Nothing is useful after 2 years of trying I’m starting to losing it ( a little rant)

Hi , , I started my journey on 2020 , I use food scale and counting my calories as my method. Like everybody sometimes I exceed over the calories ( gathering, travel .. etc) then going back to eating healthy and counting calories Since the beginning of 2023 I stopped losing and I fluctuate 2 kg up and down. No matter what I do nothing is changing its like everything stopped working with me, and I still have not reached my goal. I know when you are close to your goal it is going to be slower but being stuck for 2 years!!!
I’m 32 years old female Height: 163 cm Weight: fluctuating between 58 to 60 kg I workout 3 times a week I try to hit 8000 to 10000 steps a day
I was eating around 1500 calories but if I work out more I become sooo hungry I don’t overeat or binge but definitely exceed my calories I tried eating around 1300 -1400 cals but it is hard to sustain it ( weirdly my stomach gets really bloated with painful gas sometimes if I eat that low ) especially with working out. I tried recomp for a few months but measurements were not changing and i was gaining weight on the scale so i stopped.
I know they are people who weigh less than me ( 40-50 kg) and able to lose more. I’m started to feel really depressed about it , I don’t know what am I doing wrong in this stage
Replies
-
Well, you're mid-range or a little higher on the BMI scale for a healthy weight, so yeah it's gonna be harder.
But if you are sure you're logging correctly, then you may have to still lower your calories. Are you logging every day, every meal? That's what it took for me. There's a balance to be found between your activity and your calories and weight, you can find it.
Are you trying to eat mostly whole foods? Hitting your Protein Goals? Getting enough fiber (i.e. vegetables, fruit, whole grains, nuts, legumes?) I find certain foods leave me hungrier sooner - like bread, sweet things, prepackaged meals, basically lower nutrition foods.
It is difficult to lose weight at the end, but it can be done. I was hungry for most of the last 15 pounds I had to lose. It took me nine months to lose that last 15 and it was very hard for me, I get it. It's a grind, for sure.
Keep working at it.
2 -
You need to look at the weekly calories you're taking in. Or even monthly which is easy to do with this app because you can look at it when you looked under the PROGRESS category after hitting MORE.
Unfortunately you're just taking in too many calories overall over a period of time.
4 -
it’s a process.. if you are looking at calories and weight loss strategy- from reading your post - you say you “going over calories” here and there.
If you aren’t losing weight, those cals are likely adding up. Track the days that you go over and add up those calories.
3 -
if I were in your shoes I would maybe try to up your step goal and add an extra gym session or two. Our bodies adapt so quickly and changing things up sometime will trick the body.
0 -
Sorry, but that's not how it works. The calorie expenditure of most exercises depends largely on bodyweight, duration, distance or weight, and to some extend on speed. The body doesn't start to burn less calories for the same activity after a while.
6 -
You don't burn that many calories through exercise. A few extra sessions wouldn't allow enough of a calorie burn to offset eating at maintenance calories
0 -
I had to do a little math to put things in perspective for myself. You are 163cm (~5'3") and have weighed 58-60kg (128 -132#) for over 2 years, and there are others that are your height and 40-50kg (88-110#). Two years is a long time for sure. It does mean your net calories are too high on average to lose weight.
I'm sure it is true that there are women who are 163cm at 40kg (88#), but I'm not sure it's healthy or maintainable. That being said 50kg (110#), isn't unreasonable at your height, but it will be difficult. I'm 5'1" (155cm) and I maintained 105# (48kg) for a few years, but it was too tough, and I was never satisfied. I wanted a flat @#!!$ stomach. I cut my calories to 1300-1400 (like you) and didn't eat back many exercise calories, cut out food groups (dairy, and carbs) and exercised a lot (cardio junkie). For me the combination lead to a fairly flat tummy and extreme fatigue. I just couldn't keep it up. It put me on the side lines for over a year, in which time I gained more than the 10 vanity pounds I had lost by being excessive.
My suggestion is that you worry less about the number on the scale. Firm up that petite frame by focusing on what you eat by skipping the things that bloat you, and staying within your calorie goal. Add a full body strength routine to any cardio you already do. Eat enough calories to stay strong, for me that was 1400 + 1/2 my cardio calories (this is for me personally and everyone is different). I didn't really add calories for lifting, they were negligible next to my cardio burn.
Don't get intimidated by "YOU MUST LIFT HEAVY" crowd. Strength routines can be anything from body weight exercises to heavy lifting, as long as you tax the muscles. Because my lower body tends to be more advanced than my upper body, I prefer a combination of body weight exercises for upper body (pull ups (assisted at first), dips, a variety of planks) combined with heavy lifting for the lower body (dead lifts, weighted squats, etc.).
Again, this is anecdotal, from my experience, but I was much happier (even in a bikini) at 115 than I was at 105.
11 -
I like pridesabtch's balanced advice: More starkly, you can reduce calorie intake, or you can increase activity, or you can do a combination.
If you aren't logging the over-goal days, start doing that, even if you have to estimate. A solid couple months of logging every single thing every single day, plus your weight-change trend over those couple of months, will give you a good, personalized insight on your personal calorie needs. I'm sure you know it's vital to log every bite, lick, taste, beverage, condiment, dressing, cooking oil, etc.
When it comes to feeling full and energetic on reduced calories, food choices can matter . . . even food timing may matter. Different foods or timings are more filling for different people, so it may take some experimentation.
That said, common things people find filling are protein, high=-fiber foods, and high volume foods that are low in calories (such as but not limited to lots of veggies). Many people find that refined or highly processed foods are not as filling as foods like meat, fish, veggies, fruits, and whole grains, so if your eating includes a lot of processed foods, that would be a thing to try changing. Getting less than ideal nutrition can also hurt energy level and spike appetite.
Nutrition is not just macros, though adequate protein and fats are certainly important. (IME, too many women cutting calories shortcut protein or fats or both.) A well-rounded range of vitamins, minerals, prebiotics, probiotics, and other beneficial phytochemicals can also influence appetite and energy level.
When it comes to activity, exercise increase is usually a small contributor in the big picture. If you can fit more in your life and maintain good overall life balance, sure, do that. If you do, increase it gradually, and don't overdo for current fitness level: Overdoing is counterproductive for either weight loss (because of fatigue effects) or fitness (because of under-recovery).
If you haven't thought about daily life activity, that's an area that some people can increase and get a meaningful calorie-burn bump: It's more of a contributor than many people think. There's a thread here where many MFP-ers share their ideas and experiences about that:
I hear your frustration, and understand. But I also understand that there's no magical solution, just maybe a few tweaks that can gradually lead in the right direction. It will continue to take patience, perseverance, experimentation. Anger and frustration are understandable, but maybe not helpful.
As a final thought, have you spoken with your doctor about factors that may be limiting your weight loss, or causing bloating? There are blood tests that can help detect nutritional deficiencies or relevant health conditions.
I hope you're able to find a solution!
2 -
163cm — 58kg — F:32: (BMI) 21.8 💪
163cm — 50kg — F:32: (BMI) 18.8
163cm — 40kg — F:32: (BMI) 15.1 👎️» I know they are people who weigh less than me ( 40-50 kg) and able to lose more
I was with you till this last part.If you know people who are 163cm tall, weight 40-50kg, and are both willing and able to lose more…. then you're hanging out with an unhealthy crowd.
7 -
I’m your height and I’m my 40s, I also have PCOS without insulin resistance. I need to eat 1200-1300 calories to maintain 115lbs. If I eat 1500-1600 I gain back up to around the weight you are at now. We burn a lot less through exercise than you might think! I
1 -
consider watching this coach viva video on the phases of weight loss.
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 395.2K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.6K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.2K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 446 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.2K Motivation and Support
- 8.2K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.9K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions