Thoughts on Paleo

While I agree with the overall principles of eating the majority of your foods from whole food sources, avoid processed foods etc etc, the "all of nothing" approach is a little too far for me. Take gluten and dairy for example, I am a person who has no problem eating gluten and is not lactose intolerant...why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

There is still quite a few things that people within the paleo crowd can't seem to agree on.

It;'s also very annoying when paleo people/websites tell you that with paleo dieting, you never need to count calories.....like their diet somehow is exempt from the energy in - energy out factor.

Do you own research as to the pro/cons and figure out if it would fit within your lifestyle, don't just start because some crossfitter told you to.

Take gluten and dairy for example, I am a person who has no problem eating gluten and is not lactose intolerant...why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

Ummmm hello, inflammation.

Even if you don't know that you have it, it is there, making you feel forever less good. Chemicals from processed foods will build up in this inflammation and will give you cancer. The inflammation will cause nutrients to not work and not be absorbed and you will not be healthy. This will cause large insulin spikes when you eat any food containing even a grain of processed sugar which will make you fat and make it impossible to diet off.

Take gluten and dairy for example, I am a person who has no problem eating gluten and is not lactose intolerant...why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

Ummmm hello, inflammation.

Even if you don't know that you have it, it is there, making you feel forever less good. Chemicals from processed foods will build up in this inflammation and will give you cancer. The inflammation will cause nutrients to not work and not be absorbed and you will not be healthy. This will cause large insulin spikes when you eat any food containing even a grain of processed sugar which will make you fat and make it impossible to diet off.

Impossible to diet off..............ok.

you are making the assumption that because im not paleo, I eat a ton of processed foods, grains and sugar etc. Which I don't

If i were to eat paleo for 97% of my daily calorie allowance, then for the last 3% percent I have a cookie, while still being in a calorie deficit....you are telling me it's impossible for me to alter my body composition?

I don't think so.

processed foods will build up in this inflammation and will give you cancer.

A little strong, no?

why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

Don't be stupid - grains are killing all of us. Americans consume grains because of a great conspiracy between the government and the farming industry. All of the clinical studies done to show that grains are harmful have been buried by the governemnt cover up. Gary Taubes is a genius - all hail Gary Taubes.

The above is a small example of what to expect from the Paleo community. Yes, by all means do your research and proceed with caution. IMHO, there's nothing wrong with eating a balanced nutritional diet and exercising on a regular basis. Keep it simple.

While I agree with the overall principles of eating the majority of your foods from whole food sources, avoid processed foods etc etc, the "all of nothing" approach is a little too far for me. Take gluten and dairy for example, I am a person who has no problem eating gluten and is not lactose intolerant...why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

There is still quite a few things that people within the paleo crowd can't seem to agree on.

It;'s also very annoying when paleo people/websites tell you that with paleo dieting, you never need to count calories.....like their diet somehow is exempt from the energy in - energy out factor.

Do you own research as to the pro/cons and figure out if it would fit within your lifestyle, don't just start because some crossfitter told you to.

That's what gives me a little bit of hesitation. I tend to eat pretty well, I don't really do sugary foods, I just tend to use dairy quite a bit. I was in the belief that things like greek yogurt and cottage cheese were good for you, but I wonder if I am doing my body harm? Either way, taking grains and dairy out of my diet will be really hard for me, but I can do it.

Paleo was rough for me as I'm a dairy junkie. I like to do a low carb life but had a lot of cheese (esp. Cottage Cheese it's my fav!!) in my world. I'm now doing a slow carb (legumes make it slow carb) and although there is no dairy allowed (a couple of tablespoons of heavy cream in coffee is about it) I don't miss the cheese quite as much. Granted, there's a 'free day' built in every 6 to 10 days so if I'm craving the cheese, I can go hog wild on my free day.

Although it seems some folks were getting off track I think the best thing here is for you to do what you think is best for your body. It seems the cross fit folks have adopted the Paleo lifestyle as their diet of choice. It seems to work for them. I have a few friends that do cross fit and the paleo and I'm always amazed by their strength.

Best of luck to you!!!!

why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

Don't be stupid - grains are killing all of us. Americans consume grains because of a great conspiracy between the government and the farming industry. All of the clinical studies done to show that grains are harmful have been buried by the governemnt cover up. Gary Taubes is a genius - all hail Gary Taubes.

The above is a small example of what to expect from the Paleo community. Yes, by all means do your research and proceed with caution. IMHO, there's nothing wrong with eating a balanced nutritional diet and exercising on a regular basis. Keep it simple.

Okay, other than personal slams on the 'Paleo community', so far I haven't heard much that should be disagreeable. I admit, I need to do more research before I can speak with any depth.

Why would the concept of eating whole foods trigger such a disproportionate back lash?

That is the difference between the average "calorie counter" and someone that follows the Paleo lifestyle.

We do so for health benefits. The weight loss and changing body composition is merely an added benefit. We focus on health first and foremost to heal from the inside out.

And I agree with that.

But you do accept that, if you were unaware of your maintenance level calories and the amount of calories you were taking in, even on a paleo diet that you could in theory gain weight /get fatter by being in an calorie excess?

I go in and out of weight loss mode to test my ability to maintain my weight............I used to live the Atkins lifestyle so I already have the foundation for maintaining my weight.

For me personally..............this is how it works for me (my own experimentation for what works for my body and lifestyle).

When I am in weight loss mode: Extremely high fat, moderate protein and dark green leafy vegetables only. I track my foods to make sure I am nutrient dense, and eyeballing my calories I tend to be between 1,100 and 1,300.

When I am maintaining I tend to eat lower fat, moderate protein and then I have tubers, lots of vegetables, add in some fruit and I am able to maintain easily.

I listen to my body, practice intermittent fasting, meditation and deep breathing. I have made a great deal of progress over the past year.

A year ago I was insulin dependent Type 2 Diabetic, on 175 mcg Armour Thyroid medications and taking hormones for treatment of PCOS.

I am down about 50 pounds, sleep well at night, have lots of energy, on NO Diabetes medications, down to 25 mcg of Armour Thyroid medication and no longer having to take hormones for PCOS.

With the right nutrition the body will heal itself, just as Hippocrates stated so many years ago.

And yes, maybe I am a Zealot, but I have made so much progress since moving to this lifestyle and being off meds is the BEST bonus of all.

:drinker: :flowerforyou:

why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

Don't be stupid - grains are killing all of us. Americans consume grains because of a great conspiracy between the government and the farming industry. All of the clinical studies done to show that grains are harmful have been buried by the governemnt cover up. Gary Taubes is a genius - all hail Gary Taubes.

The above is a small example of what to expect from the Paleo community. Yes, by all means do your research and proceed with caution. IMHO, there's nothing wrong with eating a balanced nutritional diet and exercising on a regular basis. Keep it simple.

Okay, other than personal slams on the 'Paleo community', so far I haven't heard much that should be disagreeable. I admit, I need to do more research before I can speak with any depth.

Why would the concept of eating whole foods trigger such a disproportionate back lash?

Because people are so addicted to the fast food, chain restaurants and junk, processed food products the thought of having to give them up makes people lose their minds.

Ok, this thread will probably explode. Before it does, I just want to slip in my experience to OP and then I'm out!

I tried Paleo for 30 days and loved it. I'm hypothyroid and the lower carbs work. But then I realized I still wanted an occasional cookie or bowl of oatmeal. So I took much of what I learned from Paleo and made it work for me.

My husband and I eat meat and veggies for our meals. We don't buy bread, we mostly drink almond milk or canned coconut milk (he still plays around with soy, but Im not as big a fan.) I've cut out artificial sugars and keep fruit to a minimum, using Agave as a sweetner if it's needed. Do we still eat an occasional cookie? Sure do. When we go to friends house do we demand Paleo foods? Nope. We even eat out sometimes!

We made it livable. When it's our choices and our house, we go Paleo-esque. But sometimes we live a little.

You have to find what will work for you long term so you can make it a lifestyle. I love the Paleo clean eating principles, and I do feel different when I adhere to it. You can't get caught up in it though.

Like I said- make it work for you. You'll enjoy it more that way.

Besides- veggies rock.

Good luck!

That is Mark Sisson's approach with the Primal Blue Print.

Eat clean 80% of the time and there is 20% wiggle room for splurges.

I personally can't do the 80/20 rule. It doesn't work for me because of the health issues I am battling.

For my husband the 80/20 rule works.

We eat out also. I tend to stick with grilled fish, chicken or a steak and steamed vegetables and a side salad.

While I agree with the overall principles of eating the majority of your foods from whole food sources, avoid processed foods etc etc, the "all of nothing" approach is a little too far for me. Take gluten and dairy for example, I am a person who has no problem eating gluten and is not lactose intolerant...why should I completely eliminate these foods instead of just having them in moderation within a balanced diet?

There is still quite a few things that people within the paleo crowd can't seem to agree on.

It;'s also very annoying when paleo people/websites tell you that with paleo dieting, you never need to count calories.....like their diet somehow is exempt from the energy in - energy out factor.

Do you own research as to the pro/cons and figure out if it would fit within your lifestyle, don't just start because some crossfitter told you to.

^^^ I'm with this guy.

I have been doing crossfit on and off for 2+ years and yes, they strongly advocate the Paleo diet. Here is my take - I did an 8-week Paleo challenge and it was the hardest "diet" I have ever been on. I did end up losing a % or 2 body fat, however I was at lowered calories because essentially, I can't eat that many calories when it is so restrictive and I think that is the real reason I ended up losing body fat. I didn't feel it was very natural, infact, I had to try really, really hard to figure out things to eat that fit in this diet.

I'm also a dairy girl, I like to eat greek yogurt every day (which happens to be gluten free so the diet is very contradictory to me), and I also like grains. Although I know some people have great results from eating gluten free and dairy free, it is just too restrictive for me to maintain long term.

My take is, I try and eat mostly natural and low or no processed foods as much as possible, and I read labels and try to eat the most nutritious foods I can find. I like doing 80/20 mentality also - 80% as healthy as possible and 20% what I want to eat within my calorie goals. I've maintained (or have gotten more fit) for over 7 years so whatever I am doing is working so I am not going to change it anytime soon.

To each their own.

Paleo is extremely time consuming unless you are just eating raw fruits and veggies and chicken breasts! If you want variety, you have to cook, and the way the foods are prepared take a lot of time. The good thing is that you can get at least 2 meals from the recipes. If you have a lot of time and access to specialty grocery stores, it can be helpful. If you don't, it is overwhelming.

What Magma said, except on my diet I avoid fruits unless it's a rare treat (once a week a little cup of strawberry or something.) Have been on it for 43 days now, my diet diary is public so peep it if you want to get an idea of what eating paleo style on a student budget is like! I have lost 13lbs so far and my energy levels seem a lot better than when I was carbin'. having said that, my cravings have not gone away and I've taken up soap making as a new hobby just to keep myself distracted from the thought of sweet sweet sugars...

I personally love it, and have more energy than I had before and overall feel much better. Currently my son is now starting it as well (he will still have potatoes, and full fat dairy) because we are trying to help with his allergies, GERD, and esophagitis.

Just my two cents

I like Mark Sisson's approach to paleo and his primal blueprint cook book & shopping list isn't really restrictive IMHO, but I understand that his approach to paleo is much more 'liberal' than some folks.

His website is good. http://www.marksdailyapple.com

ditto!

Try it as an experiment for 6 weeks, log everything, keep a blog, see how you feel
You are an experiment of one!
(damn, I knew I could nick that line at some point Kara)