Placenta Eating (DO NOT MOD)

12346»

Replies

  • Rhea30
    Rhea30 Posts: 625 Member
    http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/some-mothers-see-health-benefits-in-eating-their-placenta-after-giving-birth/2012/04/02/gIQAVfgLrS_story.html

    Doula Tabare Depaep is a placenta lady. She works out of her Annapolis kitchen, and said a placenta feels “like a big rump roast.” She doesn’t find it any worse than handling meat. (Depaep is a vegetarian.) “I actually feel warmer toward the placenta because it grew a baby,” she said.

    If all this sounds a bit too cannibalistic, there are “placenta encapsulation specialists,” often midwives or doulas, who transform the placenta from its messy postpartum condition into neat, sometimes even flavored, pills. “Mad Men” actress January Jones told People magazine that she began taking placenta pills after giving birth last fall and credits them with helping her to bounce back quickly. “It’s not witchcrafty or anything! I suggest it to all moms,” she told the magazine. “Your placenta gets dehydrated and made into vitamins. It’s something I was very hesitant about,” but she ended up taking the pills daily



    personal opinion?

    would you do it?

    how did this become a craze?

    I would do it. It has shown to help ward off postpartum depression and if it would keep me from having to take anti depressants which are not natural at all and come with side effects I'll eat my placenta in a heart beat.
  • kstep88
    kstep88 Posts: 403 Member
    Gonna have to with big fat NO, Never...never... I have two daughters, and I did just fine without eating it, or having it in pill form. Are there any large studies to prove this is actually helpful? Exercise and eating right after having a baby can also help with PPD, so can sunlight (Vitamin D)

    ---To each their own, I guess.
  • CuteAndCurvy83
    CuteAndCurvy83 Posts: 570 Member
    I'd encapsulate it,but not just eat it, that would be weird..
  • slrose
    slrose Posts: 164 Member
    Animals eat their placentas to regain some nutrients that are lost through pregnancy and *MOSTLY* to clean up the mess so predators can not find their den. There is no nutritional value for modern women (goofy-*kitten* Hollywood women) to gain from eating their own placenta. And if you have to pay some doctor thousands of dollars to make it into a pill, don't talk to me. Slurp it down raw, or shut up. Otherwise it's all pretense.

    Hardcore!
  • sleepytexan
    sleepytexan Posts: 3,138 Member
    barf.
  • tulip07
    tulip07 Posts: 167 Member
    I had twins, milk came in after 3 days, breastfed both of them for 18 months, did not have any PPD. And NO I did not eat my placenta.

    Every pregnancy is different and every post-pregnancy experience is different and I don't believe it has anything to do with placenta eating.

    I come from one of the oldest and largest cultures (Indian) in the world and have never ever heard of this in our culture. Please don't say this has been done for thousands of years. There is no proof of that.
  • Virginia90
    Virginia90 Posts: 317 Member
    Gonna have to with big fat NO, Never...never... I have two daughters, and I did just fine without eating it, or having it in pill form. Are there any large studies to prove this is actually helpful? Exercise and eating right after having a baby can also help with PPD, so can sunlight (Vitamin D)

    ---To each their own, I guess.

    Large studies, no, and there likely never will be - there is no financial benefit for proving the placenta can be beneficial if consumed after birth to anyone but the few people who encapsulate the pills, so who would bother funding a study for it? The CDC would never touch it with a 10 foot pole, because could you imagine the money big pharma would lose on anti-depressants if it was proven that it does effectively reduce PPD? There are many women who, if benefits were proven on a large study made by some big name, would pay the $200-300 to get their placenta encapsulated to take rather than the $500+ (in some cases) one might spend on chemical anti-depressants...or maybe not. I don't tend to hang out with many "mainstream" people, so maybe my perception of society is skewed. It only just occurred to me today that breastfeeding during pregnancy and tandem nursing wasn't a common practice. lol. :laugh:
  • Macrocarpa
    Macrocarpa Posts: 121 Member
    I'm breast feeding. . . But when you breast feed in public people stare and stare and make comments like its wrong. . . I don't think its taboo. I'm just trying to say that most people (that dont have kids, or have kids and never Breast feed, or men) find it odd that a woman pulls out her boob to feed her child in public. At least thats how it is in chicago. . .

    I've gotta go into bat for the men here as by 'people', breastfeeding women generally mean 'men' because men are far more likely to openly look / stare at breastfeeding women.

    Also before I commence I have a gorgeous wife & daughter and am totally pro breastfeeding wherever, whenever. I think breastfeeding is absolutely fantastic. Appreciate and sympathise with those that cannot physically breastfeed though.

    OK onto boobies. For some bizarre reason breasts are irrevocably associated with sex. That is the context in which men most frequently see bare breasts being shown / used and is the context that most men view breasts. Again note this is product of environment & education.

    As such men are programmed from birth to view breasts as sex organs, not food. This is hammered into our heads again and again and again and again and again and again and again by movies, popular culture, and the most insidiuous influencers in the use of breasts as attention-seekers - young women.

    Don't stop to argue, just go for a walk out at about 11pm around a bar and see what I mean. Ever worn a push-up bra to make your boobs look bigger? Hey, you just used your breasts as sexual objects to attract attention. Likewise for low cut tops, boob tubes, lifters, separators, and anything which is boob-related that doesn't specifically relate to your comfort. 'But I just wanted to look nice!' - well what links boob prominence with looking 'nice'??

    The net result of this is that men see boobs as being part of sexytime. The awkwardness felt by men when they're confronted with a woman breastfeeding is the CONTEXT. "I am seeing something OUT OF CONTEXT. This breast, which I know as a sexual organ, is being used to feed a small child." It's nothing to do with the action of feeding any more than watching a child eat or use a bottle is disgusting. Proof? Woman breastfeeding a child vs woman bottle feeding a child with expressed breast milk. If the objection of the viewer is that the child is eating a human product then they would surely react to the latter situation with as much objection as to direct feeding.

    Further proof? Other cultures. Tribesmen out in African countries aren't titillated by boobies - and don't care if babies latch onto their moms in public. Why? Because those societies don't label breasts as sexual organs, and as a result they're fine to have them hanging out.

    Western society has its roots puritanical religion ('reproduction is dirty, you filthy sinners') and has some idiotic components to it. Boobs (a) aren't sexual and (b) are an incredibly important part of baby nutrition, and we should support women who are willing and capable of breastfeeding in whatever environment they choose (within reason).

    Thankfully we are moving towards a more open society where simple body functions like breastfeeding are accepted, or at the least tolerated.
  • Macrocarpa
    Macrocarpa Posts: 121 Member
    Thoughts:

    Personally not something I support, for the following reasons:

    (a) apes, humans' closest genetic relatives, do not habitually eat placenta

    (b) The postpartum depression mitigation effects are disputed and there is no definitive medical or scientific research (ie one under controlled conditions, double-blinded, with a large sample, over a large period of time) to support the hypotheses

    (c) Obstetrician and spokesperson for the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists Maggie Blott disputes the post-natal depression theory, stating there is no medical reason to eat the placenta; "Animals eat their placenta to get nutrition - but when people are already well-nourished, there is no benefit, there is no reason to do it." source http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/4918290.stm

    But hey, if it's what gets these moms through a really hard part in their lives then sure, go for it.
  • SARBelgians
    SARBelgians Posts: 46 Member
    If you don't want to eat it, donate it to the local Search & Rescue K9 unit for cadaver training!

    It's difficult to get human material to train the dogs with, so we rely heavily on donated placentas. It allows us to train the dogs to recognize human tissue scent, human decay scent and appropriately alert on it. We also rely on pulled teeth, detached fingers that couldn't be reattached, bloody gauze, nose bleed tissues, and if we are really, really lucky...donated tissue/bone when a family member dies and wanted their body to be used for SAR K9 training. We can even use tissue/bone from people that might not qualify for transplant or regular tissue harvesting.

    Something to think about....

    Jillian
    with 2 dual-certified airscent (live find) and cadaver SAR dogs!

    15449148.png
    Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Calorie Counter
  • dawnkay1
    dawnkay1 Posts: 41
    Nope.
  • Why are people on here comparing humans to animals as a reason to justify eating their own placentas!?! Animals also eat their own feces, should humans start doing that too??? I, for one, do not want to compare myself to an animal! Animals engage in cannibalism, and eat their own offspring...is that acceptable for humans too? GIVE ME A FREAKIN BREAK!
This discussion has been closed.