Cardio doesn't help you lose weight...
Replies
-
I hate exercise. I have always hated exercise. I will probably always hate it!!
Back in 2002, I joined Weight Watchers. I followed the plan Monday through Friday, and ate whatever I wanted on Saturday and Sunday. I did not exercise at all. I lost anywhere from 2 to 5 lbs each week. I noticed when I ate more protien, I lost more weight. The information that I received from Weight Watchers basically said that I could eat more if I exercised. I chose to eat less and exercise none. The program worked for me. When I stopped following the program, I began eating more and more. The weight did come back because my diet changed.
What you are describing is the classic pattern of the overwhelming failure rate of "diet only" programs.
Anyone can lose weight through all sorts of intervention. Weight loss "success" is only achieved when that weight has been kept off for at least two years. That's where the "diet only" (or diet pills, drugs, HCG, etc) plans fail 95% of the time and exercise-based programs succeed at a much higher rate.0 -
Cardio burns fat. Lifting weights by itself will not burn the fat.
I love cardio. I'll pick it over lifting weights any day.
Cardio doesn't burn fat. Cardio improves cardiovascular health and conditioning as well as it creates more of a calorie deficit because it burns calories.
Eating a calorie deficit = burns fat.
Period.
Cardio creates the deficit = burns fat0 -
Cardio doesn't burn fat. Cardio improves cardiovascular health and conditioning as well as it creates more of a calorie deficit because it burns calories.
Eating a calorie deficit = burns fat.
Period.
That pretty much sums it up.0 -
Cardio burns fat. Lifting weights by itself will not burn the fat.
I love cardio. I'll pick it over lifting weights any day.
Cardio doesn't burn fat. Cardio improves cardiovascular health and conditioning as well as it creates more of a calorie deficit because it burns calories.
Eating a calorie deficit = burns fat.
Period.
Cardio creates the deficit = burns fat
diet alone can create the deficit too. so can just weights, so can cardio. Cardio in and of itself does not burn fat, cardio in a caloric deficit will burn fat, but in that case so would weight training.
The main benefits to exercise are not weight loss, that can be achieved from diet alone.0 -
Bump......0
-
If you want to lose weight you MUST be doing BOTH cardio and strength.
^ Neither of these are necessary to lose weight. Both are helpful but to say it's a MUST is absurd.
Language can be such a tricky thing.0 -
Should have said if cardio creates deficit then it burns fat. Oops my bad. There's no way for cardio ALONE to burn fat.0
-
I went through metabolic assessments at my health club (O2 uptake evaluation using New Leaf equipment) and the program they recommended has worked for me. The basic notion is: there is a zone of cardio activity (based on heart rate) that optimizes weight loss aka the fat burning zone ... if you walk too slow or run too fast, you're not at the optimal zone so you won't burn as much fat as you would in the "zone". Here's a couple of pages from about.com that discuss exercise intensity and weight loss:
http://exercise.about.com/od/weightloss/a/The-Truth-About-The-Fat-Burning-Zone.htm
http://exercise.about.com/od/cardioworkouts/a/Cardio-Workout-Program-For-Weight-Loss.htm
Your success is coming from the volume and mix of the program, not because of the "fat burning zone". This is my biggest complaint with the New Leaf system and the clubs that offer that service.
The fuel substrate used during exercise has no effect on overall fat oxidation (fat loss). In my discussions with the "trainers" at New Leaf, the good ones are starting to realize this and some of their newer printouts emphasize overall caloric expenditure rather than "fat burning", but many clubs have purchased the entire system as a "product" and parrot the boilerplate language without really understanding the science.
Metabolic testing has many uses and benefits. IMO, New Leaf has not worked as hard as they could to give people the most factual information.0 -
I'd hate to see anybody discouraged from doing either, honestly.I have always heard the opposite - that cardio is the calorie burner but strength training is great for retaining lean muscle mass and thus keeping the metabolism up. Regardless, cardio is good for your overall health so I hate to see them discouraging anyone from doing it.
Sometimes there is misinformation on here.
Totally agree!0 -
Haha, I had a debate about this with a friend the other day. He is taking some type of exercise science in college right now. He was convinced that eating properly was not the main factor. I tried to help him understand what's being said below.
Most important rule to weight loss is caloric deficit. Calories consumed vs Calories used. As people have stated, cardio isn't what's burning the fat. The reason muscle development (lifting heavy weights) can be considered fat burning is that once you increase your muscle mass, your body will burn more calories at rest. Whereas cardio isn't going to add much muscle mass and may actually reduce your muscle mass if done exessively with improper eating. Lower muscle mass would mean less calories burned at rest.
So in theory, he is correct. Your eating is most important. As someone else mentioned though, it's hard for many people to diet only. There are many other benifits of exercise other than weight loss too.Cardio burns fat. Lifting weights by itself will not burn the fat.
I love cardio. I'll pick it over lifting weights any day.
Cardio doesn't burn fat. Cardio improves cardiovascular health and conditioning as well as it creates more of a calorie deficit because it burns calories.
Eating a calorie deficit = burns fat.
Period.
Cardio creates the deficit = burns fat
diet alone can create the deficit too. so can just weights, so can cardio. Cardio in and of itself does not burn fat, cardio in a caloric deficit will burn fat, but in that case so would weight training.
The main benefits to exercise are not weight loss, that can be achieved from diet alone.0 -
Cardio burns fat. Lifting weights by itself will not burn the fat.
I love cardio. I'll pick it over lifting weights any day.
Cardio doesn't burn fat. Cardio improves cardiovascular health and conditioning as well as it creates more of a calorie deficit because it burns calories.
Eating a calorie deficit = burns fat.
Period.
Cardio creates the deficit = burns fat
diet alone can create the deficit too. so can just weights, so can cardio. Cardio in and of itself does not burn fat, cardio in a caloric deficit will burn fat, but in that case so would weight training.
The main benefits to exercise are not weight loss, that can be achieved from diet alone.
Again, it kind of depends how you use the terms. Technically, yes, weight loss can be achieved from diet alone. However, since the long-term failure rate of "diet only" programs is around 95%, can it really be said that "weight loss" has actually been achieved?
OTOH, about the only weight loss programs that DO achieve permanent changes are the ones that include regular, vigorous exercise.0 -
Cardio burns fat. Lifting weights by itself will not burn the fat.
Yes, lifting weights by itself does burn fat. You're completley wrong on that point and I don't know why you keep repeating it as if it's a fact.0 -
so have I and I am living proof...I hate cardio. Stick to a few HIIT and thats it. I love lifting weights and I love eating lots of food! But hey this lady is always right...right!:huh:Still can't believe a worker at the gym told me this. I have lost 34 lbs. recently and went looking for a second gym near work (I lose some motivation on the drive home). The person showing me around said the weight loss was due to diet changes and not all of the excercise since I don't do weights. I do cardio 5-6 days a week, crunches nearly every day I work out and pilates for about 20 min. nearly every day, go to the class twice weekly. How discouraging this would be to someone who was planning to walk/run only.
Cardio burns fat. A lot of people want people to believe that lifting weights or should I say, lifting heavy is the answer and it's not. A person can lift weights until they are blue in the face, but that will not make the fat go away. It will develop the muscles under fat.
I don't think this is true.. do you have solid research to back this up? From my understanding, I've read otherwise.0 -
my dad went to an obesity conference last year. apparently the latest theory is that if you eat enough calories, cardio helps you lose weight. If you dont eat enough then weights and strength training helps you lose. Dont ask me why!?0
-
I believe it. I hurt my knee and went 3 weeks without any exercise and I sit at a desk all day. I stayed under my 1200 calories a day and lost 1 to 1 1/2 pounds a week same as when I was exercising.0
-
Personally, i agree with the guy at the gym. You didnt have to workout to lose that weight. I believe it is mostly on your diet, but this is also why i dont eat my exercise calories back. That doesnt make any sense to me and it doesnt work for me either.
Exercises is excellent for health reasons, toning and will help your body as you age, but i dont think it is necessary for weight loss.Still can't believe a worker at the gym told me this. I have lost 34 lbs. recently and went looking for a second gym near work (I lose some motivation on the drive home). The person showing me around said the weight loss was due to diet changes and not all of the excercise since I don't do weights. I do cardio 5-6 days a week, crunches nearly every day I work out and pilates for about 20 min. nearly every day, go to the class twice weekly. How discouraging this would be to someone who was planning to walk/run only.0 -
this!!!!! ffs this!!!!
Even though she has me "ignored", I feel I need to rebut her misconception, so that nobody else falls for it.
What did you read?
I don't think this is true.. do you have solid research to back this up? From my understanding, I've read otherwise.Cardio burns fat. A lot of people want people to believe that lifting weights or should I say, lifting heavy is the answer and it's not. A person can lift weights until they are blue in the face, but that will not make the fat go away. It will develop the muscles under fat.
Hell, even your beloved eHow says it burns fat! (http://www.ehow.com/how_4500347_burn-fat-weight-lifting.html) :laugh:
Here is one article with credible sources: http://www.livestrong.com/article/382599-does-weight-lifting-burn-fat/0 -
I've seen many a heavy weights run their @sses off on treadmills and drip buckets of sweat without much progress. I admire their endurance. It sure is better than mine.0
-
Why does everything have to turn into an argument? We are all entitled to our own opinions, but when knowledgeable posters who have had success at improving their fitness post irrefutable facts, that is probably the time to allow your opinion to be swayed.
Let's not be silly, here. Learning something isn't backing down from an argument. It's education.0 -
Yes, lifting weights by itself does burn fat. You're completley wrong on that point and I don't know why you keep repeating it as if it's a fact.
It doesn't.0 -
Also, why dont you test the theory yourself. Try eating your basic calories for two weeks...see what happens. I injured my foot, so ive been doing this for two weeks and no difference for me in weightloss0
-
lost 44 lbs in 3 months doing EXCLUSIVELY cardio . Just now starting stregnth training now that the "biggest looser" contest is done ..0
-
Cardio doesn't burn fat. Cardio improves cardiovascular health and conditioning as well as it creates more of a calorie deficit because it burns calories.
Eating a calorie deficit = burns fat.
Period.
Cardio burns fat.0 -
I just wanted a clear up a few misconceptions in this thread.
1. Currently there is a "backlash" against cardio for weight loss. This is because for the past several decades cardio has been touted as the "end all be all" of weight loss. Recent research has actually demonstrated that interval training and resistance training are probably superior to cardio for weight loss, and as a result there has been a huge backlash. However, that doesn't mean that you can't use cardio for weight loss, OF COURSE YOU CAN!!! Anyone who says otherwise is a moron. It's just that cardio isn't the only or best way to lose weight.
2. Part of the reason cardio often fails for weight loss is because people do it incorrectly. The "fat burning zone" is a big reason for people failing to work out in a way that will benefit them the most.
3. While it's true that diet is important for weight loss, it's actually a very bad idea to diet without exercising. You'll lose BOTH fat and muscle if you diet w/o exercise. Then, when the weight comes back, it'll come back just as fat. This can lead to a viscious cycle, the end result being the dreaded "skinny fat" condition.
4. The best exercise regimen is, Ta da, the one that you'll actually do! That said, you have to push yourself and continually make progress. If you hang back in the "fat burning zone," with endurance cardio, and never increase your speed, then you'll quickly plateau and fail to lose much weight.0 -
People say it's all diet, and while it does seem to be mostly diet for me, I swear I AM losing more weight on the days I do cardio (even when eating the exercise calories back). There has to be some individual variation if everyone has such strong opinions one way or another.0
-
PCBF
I've been waiting to use that. *giggles*0 -
People say it's all diet, and while it does seem to be mostly diet for me, I swear I AM losing more weight on the days I do cardio (even when eating the exercise calories back). There has to be some individual variation if everyone has such strong opinions one way or another.
Keep in mind that exercise also increases your metabolism for 1-2 days after the exercise session. So if you burn 500 calories running, and then eat 500 calories back, you'll still be burning additional calories as your body rebuilds your muscles and strengthens them.0 -
What did you read?Cardio burns fat. A lot of people want people to believe that lifting weights or should I say, lifting heavy is the answer and it's not. A person can lift weights until they are blue in the face, but that will not make the fat go away. It will develop the muscles under fat.
I don't think this is true.. do you have solid research to back this up? From my understanding, I've read otherwise.
[/quote]
I cant tell you everything Ive read but I have read a lot online lately, and yes I know everything online isnt true. But from my understanding losing weight comes from calorie deficit, whether it be eating lose calories, burning calories by cardio or burning calories by strength training.0 -
I find that hard to believe... How can cardio exercises, that keep you moving, not help you lose weight?0
-
When I say something, people think I'm arguing, but when other people say something, they think the person is giving knowledge. I don't have time to fight with people. If a person believes I'm wrong, then fine. Use the ignore button.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions