Olive oil, how much is too much?
karin_02
Posts: 7 Member
I'm pretty much in love with olive oil and was under the understanding that it was a 'good fat' and that you can pretty much have as much as you like. Until recently when I saw a cooking show and the guy said it was very fattening....
I know it's fat, but does it really cause weight gain if its the only fat your really eating? i know a table spoon has like 15g's of fat (overall I had 3tbls of it), but its all good for you!
I'm confused, the question is; should I cut down on my olive oil, or is it a good part of my diet?
I know it's fat, but does it really cause weight gain if its the only fat your really eating? i know a table spoon has like 15g's of fat (overall I had 3tbls of it), but its all good for you!
I'm confused, the question is; should I cut down on my olive oil, or is it a good part of my diet?
0
Replies
-
Barring any medical conditions, if you are in a calorie deficit you will lose weight. If you are in a surplus you will gain. Have as much as you want. If you're hitting your numbers you're fine.0
-
It's good fat, but you still need to keep within your calorie allowance if you don't want to gain weight from it. Excess calories are excess calories.0
-
As long as you count the calories thats all that matters.
3 tbls has about 300 calories. If those fit in your diet then good.
The actual fat content doesn't matter. As long as it fits your macros and/or your calories.0 -
I like olive oil too, the staple of a great meditaranean diet. The answer lies in what else you are eating: if you're keeping to goal cals and watching your overall nutrients then don't stress it: olive oil IS great for you. Having said that, it is an energy dense food so a little moderation is a good idea (as with most foods btw!)0
-
FYI it's really nothing special health wise if you cook with it. The health benefits are realized when it's eaten uncooked.0
-
1 gram of fat contains 9 calories. As long as you fit those calories into your weight loss and nutritional goals, there is no such thing as too much olive oil. It is good for you.0
-
FYI it's really nothing special health wise if you cook with it. The health benefits are realized when it's eaten uncooked.
I'll add to that that it has to be stored properly and used quickly. Too many people buy in large quantities, store it over the oven, etc.
It goes rancid, it loses it's "healthy" benefits, etc when not handled with care.0 -
As long as you count the calories thats all that matters.
3 tbls has about 300 calories. If those fit in your diet then good.
The actual fat content doesn't matter. As long as it fits your macros and/or your calories.
All the kinds I have ever used are 70 cal/tbls - that's only 210 for 3.0 -
I use it for both cooking and dressing salads, maybe i should use less in cooking then.0
-
As long as you count the calories thats all that matters.
3 tbls has about 300 calories. If those fit in your diet then good.
The actual fat content doesn't matter. As long as it fits your macros and/or your calories.
All the kinds I have ever used are 70 cal/tbls - that's only 210 for 3.
What Olive oil are you using?? I've never found one under 120 calories per Tbsp0 -
My olive oil bottle said 120 calories for Tablespoon. I can eat my real Ranch dressing for the same calories!!0
-
Olive oil tends to put me over my fat goal, but I stay under my calorie goal.... is that ok as its good fat? or still a weight loss no-no?0
-
Olive oil tends to put me over my fat goal, but I stay under my calorie goal.... is that ok as its good fat? or still a weight loss no-no?
Still fine.
But watch that you're not consuming so much fat that you don't have room in the budget for protein.0 -
I use it for both cooking and dressing salads, maybe i should use less in cooking then.0
-
My olive oil bottle said 120 calories for Tablespoon. I can eat my real Ranch dressing for the same calories!!
yea, but olive oil is great for cardiovascular health, and the saturated fat in ranch dressing is not0 -
Olive oil is a healthy fat when it's in the form of an olive. Once you strip the olive of its fiber, nutrients (most) and cellular structure, all you are left with is the fat. Olive oil damages the endothelial cells that line your arteries. These cells protect our blood flow and prevent cholesterol and plaques from building up on the cell walls. I guess if you don't have heart disease and you don't mind consuming high quantities of empty calories, you may enjoy your oil in moderation.
Once I quit adding oils to my food, I much prefered the natural flavor. I hate going to a restaurant and being served an oily dish.0 -
For cooking, you are better off using oils that can take higher temps. Stuff like safflower oil or avocado oil, for examples. Mostly you don't want to have your oil smoking from being too hot, that's not a good thing :drinker:
nor is it good to have anything "carmelized" from what I've heard...and that includes crusty melted cheese0 -
Olive oil is a healthy fat when it's in the form of an olive. Once you strip the olive of its fiber, nutrients (most) and cellular structure, all you are left with is the fat. Olive oil damages the endothelial cells that line your arteries. These cells protect our blood flow and prevent cholesterol and plaques from building up on the cell walls. I guess if you don't have heart disease and you don't mind consuming high quantities of empty calories, you may enjoy your oil in moderation.
Once I quit adding oils to my food, I much prefered the natural flavor. I hate going to a restaurant and being served an oily dish.
Could you please post a histological study that confirms that olive oil damages the endothelial layer of blood vessels?0 -
Olive oil is a healthy fat when it's in the form of an olive. Once you strip the olive of its fiber, nutrients (most) and cellular structure, all you are left with is the fat. Olive oil damages the endothelial cells that line your arteries. These cells protect our blood flow and prevent cholesterol and plaques from building up on the cell walls. I guess if you don't have heart disease and you don't mind consuming high quantities of empty calories, you may enjoy your oil in moderation.
Once I quit adding oils to my food, I much prefered the natural flavor. I hate going to a restaurant and being served an oily dish.
This is the first I have ever heard olive oil is UN-healthy! It's usually praised as a food of utter health, where did you learn it was bad for you?0 -
Olive oil is a healthy fat when it's in the form of an olive. Once you strip the olive of its fiber, nutrients (most) and cellular structure, all you are left with is the fat. Olive oil damages the endothelial cells that line your arteries. These cells protect our blood flow and prevent cholesterol and plaques from building up on the cell walls. I guess if you don't have heart disease and you don't mind consuming high quantities of empty calories, you may enjoy your oil in moderation.
Once I quit adding oils to my food, I much prefered the natural flavor. I hate going to a restaurant and being served an oily dish.
This is the first I have ever heard olive oil is UN-healthy! It's usually praised as a food of utter health, where did you learn it was bad for you?
It is healthy. Please don't believe all the nonsense you read on these forums. If you are concerned ask your doctor, or check a reputable medical site (e.g. hospital, medical university, etc.)0 -
Umm. Bertolli?
I'm in Canada though? Or hey, I could have been reading the label wrong all this time, but I'm pretty sure I haven't since I remember looking at it and thinking "wow, same calories as Crisco.."0 -
Umm. Bertolli?
I'm in Canada though? Or hey, I could have been reading the label wrong all this time, but I'm pretty sure I haven't since I remember looking at it and thinking "wow, same calories as Crisco.."0 -
Olive oil is a healthy fat when it's in the form of an olive. Once you strip the olive of its fiber, nutrients (most) and cellular structure, all you are left with is the fat. Olive oil damages the endothelial cells that line your arteries. These cells protect our blood flow and prevent cholesterol and plaques from building up on the cell walls. I guess if you don't have heart disease and you don't mind consuming high quantities of empty calories, you may enjoy your oil in moderation.
Once I quit adding oils to my food, I much prefered the natural flavor. I hate going to a restaurant and being served an oily dish.
This is the first I have ever heard olive oil is UN-healthy! It's usually praised as a food of utter health, where did you learn it was bad for you?
It is healthy. Please don't believe all the nonsense you read on these forums. If you are concerned ask your doctor, or check a reputable medical site (e.g. hospital, medical university, etc.)
It is one thing to disagree based upon your own educated research, but it's another to label someone's comment as "nonsense".
Dr Robert Vogel of the University of Maryland did a study on the effects of olive oil after consuming it. He found that it slowed the blood flow (referred to as FMD) by 31%. This results in damage to the endothelial cells and diminishes their capacity to produce nitric oxide. You may read the report at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11079642
Similar results have been found in later studies.0 -
It is one thing to disagree based upon your own educated research, but it's another to label someone's comment as "nonsense".
Dr Robert Vogel of the University of Maryland did a study on the effects of olive oil after consuming it. He found that it slowed the blood flow (referred to as FMD) by 31%. This results in damage to the endothelial cells and diminishes their capacity to produce nitric oxide. You may read the report at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11079642
Similar results have been found in later studies.
Dr Vogel has a LOT of publications that are very good, but when you research this article on pubmed, there are 6 other articles, all containing different opinions on the same issues. I didn't take the time to compare each study or prepare a meta-analysis, but I did notice that the study you reference only used 10 subjects...0 -
I use a spray bottle for salads and a doctoral student in nutrition told me it could be used for cooking (can be if you do not exceed 180 degree?)0
-
I'm not sure. When I looked it up, the smoke point of olive oil is much higher...like 320-460 (varies by how "light" it is).
And that sounds like a healthy range, because chefs on tv frequently use olive oil on roasted veggies that are cooked in that range.
Although 180C = 356F, so maybe we're both right0 -
oh yeah I meant 180 °C, I am french0
-
Olive oil is a healthy fat when it's in the form of an olive. Once you strip the olive of its fiber, nutrients (most) and cellular structure, all you are left with is the fat. Olive oil damages the endothelial cells that line your arteries. These cells protect our blood flow and prevent cholesterol and plaques from building up on the cell walls. I guess if you don't have heart disease and you don't mind consuming high quantities of empty calories, you may enjoy your oil in moderation.
Once I quit adding oils to my food, I much prefered the natural flavor. I hate going to a restaurant and being served an oily dish.
This is the first I have ever heard olive oil is UN-healthy! It's usually praised as a food of utter health, where did you learn it was bad for you?
It is healthy. Please don't believe all the nonsense you read on these forums. If you are concerned ask your doctor, or check a reputable medical site (e.g. hospital, medical university, etc.)
It is one thing to disagree based upon your own educated research, but it's another to label someone's comment as "nonsense".
Dr Robert Vogel of the University of Maryland did a study on the effects of olive oil after consuming it. He found that it slowed the blood flow (referred to as FMD) by 31%. This results in damage to the endothelial cells and diminishes their capacity to produce nitric oxide. You may read the report at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11079642
Similar results have been found in later studies.
Suggesting people dispel nonsense by checking out reputable scientific or medical sources is good advice, Otherwise you end up believing posts that offer one or two random studies to "prove" a point on a subject for which there are hundreds, maybe even thousands, of studies.0 -
Olive oil is good fat but it is still a fat. I don't think you should go overboard just because it's a better fat then others.0
-
It is one thing to disagree based upon your own educated research, but it's another to label someone's comment as "nonsense".
Dr Robert Vogel of the University of Maryland did a study on the effects of olive oil after consuming it. He found that it slowed the blood flow (referred to as FMD) by 31%. This results in damage to the endothelial cells and diminishes their capacity to produce nitric oxide. You may read the report at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11079642
Similar results have been found in later studies.
Dr Vogel has a LOT of publications that are very good, but when you research this article on pubmed, there are 6 other articles, all containing different opinions on the same issues. I didn't take the time to compare each study or prepare a meta-analysis, but I did notice that the study you reference only used 10 subjects...A high-oleic and linoleic acid meal has recently been shown to impair FMD in comparison with a low-fat meal
Also the quality of olive oil and the phenolic content does influence outcomes. The platform that EVOO is less healthy than canola is not a good one to be preaching from. Putting this study in perspective in relation to diet is not considered, only the overall effect of fat on FMD. Hopefully we know that olive oil or any monounsaturated fat or omega's are healthy in regards to diet. imo0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions