Dismissing all protein shakes because some are higher in sugar kind of misses the point here. Each different formulation type has a specific use.
5 -
krjohnson1292 wrote: »I’ve been using dry peanut powder with cacao. Those packaged shakes have so much sugar and additives you might as well have a milkshake.
Premier protein has no added sugar and 30 grams of protein. The peanut butter I use has added sugar though (2grams).
Yeah and even removing 'added' from the equation it has one whole gram of sugar.
They're fine.4 -
MargaretYakoda wrote: »If oatmeal isn’t an option due to cooking times, you could try refrigerator oatmeal.
Just put a quarter cup regular oatmeal in a travel container - mason jars work great.
Add some milk, yogurt, fruit, nuts if you like, and let it sit in the fridge overnight. These keep a week refrigerated, so you can make them ahead of time and just grab them as you zoom out the door.
Then you can have the protein shake for lunch.
Thanks! I might try this too. Sounds easy and delicious!1 -
krjohnson1292 wrote: »I’ve been using dry peanut powder with cacao. Those packaged shakes have so much sugar and additives you might as well have a milkshake.
Agreed! This one might be low in sugar, but some of them are crazy high!1 -
Fairlife are great, 30 protein and only 150 calories.3
-
I love premier protein shakes. They were actually suggested to me by my nutritionist, because they do have alot of nutrients in it, and low sugar. I like the chocolate, coffee, and blueberry flavors. If you aren't a breakfast person, I think a shake is a good alternative, you may also want to look up recipes for smoothies and add a protein powder to it for some variety.4
-
Priasmama416 wrote: »I love premier protein shakes. They were actually suggested to me by my nutritionist, because they do have alot of nutrients in it, and low sugar. I like the chocolate, coffee, and blueberry flavors. If you aren't a breakfast person, I think a shake is a good alternative, you may also want to look up recipes for smoothies and add a protein powder to it for some variety.
Blueberry??? They have BLUEBERRY????
(mumble mumble Podunk town I live in mumble mumble)1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions