Do you feel hungry when dieting?

2

Replies

  • pukekolive
    pukekolive Posts: 237 Member
    Try upping your protein intake with healthy lean protein or nuts - I almost never feel hungry unless I have been eating more (refined) sugar which sets off cravings - keep your blood sugar levels even with low GI carbs and fruit and you should be fine
  • buzzcogs
    buzzcogs Posts: 296 Member
    I'm hungry a lot and often feel weak or light-headed. I attribute this to the fact that I'm losing weight. If losing weight was "comfortable" it would be easy. Nature doesn't like it when we lose weight it tries to "trick" us into eating, therefore feel crappy when dieting! ;-)
    I figure it's not going to kill me to feel hungry and to get used to it. As long as you are eating healthy just figure you are losing weight when you feel hungry and you will feel better about it.
    It's been proven that people with sedentary "thinking" jobs crave carbs (which help the brain). If you have a job like that, that may be another reason you feel hungry. When I had a more physical, moving job I would actually not feel hungry as much.
    I drink a cup of green tea slowly and it helps kill the "hungries"
    Good luck!
  • SalishSea
    SalishSea Posts: 373 Member
    I felt more hungry all the time when I was eating in my old ways. I would be hungry every two hours because of the spikes in my blood sugar.

    Now that I am trying to make my eating more compatible with a healthy and slender life I don't get as hungry. I still can be very hungry at times. Just not in the same way.

    When I am hungry now I find myself in a quandary. Do I eat my meal now and not have enough calories for when I am hungry later in the day? Or do I push thru this hunger so I can eat later in the day which will satisfy me until dinner? Decisions, decisions!!!

    I know a hungry person does not make a slender person. My weight loss coach tells me you have to eat to lose weight. The key is eating the right thing. Most often that is protein.

    I hate being hungry. I lose focus and control. When I am hungry is when I make terrible, sabotaging choices. Trying to stay satisfied with foods that fit into my calorie allowance will be a challenge for the rest of my life. I am not alone in this challenge, most slender and fit people deal with this everyday too.

    I bought some shirataki noodles today. I am going to dry-fry them. I hear that is the way to cook them. I am hoping these noodles can be part of my arsenal to avoid hunger yet stay satisfied.
  • Tajdancer
    Tajdancer Posts: 82 Member
    I definitely do! The healthier I eat, the hungrier I am. It's very annoying b/c I hate feeling hungry ;(

    Then I would suggest you aren't eating enough. Just mho. I eat healthy, and if I'm hungry, I eat more healthy. Hence: never hungry.
  • Shirvona
    Shirvona Posts: 43 Member
    I usually feel like I am starving even though I can physically feel that I am full, and then would break down and eat something anything (chips, chocolate, soda, cookies, etc) that would make the starving feeling go away so I could continue my day without feeling awful. I had to change it, so this is what I do most days and I don't get that bad "starving although I am full" feeling:

    Start right from the time that you wake up:
    -Smoothie (I usually have a green smoothie, something with leafy vegetables w/fruit and yogurt) (250-350 cal)
    -Do my workout for the day
    -grab raw veggies and fruits put on a platter/bowel, with some raw almonds, couple slices of turkey/chicken/ham and a bottle of water (I keep the veggies and fruits in portioned out baggies in the fridge to help keep them more convenient to grab, especially if I got to go) (about 350-500 cal)
    -put them where I am going to be walking by the a million times a day or if I am not moving around a lot the I put them in arms reach of where I am sitting and munch out all afternoon(10am to an hour or so before supper)
    -have a normal meal for supper (if I make it then it is usually around 350 – 500 cal, if my husband makes it then it is load with salt)
    -go for a walk for 15min to an hour
    -get ready for bed
    -go to sleep

    I feel full all day because I am eating all day; if I finish my platter then I just go and grab more veggies. Also I never feel like eating a full plate of food at supper, just enough for the rest of the night. If I want dessert then in my freezer I have fat free yogurt pops.

    I don’t usually eat an all of my exercise calories; I usually leave them as a buffer, so that I am never over. I am never usually too much under.
  • ashnm88
    ashnm88 Posts: 748
    That's the problem. People do these "diets" instead of changing the lifestyle to a healthier one.
  • jpfost
    jpfost Posts: 192 Member
    I eat like 6 times a day, I am full all day long.
  • albinogorilla
    albinogorilla Posts: 1,056 Member
    double post delete........
  • BPayton27
    BPayton27 Posts: 626 Member
    I don't diet. The minute I start thinking "diet," I panic. I am hungry and miserable ALL DAY. It definitely is a mind game. Really though, don't think of it as a diet. I still eat unhealthy foods from time to time, but it is in MODERATION. I eat a lot less than I once did and work out 5-6x a week. If I went organic or restricted myself from certain foods I would not continue to lose. For me, that causes binging.

    If you're feeling hungry, maybe your weight loss per week goal is too ambitious right now. More protein and water will help!
  • albinogorilla
    albinogorilla Posts: 1,056 Member
    Why do we always get so caught up on the verbiage? This person is looking for help and it never fails that people will always pick a part the word diet! If you are hungry it maybe because you are having withdrawals from certain foods! Your body has to get use to eating health foods and once it does it will be satisfied with them and it wont crave the quick fix of poor food choices! Or not I just made that up off the top of my head!!!!

    Because people need to make a distinction. Dieting is restriction - a form of punishment and not something you want to sustain. A positive lifestyle change on the other hand is about balance, control and learning to respect your body for the rest of your life. A positive lifestyle change is a permenant fix.

    well eating at a deficit is a restriction.........a punishment if you will for eating too much for too long..............lifesyle change refers to eating healthier, not eating a a deficit (which most people on here are) for the rest of their lives..........so i think calling it a diet is fine..............you are restricting your calories to undo the damage you have done.........but you won't eat at a deficit forever.........at least i would hope not.............

    side note, been here over 300 days, and have been hungry everyday..........
  • ScarletShopaholic
    ScarletShopaholic Posts: 169 Member
    I have never been hungry and not eaten - I couldn't do this if I was. I'd just go back to eating all of the junk I used to, so if I'm hungry I eat, usually fruit, or something low calorie that I like. I've eaten some more of what I call junk this last week too lol but within my goals so am good with it.
  • Fairysoul
    Fairysoul Posts: 1,361 Member
    Nope and if I do I fill up on fresh veggies!
  • taso42
    taso42 Posts: 8,980 Member
    Usually only around the transition points. When I transitioned from a surplus to a deficit, I felt hungry for the first several days. Even the opposite is true: when transitioning from a deficit to a surplus, the first few days where like, "whoaaa! how am i supposed to eat all these calories!"

    With a little practice you can come up with a menu that meets your needs and is satiating. This often means plenty of protein and fiber. If you take most of your calories from fast food and starbucks drinks, of course you'll be more hungry than if you were eating lean meats and lots of veggies....
  • christibam
    christibam Posts: 478 Member
    I used to until I started packing protein into every meal and making sure my nutrients were balanced.
  • prettygirlhoward
    prettygirlhoward Posts: 338 Member
    Why do we always get so caught up on the verbiage? This person is looking for help and it never fails that people will always pick a part the word diet! If you are hungry it maybe because you are having withdrawals from certain foods! Your body has to get use to eating health foods and once it does it will be satisfied with them and it wont crave the quick fix of poor food choices! Or not I just made that up off the top of my head!!!!

    This is true! When I first started to eat healthier my body wasnt used to it but after a while I didn't crave the foods I used to at and wasn't hungry as often...... But its hard for me to get back on track.
  • dalgal26
    dalgal26 Posts: 781 Member
    No. :drinker:
  • BaconMD
    BaconMD Posts: 1,165 Member
    Why do we always get so caught up on the verbiage? This person is looking for help and it never fails that people will always pick a part the word diet!

    Because this:
    Think its more psychological than physic.
    indicates that the OP believes it's a mental thing, rather than actual physical hunger. Perhaps, by shifting from the "diet means I am starving myself" mentality, to the "diet just means all of the foods that make up my nutritional intake, and this is a permanent change towards better health" one, something will click in the OP's head - psychologically, you see - therefore eliminating the problem.
  • ahealthy4u
    ahealthy4u Posts: 442 Member
    I can't think of it as a diet. I hate the word diet. I'm thinking of it as changes I can live with forever. I don't deprive myself if I really want something.

    I guess if you are still hungry you need to adjust your schedule and change things up and around I have to do that every so often sometimes it is because I am not getting enough protein in my diet or fiber. I need to go back and review what is working and what is not working. My body gets use to it. But I don't think of it as a diet either I think of it as a lifestyle change. Good luck to you I hope you find what works for you.
  • I think some of it is learning that not being full doesn't mean you feel hungry. If it's between meals eat a handful of almonds to get some protein in you and you should be good. It may be different for you, but I've found that I think clearer and my mood is better when I'm a little hungry, and so I've learned to like that feeling to an extent.
  • hannahbanana0480
    hannahbanana0480 Posts: 46 Member
    I am always more hungry too. I think it's because I'm not stuffing my face with fried fatty goodness.
  • tantalee
    tantalee Posts: 130 Member
    I definitely do! The healthier I eat, the hungrier I am. It's very annoying b/c I hate feeling hungry ;(
    Exactly! This is the most big pain in the *kitten* of losing weight. Im always hungry.
  • tantalee
    tantalee Posts: 130 Member
    I can't think of it as a diet. I hate the word diet. I'm thinking of it as changes I can live with forever. I don't deprive myself if I really want something.

    ^^^^
    This. It's not a diet, it's a healthy balanced lifestyle that I can keep up forever. I'm hardly ever hungry and losing 1.5lbs most weeks. If you are constantly hungry your weight loss goals are probably set too high x

    The goals are realistic, but just the idea of eating things i dont like, like fruit and vegetables and grilled meat, just makes me depressed
  • TurtleTape
    TurtleTape Posts: 254 Member

    The goals are realistic, but just the idea of eating things i dont like, like fruit and vegetables and grilled meat, just makes me depressed

    I've lost 23 pounds eating things I love. I simply eat them in moderation now instead of eating half a pizza at a time. There's no reason to torture yourself. Right now? A huge chili bread bowl that fits neatly into my calories for the day. I'm very rarely hungry.
  • Spanaval
    Spanaval Posts: 1,200 Member
    I may be eating more now than I used to, just less of the junk and more of the stuff that's good for me. The way I see it, if I cannot sustain this way of eating for the rest of my life, I'm doing it wrong.
  • Spanaval
    Spanaval Posts: 1,200 Member
    The goals are realistic, but just the idea of eating things i dont like, like fruit and vegetables and grilled meat, just makes me depressed

    Sounds like a punishment. I've always found that eating in moderation, and making small changes work better than going all out and making huge changes that I hate and wouldn't want to abide by in the long run.
  • tantalee
    tantalee Posts: 130 Member
    I definitely do! The healthier I eat, the hungrier I am. It's very annoying b/c I hate feeling hungry ;(

    Then I would suggest you aren't eating enough. Just mho. I eat healthy, and if I'm hungry, I eat more healthy. Hence: never hungry.
    Exactly! I feel like im starving all the time unless i eat something i really like, like a small portion of fries (around 200 calories) or a little bit of chocolate (around 150 cal) by the end of the day, like a prize for being a "good girl".
  • tantalee
    tantalee Posts: 130 Member
    The goals are realistic, but just the idea of eating things i dont like, like fruit and vegetables and grilled meat, just makes me depressed

    Sounds like a punishment. I've always found that eating in moderation, and making small changes work better than going all out and making huge changes that I hate and wouldn't want to abide by in the long run.

    I want to lose weight but eating those stuff that i really dont like its just awful. So why cant i lose weight having my "every day" treat? I dont mind of the vegetables or the soup, but please please...i just want to be able to eat a small portion of fries or a little kinder chocolate. Each have less than 200 calories and make me happy. Its that so bad?
  • tantalee
    tantalee Posts: 130 Member
    I may be eating more now than I used to, just less of the junk and more of the stuff that's good for me. The way I see it, if I cannot sustain this way of eating for the rest of my life, I'm doing it wrong.

    :D
    My style :D
  • mcquilna
    mcquilna Posts: 8
    try eating more fiber. It keeps you feeling fuller, longer.
  • What i do isnt a diet. This not something im going to do for 2 months to get to a certain pants size. What i have done is completely changed my lifestyle. I eat 5 times a day and i am never hungry. Eating 5 times a day isnt for everyone and it is ok for u to feel a little hungry but if ur starving u need to eat a snack. I use to think if my hands were shaking and i had headaches from hunger i would lose weight and it is quite the opposite u have to eat to lose weight. Good LUck!