Holly Madison & Shape Magazine??? WTF??
Sweet13_Princess
Posts: 1,207 Member
Okay, I have to vent a little bit about seeing Holly Madison as a success story in Shape Magazine. Read the article here:
http://www.shape.com/weight-loss/success-stories/celeb-slim-down-playboy-beauty-holly-madison
I was so irritated about her being a poor example, that I wrote the following to Shape's editorial department:
"Although I have been a Shape reader for years, I was disappointed for the first time when I saw Holly Madison as a success story in the March issue. Although she's a lovely lady and should be proud of her weight loss, she's not the best choice as a mentor for the readers. Shape always preaches healthy eating and exercise as the path to a better self, not weight loss supplements. This seemed more like an advertisement than a success story and a sell-out of the magazine's core values."
Anyone agree or am I just being insane here?
Shannon
http://www.shape.com/weight-loss/success-stories/celeb-slim-down-playboy-beauty-holly-madison
I was so irritated about her being a poor example, that I wrote the following to Shape's editorial department:
"Although I have been a Shape reader for years, I was disappointed for the first time when I saw Holly Madison as a success story in the March issue. Although she's a lovely lady and should be proud of her weight loss, she's not the best choice as a mentor for the readers. Shape always preaches healthy eating and exercise as the path to a better self, not weight loss supplements. This seemed more like an advertisement than a success story and a sell-out of the magazine's core values."
Anyone agree or am I just being insane here?
Shannon
0
Replies
-
you're not out of line. Shape mag really has changed how they do their mags recently, so I stopped reading them0
-
Agree!!
Sounds like an ad for NV.
Thumbs down to Shape.
Thumbs up for your review and letter!0 -
I bought that issue for the Kate Walsh interview, and when I got to the article about Holly Madison, I couldn't believe I was reading Shape! Definitely thumbs up to your letter!0
-
I saw this magazine at the gym & thumbed through it while I was on the bike. I never really read Shape but am disapointed they made it sound like NV was a magic pill. I am sure a lot of people will be rushing to the store to waste money on something that doesn't work because most people want a quick fix and not a lifestyle change.0
-
Shape Magazine has gone to S**t as far as I'm concerned.
It's not about quality anymore, it's about advertising and trying to make money.0 -
Yeah, I was pretty miffed at that article too. I didn't even think to write to the magazine. Great idea. I couldn't believe that they'd have her as a "success".0
-
Agreed and thought the same thing. If I hadn't gotten the subscription free, I'd be really peeved.
I also don't believe for one second that she lost 20 pounds and weighs 110 pounds at 5'5, unless her head and boobs are full of helium.0 -
Things are really bad in the newspaper/magazine industry right now. It's part of a long developing trend, going back to the early 2000s, where more traditionally print oriented publications have been struggling to adapt to the new paradigm, the digital media landscape.
This type of story may alienate more than bring in more advertising revenue. Content is king. Keeping the target audience happy and engaged should be goal. Other things should fall into place after that.0 -
She wasn't big before from the pictures? You can't see all of her in the after either. Rubbish article, I agree! Boo0
-
I do love her, but I think its a poor choice too! Just another plug for her stupid pills.0
-
Really interesting comments, guys. I've also always been anoyed by the advertisements in Self, Fitness, and Shape Magazines. A lot of them are for diet pills, which when you read the actual magazine content, the readers are told that supplements aren't FDA approved that their claims haven't been substantiated with scientific evidence. If that's the case, why do magazines accept these advertisements? Surely, we can healthier companies like Morning Star, Jenny-O, Jello, etc. to put in their advertisements and the magazines can make revenue that way. Gotta love corporate America.
GRR!
Shannon0 -
The only "fitness Magazine" I read is Womens Health. I find good articles and excellent workout advice. Not nearly as many supplement ads...It's not just a book full of ads like the others.0
-
I agree with you, it is promoting negative ways to lose weight! I know not all diet pills are going to harm your body, but they can be unhealthy ways to lose weight in a short amount of time and that is just promoting people to take them! I don't like it at all...0
-
Unfortunately - its more about what sells magazines - they're looking at the bottom $$$. After having a subscription for 2 years, I got very disappointed and did not renew.0
-
I never found her that good looking anyway. She looks fake to me with the bleach blond hair, orange tan, and surgically grown breasts. I don't find that attractive at all.
Not to mention she sounds so scripted: "NV helped me drop one jeans size in two weeks and increased my energy." "These days, I’m slim and fit, and I still have the fabulous curves I've always loved!"
I would have been mad too.0 -
FWIW, I really like Self Magazine. I haven't read shape in a few years, but from what I've read, Self has good workouts and meal ideas.0
-
I saw this magazine at the gym & thumbed through it while I was on the bike. I never really read Shape but am disapointed they made it sound like NV was a magic pill. I am sure a lot of people will be rushing to the store to waste money on something that doesn't work because most people want a quick fix and not a lifestyle change.
most mainstream self-help magazines are thinly-disguised, lengthy manufacturer's advertisements. Only.
There is very little hard science or independant reasearch done on any article, popular trends are quoted as fact and easy solutions to complex situations are promoted as the final say. The models are airbrushed to fit the issue's theme, so overal, it's about $6 spent on one giant, pretty ad.
No thanks.0 -
Toatally pi**ed me off! She is a poor roll model.0
-
I am a shape reader too. However, there have been many times in the past year that I'd be in the supermarket, walk up to grab the magazine, see who was on the cover and just turned around. It's an obvious problem for all magazines, but why are there not curvier women with bigger frames on the cover: christina Hendricks and Queen Latifa, etc! Sorry but I have bigger bones and bigger frame than holly madison. If I was her size now or when she was "fatter" I would look sick. So you were not out of line. I found it interesting the other day in the book store that I saw Megan Fox on the cover of Cosmo in the US but the UK version is always someone like Adele, or (this month is) Christina Hendricks--women who are real too. I think you have inspired me to write a letter to SHAPE!0
-
I totally agree! Holly send the absolutely wrong message about weight loss and fitness, in my opinion. But it isn't that different of a message then the "be bikini ready in 30 days" articles that they include either. Yes, so of the exercises are interesting and I can incorporate them in my own workout, but the message is the same, Quick easy weight loss. Not sure about you, but I have nothing quick and easy about weight loss. It was hard work, but it has been well worth it!
I hope you sent your letter!0 -
Wow, I definitely am surprised by that article. I used to read Shape YEARS ago, and this article does NOT fit in with their content from years back.
I commented under the article:
"I am disappointed in this article. I have seen Shape take a negative turn toward more advertising, but this really takes the cake. Weight loss supplements are not an appropriate substitute for nutritious food, and are not an adequate long term plan. Please get back to what Shape used to stand for, which was healthy, sustainable fitness tips and advice. Thank you."0 -
If you're looking for a better fitness magazine try Experience Life (lifetime fitness' magazine). I LOVE it! No creepy pill adverts and I feel like they do a great job promoting all around health - not just a quick fix.0
-
I got the new issue of Shape yesterday and immediately went to the letters section to see the feedback. Wow! Not only did they not print any complaint letters (which I'm sure they got), but they printed a "pro NV" letter that included information on the company's web site and pricing information for the product at Walmart.
Further proof that magazines are just one giant paid advertisement. I wont' be renewing this one.0 -
Yeah, that's one fitness magazine I don't buy regularly, because they don't cater to the kind of fitness I strive for.0
-
:noway: You are right! Plus it's the pilates, yoga and cutting out fast food and eating healthy snacks that would have done it, no the pill SHape was probably paid to promote. It's a real shame and I am dissapointed too! I noticed that EVERY SINGLE ad for a magic weight loss pill says excercise and eating plan required to acheive results! how convient for them HA LOL:explode:0
-
Shape is all about adds & marketing now. I prefer Women's Health. More substance, less bull *kitten*.0
-
what a shame. I wonder if they ever thought about what kind of message that is sending out... good review you wrote up!0
-
Shape stopped being a good fitness magazine around 7 years ago. Now I am amazed if they put someone on the cover who is actually practicing good fitness and health. It is no longer inspirational for me. I've dropped it from the rotation, and there is much better info available online these days from independent sites (fitsugar.com is a great example even though it is more of a content aggregator)0
-
Agreed and thought the same thing. If I hadn't gotten the subscription free, I'd be really peeved.
I also don't believe for one second that she lost 20 pounds and weighs 110 pounds at 5'5, unless her head and boobs are full of helium.
yep on all. Shape has def sold out...0 -
I agree!!! Good for you for writing to them! 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!