No Carbs for how long? How long could one survive?

RachelsReboot
RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
edited December 17 in Food and Nutrition
How many days could one survive without ANY carbs in their diet?

I'll be the tester since my team of doctors recommends I consume as few carbs as I possibly can. I already have medical clearance for zero carbs so don't fret. I have a team of doctors standing by.

Since my brain won't be able to function and they are essential for red blood cells and all, how long do I have to live guys? Place your bets!

And if anyone wants to take bets on whether I can maintain at least a 3.5 GPA with my non functioning brain I'm up for that too!
«134

Replies

  • MrEmoticon
    MrEmoticon Posts: 275 Member
    I'm going to say 13 days. GO
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
    I didn't say before I go crazy, I said how long could I survive! LOL
  • karmelkutie310
    karmelkutie310 Posts: 50 Member
    I didn't say before I go crazy, I said how long could I survive! LOL

    I just did like 3 posts trying to spread the word… I had the same problem girl, there is a solution and I’d been eating for years before I knew it do any good. Google “Shirataki Pasta” you’ll be happy you did. Look it up on Youtube, and enjoy :heart:
  • WhitneyAnnabelle
    WhitneyAnnabelle Posts: 724 Member
    I know someone who was put in the hospital because she cut out carbs completely. I'm not sure cutting them out entirely is a great idea
  • wildboar1
    wildboar1 Posts: 88
    Ummm I would say about forever. There is no such thing as an essential carb. You could live a long happy healthy life without ever having a single gram of carbs.
  • shelton2202
    shelton2202 Posts: 4
    I really suggest you don't forgo carbs altogether. They are an important source of fiber, vitamins and minerals. It doesn't hurt to cut out bread products, but I'd include healthy carbs like brown rice, whole wheat pasta, new potatoes, sweet potatoes and beans. It's all about quantity. Keep your portions about like a half cup and you'll do fine. An easy plan to follow is to eat half your plate of vegetables, one quarter starchy food like potatoes, and one quarter meat. Top that off with a milk or yogurt and a piece of fruit and you can't go wrong, plus it's healthy. Free advice from a dietitian who is using this fabulous site to track my own calories! Good luck. Remember muscles need carbs and your brain prefers carbs too!
  • spngebobmyhero
    spngebobmyhero Posts: 823 Member
    ketogenic diet? You'll be fine and you won't die, especially under a doctor's care. I know you were being sarcastic, just saying I agree!
  • jcgrant43
    jcgrant43 Posts: 64
    Ummm I would say about forever. There is no such thing as an essential carb. You could live a long happy healthy life without ever having a single gram of carbs.

    This!
  • heybales
    heybales Posts: 18,842 Member
    As long as you like.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-carbohydrate_diet

    Great 1 year study done on explorers that had already seen it done and had done it themselves.
  • Summer5555
    Summer5555 Posts: 104 Member
    Looking at your food diary, maybe you should have a nutritionist menu plan for you.
  • KareninCanada
    KareninCanada Posts: 962 Member
    So... what are you going to eat? Just meat and water?
  • theoriginaljayne
    theoriginaljayne Posts: 559 Member
    "Zero" carbs? What are you planning to eat besides steak and olives?

    Personally, I don't like very low-carb diets, but I understand that many people do – so if you'd like to go low-carb, then more power to you. But be aware that a "zero-carb" diet is unhealthy and unrealistic; most foods – including basically all fruits and vegetables – do contain carbohydrates.

    Edit: This is unrelated to this post, but I checked out your food diary, and I'm confused. How did you consume negative half of an apple, or negative three slices of tomato? Does not compute.
  • SammyKatt
    SammyKatt Posts: 363 Member
    How many days could one survive without ANY carbs in their diet?

    I'll be the tester since my team of doctors recommends I consume as few carbs as I possibly can. I already have medical clearance for zero carbs so don't fret. I have a team of doctors standing by.

    Since my brain won't be able to function and they are essential for red blood cells and all, how long do I have to live guys? Place your bets!

    And if anyone wants to take bets on whether I can maintain at least a 3.5 GPA with my non functioning brain I'm up for that too!


    Unless all you are going to eat is meat and nothing else, there is no such thing as a ZERO carb diet.

    Carbs are in veggies, dairy, fruit, even eggs have .7 carb. You can get plenty of healthy carbs and not eat a single grain (rice, pasta, wheat)
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
    Looking at your food diary, you will either crack and binge or you will end up hospitalised for an eating disorder. Maybe you should have a nutritionist menu plan for you.

    Really what's wrong with my food diary?
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
    "Zero" carbs? What are you planning to eat besides steak and olives?

    Personally, I don't like very low-carb diets, but I understand that many people do – so if you'd like to go low-carb, then more power to you. But be aware that a "zero-carb" diet is unhealthy and unrealistic; most foods – including basically all fruits and vegetables – do contain carbohydrates.

    Edit: This is unrelated to this post, but I checked out your food diary, and I'm confused. How did you consume negative half of an apple, or negative three slices of tomato? Does not compute.

    because it was already counted into that particular resteraunts food item or that recipe and I picked it out.
  • JaceyMarieS
    JaceyMarieS Posts: 692 Member
    As long as you need to. Your body does not "need" carbohydrates. It does need glucose. While carbohydrates are the macronutrient most quickly converted to glucose, protein is also eventually converted to glucose. YMMV based on your activity level. Many diabetics and others with metabolic disorders follow an extremely low carb diet. You can google Dr. Richard Bernstein
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
    Looking at your food diary, maybe you should have a nutritionist menu plan for you.

    I do, and again I ask you what's wrong with my food diary?
  • theoriginaljayne
    theoriginaljayne Posts: 559 Member
    "Zero" carbs? What are you planning to eat besides steak and olives?

    Personally, I don't like very low-carb diets, but I understand that many people do – so if you'd like to go low-carb, then more power to you. But be aware that a "zero-carb" diet is unhealthy and unrealistic; most foods – including basically all fruits and vegetables – do contain carbohydrates.

    Edit: This is unrelated to this post, but I checked out your food diary, and I'm confused. How did you consume negative half of an apple, or negative three slices of tomato? Does not compute.

    because it was already counted into that particular resteraunts food item or that recipe and I picked it out.

    Ah, that makes sense. I was really confused at first...
  • Toddrific
    Toddrific Posts: 1,114 Member
    I'm guessing you could survive quite a while, but be healthy...I doubt it.

    From what I heard eskimos ate a mainly carb free diet (Although they did eat vegetation out of animal stomachs)
    and fermented some of their food.

    Your intake would be like 70% fat and 30% protein. I dunno, but that's a pretty gross diet.
  • TeMpi
    TeMpi Posts: 53 Member
    http://www.leangains.com/2009/02/low-carb-talibans.html

    Enough said.
  • orangecrayon
    orangecrayon Posts: 293 Member
    Um...I didn't even think that was possible. But I'd say not for long. My advice is to just eat a balanced diet and watch your portion sizes. Oh, and eat slowly. When you eat slower your brain has more time to signal when it's full. People have fridges. Put leftovers in them :) But if you are worried about carbs, just watch them. Don't go super-under. It's not realistic. But be aware that to be healthy some are required. (Take into account I've never actually tried and am not a professional)
    If all else fails, you can never go wrong with a nutritionist!
  • Summer5555
    Summer5555 Posts: 104 Member
    Because your calories are so low, maybe you are tiny? I don't know. But did your doctor refer you to a see a nutritionist as well seeing as he suggested you modify your diet?
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
    I'm guessing you could survive quite a while, but be healthy...I doubt it.

    From what I heard eskimos ate a mainly carb free diet (Although they did eat vegetation out of animal stomachs)
    and fermented some of their food.

    Your intake would be like 70% fat and 30% protein. I dunno, but that's a pretty gross diet.

    Actually I lack the proper enzymes and amino acids to process carbohydrates so I am one of those few that it is suggested that I maintain less than 20g of carbs per day for the rest of my life. Since I try to keep to that I am healthier than I have ever been.
  • SammyKatt
    SammyKatt Posts: 363 Member
    I think you diary looks pretty good. When doing Low carb, your appetite will go down so make sure you are eating enough. Try to hit your calorie count every day. That's the only reason I stopped doing LC. I did it for over a year and a half and loved it but towards the end I just couldn't eat enough. Volume wise, I ate like crazy, calories wise, not enough.
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member
    Because your calories are so low, maybe you are tiny? I don't know. But did your doctor refer you to a see a nutritionist as well seeing as he suggested you modify your diet?

    My calories are normally 1800 and if I am hungry I eat. I haven't been working out this week because I put in 56 hours of physical labor last week and not only am I sore but I am playing catch up with my school work. Not moving my butt means I'm not as hungry. Oh and I only have 1/3 of a stomach, if that. So your judgement was based purely on calories for a couple of days?
  • tgzerozone
    tgzerozone Posts: 160
    I'm guessing you could survive quite a while, but be healthy...I doubt it.

    From what I heard eskimos ate a mainly carb free diet (Although they did eat vegetation out of animal stomachs)
    and fermented some of their food.

    Your intake would be like 70% fat and 30% protein. I dunno, but that's a pretty gross diet.

    Actually I lack the proper enzymes and amino acids to process carbohydrates so I am one of those few that it is suggested that I maintain less than 20g of carbs per day for the rest of my life. Since I try to keep to that I am healthier than I have ever been.

    You won't die, unless a truck hits you. Your body is completely capable to convert other things to glucose. I would imagine you might feel very tired for a few days until your body adjusts. You might want to stock up on some breath mints as well. :)
  • seansquared
    seansquared Posts: 328 Member
    I eat 20g carbs per day max, and am perfectly healthy.
  • RachelsReboot
    RachelsReboot Posts: 569 Member

    You won't die, unless a truck hits you. Your body is completely capable to convert other things to glucose. I would imagine you might feel very tired for a few days until your body adjusts. You might want to stock up on some breath mints as well. :)

    I've been doing this long enough I am over the tired, I have enough energy to run a business(part time), a non profit(part time) be a full time student, a full time single mom, active in Church groups and organizations (some event weekly), maintain a house, and work out 2 hours a day. Now the keto breath, gums, mint, cinnamon pills, whatever it takes! It's still not as bad as coffee breath!
  • Tajdancer
    Tajdancer Posts: 82 Member
    Tomorrow.
  • jsapninz
    jsapninz Posts: 909 Member
    Since my brain won't be able to function and they are essential for red blood cells and all, how long do I have to live guys? Place your bets!

    Are you seriously joking around about DYING? :huh:

    If your doctor says you will be ok without them, then unless he is a nut, you will be ok.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories