Lowering LDL through diet alone?
newmein2013
Posts: 674 Member
Has anyone been successful in lowering their LDL to within normal range, without medication, but doing this strictly through nutrition? Due to my family history, all my doctors are insisting that I take a statin as a preventative and they say that LDL can NOT be lowered to within normal range through diet alone. I get very bad muscle pain from all the statins I’ve tried. And I wholeheartedly believe that one of the statins caused my acute pancreatitis years ago. I’m determined to do this with a nutrition plan. But I wonder, am I spinning my wheels? As determined as I may be, can I defy my genetics? My dr gave me one year to see what happens doing it my way. I’d love to hear from you all, especially those with a family history of heart disease.
To give you an idea of how determined I am.... I received my lab results on 1/9/19 & started eating healthy a few days later. I am by no means starving myself. I’m just eating super healthy & I love it. But now I’m reaching out to you guys for more help.
Weight loss = 31 lbs in 13 weeks
Lab results:
12/27/18 4/11/19
Triglycerides 445 157
Tot Cholesterol 314 235
LDL Trigs 2 high to mzr 167
LDL (Direct) 225 169
HDL 42 37
A1C 9.6 6.5
I had to take insulin for the 1st time in my life. It terrified me. Fortunately, I only had to do it for 9 days & then I was able to control my blood glucose with diet & oral meds
AST 81 18
ALT 65 18
Thanks for reading. Looking forward to your replies!
To give you an idea of how determined I am.... I received my lab results on 1/9/19 & started eating healthy a few days later. I am by no means starving myself. I’m just eating super healthy & I love it. But now I’m reaching out to you guys for more help.
Weight loss = 31 lbs in 13 weeks
Lab results:
12/27/18 4/11/19
Triglycerides 445 157
Tot Cholesterol 314 235
LDL Trigs 2 high to mzr 167
LDL (Direct) 225 169
HDL 42 37
A1C 9.6 6.5
I had to take insulin for the 1st time in my life. It terrified me. Fortunately, I only had to do it for 9 days & then I was able to control my blood glucose with diet & oral meds
AST 81 18
ALT 65 18
Thanks for reading. Looking forward to your replies!
3
Replies
-
From what my physician told my husband, he might lower it with exercise and losing weight/maintaining a healthy weight and if not successful he’ll be on the statin later. Sounds similar to you. It’s not the type of food you eat, just your actual weight. According to my physician.3
-
@GoodLardy
Yes, it does sound similar. My doctors explain it as the genetics are too strong for the nutrition (or even weight loss) to bring it down to within normal range. I guess they feel I’m hitting my head against a brick wall. My cardiologist begged me years ago to at least go on the maintenance dose. I just couldn’t handle the muscle pain. I have a very difficult time understanding how in today’s world of high tech medicine & natural holistic healing, there isn’t a way to do this. Thanks for your response.0 -
My sisters blood pressure and cholesterol were both high and her doctor wanted to do meds for both. She refused meds and asked about other options. He encouraged her to try DASH for the blood pressure and schedule a return a month later. She did try to include walking at a moderate pace for 30 minutes 3-4 times per week but her main focus was DASH. One month later her blood pressure and cholesterol were both reduced to normal levels and she was able to avoid meds. She hadn’t expected it to have a big impact on cholesterol and was mainly concerned about the blood pressure. She was surprised to see the number go down so quickly.4
-
@emmamcgarity
I’m glad that worked for your sister. I have heard DASH is great at lowering BP but like your sister, I hadn’t heard about the cholesterol lowering benefits. I’m really not familiar with the diet though. I’ll have to familiarize myself with it. Does your family have a history of heart disease? I’m fighting genetics. Thanks for your reply.
0 -
My father had cholesterol problems and did have a heart attack later in life. He did ultimately have to take statins and hated the leg cramps. But most of my family history has blood pressure issues. I follow DASH loosely to support my sister. The results she shared with me about cholesterol were I think for total cholesterol. Her initial number was 217 and it dropped to 160. Her blood pressure was in the 150s and dropped to 105 a month after beginning DASH. She was very rigid with it in an effort to avoid meds. Now that several months have passed she is not as rigid but is 80-90% compliant and has still avoided medication.
The Americans Heart Association gives a pretty good breakdown, but with your blood sugar issues you’d need to make sure you talk to your doctor. Some foods that are DASH friendly (potato and fruit) might not be appropriate for people with blood sugar issues. There is a nutrition podcast n=1 that did a really thorough breakdown as well.
My father had stroke a couple years ago that he didn’t survive, but at that stage in life he had Parkinson’s and his medical history had become quite complicated.
Your doctor is right that weight loss can only do so much. My sisters doctor didn’t expect her dramatic results and quizzed her about how closely she followed the diet. After some discussion, he told her that most patients have good intentions but are not able/willing to follow the diet changes. Since you have a cardiologist, he’d be a good person to discuss it with.
0 -
I had a bit of success reducing LDL and raising HDL with losing weight, increasing fish consumption over meat consumption, consuming a lot of legumes and having oatmeal with added oat bran, and dropping weight. When I feared that my dr nonetheless was going to prescribe statins which have been hard to tolerate because of muscle pain, I ran across this article which gave me some ideas I could talk to my dr about. Fortunately, I don't have a strong family history and my levels dropped enough so that my overall Framingham Risk score was pretty low and I escaped the prescription. Maybe something in here will help you: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3920796/2
-
I got that same crap from my doctor. I refused to take any more of his horrid death drugs so he got fed up and sent me to an endocrinologist...
Who told me I absolutely can diet myself into better numbers. And with his help in just 6 months I nearly halved my bad numbers. I just stopped eating carbs. I'm eating them again now, but that's because I'm calorie counting so we'll see how that goes.
Your doctor can prescribe you drugs until he's blue in the face but you can refuse them. Nobody is forcing them down your throat. Do some reading, talk to some second and third opinions and do what you think is best. I'll NEVER take statins again. What meaning in low cholesterol if you're slowly poisoning yourself to death to get there.17 -
I currently am working on the same thing plus other pieces. With diet alone I've manage to reduce LDL by 35% in a month. I haven't lost any weight. I have been doing diet and trying to exercise more. Due to my feet the increased exercise is very moderate. I'm sure if you are willing to stick to select foods, exercise maybe lose weight that you can have an impact. I'm eating very specific foods, taking vitamins and trying to exercise. I'm sure I can get my numbers even better. Below is my link to my thread.
https://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10734481/c-reactive-protein-cholesterol-gut-bacteria#latest0 -
Yes, LD-C around 200+ mg/dL, Total Cholesterol ~360mg/dL (HDL ~100 mg/dL, triglycerides pretty low)
This was from high fat, moderate protein, minimal carbohydrate diet....simply changed to restricted fat intake, higher protein diet, some carbohydrates. LDL-C only around 100 mg/dL and total cholesterol around 200mg/dL with HDL tanking a bit (now only 70-80 mg/dL). Triglycerides/LDL roughly the same2 -
It depends on the person. Some people are already at a healthy weight and have very high lipids and need medication. If you have some weight to lose, weight loss will help. Eating a plant based diet will help.2
-
I would also caution if a doctor is putting you are a medicine based solely on LDL. You made significant progress most of your numbers.
I barely moved mine and laughed at my doctor when they brought up meds. All my other numbers are perfect and i am pretty sure most of the current evidence doesn't show much, if any, reduction in heart related events by taking statins.
But in general thinks like lower red meat and Sat fats, and increasing fish, whole grains, fruits and veggies will help.4 -
Just completed a 45 day OMAD experience for Lent 2019 that included abstinence from eating meat, long daily fasting periods and eating eggs with about normal frequency. Had blood done the other day to compare to last blood work done on my birthday about 2 weeks prior to beginning OMAD.
Cholesterol stats were as follows (before/after)
LDL - 109/121
HDL - 38/43
Triglycerides - 89/70
Total - 165/178
I have a good history of recorded cholesterol lab results going back to 2001 and only once was my LDL below 100. I’ve always had low HDL. I remember one time long ago when having a rare physical and doctor’s visit, the doctor said that perhaps I would need cholesterol medicine because of my LDL lab result that may have been 110. That was the last time I saw him. Now, I order lab work online, pay myself because I have a high deductible health insurance plan, and bypass all the mainstream healthcare nonsense.
Do believe a plant-based diet or eating following Dr. John McDougall’s starxh-based approach would lower cholesterol readings.
Me, I’m going to continue eating eggs.1 -
@emmamcgarity
Thank you so much for sharing. I’m sorry for your loss. It is balancing act with the blood sugar & all. I’ll listen to the podcast. Thanks again for all your input!
@Maxxitt
The article was extremely informative. Thank you. I believe my dr is waiting for those new meds that were mentioned at the end of the article. That’s why he said I have one year. He’s hoping it will be released by then.0 -
@Terytha
Thanks for your reply. Congrats on getting your numbers down! Do you have a family history of heart disease? This is the important factor and main reason all my doctors say this can’t be done through diet alone. The genetic component is the problem.0 -
@kizanne2
Awesome job! Thanks for sharing. I pulled up your link & I’ll be reading it in full later tonight. It seems our food plans are somewhat similar. The dreaded question... is there a family history of heart disease?0 -
@Keto_Vampire
Do you have the family history of heart disease?1 -
newmein2013 wrote: »@Keto_Vampire
Do you have the family history of heart disease?
Yes, both parents but I am a firm believer in nature vs. nurturer with environment generally being more important than genetics (does not always hold true though). Parents eat junk/SAD, influences children to adopt similar patterns of eating. My parents have risk for CVDx because they are lazy & follow a Standard American Diet. I can't say I have any genetic polymorphisms that make me susceptible to having high cholesterol
Kind of wanted to shock my MD TBH...she said I don't look like someone with TC of ~360mg/dL (same weight before & after around 165lbs, 6'0, doing high fat version of keto at the time); ratios of LDL:HDL still good. Just changed my macros around to demonstrate how powerful dietary changes can be on cholesterol & @ her recommendation simply because my LDL-C was too high (no talk whatsoever about meds because my ratio was still very good & her prescribing habits were not the typical guideline based ATP4 treat to X # LDL)
Diet @ the time having TC~360mg/dL consisted mostly of whole eggs, bacon, fish, coconut oil, & EVOO3 -
@psuLemon
You bring up very valid points. For the 15 years that I was on / off several different statins, my numbers didn’t decrease enough to warrant the severe myopathy. Here’s the medical reasoning behind it though... Nowadays, what concerns doctors more is the quality, (also quantity but def more so quality) of the cholesterol particles. Trying not to get too technical here.... there are 3 types of particles that are measured. The small dense particles, are like BB gun pellets wreaking havoc inside your body, drastically increasing your risk of atherosclerosis & cardiovascular disease. Ideally, you would have the light fluffy particles that just bounce around like beach balls inside of you. I, of course, have the small dense particles (coupled with my strong family history of heart disease), hence, my doctors are not happy at all with my stubbornness in continuing to refuse the meds.0 -
@pierinifitness
It’s funny how there’s still controversy over the eggs. The yolk has so much nutrition. I’m still eating eggs and I don’t think I’d ever stop, unless I had hardcore solid proof that it increases LDL.
0 -
@Keto_Vampire
Ok, 1st, pls tell me how I can reply within your response, ty, lol.
So I’m not sure I understood correctly.... are you saying your parents are high risk for heart disease because of their sedentary lifestyles & poor eating habits or b/c you have a family history of heart disease?
0 -
My mother on died of heart disease and my grandfather on my father side died of heart disease at 55. So yes there is some family history there.
Myself I wouldn't want the statin side effects that with the legs but I"m seeing more research that indicates possible dementia as long term effects of statins. I'd rather have the heartattack than lose my mind.
Now my family didn't eat well so I may not have the kind of strength of bad genes you have.
I have metabolic syndrome, I'm short and older so losing weight is hard for me. Counting calories often times doesn't really work for me. I'm hoping they finish the research into stomach biomes. Moderate daily exercise does normally make it where I can lose 0.25 pound per week with reduced calories. My feet are messed up right now making exercise difficult but I"m still working at it.
You seem to be losing weight. That should really help if you keep that up and depending on how far you have to left to go.
Have you tried daily consumption of komboucha? It was a study in ducks but they added koumboucha to their water up to 25% and reduced some of the cholesterol components by up to 50%. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267249196_The_effect_of_feeding_fermented_kombucha_tea_on_HLD_LDL_and_total_cholesterol_levels_in_the_duck_bloods
Yes I'm much more worried about the VLDL and CRP that just overall numbers. I'm currently eating healthy fats like salmon, walnuts, avacado. But probably next summer I will do a 40-60 day Ornish diet. Have you read about Ornish. My mom's heart surgeon, one of the best doctors I've met agree Ornish is great for actually reversing blockages (which is what the research supports) but people have trouble sticking to it. His original study was only like 3 weeks. I don't think I could do it for long periods of time but reversed some blockage. But I'm thinking every year or so doing a month or so to help reverse any I have. Right now I don't think I have much but a prevention isn't a bad thing right?0 -
newmein2013 wrote: »@GoodLardy
Yes, it does sound similar. My doctors explain it as the genetics are too strong for the nutrition (or even weight loss) to bring it down to within normal range. I guess they feel I’m hitting my head against a brick wall. My cardiologist begged me years ago to at least go on the maintenance dose. I just couldn’t handle the muscle pain. I have a very difficult time understanding how in today’s world of high tech medicine & natural holistic healing, there isn’t a way to do this. Thanks for your response.
I think this is a load of crap. Genetics load the gun, lifestyle pulls the trigger. For grins, please watch the movie Forks Over Knives and see a functional medicine professional.6 -
I’ve read about the Ornish Duet. I’m not really following any specific diet. But if I were to describe my diet, i would say it’s similar to Athens Mediterranean Diet and the Ornish Diet, just not as strict.
I hadn’t heard about statins causing dementia. Great, yet another reason to refuse it.
I wonder if u can do short workouts with resistance bands or dumbbells? Or maybe water aerobics?My mother on died of heart disease and my grandfather on my father side died of heart disease at 55. So yes there is some family history there.
Myself I wouldn't want the statin side effects that with the legs but I"m seeing more research that indicates possible dementia as long term effects of statins. I'd rather have the heartattack than lose my mind.
Now my family didn't eat well so I may not have the kind of strength of bad genes you have.
I have metabolic syndrome, I'm short and older so losing weight is hard for me. Counting calories often times doesn't really work for me. I'm hoping they finish the research into stomach biomes. Moderate daily exercise does normally make it where I can lose 0.25 pound per week with reduced calories. My feet are messed up right now making exercise difficult but I"m still working at it.
You seem to be losing weight. That should really help if you keep that up and depending on how far you have to left to go.
Have you tried daily consumption of komboucha? It was a study in ducks but they added koumboucha to their water up to 25% and reduced some of the cholesterol components by up to 50%. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267249196_The_effect_of_feeding_fermented_kombucha_tea_on_HLD_LDL_and_total_cholesterol_levels_in_the_duck_bloods
Yes I'm much more worried about the VLDL and CRP that just overall numbers. I'm currently eating healthy fats like salmon, walnuts, avacado. But probably next summer I will do a 40-60 day Ornish diet. Have you read about Ornish. My mom's heart surgeon, one of the best doctors I've met agree Ornish is great for actually reversing blockages (which is what the research supports) but people have trouble sticking to it. His original study was only like 3 weeks. I don't think I could do it for long periods of time but reversed some blockage. But I'm thinking every year or so doing a month or so to help reverse any I have. Right now I don't think I have much but a prevention isn't a bad thing right?
0 -
Yes, now this is exactly what I’m talking about! The documentary doesn’t state that much about genetics but if heart disease can be reversed through a plant based diet, why are doctors pushing the meds so badly?!newmein2013 wrote: »@GoodLardy
Yes, it does sound similar. My doctors explain it as the genetics are too strong for the nutrition (or even weight loss) to bring it down to within normal range. I guess they feel I’m hitting my head against a brick wall. My cardiologist begged me years ago to at least go on the maintenance dose. I just couldn’t handle the muscle pain. I have a very difficult time understanding how in today’s world of high tech medicine & natural holistic healing, there isn’t a way to do this. Thanks for your response.
I think this is a load of crap. Genetics load the gun, lifestyle pulls the trigger. For grins, please watch the movie Forks Over Knives and see a functional medicine professional.
0 -
newmein2013 wrote: »Yes, now this is exactly what I’m talking about! The documentary doesn’t state that much about genetics but if heart disease can be reversed through a plant based diet, why are doctors pushing the meds so badly?!newmein2013 wrote: »@GoodLardy
Yes, it does sound similar. My doctors explain it as the genetics are too strong for the nutrition (or even weight loss) to bring it down to within normal range. I guess they feel I’m hitting my head against a brick wall. My cardiologist begged me years ago to at least go on the maintenance dose. I just couldn’t handle the muscle pain. I have a very difficult time understanding how in today’s world of high tech medicine & natural holistic healing, there isn’t a way to do this. Thanks for your response.
I think this is a load of crap. Genetics load the gun, lifestyle pulls the trigger. For grins, please watch the movie Forks Over Knives and see a functional medicine professional.
Because doctors' long experience suggests that most people won't stick with dietary changes long enough for those to be effective.
When, after refusing statins, I lost enough weight to correct my bad cholesterol/triglycerides/blood pressure, the staff at my doctors' office were very, very surprised. Stunned, even. Almost no one ever actually does it. (Lots of people here on MFP do. Not very many in everyday life.)5 -
True. That’s why my dr gave me 1 year to see how far I can get doing this through nutrition & exercise. Although his training says you need the meds to fight the genetic component, I’m sure he’s secretly hoping this works.newmein2013 wrote: »Yes, now this is exactly what I’m talking about! The documentary doesn’t state that much about genetics but if heart disease can be reversed through a plant based diet, why are doctors pushing the meds so badly?!newmein2013 wrote: »@GoodLardy
Yes, it does sound similar. My doctors explain it as the genetics are too strong for the nutrition (or even weight loss) to bring it down to within normal range. I guess they feel I’m hitting my head against a brick wall. My cardiologist begged me years ago to at least go on the maintenance dose. I just couldn’t handle the muscle pain. I have a very difficult time understanding how in today’s world of high tech medicine & natural holistic healing, there isn’t a way to do this. Thanks for your response.
I think this is a load of crap. Genetics load the gun, lifestyle pulls the trigger. For grins, please watch the movie Forks Over Knives and see a functional medicine professional.
Because doctors' long experience suggests that most people won't stick with dietary changes long enough for those to be effective.
When, after refusing statins, I lost enough weight to correct my bad cholesterol/triglycerides/blood pressure, the staff at my doctors' office were very, very surprised. Stunned, even. Almost no one ever actually does it. (Lots of people here on MFP do. Not very many in everyday life.)
1 -
Lowered my LDL, Raised the HDL:LDL ratio and lowered my triglycerides from over 300 down to 45 with no medications.
Cut way down on carbs. Increased fatty meat and whole eggs intake.
Doctor thought I was telling her what I cut down when I said "whole eggs, sausage, bacon, pork, steak ..."1 -
Nice. Congrats! That happened to me years ago when I was on the Atkins diet. Do you have a family history of heart disease?0
-
As a nurse and one with elevated cholesterol and triglycerides I get it. I have started to eat oatmeal every morning, started taking fish oil supplements and cutting back/out the fatty greasy foods. I also take a low dose statin. I’ve started back to walking at least 3 times a week. I will repeat my labs in July. Good luck to you!0
-
I lost 50 pounds using Optavia plan. LDL actually didn’t go down. Dr stating must be genetic issue. Wants me to increase exercise then retest cholesterol in 6 months but if not lower then discuss meds. A friend told me to try the supplement Red Yeast Rice. It comes in pure form in capsule or powder to sprinkle on food. Im going to give it a try. Anyone here have any experience with that supplement?0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions