So I just started working out, and I'm losing nothing?!
bms34b
Posts: 401 Member
Alright MFPers. I've been on here for a while and I've lost around 26 pounds. All of that weight loss was from dieting alone. This last week (roughly, every day since saturday) I've been exercising - usually 20 minutes of elliptical or arc trainer and 20ish minutes of some sort of bike. I've been counting calories and I swear I haven't cheated!
I should have lost a little, at least. I've got my stuff set to one pound per week. I haven't lost ANYTHING. I'm just frustrated.
Is there a scientific explanation to why this is happening so I can keep myself from getting discouraged? When can I expect this pattern to stop?
I should have lost a little, at least. I've got my stuff set to one pound per week. I haven't lost ANYTHING. I'm just frustrated.
Is there a scientific explanation to why this is happening so I can keep myself from getting discouraged? When can I expect this pattern to stop?
0
Replies
-
I am in the same boat. I started dieting first and lost around 8 lbs then when I incorporated working out, it stopped. I haven't lost a pound since saturday and I am ALWAYS under my calorie intake. It makes me work even harder because I havent lost a single pound but my clothes are looser. I think we might be gaining muscle.0
-
Are you eating back the calories you burn from exercising? That could be the problem. Also if you are starting to build muscle you could be seeing a weight gain but really losing fat.0
-
It just takes time!! If you have not been exercising at all, it may be just your body is taking time to wake up to the changes. Please be more patient, weight loss takes time!! You may of hit a plateau also, so exercise, anchange to diet may help. Also because you are exercising, make sure you are eating more protien, and drinking more water, and eating back your calories, this will help!! Good Luck!0
-
I can't see your diary but ..
Eat back your workout calories.
If you aren't lifting weights, start.
Those are my first two suggestions.0 -
I am eating back some. Still my intake is around 1400 or 1500 a day, maybe 1600 if I really worked out hard.0
-
If your muscles are a little sore, they're probably retaining water. Keep at it, and drink tons of water! =]0
-
Well just remember that MFP has already provided a deficit so you do want to get as close to eating all the calories for your day.
Oh and like others said, it takes time and sometimes you have to switch it up. Try something new for cardio or outside of the gym completely.0 -
Diary now public! I do need to start lifting weights, I'm just not really sure on how to do any of the free weight stuff. And YES my muscles are sore, not by a ton, but I can definitely feel it. Water - I can do that!0
-
You will get a muscle weight gain for a few weeks, so just keep it up. It will balance out eventually and you will see wt loss again.0
-
A few things I notice immediately (I only looked back a few days):
1. You are not logging any water. Are you drinking it? Especially when you are working out your body needs more water.
2. It seems like you're not always eating full meals. For example, I would say that you should include a protein, carb, and fruit/veggie for all of the big three meals (Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner). There were a few days that all you ate for lunch was a bagel and cream cheese. When you workout, you need to fuel your body correctly before and after your workouts.
3. Do you eat any protein right after you workout? This will help your body repair muscles that you used while working out.
4. Start lifting weights/circuit training. What kind of cardio are you doing? Do you change it often?0 -
iuangina:
1. I drink loads of water. I'm a vocalist, and whether I'm working out or not I never have trouble getting in 8 or 9 glasses of water, so I don't usually bother to log.
2. This is a good point! I guess the reason I do a bagel/cream cheese is for two reasons: 1. low calories and 2. I'm running between classes and don't have a lunch break every day. I hadn't thought of my meals in protein,carb, fruit and veggie means though, so I'll definitely take that into account.
3. No. I should. Maybe I'll start packing a protein shake or protein bar that will be good on the run and also be a part of my lunch? I usually work out at 10am.
4. I intend to start lifting. I usually do arc trainer or elliptical, and sometimes add bike. I'm open to other suggestions, but I don't really know what to do.0 -
give it some more time, you should see a drop soon. make sure your getting enought water. and remember muscle weigh more than fat so you should start seeing a loss in inches.0
-
Stick with it! It can be frustrating until your body figures out what you're doing. I was stuck at 5 pounds lost for EVER it felt like, then suddenly I dropped 3 1/2 pounds overnight. I'm guessing it's water retention fom the exercise. Plus, there are so many other great benfits of working out - more energy, better sleep. It is a great habit to get into!0
-
80% is what you eat. I workout like crazy but I only loose when I cut back on calories and processed foods. egg whites and fresh produce (i know it gets old) but it works0
-
If your working out, make sure you eat back all or close to all your earned extra calories from working out! That may be the problem...sometimes its hard to wrap your head around it, but if your active, you need to eat more to have better results!!!0
-
When you're doing the elliptical or bike, are you using the resistance button? You /should/ be drowning in sweat by the time you get off those things in twenty minutes. Resistance is SO much more important and beneficial than speed will ever be on those devices.0
-
Maybe you're building up the muscles that's why there in no weight loss.0
-
I never thought to eat back calories. thanks!:happy:
url=http://www.myfitnesspal.com/weight-loss-ticker][/url]
Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Nutrition Facts For Foods0 -
Don't give up! You body will gain muscle from excersising. And as we've all heard before... "muscle weighs more than fat". Don't pay too much attention to the number on the scale. Your body will start to tighten and tone the more you work out!
Good luck!0 -
Are you doing the Turbofire DVD set??? or did you do it??? I was looking at your weightloss ticker....0
-
Maybe you're building up the muscles that's why there in no weight loss.
Physiologically speaking, It takes 6 to 8 weeks to actually start "building" muscle. You will notice gains in strength sooner than that, but those are neurological as your brain and nerves coordinate and learn how to recruit more muscle fibers when you lift, thus you'll feel stronger.
No matter what, keep exercising and worry about inches rather than weight loss. You seem to be eating back your calories and not in excess. If you haven't workout before, you body may just be in shock and trying to adjust to get used to it As some one else said, exercise is good for you in general, not just for weight loss.0 -
Maybe you're building up the muscles that's why there in no weight loss.
with 5 days of cardio?0 -
This would be a great time to take your measurements and do a reality check on how your clothes are fitting.
I have just restarted MFP, but when I was working out regularly (I use to be very athletic), plateaus were not uncommon. I'd gain muscle, lose fat and the scales remained the same... BUT my measurements would change drastically!
That is one reason I love MFP. Not only should we weigh-in regularly, but we should be taking those measurements as well.0 -
Its only been 5 days!!! You should weigh in less, helps me a lot. This always happens to me when I up exercise or change it up, but then I get a big drop. I expect it now and wait for the big drop. Give it another week and you should see results. You look quite slim already so you do need to eat quite a few of your calories back. My advice? Ignore the scales for a week or so, then check... You may get a nice surprise! X0
-
The scale is our worst enemy..buy a tape measure (for clothing or bodies) and start measuring you will see a difference that way if you do all the above..I know it's still irritating to not see a drop on the scale, I have been there done that and still do it from time to time..but I know I am losing inches and muscle does weigh more than fat..and most of the time when you start working out you always actually gain a few pounds but still lose the inches eventually...also remember like stated above eat your calories..MFP has already deducted for your goal weigh loss..if you don't eat enough your body goes into starvation mode.0
-
This week? Get back to us in 1 or 2 months and evaluate then.0
-
I use to have a personal trainer MANY years ago and she told me that once you start working out, you start gaining muscle (even if you do cardio alone) so be patient and give it a couple of weeks. Congrats on loosing 26 lbs, keep the working out up and I promise you will see a difference SOON!0
-
Ok here we go again.
Read this
http://body-improvements.com/resources/eat/
And cardio doesnt build muscle.0 -
have you worked out before??? it could be that you are gaining muscles from what ypur doing and then you would be losing fat but gaining muscle and that weighs more then fat:happy:0
-
Best way to look at it....are your clothes feeling lose? That's the best feeling. And also when you log everything on MFP sometimes foods can be more calories then what is logged in here and portion size can be different. And also when you go for a walk or if you're riding the bike, the calories lost aren't always accurate. Also when you log that you exercised and lost those calories, MFP adds that back into your calories that you can eat for the day. If I were you I would Log your exercise at the end of the day. That way your consuming 1300 calories per say and then losing 200 with exercise, rather then consuming1500calories in a day. Also keep in mind, they say that 3,500 calories is roughly a pound. So it takes a lot to lose, but you can do it.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions