Friends with a girl

Options
1235

Replies

  • CrystalMarie253
    Options
    Dude... that's fire!

    No Marge = Happy Fiance

    Marge = Marge (No Fiance)

    If Marge isn't as committed to your fiance as you are (and she won't be), then she'll be trying to revert to sex with you.

    Option 1: Wait till Marge has a significant other that she's committed to. you stand a much better chance of keeping your Fiance under those conditions.

    Option 2: Bye bye Marge. Have a good life.

    Yup!
  • cydonian
    cydonian Posts: 361 Member
    Options
    How do you handle this? You don't. There is no switching from sexy fling to platonic friend. It doesn't work, and I've seen it go downhill where my friends were involved -- happens every time. Plus, how would your fiance feel? I think it depends on the person but I know my husband surely wouldn't be hanging out with an old fling.
  • msciccone1
    msciccone1 Posts: 288 Member
    Options
    Dude... that's fire!

    No Marge = Happy Fiance

    Marge = Marge (No Fiance)

    If Marge isn't as committed to your fiance as you are (and she won't be), then she'll be trying to revert to sex with you.

    Option 1: Wait till Marge has a significant other that she's committed to. you stand a much better chance of keeping your Fiance under those conditions.

    Option 2: Bye bye Marge. Have a good life.

    Amen!
  • jacquelyn_erika
    jacquelyn_erika Posts: 524 Member
    Options
    This is ridiculous to even be asking. I know that you already know the answer, but felt the need to post about it for whatever reason. If you have such a great relationship with your fiance, she's the one, etc. etc. then you wouldn't even be considering going down this road. That's just my opinion. It's one things to BE friends with a female, maybe an old friend from college, high school (depending on your age), but an ex-fling who you have sexual feelings for? Nah. And any MAN would respect those boundaries for the sake of their relationship. But...what do I know.
  • Bella3119
    Bella3119 Posts: 104
    Options
    I would suggest talking with Marge first and telling her your intentions and the direction where you want to take your friendship. If you get any vibes that she isn't on the same page, then you would have to cut off the friendship.

    You would also have to talk to your fiance and explain the situation. A woman will feel insecure only if her man gives her reason to be. Make your fiancee feel like the only woman in the world and you'll be fine,

    :) Good luck.
  • KaiteeKarrot
    Options
    My two closest friends are men. Now saying that, we've never had any sort of sexual relationship history. However, i believe that if, inside, you truly think you just want to be her friend, than you can do it. If there is any even relatively small inkling of chemistry with her, than I think it's not worth it and too dangerous. (saying that, I find both my male friends very attractive, and I'm aware of it, but it doesn't mean I want them sexually) What happens a few years down the road when you and your soul mate get into a fight, like every couple does, and you go seek comfort with the wrong person? We're all human, mistakes happen. However, if this friendship is going to be a mistake than let it be the one mistake that doesn't happen to your great relationship.

    It works for me though ( having close non-sexual relationships with men) and it's a real blessing in life. I constantly benefit from their take on life, and they occasionally benefit from mine. I've been very blessed with the somewhat unaccepted lifestyle. I think quite a few people are very skeptical of male/female relationships, but i think it's only because those people wouldn't be able to have them, so they distrust others. If you think it can work, than hang out with her, during the day time (at first so as to avoid a "datey" scene) and go bowling or something like that, it means no physical contact, just hanging out and it's in no way romantic. Pretty soon you won't have to "try" to slip out of the hook-up type relationship you two had, it'll just be easy and natural.

    if your intentions are honest, your actions will be to.
  • JDMPWR
    JDMPWR Posts: 1,863 Member
    Options
    For every girl.....you are fooling yourself and for every guy that thinks the same.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_lh5fR4DMA

    Watch the video....

    I think I have been friends with ex's and been ok with that because I was with someone else but if I was given the chance to go back with the girl and it worked out and I wanted to be with her then yes I would, so it's a fine line. Can I be friends yes, do I want to, maybe.
  • atsteele
    atsteele Posts: 1,358 Member
    Options
    You can't find anyone else to eat with? Seriously?
  • fitplease
    fitplease Posts: 647 Member
    Options
    Do you think your fiance (soon to be wife) would want you to be best friends with someone whom you used to sleep with? I highly doubt it. Why tempt your marriage like that? There is a reason you broke it off with Marge, accept that and move on. For good.
  • EmpressOfJudgment
    EmpressOfJudgment Posts: 1,162 Member
    Options
    I never understood the whole guys and girls can't be friends nonsense.

    My advice? Don't take advice from people on the net.
    Haha. Very true. Guys and girls can totally be friends. But I think when your "friendship" starts of as a sexual relationship and never gets the chance to fizzle out it can spell trouble. It's hard to just turn it off.

    True. And considering he still wants to bang her, it's probably a good idea that he doesn't take her out for a little tripe.
    I'm starting to think "taking her out for tripe" is a euphemism.
  • KaiteeKarrot
    Options
    For every girl.....you are fooling yourself and for every guy that thinks the same.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_lh5fR4DMA

    Watch the video....

    I think I have been friends with ex's and been ok with that because I was with someone else but if I was given the chance to go back with the girl and it worked out and I wanted to be with her then yes I would, so it's a fine line. Can I be friends yes, do I want to, maybe.


    College guys, wanting to hook up with every girl in sight? NO way!?!? A youtube video interviewing soley 18-21 yr olds, in a University setting? very diplomatic and therefor an accurate depiction... ;)

    I think you have a valid point, to a degree. However maybe some people can be friends, that are the opposite sex, that find the other person attractive, (in the same way you might find someone of the same sex attractive without wanting them sexually) and be able to value the friendship more than any other possibility...("hooking up", having sex, dating) Maybe you just can't be friends with women? Who knows. C'est la vie.

    I believe my closest friends are my closest friends, I dont care what their gender is, and i believe them to feel the same way.
    If that seems impossible to anyone? So it goes.
  • asgard825
    asgard825 Posts: 1,516 Member
    Options
    So two years ago, I was dating around and I had a fling with this pretty darn awesome woman.Let's call her Marge. We had loads of fun, great physical connection, but she flaked on me and then went on vacation. The following week, I met the woman I expect to spend the rest of my life with (or the rest of hers, whichever comes first). My fiance and I share a bond I never thought possible. We just fit together. If I hadn't met her, I'm pretty sure I might have managed to make a go of it with Marge and been very happy, just not AS happy.

    Now, I think I would like to hang out with Marge as a friend now, because we share certain interests, such as eating organ meats in sketchy ethnic restaurants. However, the only time we have hung out together was in the context of a sexual fling and she is as attractive as ever. It's not that I think there would be any chance of me cheating - I can keep it in my pants, thank you. But I just don't know how to make a good transition from fling/potential girlfriend to platonic friend I want to eat tripe soup with. I feel like she would be like my food girlfriend. Any advice?

    Wether u realize or not -- ur curious about what might still be there--don't play that game
  • ilookthetype
    ilookthetype Posts: 3,021 Member
    Options
    Let's call her Marge.

    BEST "Let's call her..." EVER
    Now, I think I would like to hang out with Marge as a friend now, because we share certain interests, such as eating organ meats in sketchy ethnic restaurants. However, the only time we have hung out together was in the context of a sexual fling and she is as attractive as ever. It's not that I think there would be any chance of me cheating - I can keep it in my pants, thank you. But I just don't know how to make a good transition from fling/potential girlfriend to platonic friend I want to eat tripe soup with. I feel like she would be like my food girlfriend. Any advice?

    EASY, don't take off your pants!
  • bringingsexybackx
    Options
    dont do it to yourself
  • AmandaCaswell1982
    AmandaCaswell1982 Posts: 170 Member
    Options
    If you have to ask...you already know the answer.

    Exactly.
  • jenny95662
    jenny95662 Posts: 997 Member
    Options
    My fiance would be totally cool with it - hell, she thinks I should hang out with my ex-wife, and she has several friends she used to date. But as for me, I just don't know if I can be friends with someone I still kinda want to sleep with. I mean, I could certainly hang out with my ex wife... we never had sex while we were married, no reason why we would start now! Come to think of it, I have other female friends I've slept with and I don't even think about it even though they are totally hot. More reason to stay aweay in this case!

    I'm gonna be blunt. She's not okay with it. If she is, she was born with an additional copy of chromosome 21. No women in their right mind would be okay with their significant other hanging out with a previous SEXUAL partner. The way you explained it, all you guys did was have sex. What is the point?


    i agree with this every girl wants to be ok with it but i think after u start hanging out she wont feel that way. And if it was just a sexual relationship whats the point. Go find a dude that shares your interests or a girl that you did not have a past with
  • Rae6503
    Rae6503 Posts: 6,294 Member
    Options
    So lets say your fiance comes to you and says "Hey, there's this really attractive dude that I used to boink.... I wanna be his friend and go have dinner."

    How would YOU feel about this?
  • charityateet
    charityateet Posts: 576 Member
    Options
    Oh WHATEVER! The next one of you I see calling my friend Formic...Espressoman dumb or dense is going to have a very unpleasant forum life courtesy of yours truly.

    I'm telling you right now change the gender of this topic and every response would change. Have a woman ask if it's ok to have lunch with an ex and all you're going to hear is "No man owns me! I'll have lunch with who I want! We're just friends."

    I have to agree with this.
  • thor1god1of1awesome
    thor1god1of1awesome Posts: 481 Member
    Options
    You still have some feelings for this "marge" i think. Did you talk to your soon to be bride about this and how she feels? Also it just a bad idea to put yourself in that situtation. If you keep throwing steak at a lion sooner or latter the lion going to eat it.
  • Puffins1958
    Puffins1958 Posts: 614 Member
    Options
    I think if you wanted to be platonic friends/food friends with her, that's how it should have stayed. I feel once that line is crossed and there is a sexual thing going on, it's not ever easy going back to being platonic. I would not have kept it at being friends..... JMO