What exactly is "Processed Food"?
emstgm
Posts: 117 Member
It seems like a stupid question, but it's not that clear. OK, some things are clear. Twinkies are processed food. Raw carrots are not. I've got that part down.
But what about bread? Would you call that processed? I am talking about the hearty, healthy, whole grain goodness kind of bread. Not wonder bread.
What about canned veggies? I don't care for them, but sometimes eat them. Like beans, black beans and kidney beans. I usually eat those from a can. Is that processed?
What about peanut butter? I could buy a bunch of peanuts and smash them up myself, but it's a lot easier for me to buy it already made. I get the "Adams" kind with no sugar. Do you consider that processed?
I'm trying to eat healthier and eliminate processed foods from my diet, but I do still eat some (yes, I eat frozen entrees for lunch 3 x a week! Don't judge me!) So yes, I know those are processed. But there are lots of gray areas. Your thoughts?
But what about bread? Would you call that processed? I am talking about the hearty, healthy, whole grain goodness kind of bread. Not wonder bread.
What about canned veggies? I don't care for them, but sometimes eat them. Like beans, black beans and kidney beans. I usually eat those from a can. Is that processed?
What about peanut butter? I could buy a bunch of peanuts and smash them up myself, but it's a lot easier for me to buy it already made. I get the "Adams" kind with no sugar. Do you consider that processed?
I'm trying to eat healthier and eliminate processed foods from my diet, but I do still eat some (yes, I eat frozen entrees for lunch 3 x a week! Don't judge me!) So yes, I know those are processed. But there are lots of gray areas. Your thoughts?
0
Replies
-
there are different degrees of processing so it depends on the person and how much they want to cut out.
technically, anything that is not in its original form is processed, so that would include wheat bread, peanut butter etc.
I would define processed as ready meals / convenince food / some canned foods (veggies are not as bad as they are just plain veggies with water / salt, but meat in a can like Spam is just so wrong :sick: ) / bread that stays fresh for weeks / things that take some thinking about to work out what it is actually made out of!0 -
I agree with em9371.
Also, when you get canned veggies: look for no added salt, low salt or similar.0 -
Frozen veggies are awesome...not as mushy as canned and just like fresh ones, IMO.0
-
All bread, pasta, cereals etc
Some would even say rice.
Most canned / frozen veg is fine.
I wouldn't worry too much about nut butters, but the organic ones that have had the peanuts dried in the sun would be preferable, such as Whole Earth (not sure if thats available in the US but must be similar ones).0 -
If you're trying to stay away from processed food, shop the outer walls of the grocery store and avoid the aisles.0
-
check out the eat clean diet and eating clean magazine... both resources have sort of cleared it up for me! And give good recipes0
-
I tend to consider processed food as anything that has multiple ingredients crushed up and mushed together into a whole new item by someone who is not you, or things that have been altered in some way - pre-cooked, frozen, etc.
If you spend most of your eating-time in the meat and veg section, you're probably eating well. If you have to eat something processed, like bread, or pasta, choose the least-processed whomeal/wholegrain option.
The idea is to avoid highly processed and simplified carbs like white flour and sugar. These have come a long way from squeezing cane juice and grinding up wheat. The more that you allow your body to do the processing, the better (that includes chopping things up and in terms of digestion).0 -
I go by "5 ingredients or less" principle. Bread should have 5 or less, yogurt 5 or less etc... Beyond that I've never really seen the point of frozen or canned vegetables.0
-
I don't really like to eat canned veggies, but sometimes we run out of fresh stuff before we get a chance to go shopping, but they are terribly high in sodium! I know that now!
And Spam!! LOL!! That is so wrong! :sick:0 -
Oh, I also wanted to mention that a friend suggested I try Jenny Craig or Nutrisystem. WHY?? Aren't those diets almost completely processed foods? I cannot believe they are so popular.0
-
"Just add water". I steer clear of these. Hamburger helper also if at all possible, things like that.0
-
Oh, I also wanted to mention that a friend suggested I try Jenny Craig or Nutrisystem. WHY?? Aren't those diets almost completely processed foods? I cannot believe they are so popular.
Some people are more concerned with losing weight more so than being healthy.0 -
they are popular because you don't have to think. they do the 'cooking' for you.
my opinion is to shop on the edges of the grocery store (like mentioned above). You might have to go back every other day but you buy less at a time so the cost is the same. This way you can keep fresh foods in stock more readily.
The only issue I see with the canned / frozen stuff is the sodium. I have eaten tons of 'processed' foods and haven't had any issue. Just know what you are buying - read the nutrition label in the store0 -
Some people might consider bread processed, but I buy mine from the bakery and have every ingredient in my pantry. Just because it's baked, I don't consider it processed, but if you want to get into the origin of the flour yadda yadda, then I stop there! haha If I buy bread from the bread aisle of a normal grocery, I'd consider it processed though because those "commercial" breads contain a lot of preservatives and things.
All-natural peanut butter I don't consider processed.
My rule is to look at the ingredients. If there are chemicals, preservatives, or other things to enhance shelf life, then I know it's processed.
If it didn't exist 100 years ago, it's probably processed.0 -
In all honesty everything you buy from the supermarket that isn't in it's raw (straight from the ground) form is processed. Especially everything that is located in the middle of the supermarket is processed.0
-
A lot of what we eat is processed to some degree or another, but I'd call it processed if the cooking directions are "Open box, heat food."0
-
check out the eat clean diet and eating clean magazine... both resources have sort of cleared it up for me! And give good recipes
I analyzed this book for my nutrition class (I'm a Human Kinetics student...go figure), and it's actually a very good book. One problem with the book, you don't need that many servings of protein in your diet. Everything else is great. If you buy a book, try to avoid books that include "steps" and "phases", because these books are rarely successful, and it's very difficult to stay in each step.0 -
there are different degrees of processing so it depends on the person and how much they want to cut out.
technically, anything that is not in its original form is processed, so that would include wheat bread, peanut butter etc.
I would define processed as ready meals / convenince food / some canned foods (veggies are not as bad as they are just plain veggies with water / salt, but meat in a can like Spam is just so wrong :sick: ) / bread that stays fresh for weeks / things that take some thinking about to work out what it is actually made out of!
What this person said, in my opinion. There was a commercial a few years ago that said, "If you can't pronounce it, don't eat it." Not a bad rule of thumb. I do eat a little packaged bread, but I also got a bread machine, and make my own for pennies. I am not a fanatic-- I eat English muffins, and have no idea how to make them. I eat real butter instead of margarine or things like that. I store a few frozen lean cuisines in the work fridge for those days I'm running late. But as often as I can, I make a batch or two of soup over the weekend to bring to work for lunch. I eat "real" cheese, and avoid "cheese-type food products". I try to buy eggs from chickens who were allowed to occasionally walk around (I'm not rabid on "free range", but there are some from happy mediums), and I buy only "gate to plate" meat from local farms. The bummer is that it is almost always more expensive to eat "real food".0 -
Frozen veggies keep longer and are just as nutritious as their fresh counterparts. Canned however aren't as good if there is no salt added. Keep in mind that they are cooked inside of the can which means much of the nutritional content is leached into the liquid. Keep that in mind. The one canned item I don't have a problem with is beans, they are pretty safe bets but anything else (for me) I'd get fresh or frozen. But even now, since I eat so many beans, I've decided to start buying them dry. It takes much more time to prepare but I 'll get a lot more for my money.0
-
Think of how close the end product is to the way the food grew. Peanut butter is minimally processed if it's natural (not a lot of added ingredients). Breads vary. 100% whole grain bread is less processed than white bread, which has had the bran removed and is bleached. Sausage, bacon and deli meats are processed because they have added ingredients.0
-
Some people might consider bread processed, but I buy mine from the bakery and have every ingredient in my pantry. Just because it's baked, I don't consider it processed, but if you want to get into the origin of the flour yadda yadda, then I stop there! haha If I buy bread from the bread aisle of a normal grocery, I'd consider it processed though because those "commercial" breads contain a lot of preservatives and things.
Totally agree with that-- bakery bread generally has about four ingredients, and won't last more than a few days without going stale. I don't consider that processed. Wonder Bread, however, will last through the next millennium.0 -
Oh, I also wanted to mention that a friend suggested I try Jenny Craig or Nutrisystem. WHY?? Aren't those diets almost completely processed foods? I cannot believe they are so popular.
Some people are more concerned with losing weight more so than being healthy.
They are very tempting, but I didn't want to pay the money to be a member every month...for support and ideas. Why do that when I can come here and get it all for free?
Also, I'm afraid if I did do something like Jenny Craig or Weight Watchers that I'd gain all the weight back when I got off their "plans." Just seems like a fancier Slim Fast or diet pill. IDK...0 -
Most food is processed in one way or another. I bake my own bread and don't particularly like most big name shop breads. They are made using a process usually derived from the Chorleywood process which is designed to make the dough rise very quickly.
I buy some foods that are ready prepared or part cooked like ready meals when I need convenience and make from scratch when I have the time to spend cooking.
I prefer home made but I am often out and convenience is a big consideration for me.0 -
Simplist way to answer that question is to hold the food in your hand and ask yourself 'Did it grow that way?' If it had to be processed and things had to be added to it, or taken out of it to make it part of what you're holding in your hand, it's processed.0
-
I say to each their own... I like cereal, bread and pasta, and I eat them. That works for me. I have zero desire to "eat clean". Do I know it would probably be "better" for me? Sure I do. Can I still maintain a healthy lifestyle while eating these things? Sure I can. I don't have the time in my day or week to make all of my own foods from scratch and spend that much time worrying about it.0
-
I mainly look for added chemical ingredients and preservatives.. extra ingredients I wouldn't add if I made it fresh..0
-
If you're trying to stay away from processed food, shop the outer walls of the grocery store and avoid the aisles.
I see people saying this a lot, but it's kind of over simplified. At my grocery store the healthy oils and many of the raw nuts and such are in the inner isles. Knowledge is better here than a mnemonic here IMHO.0 -
Oh and wanted to say I don't think you can get away from some processing, in the sense like oils, but I do go out of my way to get expeller pressed safflower and extra virgin olive oil so that it's processed as little as possible.
Some of it is reading labels and making smart choices. When I buy nuts I could reach for the ones that are heavily processed sprayed with salt and fat and preservatives. Or I can reach for the ones that say "organic raw" contains only pecans.. for example.
I also buy almond milk, which while it's processed it has simple ingredients and nothing I don't want in it.
So some you have to figure out what feels right for you. But I avoid all pre-prepared frozen dinners, cans of soup and veggies, meal kit type items. And a good check can be look at the ingredients and if it's a fairly short list of stuff you can recognize as food then great, but it's a mile long with things you can't pronounce, then it's definitely processed.0 -
anything NOT in it's natural state is processed. the bad stuff to look for is sodium, sugar, corn syrup, words you don't understand, etc. bread; it depends on what it's made from. same rule applies and also if it's made from processed wheat flour. there's a lot more to it than just this, but it is something to keep in mind.
note: any food that is "lite" as in "less sugar", usually has more sodium and "low fat" stuff has more sugar to make up for the taste lost in processing for the end effect. i try to use as little of these products as possible and use real food in moderation such as raw sugar or agave, olive oil or even butter in small amounts as it is healthier than any margarine. IMO margarine is pure chemicals and is like eating poison.. it's just a matter of "how much can i eat and still get away with it?"0 -
If you're trying to stay away from processed food, shop the outer walls of the grocery store and avoid the aisles.
I see people saying this a lot, but it's kind of over simplified. At my grocery store the healthy oils and many of the raw nuts and such are in the inner isles. Knowledge is better here than a mnemonic here IMHO.
Agreed. Not to mention that one of the outer walls of mine has the bakery and all of the process snack bread items, like Hostess cupcakes, etc.
I am trying to eat "cleaner", but I have no intention of ever eating "clean". I like white sugar for baking. Sue me. I travel a lot for work on very short notice, so frozen meals are always in my freezer. I do try to stick mainly with Kashi or Amy's brand, but there is an odd Lean Cuisine there too. Eating clean may be great for many people, but for me, I have to find a balance between eating cleaner, healthier foods and still having some convenience items.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions