Looking for a gym?
JoRocka
Posts: 17,525 Member
Read this- ask yourself what you really want out of it and what you expect from the space your paying for in the long run.
http://uproxx.com/webculture/2014/12/how-low-cost-gyms-like-planet-fitness-psychologically-manipulate-people-into-not-going-to-the-gym/
http://uproxx.com/webculture/2014/12/how-low-cost-gyms-like-planet-fitness-psychologically-manipulate-people-into-not-going-to-the-gym/
There’s an absolutely fascinating episode of the Planet Money podcast up on NPR now (or subscribe via iTunes) about the tactics that low-cost gyms use in order to make a fortune on low $10 a month membership fees. I’m particularly fascinated by it because I’m the exact kind of gym member that a place like Planet Fitness craves. I’ve been a member for five or six years, and I’ll go five times a week for three or four months and then get sidetracked by work or kids or other commitments and not attend the gym again for three or four more months.
I’m the ideal gym member.
Why? Because places like Planet Fitness are not actually designed to accommodate the number of people who enroll as members. For instance, the gym used as an example in this episode of Planet Money had about 6,000 members, and yet the facility itself could only accommodate about 300 people at a time. If all the members who signed up actually went, franchises like that Planet Fitness would have to charge far more than $10 a month.
In fact, of the members who get gym memberships, about HALF never actually visit the gym once.
So, how does a place like Planet Fitness attract a clientele that’s earnest enough to sign up for the gym but not dedicated enough to actually go?
Part of it has to do with design: They create gyms that are meant to look like bars. They are designed to make out-of-shape people feel comfortable being there, because the gyms know out-of-shape people are not likely to attend frequently once they sign up. They do that with mirrors and disco music and even massage chairs. Meanwhile, the actual gym part of the gym — the free weights and weight machines — are typically hidden away from the main part of the gym, back in a more intimidating space that those comfortable in the bar-like atmosphere would be less likely to visit. Low-cost gyms don’t actually want the body-builder types — they’d actually go to the gym more frequently — they want those who climb on the treadmill every once in a while. (I can confirm this: In the five or six years I’ve been attending my gym, I’ve visited the weight room twice, and both times, felt like an alien outsider).
Psychologically, when it comes to gym memberships, contrary to what you might think, we also LIKE the idea of long-term contracts, because it locks us into a commitment of going to the gym that we will feel compelled to follow through on. The thinking is, “Well, I’m paying $10 a month, so I HAVE to go,” except when it comes right down to it, the thinking is more like, “Well, it’s only $10. I’m not losing that much. I think I’ll have a pizza and watch The Blacklist tonight, instead.”
Speaking of pizza, I always found it strange that the gym I attend has pizza night and bagel breakfast once a month. That seems kind of self-defeating for a gym, but again, that’s part of the design. The average low-cost gym loses about half of its members each year, so in order to entice people who don’t go to the gym to sign up for another year, these gyms offer free food so at least members get something out of their membership. Many, in fact, will attend only on those days with free food — it doesn’t make them any more healthy but hey! For $10 a month, you get two slices of pizza.
Meanwhile, a good gym is the total opposite. They don’t look like nightclubs. They do not have mirrors, and some will actually kick you out if you don’t attend often enough. They are smaller, and they have more serious members.
How much does a good gym run? As much as $500 a month, and if you’re paying that much, you’re sure as hell gonna make sure you get something out of it.
So, as the New Year rolls around and you begin to consider your resolutions, if you decide to enroll in a low-cost gym, consider the possibility that you’re almost certainly not going to attend frequently. But if you really want to game the system, go everyday out of spite. You’ll show them, and you’ll get positive health results in the process.
0
Replies
-
One of the first, or second gyms, I joined (on my own, not family membership) actually did have a bar and disco lights with dance floor. The weights were located in one of the two disused racquetball courts downstairs.They create gyms that are meant to look like bars
It may have had the bar and dance floor, but it was still more of a gym than PF.0 -
were there drinks? because we all know lifting and drinking is ALWAYS a good time
That's weird- disco lights LOL- I think I'd have quit- sh1t like that gives me a headache at this point in my life- so I have to be out drinking in order to put up with it.0 -
I think most gyms oversell their memberships because they know 1/2 don't come. What the gyms REALLY want is the automatic payment though your savings/checking accounts.0
-
I find this really funny because my friend is one of those people that the gym loves because he doesn't show up, but still pays the membership.
What they don't know is that I use the membership now, but I'm not the one paying for it...
so win for me? yes, I'll go with that.
0 -
I never imbibed at that gym and from all the skateboarding and snowboarding I used to do, I knew better. Here's the description on their website about that location:
"Stop by... for a beverage after your workout or just or sit by the cozy fireplace – day or night! This full service bar and grill is the perfect place to unwind, relax and socialize with fellow WAC members."
That gym was a total throw-back.0 -
lol- I've only ever had a beer with dinner THEN gone lifting- I've never gone drunk- mostly because I"m not that stupid- if I feel the need to drink and work out- I go running.
That's hysterical- not sure why I'd want to unwind with a bunch of sweaty guys AT my gym- but I remember at LA Fit- I left the gym a couple of times and headed straight to sushi. NOMNOMNOM
lifting with body builders is a win.0 -
JeffseekingV wrote: »I think most gyms oversell their memberships because they know 1/2 don't come. What the gyms REALLY want is the automatic payment though your savings/checking accounts.
Yep, it's a for-profit business and money is the bottom line. Attaining physical fitness isn't exactly their concern. (I mean overall; I'm sure there are local gym-owners who are fitness buffs themselves and are concerned about their clientelle.)0 -
lol JoRocka.
And you could smoke inside in those days. I remember some of the older ladies ogling us young bucks as we made our way down to the locker room to the weight rooms - and without tipping. Jerks.
IF that wasn't bad enough, you'd have creepy pastors trying to bring you to Jesus as you got your lift on. Funny I stayed there for so long - lack of choices in those days.0 -
First hand. The amount of money I've wasted in keeping a gym membership and not going.Psychologically, when it comes to gym memberships, contrary to what you might think, we also LIKE the idea of long-term contracts, because it locks us into a commitment of going to the gym that we will feel compelled to follow through on
Hate to say, but PF is kinda brilliant.0 -
Anything to get a lift on my friend- you gotta do what you gotta do. I worked out at a Bally's for a LONG time- it was far from pretty.
But as long as there is a bar that's mostly straight- and I can fit plates on it-and a squat rack and no ridiculous 'no dead lifting' rules- I'm good to go.
LOL_ yeah preachy people always make me crazy too- I'm at the gym damnit- not on a street corner!!0 -
I'm at the Y, very family and older generation oriented. Call me whatever, but sometimes I wish I was at one of those meat market gyms where yoga pants and sports bras rule.0
-
Yeah, no rules there lifting in the basement. Had me so many good sessions and I was still rather new at lifting so I'd be there 3 hours per 3 days a week.Anything to get a lift on my friend- you gotta do what you gotta do. I worked out at a Bally's for a LONG time- it was far from pretty.
But as long as there is a bar that's mostly straight- and I can fit plates on it-and a squat rack and no ridiculous 'no dead lifting' rules- I'm good to go.
LOL_ yeah preachy people always make me crazy too- I'm at the gym damnit- not on a street corner!!
Do Bally's still exist?
First Y I lifted at even had a oly deadlifting station, complete with chalk.JeffseekingV wrote: »I'm at the Y, very family and older generation oriented. Call me whatever, but sometimes I wish I was at one of those meat market gyms where yoga pants and sports bras rule.
You're probably better off at the Y, otherwise you'd be getting the wrong "lift" on too much and that might hurt your gains.0 -
Not really- they sold out about 170 of them across the country- there were a handful as of 2-3 years ago still holding on- so they essentially just downsized the hell out of the company- anyone who had a Bally's could keep it - or essentially their membership was transferred to LA Fit.
damn yoga pants- get ya ever time 0 -
I'd kill for a platform. Our Y just spent a ton on a motorized climbing machine but won't spend the few dollars for an deadlifting platform. And this is AFTER they removed the carpet and found some hairline cracks in the concrete from people doing deads. Go figure.
Hey I just wanted to get my oogle on once a week. haha0 -
Weight Watchers has a killer financial model, too. How do you achieve free lifetime membership? You have to be at maintenance weight for so many months and remain within two pounds of that weight for the rest of your life. Must weigh in monthly. Remember the rate of recidivisim? Isn't it like around 80%? Not to mention my weight fluctuates monthly about five pounds.
Win all around in the fitness and weight loss game.0 -
When I was looking for a new gym a few months back, I was reading Yelp reviews and found a few b*tching about how the weight room was too crowded with equipment, the gym doesn't have wifi and there's no towel service. Apparently that was supposed to be a negative review...?0
-
Read this- ask yourself what you really want out of it and what you expect from the space your paying for in the long run.
http://uproxx.com/webculture/2014/12/how-low-cost-gyms-like-planet-fitness-psychologically-manipulate-people-into-not-going-to-the-gym/
I found this article fascinating! It makes perfect sense, I'd just never thought of it in this manner before. Wow! Thanks for the eye opening article.0 -
I like the group classes that my chain fitness club attracts. Look at it this way. The no-shows with the great intentions subsidize your membership.0
-
Not really- they sold out about 170 of them across the country- there were a handful as of 2-3 years ago still holding on- so they essentially just downsized the hell out of the company- anyone who had a Bally's could keep it - or essentially their membership was transferred to LA Fit.
damn yoga pants- get ya ever time
So that's where Bally's went too. The closest one to me shuttered a few years ago after it became a blast for a month or two and then failing.
My brother-n-law is more yoga pants crazy than I am. They're cute... on my floor.0 -
lolJeffseekingV wrote: »I'd kill for a platform. Our Y just spent a ton on a motorized climbing machine but won't spend the few dollars for an deadlifting platform. And this is AFTER they removed the carpet and found some hairline cracks in the concrete from people doing deads. Go figure.
Hey I just wanted to get my oogle on once a week. haha
On the subject of gym complaints....
The stupid Anytime I sometimes go to (because I'm out again in the sticks) across the street finally got a power rack. Sure, buy a massage thing first and another tanning bed, but a power rack and oly bar? Nah that can wait.
And the power rack they bought, is more for the home and not a commercial gym.0 -
Yeah I agree. My gym is very no thrills and not particularly inviting but has all the equipment I would need and is cheap. I imagine they get a lot of sign ups that quit immediately like other gyms just on the price of their nearby competitors.0
-
I paid $449 for three years at 24Hr fitness and then $49 a year after that for access to all their gyms up to Sport level. I've had the membership for over 5 years now and usually go 5 days a week. I am not ever going to not pay them the $49 a year and lose this deal.0
-
Yeah, my first thought was "Is this a psychologist making comments about how gym lay-outs effect people psychologically?"
My gym is one of the greatest in the state, but it only cost $10 because I work for the University. If I was an outsider it'd be about $80 per month I think.
But I do fall into the the "It's OK if I don't use it cause it's so cheap" mindset.
But I also love outdoor activity and hike around a lot.
In my gym there are three "stories".
The very top story is a track with white cardio and more basic level machines. Intimidation level, maybe 1.
The middle level is the cardio room, a rock wall, and some crawling and stretching stuff and the class rooms. Intimidation level 0.
Now the bottom floor, if you're brave enough to descend (which I always do, I'm no novice) There's a few weight rooms, racket ball courts, basketball courts, more advanced machines (black, not white!), free weights, in two rooms and some weird things I don't understand if you want to skateboard in a pipe there's one down there too... All the guys pumping iron are college guys, Intimidation level: 10 or more!
So there are "psychologically intimidating" areas in my non-psychologist opinion, but fortunately I can do two full levels if I don't feel like rocking out and being a bad ***** that day.0 -
Smells like axe-grinding to me. Heck, I'm sure my gym loves people showing up -- that way they can sell them personal training, supplements, and after-workout protein shakes.0
-
My university gym is awesome too. I only wish it had an indoor track. (I don't think they could justify it weather wise). I also wish there were more free weights in the faculty/staff area since the regular area isn't always open to non-classes. But it's free, which is awesome. My health insurance also comes with gym access at a whole set of gyms (including some Ys with good free weights). That's great too.AsaThorsWoman wrote: »Yeah, my first thought was "Is this a psychologist making comments about how gym lay-outs effect people psychologically?"
My gym is one of the greatest in the state, but it only cost $10 because I work for the University. If I was an outsider it'd be about $80 per month I think.
But I do fall into the the "It's OK if I don't use it cause it's so cheap" mindset.
But I also love outdoor activity and hike around a lot.
In my gym there are three "stories".
The very top story is a track with white cardio and more basic level machines. Intimidation level, maybe 1.
The middle level is the cardio room, a rock wall, and some crawling and stretching stuff and the class rooms. Intimidation level 0.
Now the bottom floor, if you're brave enough to descend (which I always do, I'm no novice) There's a few weight rooms, racket ball courts, basketball courts, more advanced machines (black, not white!), free weights, in two rooms and some weird things I don't understand if you want to skateboard in a pipe there's one down there too... All the guys pumping iron are college guys, Intimidation level: 10 or more!
So there are "psychologically intimidating" areas in my non-psychologist opinion, but fortunately I can do two full levels if I don't feel like rocking out and being a bad ***** that day.
0 -
I have a great gym which is one building over from where I work, it's low cost and convenient. I have no excuse not to go work out, it's a basic gym no frills and since most people fall into the morning and lunch workout group, us evening people usually have it all to ourselves.0
-
I have a great gym which is one building over from where I work, it's low cost and convenient. I have no excuse not to go work out, it's a basic gym no frills and since most people fall into the morning and lunch workout group, us evening people usually have it all to ourselves.
nice!0 -
Doesnt this article state the obvious. Its not just gyms. Any business which requires you to pay an annnual or monthly subscription is going to make more money if you dont use their service. banks are buil on the idea that everyone doesnt ask for their money back all at the same time. Airlines sell more tickets than they have seats for.
People start and then fail to show at gyms for obvious reasons, namely for some its hard and boring. These days the gym market is more competitive with monthly not yearly contracts being more common place and you cna cancel more easily.
At some point the person joining has to take responsibility, if they arent going to use it then dont join doh.
0 -
civilizedworm wrote: »
One of the first, or second gyms, I joined (on my own, not family membership) actually did have a bar and disco lights with dance floor. The weights were located in one of the two disused racquetball courts downstairs.They create gyms that are meant to look like bars
It may have had the bar and dance floor, but it was still more of a gym than PF.
Okay, when I was searching for a gym, I had to look across three neighborhoods. I found one that the free weight section actually has a GLASS FLOOR! I *kitten* you not! You can look thru the floor to the aerobics room. I'm guessing NO dropping! Lol!
Unfortunately with all these jokes of a gym, when I finally found one with a decent weight section, it was the only one that ANYone seriously looking to train in three neighborhoods had found too, and in my limited 45 minutes in the afternoon, I can't even get NEAR the free weights, single squat rack or benches. Thank goodness my lil girl starts kindergarten next year and I'll go in the morning. But I should totally open a good gym in one of these neighborhoods (too bad everyone is too broke in Greece for it to actually make any money
)
0 -
FromHereOnOut wrote: »civilizedworm wrote: »
One of the first, or second gyms, I joined (on my own, not family membership) actually did have a bar and disco lights with dance floor. The weights were located in one of the two disused racquetball courts downstairs.They create gyms that are meant to look like bars
It may have had the bar and dance floor, but it was still more of a gym than PF.
Okay, when I was searching for a gym, I had to look across three neighborhoods. I found one that the free weight section actually has a GLASS FLOOR! I *kitten* you not! You can look thru the floor to the aerobics room. I'm guessing NO dropping! Lol!
Unfortunately with all these jokes of a gym, when I finally found one with a decent weight section, it was the only one that ANYone seriously looking to train in three neighborhoods had found too, and in my limited 45 minutes in the afternoon, I can't even get NEAR the free weights, single squat rack or benches. Thank goodness my lil girl starts kindergarten next year and I'll go in the morning. But I should totally open a good gym in one of these neighborhoods (too bad everyone is too broke in Greece for it to actually make any money )
That glass floor bit made me laugh harder than I should have LOL
I agree and the monstrous initiation fees that some have, my god. Like the equinox I hear is $1000 or less?
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions