Greek yogurt v. regular yogurt

2

Replies

  • realhousewife_windsor
    realhousewife_windsor Posts: 63 Member
    I use the plain yogurt as substitution for sour cream. When I make me dips or use it in tacos it cuts the fat and yet has that creamy texture like regular sour cream. You honestly can't tell the difference.
  • EmCarroll1990
    EmCarroll1990 Posts: 2,832 Member
    I like Greek yogurt's consistency. It reminds me of pudding.
  • Elizabeth_C34
    Elizabeth_C34 Posts: 6,376 Member
    Since we are on the subject of yogurt,
    Is Yoplait really the junk-food of yogurts? It's the only kind/brand that I like.
    And I really like the vanilla...

    Nah. If you like it and it fits your calories for the day, eat up!
  • belgerian
    belgerian Posts: 1,059 Member
    Ive aquired the taste for fat free greek yougurnt which is mostly Protein as I dont eat that much meat anymore nor do I drink milk too much anymore. So that is my primary source of protein. I mix it with my oatmeal for breakfeast.
  • MrsLVF
    MrsLVF Posts: 787 Member
    I use the plain yogurt as substitution for sour cream. When I make me dips or use it in tacos it cuts the fat and yet has that creamy texture like regular sour cream. You honestly can't tell the difference.

    I agree with this, I can handle the Greek yogurt is small doses, like say a Tablespoon, as a substitute for sour cream, or mayonnaise, I can also tolerate my homemade Tzatziki Sauce.:smile: But using 8 ounces in my protein shake just made me sick. Everything in moderation.
  • jsapninz
    jsapninz Posts: 909 Member
    On average it has about 12g of sugar, 15g of protein and 110 calories.

    It depends on what brand you get. I get the plain 2% Fage and it has 20 gs protien and only 8gs sugar....all for 150 cals! Show me something else that has that much protien (and that little sugar) for that calories! What a terrific snack. :smile:
    Yeah it's a little sour but whatever, I am SO SICK of eating yogurts with ridiculous amounts of sugar in them. And I kind of like something a little different.
  • Skeels
    Skeels Posts: 929 Member
    Fage 0% Blueberry is my cats meow !!!!:bigsmile:
  • medennison123
    medennison123 Posts: 191 Member
    Im in love with greek yogurt. blueberry is the best.
  • tyrog11
    tyrog11 Posts: 35 Member
    Fage 0%...I completely agree with many of the comments about the macros. The 1 cup comment earlier is right on. I get Walden Farms Strawberry syrup (they have blueberry too) and mix it in. It tastes great and if you aren't familiar with Walden Farms, it is 0 every thing. No fat/protein/carbs/sugar/gluten...nothing. But it adds a great flavor and makes it taste like normal yogurt. Best of both worlds!!
  • nakabi
    nakabi Posts: 589 Member
    To each their own. If you don't want to eat it, you don't have to. I personally prefer Greek yogurt to regular yogurt - I don't like how runny regular yogurt is. I don't worry about the sugars in it at all. I do like that it doesn't contain high fructose corn syrup which my body has some trouble with, so that is important to me. But, overall .. it is all about preference. I like that Greek has protein in it.

    Eat whichever one you prefer... no one says you HAVE to eat Greek yogurt.

    This

    I love the Oikos kind made by Dannon..mmmmmmmmmmm so good! and it keeps me full! I love to put some grapenuts in it and have it for breakfast with some fruit.
  • original_cake_face
    original_cake_face Posts: 131 Member
    I actually like the texture of Greek Yogurt more than the goopy texture of other yogurts. It makes me feel like I'm actually EATING something, and it makes me feel fuller. I buy the plain stuff and mix in some honey and fruit -- it's awesome. And a little sugar from natural sources doesn't bother me one bit.
  • marieautumn
    marieautumn Posts: 928 Member
    greek yogurt is disgusting. i REALLY tried to like it but its gross. but then again i dont really like yogurt anyways.
  • fitacct
    fitacct Posts: 242 Member
    Greek yogurt is definitely an acquired taste, especially the plain variety. The first time I tried it, I said, "NO WAY!", but after reading more about the benefits, I decided to try different varieties until I found one I liked. That brand, Stonyfield Farm, has a line that is low in fat, sugar and sodium and, of course, Greek yogurts are high in protein. Now, I buy Chobani's non-fat, plain yogurt and add a bit of honey or flavored sweetener to it to make it more palatable (that way I am the one who controls the sugar content). I even eat it as-is at times since I'm now used to the taste and texture.
  • Kittie_Kat
    Kittie_Kat Posts: 101
    Plane Fage Greek Yogurt packs alot of protein, it has 9carbs a serving.....
    It's really good if you mix a little honey and fruit into it. I can't eat it plain! Personally I prefer it to the pre-flavored ones since they have way more sugar in them...
  • sgtlittle
    sgtlittle Posts: 258 Member
    Get plain Greek Yogurt (what I do) to dodge the sugar intake. I flavor mine with protein powder to make a suped up snack.
  • mmklinemm
    mmklinemm Posts: 58 Member
    I mix a 1/2c. of Chobani vanilla yogurt every morning with my cereal, instead of milk. It's delicious, fills me up, keeps me fueled after my workout, and it has ZERO chemicals. The lack of chemicals is the most important aspect for me. I like to know and understand what is in the food I'm eating.
  • mmklinemm
    mmklinemm Posts: 58 Member
    Another thing - not all Greek yogurt is created equal. You have to read the labels. Just like all other food, some of them are just as crappy for you as junk food. They just hide it behind the "Greek" label.
  • Flixie00
    Flixie00 Posts: 1,195 Member
    I started strength training a few months ago and my PT recommended I up my protein intake as I don't eat meat or poultry. I tried cottage cheese (nasty nasty stuff) and then stumbled across Greek yogurt. I eat Fage 0% fat Greek Yogurt straight out of the tub and I love it. The benefits are great, high in protein, low in carbs, no fat and only natural sugars.
  • G30Grrl
    G30Grrl Posts: 377 Member
    I'm reading this while eating a bowl of plain Greek yogurt to which I added home-made granola, dried blueberries, and local honey. OMG-YUM!

    I used to eat Yoplait (generally the flavors that taste most like dessert), but they never satisfied. I get a larger serving of Greek Yogurt with fewer additives and fillers, less processed sugar (remember, I eat plain, so my sugars come from what I add in fruit or honey) and FAR more protein. And I feel as if I've eaten an entire meal. And if I mix it with protein powder, it's a tremendous protein boost that I often need on weight lifting days.

    I wasn't crazy about it at first, but I tried it a few different ways because the macros were so good, and now I prefer it to the stuff I used to eat. That being said, to each her own, so if you really don't like it, there's no reason to eat it.
  • tigersword
    tigersword Posts: 8,059 Member
    Along with the awesome macro ratios others have mentioned, the straining process of Greek yogurt also removes much of the lactose. Often, people that are lactose intollerant can handle Greek yogurt, but not regular. Personally, I like to buy plain Greek yogurt and add my own natural sweetener (usually stevia or honey), and some fruit. Removes the tart taste, and I know exactly what's in it.

    ETA: I had to try Greek yogurt 3 times to get a taste for it. Try different brands and flavors until you find something you like!
    Yogurt doesn't have much in the way of lactose, yogurt is made by inserting bacteria into milk, the bacteria converts the lactose into lactic acid, which is what thickens yogurt and gives it the tartness. Straining gets rid of whey to further thicken the yogurt, but most of the lactose is already gone before that.
  • eviltwinkie
    eviltwinkie Posts: 153
    I had to get use to it - at first I thought it was a stronger 'tang' than regular yogurt. Now I love it. I prefer Dannon Fat Free Oikos Plain yogurt. That's 80 cal (5.3 oz?), 0 fat, 6 sugars, 6 carbs, and 15 protein. For flavoring I often use stevia, true lemon, and either frozen blueberries or a tablespoon of reduced sugar jam (25 cal.) I've stirred powdered peanut butter in it too.

    I find that a higher protein content does a way better job of keeping me full than a standard yogurt. And getting plain allows me to vary it by how I feel. When I'm in a hurry, I eat it with just the stevia and lemon, which is still pretty nice.

    I love to use it at the end of stir frys as well, to make a sauce.

    Honestly, as I've tried consciously to 'like' different things over the past few years, I've found half of my 'likes and dislikes' taste wise seem to come from familiarity (not 'use' to a flavor) and preconceived notions. Continuing to try it (like my forays into greek yogurt) ended up with me finding one way to like it... then another... now its a regular on the menu.
  • shellrae1973
    shellrae1973 Posts: 66 Member
    I eat plain lower fat greek yogurt because of the protein and most flavored yogurts are sweetened with artifical sweetners and I don't like the taste of it in the yogurt. I usually mix frozen mango into my greek yogurt to sweeten it up!
  • Feathil
    Feathil Posts: 162 Member
    I never tasted greek yoghurt before MFP and I love it - I get the plain kind and happily eat it plain, but to get my fruit for the day I mix berries in with it. I heat them so that the juices run and mix with the yoghurt - you may like that better, and you'll have better control of the sugars involved.
  • kbmnurse
    kbmnurse Posts: 2,484 Member
    Just made the switch to Chobani Greek Yogurt. I love it. It keeps me fuller longer.
  • gonnabeahealthyfitme
    gonnabeahealthyfitme Posts: 1 Member
    when i get it i get the yoplait 2x protein kind because i never get my full amount of protein that i need. i also hate the texture of regular yogurt but love the texture of the greek kind!
  • mgmlap
    mgmlap Posts: 1,377 Member
    I do full fat fage greek yogurt..plain..and I add my own fruit...the non fat is what makes it tart..ick..
  • mfpcopine
    mfpcopine Posts: 3,093 Member
    I love Greek yogurt (Oikos is my favorite brand, Fage is another good one), but I believe it has less calcium than regular-style yogurt.
  • atomeatball
    atomeatball Posts: 1
    Oikos and Dannon are not as tart...Yoplait Greek has a definite taste difference. Twice the protein is the key to complement exercise.
  • Jacwhite22
    Jacwhite22 Posts: 7,010 Member
    Yeah...it's for the protein (which can be triple that of regular yogurt). I find the sugars a little troubling though. I don't like the plain kind and the fruit flavors I enjoy can have up to 15g of sugar and 160 calories--that's over half of my sugar allowance for the whole day!

    Really? You eat 30 grams of sugar per day?
  • jadedone
    jadedone Posts: 2,446 Member
    I've been hearing all of the great reviews about greek yogurt and how good it is for you. Really??? Is it really that great? On average it has about 12g of sugar, 15g of protein and 110 calories. It can be really hard to handle because of its texture and tartness. I am eating Fiber One 50 calorie yogurt and it only has 4 g of sugar, 50 calories, 3g protein and 5g of fiber. It is absolutely delicious!! I will only be using greek yogurt if a specific recipe calls for it.

    It is way higher in protein, and the sugars only come from the natural sugars in milk. There are zero added sugars in a plain yogurt.

    The Fiber One 50 calorie? Is that 4 ounces? Those greek yogurt stats sound like 6 ounces to me. So it is a 50% bigger portion.

    Also, if you are concerned about eating minimally processed food, the fiber one has gelatin (so it isn't vegetarian), food coloring and preservatives. Personally, I like to add my own fruit and sweetener to my yogurt.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories