True or False? A Calorie is a Calorie is a Calorie.
Replies
-
Unless, and until you make sustainable changes in eating habits, chances are you will be in the huge majority of people that lose weight and gain it all (and for many people even more) back. "Good" calories vs "bad calories. Your nutrition goals depend on the choices of where you get the calories from, how you want to nourish your body. Personal choices and goals. Eating less calories than you burn for weight loss, and to maintain eat only the number of calories you need. Regular exercise contributes to overall good health.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
snowflake930 wrote: »Unless, and until you make sustainable changes in eating habits, chances are you will be in the huge majority of people that lose weight and gain it all (and for many people even more) back. "Good" calories vs "bad calories. Your nutrition goals depend on the choices of where you get the calories from, how you want to nourish your body. Personal choices and goals. Eating less calories than you burn for weight loss, and to maintain eat only the number of calories you need. Regular exercise contributes to overall good health.
I agree with most of what you say even if some of it is stating the obvious.
Yes, most people need to make sustainable changes in eating habits to have long term success, and what you need to eat in terms of types of foods depends on your personal
Needs and goals. Eating less than you burn for weight loss and the number of calories you need for maitenance, and exercise contributes to good health - no kidding.
-
- But good calories vs bad calories is just silly
0 -
- But good calories vs bad calories is just silly
Really? Silly?
What I mean is (maybe hard for some to grasp the concept) you can choose calories that give your body something that is good for your health vs calories that have very little nutritional value. Your choice, your body, your health, and your decision.
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
FOOD: Any nutritious substance that is consumed in order to maintain and sustain life and growth and to repair and furnish energy.
NUTRIENT: A substance that provides nourishment essential for growth and the maintenance of metabolism and life.
CALORIE is the energy needed to raise the temperature of 1 gram of water 1 degree, I.E., a unit of energy-producing potential equal to this amount of heat contained in food.
some simple definitons I got via google (correct me if they are erroneous)
calorie does not equal nutrient. I am guessing you are talking about micronutrients- yes, some foods are more micronutirent dense than others. That is a different conversation0 -
Just because 1 food might give your body than another does not mean one set of calories are good and the other bad. You can't just isolate one food and consider a diet unhealthy. The overall contents of your daily intake as a whole is what is truly important.
Semantics. I used the wrong words. Sorry it is so hard for some people to get my meaning. I am not as good as you are at choosing the correct words.
I should have said, calories that give your body better nutritional value vs ones that may have less nutritional value. Does this make it easier to understand?
0 -
0
-
I love these boards
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
ChunkeeeMonkeee48 wrote: »_Terrapin_ wrote: »ChunkeeeMonkeee48 wrote: »_Terrapin_ wrote: »OP use MFP to count calories and track your nutrients. Asking questions about sugar versus fat is like herding cats on here. So if you want to drop 21 pounds eat a slight deficit to your TDEE. Good luck.
my cat can't be herded. She just lays down and refuses to move
Really?!? So unlike a Paleo diehard or IIFYM diehard. . . .well hopefully they are moving to provide a little more of a deficit for whatever calorie they may be ingesting
lol. I would hope so but I was trying to make a funny with the whole "herding cats" statement...sorry
I love this; yes you were funny. My point was trying to get 2 groups so distinctly separated by derp to agree is equally impossible. "unlike" use a sarcastic tone and re-read it and see how it sounds. And take the word 'so' and eally draw it out. . .better? Eat a Snickers...now better?
0 -
True.
0 -
Protein speeds your metabolism and fat gets you into ketosis so those both have benefits that sugar doesn't...
Actually, it's the lack of carbs in one's diet that will make a person go into Ketosis.
Protein & fat are necessary, but not the deciding factor for a body to become keto adapted.
A body still has protein & fat in reserves (presumably) but once liver glycogen & muscle glycogen is depleted, ketosis is the result.
0 -
0
-
yes they are the same yet if you over eat some will pack pounds on faster than others. As long as you stay under your calorie goal consistently you will lose weight. Good Luck
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
A calorie is a calorie because it is a unit of measurement and nothing more
nobody asks if a centimeter is a centimeter or a kilogramme is a kilogramme, it's all just units of measurement.
It's how that calorie is obtained, used or not used that's important.
But is a unicorn a unicorn?
No apparently a unicorn is a woman who is on the 3-5 crazy scale and 9-10 hotness scale...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuI6GTY9eVc
This guy may have been caught with a trampoline, a pair of hip boots, and a map with a big "X" indicating a sheep farm. Maybe not recently, but I'm sure is has happened.
0 -
ChunkeeeMonkeee48 wrote: »snowflake930 wrote: »Unless, and until you make sustainable changes in eating habits, chances are you will be in the huge majority of people that lose weight and gain it all (and for many people even more) back. "Good" calories vs "bad calories. Your nutrition goals depend on the choices of where you get the calories from, how you want to nourish your body. Personal choices and goals. Eating less calories than you burn for weight loss, and to maintain eat only the number of calories you need. Regular exercise contributes to overall good health.
there is NO SUCH THING as a bad calorie...they are JUST CALORIES
I disagree... I once had a calorie pull a knife on me...0 -
0
-
This content has been removed.
-
ChunkeeeMonkeee48 wrote: »bennettinfinity wrote: »ChunkeeeMonkeee48 wrote: »snowflake930 wrote: »Unless, and until you make sustainable changes in eating habits, chances are you will be in the huge majority of people that lose weight and gain it all (and for many people even more) back. "Good" calories vs "bad calories. Your nutrition goals depend on the choices of where you get the calories from, how you want to nourish your body. Personal choices and goals. Eating less calories than you burn for weight loss, and to maintain eat only the number of calories you need. Regular exercise contributes to overall good health.
there is NO SUCH THING as a bad calorie...they are JUST CALORIES
I disagree... I once had a calorie pull a knife on me...
lol...did you give the calorie your wallet...or a cookie...
if you give a calorie a cookie it will just want milk. . .
0 -
0
-
This content has been removed.
-
snowflake930 wrote: »Semantics. I used the wrong words. Sorry it is so hard for some people to get my meaning. I am not as good as you are at choosing the correct words.
I should have said, calories that give your body better nutritional value vs ones that may have less nutritional value. Does this make it easier to understand?
Doesn't really matter. Your body also has an upper limit for good nutritional values like vitamins and minerals. It doesn't do you any better to go over in those and in some cases it can even be dangerous. For someone who has to eat lots of calories in a day like someone who does a lot of exercise, having some "empty calories" could be the better course of action for both nutrition and not having to eat their bodyweight in "healthy, nutritious food" every day.0 -
I've no idea. I would say the pizza would be healthier than the candy bar, as it probably has some veg on it in some way or the other. Although it would have unhealthy fat, I think unhealthy unnatural sugar would be worse. It's not substantial. But trust, even if you ate over your maintenance with it, you would not gain weight with just one single item of food.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
A calorie is a calorie.
The only difference is depending on where the calorie is coming from. Your body will use 1 calorie from sugar differently than it would 1 calorie from quality protein.0 -
Hit and run comment...
Meat and veggie calories yum! Sugar and junk food calories yuk!
Hmmm... let's see, do I want a big pile of organic omega eggs loaded with veggies and real bacon cooked in real butter and/or coconut oil for breakfast? Or do I want a (fake/carby) bacon egg and cheese sandwich from Dunkin Donuts... both have around the same amount of calories.
The sandwich will most likely make me feel full for about an hour, and bloated and overloaded with sodium and whatever other chemicals are used to process and I'll surely be looking forward to my 10:30 snack. Oh wait... am I really hungry for a snack or did MFP tell me I should have a snack? Anyway... The sandwich is quick and easy and I can even eat it in the car on my way to work.
The first choice... filling to the point where I can't finish the appropriate portion and leaves me feeling full, satisfied, lean and strong. No bloating, plenty of energy and not even thinking about my next meal, how many calories I have left for the day... plus a powerful workout.
Fat doesn't make you fat, carbs - grains, bread, wheat, pasta do.
Sure, a calorie is a calorie but as stated here many times nutrition is different.
I'd rather eat more and eat right and not stress about calories and numbers and lose weight vs. the other option.
A lot of the nutrition plans out there are based on trial and error and a lot of math. Paleo is backed by science. Everyone's body (normally functioning body) digest food in the same manner.
Taking cover in anticipation of the nasty comments about my opinion... hahahaha!0 -
snowflake930 wrote: »- But good calories vs bad calories is just silly
Really? Silly?
What I mean is (maybe hard for some to grasp the concept) you can choose calories that give your body something that is good for your health vs calories that have very little nutritional value. Your choice, your body, your health, and your decision.
Yes I do think seeing calories as good and bad is silly.
Nobody is arguing that some foods are more nutritious than others - but a calorie is still a calorie and demonising individual foods into good and bad is not helpful for most people it is your diet as a whole that matters. Not each component in isolation.
And anyway that is addressing nutrition, not weight loss, and so is irrelevant to the question of is a calorie a calorie.
Just like walking a mile on a flat even path is easier than trekking a mile through rugged mountains, one might be better for my fitness goals than the other - but the distance of a mile is still the distance of a mile, the unit of measurement is a constant thing.
0 -
Nopecushman5279 wrote: »Hit and run comment...
Meat and veggie calories yum! Sugar and junk food calories yuk!
Hmmm... let's see, do I want a big pile of organic omega eggs loaded with veggies and real bacon cooked in real butter and/or coconut oil for breakfast? Or do I want a (fake/carby) bacon egg and cheese sandwich from Dunkin Donuts... both have around the same amount of calories.
The sandwich will most likely make me feel full for about an hour, and bloated and overloaded with sodium and whatever other chemicals are used to process and I'll surely be looking forward to my 10:30 snack. Oh wait... am I really hungry for a snack or did MFP tell me I should have a snack? Anyway... The sandwich is quick and easy and I can even eat it in the car on my way to work.
The first choice... filling to the point where I can't finish the appropriate portion and leaves me feeling full, satisfied, lean and strong. No bloating, plenty of energy and not even thinking about my next meal, how many calories I have left for the day... plus a powerful workout.
Fat doesn't make you fat, carbs - grains, bread, wheat, pasta do.
Sure, a calorie is a calorie but as stated here many times nutrition is different.
I'd rather eat more and eat right and not stress about calories and numbers and lose weight vs. the other option.
A lot of the nutrition plans out there are based on trial and error and a lot of math. Paleo is backed by science. Everyone's body (normally functioning body) digest food in the same manner.
Taking cover in anticipation of the nasty comments about my opinion... hahahaha!
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/how-we-get-fat.html/
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/nutrition/nutrient-intake-nutrient-storage-and-nutrient-oxidation.html/
"Carbohydrates can be stored as liver or muscle glycogen, under rare circumstances they are converted to and stored as fat."
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions