The 4000 calorie vs 2000 calorie argument...:)
Replies
-
Just throwing it out there, I am 5'9" and 225 lbs, my maintain is about 2700, currently I'm on about 1320/day without exercise (meaning that obviously I can have more if I exercise, which I do, haha).
My fiance is about 6'1" and 200-some and he is on 2200 cal/day and is still losing.
I think it completely depends on the person, their activity level, and gender, but GENERALLY 2000 calories is correct. I would gain a ton of weight on 4000 cal, unless I started training for a marathon or something.0 -
Michael Phelps eats 12,000 because he's high
Did the same plan, minus the swimming.I have NEVER ate 4000 cal. in a day. The guy is cuckoo for cocoa puffs. Not even professional athletes should eat that kind of amount every day.
I highly doubt you've never exceeded 4000 calories in a day. It's far more likely that back before you started tracking your intake & paying attention to the caloric content of stuff, you did & just weren't aware of it. I logged a >7,000 calorie day back in January, averaged 2k calories a day the following 6 days & was down 2 lbs by my next weighin. A couple of restaurant meals then a night at the bar can add up quick. Sure, if I averaged 4k calories a day I'd probably gain slowly, but even now that i'm trying to lose weight it's still easy to rack up the calories if I allow myself to.
To the OP, if your friend is convinced that this fixed number is what everyone should go by, he is clearly NOT someone you should count on as an authority on fitness. Who cares what he believes, anyway?0 -
I spent a long time eating 4000 calories. I had to come here to fix that.
:laugh: same here!0 -
I would weigh 500 pounds if I ate that much. Plus, it would be very difficult for me to eat that much food!
Eating like that is EXACTLY How I ended up over 600lbs:grumble:0 -
I would weigh 500 pounds if I ate that much. Plus, it would be very difficult for me to eat that much food!
Eating like that is EXACTLY How I ended up over 600lbs:grumble:
WHOA. As it appears, you've lost quite a bit of it too! Congratulations!!0 -
MFP recommends I eat around 2400 calories. AND... if I add my exercise I'll be at around 2800 calories. I could eat pretty much anything I wanted. I manually changed it to 1650. So far I'm averaging 2.6 lbs a week and I'm not starving myself either. Just eat back most of my workout calories. SO yes it depends on who you are and if you need it0
-
Of course, there's no such thing as the "right" amount of calories, you're much closer to being right than he is.
so you're saying she is a unique and beautiful snowflake??
Bwahahaha!0 -
The only time I've seen 4000 + calorie diet is in professional athletes, I read somewhere on NBA website once about diets that some players burn up to 5 lbs in just one game, that's why they consume so many calories, I guess it depends on what they're doing. I'm pretty sure Michael Phelps eats like 12,000 a day!
Michael Phelps eats 12,000 because he's high
True. But he clearly works it all off!
What I wonder is how he has time to eat that much???0 -
I spent a long time eating 4000 calories. I had to come here to fix that.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!! :noway:0 -
if he is 200 lbs plus and works out for 2 hours/day 4000 cals might be right.
I am not a large guy so, for me to lose I need to eat around 2000 cals (1700-1800 Net), my maintenance cals are only 2100, if I don't workout and eat more than 2100, I would gain weight.0 -
Are you sure they weren't confusing kcal with kj?0
-
I gained weight on 1700 a day. 4000 seems crazy for anyone other that large male professional athletes. I would say 2000 for the average 5'10 male, 1800 for the average 5'5" female to maintain a healthy weight. More if doing a lot of exercise.0
-
If I ate 4000 calories a day, I'd gain about 2 pounds per week, and I already weigh 320 pounds. As an adult, you'd have to be a pretty dedicated athlete to need that many calories to maintain weight (unless you're trying to bulk up).
Children are a different story, they need to eat more calories to sustain growth. I read somewhere that the average caloric requirement for boys aged 13-18 is 3000 per day (girls were 2200, as I recall), and I could see 4000 being reasonable for a student who was into sports throughout the year.0 -
I would weigh 500 pounds if I ate that much. Plus, it would be very difficult for me to eat that much food!
Eating like that is EXACTLY How I ended up over 600lbs:grumble:
i used to eat close to probly 4000 cals a day at my old job and during the summer when i was most active i actually lost weight.... but then i moved to a more sedentary job and kept eating that, withing 2 years i had gained like 80 pounds and tipped the scale at 535 lbs. so i came here to fix that.0 -
I think, in general, the shorter you are the less you can eat. I am only 5'1" and have to eat really low to lose weight (well not anymore since I don't need to lose weight anymore). But I still have to eat fairly low to maintain compared to the rest of society (IE if I ate 2000 calories I would gain weight for sure). We are all different and the bottom line if you are gaining weight as a trend you need to lower the calories. All these calorie estimates are just that, estimates. It is our job to use the ballpark number, monitor the scale as a trend tool, and adjust to what works. If you are losing over time then it works, if you are gaining well then lower the calories a bit and monitor until you fine what works.0
-
Yes it's true that everyone is different but your friend needs a reality check if he thinks 2000 calories is a starvation diet for most people.0
-
Try using this with his details and see what you get
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/tools/bmr-calculator0 -
2000 is considered for an athlete maintaining their weight. So yeah, 4000 is ridiculous. .....
2000 would be woefully inadequate for an athlete which illustrates the problem with making generalizations.
My TDEE (at moderately active) is 2,821 and I'm losing approx 1Lb per week at 2200 to 2300. There are skinny little triathletes at my club that will go through more than 4,000 cal per day when their training is peaking.0 -
Are you sure they weren't confusing kcal with kj?
4000 kjoules is only 955 kcalories . . . which instead of being ridiculously high for an average adult is unhealthily low!0 -
If you are eating 4000 calories a day, you better be doing 2-3 hours of exercise as well each day.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 392.9K Introduce Yourself
- 43.7K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.8K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 415 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.6K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions