When is a pound lost and where does it go?

13468912

Replies

  • MisterTEZ
    MisterTEZ Posts: 272 Member
    posts like this make me laugh! So many "experts" out there on the Internet. Just because it's on the Internet, or google, doesn't mean it's real. White in pee. Yes, consult physician!!
    If you have white **** coming out with your urine, see a doc. It ain't fat!

    I think it was a physician who told her that :ohwell:

    Does that mean if I drink tons and tons of water all the fat will come out in my pee? :bigsmile:
  • To whoever said you PEE it out:

    "Ketonuria is a medical condition in which ketone bodies are present in the urine.
    It is seen in conditions in which the body produces excess ketones as an alternative source of energy. It is seen during starvation or more commonly in type I diabetes mellitus. Production of ketone bodies is a normal response to a shortage of glucose, meant to provide an alternate source of fuel from fatty acids."

    Note where it said DURING STARVATION or in Diabetics...

    This is not a "common" type of "where does my fat go?". It is not something to strive for or be pleased to see. It is actually bad.

    Some no carb diets teach dieters to test their urine for ketones with the test strips. This is how they know if they are doing the diet properly. I agree - not good.
  • sttrinians
    sttrinians Posts: 94 Member
    Personally I prefer the Dr Who version. Your fat leaves your body as an Adipose a new baby life form and is beamed to another planet to grow and mature.

    Anyone who doesn't watch Dr Who google Adipose they are so cute.

    Googled and you are right - they are cute :love: .... I just love the thought of peeing all those l'il ole adipose out!!! :laugh:

    It just comes out of you like in alien, and toddles off to be collected by the Adipose collectors it's so funny.
  • mariasotera
    mariasotera Posts: 29 Member
    Bump!
  • To whoever said you PEE it out:

    "Ketonuria is a medical condition in which ketone bodies are present in the urine.
    It is seen in conditions in which the body produces excess ketones as an alternative source of energy. It is seen during starvation or more commonly in type I diabetes mellitus. Production of ketone bodies is a normal response to a shortage of glucose, meant to provide an alternate source of fuel from fatty acids."

    Note where it said DURING STARVATION or in Diabetics...

    This is not a "common" type of "where does my fat go?". It is not something to strive for or be pleased to see. It is actually bad.

    You cannot see Ketones... however you can smell them. So the white in her urine would not be ketones. Ketones are the result of fats being broken down. This means that the body is usig fat for energy.
  • madamepsychosis
    madamepsychosis Posts: 472 Member
    well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.

    So THIS is why drinking water helps you lose weight...the more water you drink, the more you pee, so the more fat can leave your body...good to know :huh:

    Seriously, you'd think that with all the resources we have available to us, people would not be THIS misinformed. And that doctor...how did he/she ever get a license to practice medicine?! :grumble:
    The doctor was this guy:
    snnz2f.png
  • emmamcblain
    emmamcblain Posts: 342
    Some of these answers are just spot on, hahahaha.
  • hahaha these posts made my day 10,000x better.
  • JuliaWallaceGal
    JuliaWallaceGal Posts: 24 Member
    When you put gas in your car and drive around all week, where does it go?
    Hey, I like the analogy!!
  • This content has been removed.
  • ZoeLifts
    ZoeLifts Posts: 10,347 Member
    Where do lost pounds go?

    Can they find their way home?
  • GasMasterFlash
    GasMasterFlash Posts: 2,206 Member
    BUMP!
  • kgprice11
    kgprice11 Posts: 749 Member
    usually when I lose a lb. it is in the bathroom....hehehe :blushing:
  • GasMasterFlash
    GasMasterFlash Posts: 2,206 Member
    well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.
    One of my MFP's just reported this happening to her! She lost a few pounds in a couple of days, and had chicken fat-like stuff in her pee. So cool!
  • bm99
    bm99 Posts: 597 Member
    well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.
    One of my MFP's just reported this happening to her! She lost a few pounds in a couple of days, and had chicken fat-like stuff in her pee. So cool!

    Are you joking?
  • GasMasterFlash
    GasMasterFlash Posts: 2,206 Member
    well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.
    One of my MFP's just reported this happening to her! She lost a few pounds in a couple of days, and had chicken fat-like stuff in her pee. So cool!
    Are you joking?
    She reported it on her wall today.
  • wolfi622
    wolfi622 Posts: 206
    posts like this make me laugh! So many "experts" out there on the Internet. Just because it's on the Internet, or google, doesn't mean it's real. White in pee. Yes, consult physician!!
    If you have white **** coming out with your urine, see a doc. It ain't fat!

    I think it was a physician who told her that :ohwell:

    Does that mean if I drink tons and tons of water all the fat will come out in my pee? :bigsmile:

    I seriously doubt a physician told her that.
  • MaraDiaz
    MaraDiaz Posts: 4,604 Member
    I think of food like firewood. Drop too much on the fire, you get a big ole bonfire. Drop too little, and you're likely to burn down to weak little coals. We burn, you know. Humans burn at an average temperature of 98.6, and that alone requires fuel.
  • bm99
    bm99 Posts: 597 Member
    well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.
    One of my MFP's just reported this happening to her! She lost a few pounds in a couple of days, and had chicken fat-like stuff in her pee. So cool!
    Are you joking?
    She reported it on her wall today.

    You're joking.

    ...Right? It's funny if you are but if not...
  • kgprice11
    kgprice11 Posts: 749 Member
    The original poster asked some interesting questions, and I like the way she thinks.

    A "heat engine" takes in heat and converts a portion of it into mechanical work. When nutrient molecules in the body are combined with oxygen ("burned"), that's an exothermic reaction; it produces heat. Muscle cells use that heat energy to do work. The whole human body can be usefully regarded as a heat engine.

    And yes, calories *are* energy, rigorously and exactly. A calorie is the amount of heat energy required to increase the temperature of a gram of water by a Celsius degree. (A nutritional calorie -- the sort we all talk about here -- is 1000 calories, as defined. It is also equal to 4186 joules, which is the work done by one newton of force over a parallel displacement of 4186 meters. A "typical" person weighs about 667 newtons, and can be lifted a little over six meters, straight up, by a nutritional calorie of mechanical work.)

    A pound is lost when a pound of stored nutrients in the body (hopefully, fat) has been converted to ... well, not just energy. If an entire pound of fat were all converted to energy (according to E = mc^2), a dieter would be like an atomic bomb. But, as another commenter pointed out, chemical bonds in the pound of fat are broken, some of it is oxidized, heat is produced by that reaction; most of the rest of the broken-down nutrient molecules become waste and are eliminated in the same way as any food waste. The energy required by your body is supplied by the food you eat; if you don't eat "enough," you're in a calorie-deficit situation, and some stored body fat is internally "eaten" as well. As the OP said, about 3500 cal of deficit is equivalent to a pound of fat; as for WHEN this happens: as soon as your body requires a single calorie more than you've eaten, 1/3500 of a pound gets burned. When your cumulative deficit reaches 3500 cal, a full pound will have been used. (For the elimination of the unburned waste, I suppose there's a time delay measured in hours.)

    But, in any case, that pound of fat didn't turn into nothing. A very small fraction of it is turned into heat and used by your muscles; the vast majority is turned into feces and urine, and returns to nature in the usual ways.

    People ask me from time to time how much weight I've lost. Of course, I tell them that "lost" is probably too strong a term. I pretty much know where all of it is. Most of it's at the grocery store; quite a bit is at Burger King and Taco Bell and so on. I could go pick it up at any time. So, it's not really lost; it's more like "misplaced." I hope to leave it that way.

    Being an engineer also I love this response and can't get enough of it. hahahah
  • GasMasterFlash
    GasMasterFlash Posts: 2,206 Member
    So glad to see this thread active again.
  • _HeathBar_
    _HeathBar_ Posts: 902 Member
    I lost a pound the other day but I didn't notice any white stuff in my pee. Does that mean it was just water weight?
  • GasMasterFlash
    GasMasterFlash Posts: 2,206 Member
    I lost a pound the other day but I didn't notice any white stuff in my pee. Does that mean it was just water weight?
    Exactly!
  • KatieJane83
    KatieJane83 Posts: 2,002 Member
    Honestly, this tread just made my entire month.
  • bm99
    bm99 Posts: 597 Member
    I lost a pound the other day but I didn't notice any white stuff in my pee. Does that mean it was just water weight?

    It means you're in starvation mode.
  • well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.
    Bump, as this bears bumping.
  • odusgolp
    odusgolp Posts: 10,477 Member
    well you can stay at maintainance at burn 500 cals a day n you will lose a pound every week.
    2nd ques when you are burning fat look for when thing when you go to toilet to pee you will notice something white in your pee is like chicken fat thats how some of your fat comes out n some as a sweat. because when i did a diet few years back when the white thing came in pee i got scared that its something serious but found out its nothing just fat so a doctor knows best.

    Oh, I forgot how much I loved this thread :) Thank you Fartist :)
  • Cranktastic
    Cranktastic Posts: 1,517 Member
    no
  • yummy_
    yummy_ Posts: 248 Member
    my day just got a little brighter.
  • jofjltncb6
    jofjltncb6 Posts: 34,415 Member
    no

    ^this

    (And every time this thread gets bumped, you increase the likelihood of it being mod-nuked.)
This discussion has been closed.