Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Pop-Tarts, Diet Coke, and Ice Cream!!

    13»

    Replies

    • Posts: 3,602 Member
      show previous quotes

      In all honesty (and for some people with certain medical conditions this may not work due to food in-tolerences) but if you are maintaining a calorie deficit, then you should lose weight, no matter what those calories are made up of. Exercising and lifting weights helps in body re- composition, so as to help you burn fat, and maintain (or build) muscle mass. It also has other good health effects i.e. making your heart and bones stronger, helping blood flow and circulation,giving you better lung capacity and oxygen flow throughout the body etc.

      So if you are within your cals and want to eat ice cream, candy, cookies, etc- then go for it. People who tell you that you need to cut out sweets completely either A. Have issues with eating things in moderation and will binge if they eat one sweet thing, or B. Have been told falsely that the sweets are whats causing them to not lose weight, and not the hundreds of other reasons that it could be (perhaps the are over estimating there calorie burn and underestimating the calories that they are eating...etc)

      Do what works for you- and what makes you happy.

      ^^^^ Nice answer!!!!
    • Posts: 55 Member
      mmmmmmmm love pop tarts. Special K pastry krisp taste exactly like a poptart. 100 calories in a 2 pack.
      (just sharing - it's my new thing... so yummy)

      I was JUST thinking that when I saw this thread! The special K pastry krisps are awesome! It's like the best part of a poptart because they are so thin and crispy. I stock up on all the flavors for snacks for our whole family.
    • Posts: 94 Member
      love it
    • Posts: 35,719 Member
      I want a poptart now...
    • Posts: 8,980 Member
      my weightloss this past week has been fueled by pizza and chocolate chip cookies. :drinker:
    • Posts: 123
      I have never stopped eating what I want... I just know I have to work harder afterwards but it's been so nice no feeling deprived :) And I LOVE poptarts!!!!! Iced Cherry all the way!!!! :) I've lost close to 30lbs in 4 months and it's been a lifestyle change, not a quick fix!
    • Posts: 18
      I figure that as long as you keep to your calorie goal, it wouldn't matter if you ate poptarts or cake!
    • Posts: 135
      show previous quotes

      In all honesty (and for some people with certain medical conditions this may not work due to food in-tolerences) but if you are maintaining a calorie deficit, then you should lose weight, no matter what those calories are made up of. Exercising and lifting weights helps in body re- composition, so as to help you burn fat, and maintain (or build) muscle mass. It also has other good health effects i.e. making your heart and bones stronger, helping blood flow and circulation,giving you better lung capacity and oxygen flow throughout the body etc.

      So if you are within your cals and want to eat ice cream, candy, cookies, etc- then go for it. People who tell you that you need to cut out sweets completely either A. Have issues with eating things in moderation and will binge if they eat one sweet thing, or B. Have been told falsely that the sweets are whats causing them to not lose weight, and not the hundreds of other reasons that it could be (perhaps the are over estimating there calorie burn and underestimating the calories that they are eating...etc)

      Do what works for you- and what makes you happy.

      I am the poster that told her she should cut out some (not ALL) the junk, because she's wondering why she's only lost 12 pounds in 6 months. She is not "doing what works for her" obviously, because it's NOT working. And she certainly hasn't been "happy" about it. But I also suggested to her that she might have an insulin resistance problem- which will screw up the whole calories in/calories out equation like nobody's business, and actually makes your "B" statement quite true. I know this from first-hand experience. And her representation of her few treats is quite understated, and left off the donuts, pie and fruit loops.

      When someone continually posts about the lack of progress they're making, I tend to look at what they are doing, and based on knowledge and experience offer them some help if I can.
    • Posts: 542 Member
      I have been wanting a pop tart all day.. becuase of these forums...
    • Posts: 14,517 Member
      show previous quotes

      AND if you toast them and put lots of melty BUTTER on them.............

      mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

      Favorite flavor? Blueberry, with that tasty, totally fake, sprinkly frosting on them!

      Hah! I thought I was the only one who put butter on them (I know that's kinda sick:embarassed: )

      My favorite flavor .... brown sugar & cinnamon (with frosting... of course).
    • Posts: 682 Member
      Do not feed the trolls!!! LOL
    • Posts: 110
      I love to sprinkle the mini poptarts on my ice-cream and then pour diet coke on top. Yummy!
    • Posts: 1,849 Member
      I love Poptarts!!! I love ice cream!!! And I will never give up my diet soda!!!!

      Not crazy about pop tarts (though toaster streudel is a different story) or soda in general, but ice cream is one of my many vices. I don't eat it NEARLY as often as I used to, but I do have a cupful every once in a while. Same goes for everything else I enjoy. I try to eat mostly fruits, veggies, and lean meats for the most part, but I do allow myself a treat every so often.
    • Posts: 84 Member
      Moderation is key!
    • Posts: 1,941 Member
      Serious pop-tart jonesing.
    • Posts: 6
      Love it! I did that last week, seen these delish cupcakes (raspberry ripples) however before I could get me teeth into them my daughter who is 3, opened the box, licked all the buttercream icing off them all and put them in the bin because she doesn't like cake lol! I really wanted those cakes and next time I am passing that shop I WILL buy those cupcakes and eat them before I get home :D
    • Posts: 1,828 Member
      OK, admission time....I enjoy stirring the nest of the food Nazi who deals in absolutes....:devil:
      Should I get help for myself or go eat a whopper?
      decisions, decisions.....:bigsmile:
    • Posts: 92
      I COMPLETELY AGREE! Eat and let eat!
    • Posts: 14,517 Member
      show previous quotes

      This is at the state fair this year


      OMG!!! Haha!

      Actually new fair "food" this year is fried globs of cereal ...... taste testers weren't impressed (go figure)
    • Posts: 111 Member
      If I want it I eat it as long as I have the calories, If I use them all up then oh well that's all I can have. But you know you can't deprive yourself of what you want and stay with things. Hope you enjoyed, sound yummy
    • Posts: 6
      OK, admission time....I enjoy stirring the nest of the food Nazi who deals in absolutes....:devil:
      Should I get help for myself or go eat a whopper?
      decisions, decisions.....:bigsmile:


      Eat a Whopper :)
    • Posts: 102 Member
      How funny!! I had frosted strawberry Pop Tarts this morning!
    • Posts: 206 Member
      show previous quotes

      I am the poster that told her she should cut out some (not ALL) the junk, because she's wondering why she's only lost 12 pounds in 6 months. She is not "doing what works for her" obviously, because it's NOT working. And she certainly hasn't been "happy" about it. But I also suggested to her that she might have an insulin resistance problem- which will screw up the whole calories in/calories out equation like nobody's business, and actually makes your "B" statement quite true. I know this from first-hand experience. And her representation of her few treats is quite understated, and left off the donuts, pie and fruit loops.

      When someone continually posts about the lack of progress they're making, I tend to look at what they are doing, and based on knowledge and experience offer them some help if I can.

      Shi, I am sorry. I was not insulting your advice. I am listening. I will also check into the insulin thing BUT it seems like you think I eat a whole donut or a whole pie (when did I eat pie?) or a box of sweet tarts or a box of fruit loops. Doesn't my diary reflect one serving of sweet tarts and one serving of whoopers and 1/4 a donut or 1/8 a slice of walnut cake? wouldn't that be in moderation? And I did write ALL when I shouldn't have. You did say cut down most. Again, I apologize.

      My question here was really, are you people here eating the above and seeing results? Do YOU people personally eat those and find it works? in thr past, i could basically eat what i wanted within reason and stay under cals and loose weight no problem whereas I am not having the same result now. I have lost 13 lbs (not 12, I typoed) and 24 inches in 6 months but it seems meager for the effort I put out.

      That being said. I hate pop tarts. i think I have had one my whole life but I LOOOOOOVE coke. Oh, coke, I love thee.
    • Posts: 2,097 Member
      I eat ice cream and have diet pop everyday. I don't like poptarts, but I do have a Kellog's chocolate "protein shake" that has as many calories and as much sugar as a poptart probably. Am I going to die?
    • Posts: 1,759 Member
      Dairy Queen Peanut Buster Parfait with caramel instead of fudge.
      There is a Dairy Queen Blizzard flavor that you may not know about. Yet. It is so good it can cause you to elbow small children out of the way to get to the counter. It is called Caramel Pie and it tastes like magic.

      It isn't available everywhere, but you can have them make it, because it uses ingredients they already have. It is.....
      Caramel
      Pecans
      Pie crust pieces
      Pinch from Satan's cocaine stash

      *last ingredient not confirmed.

      Go have one. Get it with a Diet Coke. You won't regret it. Unless, of course, you do. In which case we can argue on the forum about the pros and cons of eating "bad" food. But you will have at least tasted the treat that brings me almost as much joy as the birth of my children.
    • Posts: 567 Member
      I love Cherry pop-tarts, with no icing, and cherry coke. Everytime I do consume those products I feel like crap. So yea. No good.
    • Posts: 46 Member
      The only time I allow myself to have Pop-Tarts is when I'm camping, and they must be S'more Pop-Tarts. So good!
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories