Too big to exercise?
LynzeNichole
Posts: 43
I have a problem where 30seconds - 2 minutes into a workout I feel like I am DYING. I've heard several theories: I'm not breathing right, I just have to get my endurance up, and then that I'm physically too large right now to do heavy cardio. Is there any truth to this? I've seen several bloggers who were trying to lose 100+ lbs that didn't start an exercise regimen until they'd lost about half of that so I was wondering if it's true. I certainly don't want to use that as a cop-out, but I also don't want to endanger myself exercising in a way that isn't good for me. Any thoughts? Or should I speak with a doctor about it?
0
Replies
-
I weighed 290lbs. I lost 10 lbs and then started walking some. I started off only walking about 10 minutes. After about 1 month I was up to 30 minutes per day. Some days I can walk 50 minutes split up into a morning and afternoon walk. It would be best for you to see your doctor to ask how much you should be exercising.0
-
First off, always consult with a doctor about an exercise program and any potential issues. There might be underlying issues. Better to be safe than sorry.
With that said, I exercised at 350 by walking short distances and resting frequently. It takes a while but you will build an endurance. Important thing is to stick with it.0 -
I think consulting a doctor is always a good idea when you're starting an exercise program for the first time.
What kinds of activities are you doing so far? Maybe you need to slow things down and ease into it a little more?0 -
Yes, see a doctor. It's good to know the facts about your health. (personally, mine put me on Beta Blockers, but I'm old) The facts that help you lose are: what is your health like, how many calories are you taking in and how many calories are you burning.
Walking is a good place to start. I started on bicycling because it was low impact. I wear a HRM whenever I exercise.
The best exercise is the one you will enjoy enough to keep doing. For me that is currently Jazzercise, because I love to dance and they are good at showing modifications for low impact.
Perhaps swimming would appeal to you and you might try weight training to balance out your cardio.
Best of luck! :happy:0 -
Thanks for all the responses! I'll definitely see a doctor soon to see what I should be doing. I've tried a variety of things, never lasting more than a day or two on each: 30 day shred, couch to 5k plan, various workout videos. I think I'm trying to do too much too fast because I never exercised AT ALL. I'm going to start just walking and building up my endurance for other things.0
-
Thanks for all the responses! I'll definitely see a doctor soon to see what I should be doing. I've tried a variety of things, never lasting more than a day or two on each: 30 day shred, couch to 5k plan, various workout videos. I think I'm trying to do too much too fast because I never exercised AT ALL. I'm going to start just walking and building up my endurance for other things.
I think you nailed it here. See the dr, make sure you are cleared but then start slow. If you have not been exercising walking is a darn good stepping stone to the road to fitness. Good luck on your journey.0 -
Walk
A lot0 -
I approached my doctor with a question whether he sees any reason for me not to start a heavy cardio workout regimen.
I'm currently about 15 lb overweight, but I have a sedentary lifestyle. His suggestion was to start out slow with walking etc. Then gradually increase exercise. I'm assuming this would be the same advise for any weight loss target.
"weighed 290lbs. I lost 10 lbs and then started walking some. I started off only walking about 10 minutes. After about 1 month I was up to 30 minutes per day. Some days I can walk 50 minutes split up into a morning and afternoon walk. " this is great advise.0 -
Never too big to swim. I had a 100+ to lose. I have always been a swimmer but there are ladies in the water exercise group much larger than I am. Many just walk laps in the pool. I could also walk just not far. Swimming is not only easy on the joints it does provide resistance so it isn't just straight walking.0
-
I started with being 100+ pounds over weight and i started exercising right away. When i first started i could do about 2 minutes on the elliptical and 10 walking very slowly on the treadmill. I found swimming was easiest for me at my heaviest though and did a lot of swimming at first. Once i lost about 50 pounds i started really working on cardio. Just keep going. Make sure u r healthy enough for exercise but i dont think u need to wait before u have lost weight to start exercise. Every step matters!!
0 -
I was 290 2 months ago and started walking 20 minutes a day. I'm now doing 60-90 a day. Yesterday I did 50 minutes hard exercise walking, 40 minutes doing errands in the neighborhood, 30 minutes weights,and 10 minutes stretching. I"n not ready for hard cardio or anything that's going to risk tearing muscles.
I now can walk up a hill that's 17 flights of stairs - I do wear an HRM to ensure I'm not stressing myself.
Walking is a good place to start- 5 or 10 minutes for a week, then try doing that twice a day and keep building up.0 -
I am 300+ lbs and am currently doing zumba 2x a week, 30 day shred, and walking 2 miles. I have done eliptical as well. I am about 2 months in. When I first started I was very winded about 2 minutes and thought i was GOING TO DIEEEEEEEEEE. You will get stronger with each workout. I was not able to jump up and down until yesterday, so when you reach those little NSV's you will see how worth it it was to keep going. YOU CAN DO THIS!!!!0
-
Walk
A lot
this0 -
I'm going to add one on for walking! It's a great place to start.0
-
I started to run when I was 210lbs. Hard on the joints and I could only run a mile at a time, but I got it done. What about lifting weights?0
-
Walk, Walk, Walk.
Or!
Swim. Water Aerobics.0 -
I have a problem where 30seconds - 2 minutes into a workout I feel like I am DYING. I've heard several theories: I'm not breathing right, I just have to get my endurance up, and then that I'm physically too large right now to do heavy cardio. Is there any truth to this? I've seen several bloggers who were trying to lose 100+ lbs that didn't start an exercise regimen until they'd lost about half of that so I was wondering if it's true. I certainly don't want to use that as a cop-out, but I also don't want to endanger myself exercising in a way that isn't good for me. Any thoughts? Or should I speak with a doctor about it?
talk to your doctor make sure your not pushing a heart attack. Then start slow, with a walk and work your way up to heavy cardio. I am sitting at about 264 I walk for about 30 minutes twice a day now. I also garden a lot, right now my project is moving wood mulch from a pile in my driveway into my garden shovel by shovel full. So far I have moved about 8 yards of the 12 yards I bought, and my garden is looking fantastic, and my arms are getting little muscles. My whole front yard is now garden, keeping it weeded is a major challenge.0 -
I am now down to 298 and I started swimming 10 laps in a pool followed by cardio on a Cybex Arc Trainer. You hafta start somewhere and work your way up.0
-
Start by doing 10 minute slow walks..then gradually increase your time and speed. You need to build your endurance; but slowly. I use to start by walking my dog for 10 minutes every day...then started to walk around the mall parking lot. It all takes time. You will get there..be patient. 0
-
You're never "too big" to get some sort of exercise in! I started at over 350 pounds with walking. In order to prevent myself from making excuses *not* to exercise, I went to the local animal shelter and adopted a dog who liked to go on lots of walks. Three years later, I've lost over 150 pounds, Maxine and I now walk up to 9 miles a day, and I throw in lots of other exercise as well including swimming, biking, jogging, elliptical, strength training, DVDs, etc. Just start slow and don't give yourself any excuses to *not* do it!!0
-
I have a problem where 30seconds - 2 minutes into a workout I feel like I am DYING. I've heard several theories: I'm not breathing right, I just have to get my endurance up, and then that I'm physically too large right now to do heavy cardio. Is there any truth to this? I've seen several bloggers who were trying to lose 100+ lbs that didn't start an exercise regimen until they'd lost about half of that so I was wondering if it's true. I certainly don't want to use that as a cop-out, but I also don't want to endanger myself exercising in a way that isn't good for me. Any thoughts? Or should I speak with a doctor about it?
Speak to a doctor about it, could be high blood pressure or anything. Also don't think you have to start out doing alot. I actually started out just doing one minute and nothing heavy, just a light stepping semi jog in place because I would get the same feeling. I can fully jog now up to 30 minutes comfortably. So speak to a doctor and find out what you can or can not do and even if its just a minute or a few seconds that is still good and better then nothing. Walking is also a good exercise if you're heavy so you might want to start with that.0 -
I too agree with seeking your doctors/dietician advice. The workouts you listed, I didn't start with at 244. I started on a elliptical machine, swimming, then went to walking outside, and a treadmill. Swimming is a great way to start! The most important thing is that you started! Keep it up 0
-
Definitely start with walking and maybe add a little yoga as well?0
-
I weighed 290lbs. I lost 10 lbs and then started walking some. I started off only walking about 10 minutes. After about 1 month I was up to 30 minutes per day. Some days I can walk 50 minutes split up into a morning and afternoon walk. It would be best for you to see your doctor to ask how much you should be exercising.
Very good advice here ^^
Walking is a great start. In fact, if you never did anything else you'd still improve your healthy greatly and burn calories. But once you lose some weight and build up your endurance with walking, you can add other more strenuous exercises if you want. Doing too much too soon can lead to injury so check with your doctor and listen to your body.0 -
The great thing about walking is that you don't have to do it all in one shot. My 90-year old great aunt used to walk 4 miles a day.
But not all at once. She would go out 5-6 times for walks throughout the day. She had been doing it for years, and lived to be 104.0 -
Thanks for all the responses! I'll definitely see a doctor soon to see what I should be doing. I've tried a variety of things, never lasting more than a day or two on each: 30 day shred, couch to 5k plan, various workout videos. I think I'm trying to do too much too fast because I never exercised AT ALL. I'm going to start just walking and building up my endurance for other things.
Yes - speak to your doctor, and until then, stick with walking. Walking is fantastic exercise. You do not need to be doing those other things right now (though you certainly CAN if your doctor says it's no danger). Eating right and walking will do wonders to get you started.0 -
Walk
A lot
^^^^^^^^^0 -
Like others have said, consult a doctor. If you're fine then remember that most people quit way too early. they don't realize that they can do more than they think.
Muhammad Ali was once asked how many situps he does. He said he didn't know becuase he didn't start counting until it started to hurt.0 -
My exercise is primarily walking. When I started in April at 290 pounds, I could barely do 20 minutes on the treadmill. Now at 274 pounds, I can do an hour at the park with no problem. I slowly upped my time. I don't think I've gotten much faster, but my endurance is much better. I can even jog a tiny bit, but I'm worried about hurting my knees. I also do water aerobics, which is pretty easy, but you feel it in your muscles later.
So do see your doctor, and if he or she okays it, start slowly and do what you can. You'll get better at it with time.0 -
i was 270 at the beginning, and started exercising before i got my eating under control. in fact, i got my eating under control because of exercising and being at the gym.
walking is perfect, especially if you don't have a gym membership. you don't have to walk fast, you just have to do it. if you do belong to a gym or want to, i would start by doing any cardio machine with low-intensity-- think going on the treadmill for walking, using very little resistance and not going very fast on an elliptical or bike, etc.
the most important thing is to not give up! do something like that, and make your goal a little bigger every day. maybe you can only handle 20 minutes today, maybe by next tuesday you want to work up to 25 minutes. every little thing helps!
(for the record... i was like you in january. i started working on the cardio machines, went to zumba classes, and pushed myself to work harder every day. i'm just now comfortable with starting couch to 5k, and it kicks my butt every time.)0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions