have you lost weight without clean eating?

chanstriste13 · May 2012

does anyone fall in this category?

i have about 30 more pounds to lose, but i have been holding steady for nearly a full year now, and i can't figure out what to do. between august of 2010 and june of 2011, i lost around 25 pounds. it came off consistently. i was eating a tostino's oven pizza one to two times per week during this time. i also ate at a jr. burrito at moe's followed up with stonecold icecream every monday. i was not the poster child for clean eating by a long shot, but i was losing weight every week.

after the summer, i decided to clean up my diet a bit - nothing drastic, but i eat more meals at home, eat salads instead of pizza, etc. and i've been on hold ever since. i still workout hard 5 days a week, and i pay attention to my calorie intake. i don't log like i used to because i'm getting so frustrated, but i have a meal routine that i pretty much stick to, so i know when i've gone overboard on a day - this doesn't happen too often - maybe once every two or three weeks.

i just saw on another thread a slew of people saying don't eat anything that comes out of a can or a box because that can impede weight loss. has anyone had success losing weight *without* the clean eating aspect? if i fix a veggie plate for dinner, everything comes out of a can except for the sweet potato. i'm not an organic kind of gal. i understand that clean eating can have some uber healthy benefits that maybe (hopefully) i'll eventually be interested in. but i don't understand how eating processed food could completely cut off weight loss - especially when i was losing consistently when i was eating oven-sludge pizzas every week at one time.

anyhoo...just looking for anyone with similar experiences. thanks in advance! :flowerforyou:

watboy · May 2012

Yes I did. I lost 60 lbs.I wasn't eating clean. As a matter of fact I still ate processed foods. I ate lots of the same foods eiteh rins maller quantaties or substitutions. It can be done and I know tons of people who have done it without clean eating. Excercise , weight lift and be in a calorie deficit. You will do fine.

roachhaley · May 2012

I try to eat cleanER, but still eat processed food daily. Still losing weight.

subtractionproject · May 2012

Yeah I can't afford to 'eat clean', as it were. I eat as my budget allows, and that necessarily includes some share of processed 'crap'. As long as I stick to my calorie goal and try to get in my greens along with my microwaveable lasagne, I'm good.

chanstriste13 · May 2012

thanks for the input.

maybe i should go back to eating my tostinos...

skylark94 · May 2012

I still eat absolutely everything I ate when I was at my heaviest. I just eat less of it now.

Drastic changes to diet led to feelings of deprivation which led to failure in my other attempts.

meg7399 · May 2012

to lose weight all you need is a calorie deficit. Sometimes your body plateaus. Try upping calories a bit or switching up the exercise routines.

janalayn · May 2012

I have lost 40 pounds and I definitely don't eat clean. I do avoid sodas and drive thrus but I eat the foods I like including a little junk food now and then. Maybe you just need to change up your routine. You didn't say what your calorie intake has been but if it has been very low you might want to check the "eat more to lose weight" threads. I try to change my exercise routine at least every two months and I try to always eat at least my BMR and eat back enough exercise calories to net 1200.

tris2002 · May 2012

i've lost 20 pounds without clean eating. I try to make smarter choices but don't deprive myself of the things i want. If i want some type of junk food i just watch my portions and eat it and go on with my day :0)

LorinaLynn · May 2012

Yep. I have DiGiorno pizza at least once a week, Knorr rice sides, lots of pasta and breads, lots of pre-made sauces, dressings and marinades.

smithhm12 · May 2012

I don't do clean eating at all. All I focuss on is meeting my calorie and fat goal for the day. I am losing about 2 pounds a week consistantly. Maybe you could try eating more calories. I have heard a lot of people say when they up their calorie intake when at a stand still the weight starts to come off again. Just a suggestion.

Good luck! :happy:

AntShanny · May 2012

I still eat pretty much the same stuff I did before I started my Revolution, but just less of it...and I try really hard to eat more fruits and vegetables but it's a struggle for me! I like the dirty stuff...
I am getting better though...every day.

SPNLuver83 · May 2012

i don't eat "clean" and I think i've done alright!

poshcouture · May 2012

A couple years ago, I was on Nutrisystem. That program is nowhere near close to "eating clean." However, I managed to lose about 70 pounds following the plan. I say do what is working for your body and your budget - whether you're watching GI levels, eating clean or just strictly your calorie intake.

As for me, I have cut out a lot of processed foods and am trying to eat more fresh, homecooked meals. Being vegan, it can be difficult to not eat anything processed (i.e. tofu) - however, I am learning to add more beans and lentils into my diet (along with quinoa).

juleszephyr · May 2012

Ok cutting out all the fads and bull****. Losing weight is a matter of simple maths. Consume less calories than you burn in energy consistently and you will lose weight, even if every calorie is pizza and chips...

This of course is not healthy but it is a fact. You may want to shake up your diet a bit with new foods and ideas to stop the boredom but honestly a slow down or plateau is more likely to be because you are not logging and weighing everything because you think you 'know' your cals and portion sizes.

I have lost 8 stones and kept it off for 4 years now, with a healthy diet and plenty of exercise but honestly it is just simple maths, eat less cals than you burn and you WILL lose weight. simple...
Jules xx

PrinnyBomb · May 2012

I've lost 38 lbs so far and while I do a lot of cooking with 'real food' sometimes I do enjoy a can of soup or a ready meal. Doesn't make me a bad person.

Rhea30 · May 2012

Calories are calories but I do think veggies help since they are low calories and can help stretch your food and fill you up.

chevy88grl · May 2012

I've lost all of my weight eating the stuff that I love. Do I eat less of it? Absolutely. Don't get me wrong, there are foods I no longer eat but I don't eat them because they don't make me feel good when I do. I still eat stuff out of boxes, I eat stuff out of cans. I work full time, have two teenagers and a life... I don't want to work til 5 or 6pm and then have to come home and come up with some delicious homemade dinner. Add in that I am a sweet a holic who refuses to give up her daily cookies.

I am very healthy (my blood work and other tests are "excellent") AND I enjoy my life. That is what a "lifestyle change" is supposed to be about.. eating less, eating better but still enjoying life.

Do what works for YOU.

clumsymofro · May 2012

People are really scared of processed foods because there is so much sodium in them. Well, this can really be a big issue if you are seriously overweight and have high blood pressure already. But, if you are overweight, have some weight to loss and don't have any issues with high blood pressure, it's not something that you have to worry about as much. This is coming from the mouth of a nutritionist, so the biggest thing, like everyone is saying, is to try and eat a little better, watch your calories, fat and portions but you don't have to completely cut out processed foods. I've lost over 100 lbs in about 2 yrs and I continue to eat processed foods such as ranch dressing, frozen dinners, lean pockets, etc.

cjs3001 · May 2012

Clean definitely works for some people but I've never really done it and I've lost 75lbs. I think it's something we should all try to do at least sometimes but like a lot of other commenters, I eat the same as before but smaller amounts/fewer times a month and with lots more green things!

81Katz · May 2012

Yes I lost weight without being a 100% clean eater, which I feel that is impossible anyhow. I would say I am a 70/30 eater. 70% meaning I eat lotsssssss of fresh stuff through out the day, everyday. 30% meaning I still eat 'processed foods', cereal, crackers, bread, protein bars, drink packets, etc.

I try to eat fresh as much as possible and luckily I like the fresh stuff but I still like some processed food too. I'm human.

chanstriste13 · May 2012

@meg - my workout classes are varied each week (except for zumba!). i do a combination of cardio intervals and strength training. i did the c25k program last year, so i throw in some jogging too. when i need to shake it up, i use 30 day shred and p90x. i feel like my exercise routine is pretty well varied and should keep my body guessing, but who knows?

@janalyn - my calories are set to 1590. i typically burn between 450 and 700 calories when i workout, and i will eat back enough calories to net between 1200 and 1300. sometimes i eat back all of my exercise calories, but typically 50% to 75% of them.

squishycow7 · May 2012

yes. I lost most of my weight on a not-so-awesome diet.

however, I FEEL better when I eat "clean." I haven't necessarily seen complete correlation between clean eating and weight loss, but since I feel more energetic, sleep better, have fewer migraines, and have better allergies when I'm eating "real" food, my workouts tend to go better and my attitude toward eating gets much better. I also am sort of an all-or-nothing person when it comes to carbs/sugar, so if I START my day with a muffin, I'll probably end it in cake. Which probably means over eating/over cals/gaining weight (or at least stalling weight-loss).

SO in conclusion - eating clean helps ME. If you have good energy on "crap" and you feel happy/healthy, then whatever - your body is blessed and I am jealous in a way

But I don't believe clean eating is the end-all-be-all of weight loss. Still gotta have exercise, moderated calories, etc etc.

dthrnm12 · May 2012

Check the sodium content on the cans of veggies you eat. Some are high in sodium and will cause you to retain water. I am on a budget and clean eating can be more expensive if you shop at the grocery store. Try to find a farmers market or produce stand near you. I just spent 9.50 on a weeks worth of fresh veggies and fruit. Heads of lettuce were only $.59, corn was $.10 and berries were around $1.00. Hope this helps

LatinaGordita · May 2012

I do not eat clean either and have lost weight consistently. I eat many proteins that come in a box for example salmon burgers, veggie meatballs, chicken veggie grillers etc. However, I do keep a close eye on my calorie deficit and macros. I keep my protein high 120 grams or over and keep carbs to less than 100 grams per day.

I would say log everything, change your meal and exercise routine. I change my meal and exercise routine biweekly to keep my body in a constant state of change. Since January I only had 2 weeks where I had no loss and they were not consecutive weeks.

zombiefarmboy · May 2012

I don't even know what "clean eating" is, but I highly doubt it's anything I'm doing. I have cut back on portion sizes and will choose a bowl of cereal or a yogurt over a bowl of ice cream or a few cookies. And I've lost 10 lbs. First time I've been under 190 in a long time!

Dave198lbs · May 2012

for just weight loss the calories can be clean or dirty. its only the number of calories. "clean" is a relative term...doesnt mean organic or raw. the less crap you eat, the better you perform. but for weight loss, it dont matter,

rainwalkerSK · May 2012

http://www.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html

There are certain things I've had to cut out of my diet because they trigger binge eating-- I cannot eat a reasonable portion size of Cheetos, for example, so I don't bother trying. I haven't been at this anywhere near as long as most, but I'm happy with the results I've gotten so far from watching portion sizes and staying close to my calorie goal, while still enjoying my Starbucks breakfast sandwiches.

TheFitHooker · May 2012

The only things I've removed from my day to day diet is Soda's and Fried foods. I eat healthier but I don't eat clean because I can't afford to do that when my husband doesn't wish to do it, can't afford to cook different just for me.

bjshields · May 2012

Thanks for this post, I really find it fascinating. I have gone vegan, but it's not just in an effort to lose weight, although that certainly is a part of it. Cancer runs in my family (Dad died at 44), and I'd like to avoid it. I try to think of eating FOR health, not just AGAINST weight. I am having major thyroid issues, though, so it doesn't matter what I do (I'm working on it). Best of luck to you!

Perisylpha · May 2012

When the supermarket is full of pre-packed ready made foods, it's hard not buy some of it, sometimes just for the sake of convenience and speed. There's nothing wrong with canned and frozen veg and baked beans are very healthy if you buy the reduced sugar and salt type and invaluable for family meals imo. I can't afford organic either, I just buy what I can afford.

have you lost weight without clean eating?

Replies

Categories

have you lost weight *without* clean eating?

Replies

Categories

have you lost weight without clean eating?