What would you do in this situation? Very stressed over this
Suppose you had a friendship of 10+ years. This person has been with you through most of the ups and downs of your adult life.
Has supported you through rough times (moral support not financial).
Was there when you 'closed' on your home first home.
As a mortgage broker, advised that you refinance that same home and lower interest rate. (good advice)
Has offered there home when you thought you needed to find another place to stay.
Has had your child stay with them for about 1 month when you needed them.
Has listened when you have troubles and needed advice.
Has treated you almost like a family member (included you in family reunions, photos, graduations, weddings, funerals, etc.)
Kids have been friends since the age of 6 (both are now over 18).
Has asked that their family Mentor your teenager, when you had no one else.
Now this friend is in a situation, which they need help saving an investment property left to them by a parent (worked hard all her life) who died and it's in jeopardy of being taken from them (taxes). When the housing market crashed they suffered greatly and so has the credit score. However, they've held on to most of the properties.
You have never borrowed any money from this friend, but they have from you in the past and have paid it back (give or take $200). Now, they are asking if you will take out a personal loan and lend them the money to save this 'Income generating' property. You yourself are in a tight financial situation, but have managed to keep Good Credit. They promise to pay it with the tax money that is on it's way, but won't be here within the required time to save the property.
What would you do?
Has supported you through rough times (moral support not financial).
Was there when you 'closed' on your home first home.
As a mortgage broker, advised that you refinance that same home and lower interest rate. (good advice)
Has offered there home when you thought you needed to find another place to stay.
Has had your child stay with them for about 1 month when you needed them.
Has listened when you have troubles and needed advice.
Has treated you almost like a family member (included you in family reunions, photos, graduations, weddings, funerals, etc.)
Kids have been friends since the age of 6 (both are now over 18).
Has asked that their family Mentor your teenager, when you had no one else.
Now this friend is in a situation, which they need help saving an investment property left to them by a parent (worked hard all her life) who died and it's in jeopardy of being taken from them (taxes). When the housing market crashed they suffered greatly and so has the credit score. However, they've held on to most of the properties.
You have never borrowed any money from this friend, but they have from you in the past and have paid it back (give or take $200). Now, they are asking if you will take out a personal loan and lend them the money to save this 'Income generating' property. You yourself are in a tight financial situation, but have managed to keep Good Credit. They promise to pay it with the tax money that is on it's way, but won't be here within the required time to save the property.
What would you do?
0
Replies
-
That's a tough one. I was given advice of "do not lend money to a friend unless you can live with the possibility of not being repaid". If you are not in a position where you could make it a gift instead of a loan, simply explain your circumstance and hope the friendship is enough to overcome any hard feelings.
I hope it works out for you.0 -
Depends how much money it is. I would NEVER take out a loan to help a friend, but I would loan a small amount of cash to them that I can afford to pull out of my bank account. For me right now, it would probably be no more than $1000, but only if I know that person is responsible with finances. Otherwise I would say no.0
-
Can you tell a white lie and say you got refused credit?0
-
Don't do it; The People's Court was built on scenarios like this.0
-
That is a very hard situation. You sound like someone that would really like to help, but you are afraid that it could hurt you in the long run. If it's not something you can do with ease, then maybe you should explain to them that you are not in a good enough place with your own finances to help them at this time. Option 2: make them sign a contract and get it notarized so that if they do not pay you back as promised that you have grounds for action.0
-
I know that's a tough one and I'm certainly glad I'm not in that position but I would have to caution against it. Maybe you could suggest she contact Suze Orman. I've seen her shows before and she may have some good advice that could help your friend.0
-
There are so many loans and programs out there to help people with bruised credit get what they need... If the friend goes through conventional methods, it may even help her rebuild hers. I would be reluctant to do this, but also afraid of what might happen if I didn't offer. Still, if the friend was using our history as leverage for a loan, I'd be a little hurt...0
-
If you say "no," you may lose a friend. If you say "yes," you will probably lose the friend and the money. She has put you in a terrible situation, but I'd say no. Never loan a friend money that you can't afford to lose. She may not believe it, but I'd try telling her, "I value our friendship too much to risk it by lending you this money."0
-
So I still want to know how much money we're talking about here, and how much risk this poses to the OP's own finances?0
-
Loans can destroy relationships. I give to friends.0
-
I wouldn't do it.0
-
As your friend, she would have to understand the financial burden this puts you in. If you are not in a place where you can "help" her for an extended period of time (say, if her tax money falls through and she has to pay you back in another fashion) DO NOT go through with this. Money woes seriously strain even the best friendships. It would be something different if you had extra money around you were comfortable parting with for awhile, but most folks these days are struggling week by week to get their bills paid. Just my opinion... explain your financial situation and tell her no.0
-
Nothing like money kills friendship, I agree with above white lie, make her think you tried to get the money but couldnt0
-
Hmmm...heres some logic....as a rule - only put in as much as the other guy/gal.... that way to have as much vested interest as he/she does
if they allow to put a lein on the property - sure... (if its 'underwater'...well that sucks and you should stay clear)
if its an income generating property - be clear on specific benchmarks to recoup your loan first and foremost....sure
if they allow you to take a % of equity for your 'investment' as a silent partner...sure0 -
Not without a legal, court-defendable agreement that provides the investment property as collateral.0
-
NEVER sign a loan for anyone. Having the money to lend and taking out money to lend are 2 different things. What if for some reason the person you're loaning to can't get the money for the monthly? Then you're screwed. If someone has to borrow money because of a misunderstanding on how to control it on their own, that burden will be put on you if you lend them the money. Sounds harsh, but the reality is many friendships get broken up over financial situations.Suppose you had a friendship of 10+ years. This person has been with you through most of the ups and downs of your adult life.
Has supported you through rough times (moral support not financial).
Was there when you 'closed' on your home first home.
As a mortgage broker, advised that you refinance that same home and lower interest rate. (good advice)
Has offered there home when you thought you needed to find another place to stay.
Has had your child stay with them for about 1 month when you needed them.
Has listened when you have troubles and needed advice.
Has treated you almost like a family member (included you in family reunions, photos, graduations, weddings, funerals, etc.)
Kids have been friends since the age of 6 (both are now over 18).
Has asked that their family Mentor your teenager, when you had no one else.
Now this friend is in a situation, which they need help saving an investment property left to them by a parent (worked hard all her life) who died and it's in jeopardy of being taken from them (taxes). When the housing market crashed they suffered greatly and so has the credit score. However, they've held on to most of the properties.
You have never borrowed any money from this friend, but they have from you in the past and have paid it back (give or take $200). Now, they are asking if you will take out a personal loan and lend them the money to save this 'Income generating' property. You yourself are in a tight financial situation, but have managed to keep Good Credit. They promise to pay it with the tax money that is on it's way, but won't be here within the required time to save the property.
What would you do?
Be empathetic. If it was that dire then they should take out a pay day loan if the money is truly coming in.
A.C.E. Certified Personal Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
I learned the hard way to NEVER to loan money that I couldn't afford to pay back myself. I also learned the hard way to NEVER co-sign a loan for anyone. How you turn down her request is up to you, but if she is truly your friend she will understand.0
-
I would not lend it. This will be a problem between you that won't go away any time soon, whether you do or don't lend it.
I have been put in this situation before, twice. I did not lend the money. In one case the friendship survived just fine, in the other I lost the friend.
Look after yourself first.
.0 -
A loan in YOUR name will affect YOUR credit rating if something happens and they default on payments. Personally, if this was me, I would decline. Even consigning a loan will affect your own credit if there's a default. So you have to be damn sure this friend is gonna have a perfect financial life over the term of the loan and so many things can happen to prevent your friend from making a payment on time.0
-
Now, they are asking if you will take out a personal loan and lend them the money to save this 'Income generating' property. You yourself are in a tight financial situation, but have managed to keep Good Credit.
I might give them a gift, if I had the savings, but I wouldn't take out a loan and give the money to a friend. I would, however, take out a loan and buy an interest in the property, if indeed that property is a good investment.
"But this is a FRIEND" I can hear some folk saying... yup...even for a friend who bent over backwards to help me out all these years: my ex entered into all kinds of helpful loans for our "friends," including property, and guess who's going to spend the next 8 years paying them off with nothing to show for it. That would be me. Those friends? Bad mouth me for not doing more to help them.
I no longer mix friendship and business.0 -
That's a tough one. I was given advice of "do not lend money to a friend unless you can live with the possibility of not being repaid". If you are not in a position where you could make it a gift instead of a loan, simply explain your circumstance and hope the friendship is enough to overcome any hard feelings.
I hope it works out for you.
This is what I've always heard as well.0 -
I would, however, take out a loan and buy an interest in the property, if indeed that property is a good investment.
I thought of this too, but usually a loan can 't be made on a property, or an interest in it be sold, whiile there are outstanding taxes. So the friend would have to pay the taxes first - which he doesn't have the money to do. So this looks, unfortunately, like a not logistically possible option.0 -
I wouldn't do it for anyone, family or friend. It is one thing to borrow and pay back $200 it is another thing to take out a personal loan of a sizable amount.0
-
I was at lunch Sorry for my delayed response.
Thank you to all who have responded. It's appreciated. :flowerforyou:
The loan would be for over $5,000.
It has to be approved and dispursed within the next 2 weeks or they will lose the property.
To the person who mentioned "Judge Judy". I've watched her show over 10 years now and know exactly what you mean. :flowerforyou:
I'm so torn over this. I have to give them a decision TODAY
0 -
Question, have they tried talking to the bank who they owe the money to? Perhaps they can explain that they'll have the money in two weeks and see if they'll be granted an extension?0
-
I don't lend money to friends or family, I either give it to them, or I don't.
I wouldn't take out a loan. If I had it in a savings account, I might give it to her. But, i wouldn't take out a loan for it without an agreement.
Agreements are looked at as negative, but you'll have one with your loan. If you decide to do it, make her sign an agreement with a schedule of payments, and terms associated. It sounds mean, but just explain to her that you really can't afford to do this, so you are just protecting yourself.0 -
Tough spot. The only way I would do it is if I had a legally binding agreement putting the land up for collateral and only if I could afford to make the payments myself (if only for a short-term period).
With the land as collateral, it's not the same as just straight out lending money to someone. You could have some protection.
But, I am bad with money myself, so I may not be the best person to offer advice : )0 -
don't loan it... that can get messy... and don't co-sign either! give it or not. keep it clean.0
-
I might lose a good friend today.
0 -
I might lose a good friend today.
A good friend wouldnt ask something of you that you cant do.
A good friend will stick with you, even if you couldnt help them.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions