Is this rude, or am I just exaggerating the issue

magsmichelle

I have been going to the gym for about 3-4 months now. I have worked my way up to being able to jog for 3 1/2 miles. Today i was on my way to a new achievement of 4 miles.
The gym was NOT busy. There were open treadmills so you didn't have to get on one right beside someone else.
I was at 3.45 when this lady gets on one right beside me. No big deal. However, when she removed her jacket..i got a big strong wiff of cigarettes smoke. It was strong, and me being sensitive to that smell, couldn't really continue on that machine. I had to stop. Which then just ruined the rest of the workout, because it was really hard for me to finish the run on a new machine strong.
I think if you smoke, and there are open machines, you should out of respect not get one right beside someone else if you don't have to. Out of respect for others considering not everyone can tolerate that smell. I know most smokers do not realize they carry a smell, but trust me you do.
That is my rant for the day, and yeah i am probably overreacting..but as an asthmatic who has pretty much got her asthma completely under control except for scent triggers, and one of them is that particular smell it just annoyed me. She didn't have to get on the one right beside me. The one i got on, after i stopped, was on two down from me and there was no one on either side of it.

JeffseekingV

If possible, follow the men's pee stall rule or the toilet stall rule.

jdhcm2006

I don't understand people who have to workout right beside someone when there are a plethora of other machines available. No it's not overreacting to me, but then again, I'm someone who really values personal space.

Jennloella

it's annoying whether they smell or not. And yes smokers reek, no matter how careful they are. I can always tell if my father in law has been in my home, I hate it and he is no longer allowed on upholstered furniture, kitchen chairs for him. I can't stand the smell.

farfromthetree

Totally a pet-peeve of mine. Drives me insane to be that close to someone if I dont have to be.

spicy618

herrspoons wrote: »

It annoys me when some weirdo gets on the machine next to you when there are half a dozen free ones available.

So, no. Not overreacting.

My BF and I are always saying this. Why do people choose to park, walk, pee, exercise, etc. right next to someone when there is room to spread out. I will go out of my way, if the space is available, to avoid being close to people or things I'm not related too. lol

You aren't overreacting in my book.

sllm1

This actually happened to me at a conference, except with seats. There must have been 500 empty seats in the auditorium and a string of a dozen right next to me. So a lady sits down right beside me. I was flabbergasted. I never thought much about "rules" as far as personal space is concerned, but I really was taken aback that she took up the seat directly beside me when there were clearly other places to sit.

Jennloella

sllm1 wrote: »

This actually happened to me at a conference, except with seats. There must have been 500 empty seats in the auditorium and a string of a dozen right next to me. So a lady sits down right beside me. I was flabbergasted. I never thought much about "rules" as far as personal space is concerned, but I really was taken aback that she took up the seat directly beside me when there were clearly other places to sit.

I've had this happen also in a Dr waiting room.....people are freaking weird.

leggup

Social etiquette dictates that any time there is a multiple available situation, you do not crowd next to someone else. Same rules for restroom stalls, open sinks in the restroom, urinals, movie theater seats, seat yourself restaurants (chipotle, panera) and so forth. In my experience, people who ignore these standards are either oblivious or trying to hit on you.

Since this is merely etiquette and not a rule and any gym I know, you should have switched machines if anything about her made you uncomfortable. That it "ruined" the rest of your workout is the only bit where you're being a bit dramatic. You could have switched machines.

higgins8283801

britishbroccoli wrote: »

Social etiquette dictates that any time there is a multiple available situation, you do not crowd next to someone else. Same rules for restroom stalls, open sinks in the restroom, urinals, movie theater seats, seat yourself restaurants (chipotle, panera) and so forth. In my experience, people who ignore these standards are either oblivious or trying to hit on you.

Since this is merely etiquette and not a rule and any gym I know, you should have switched machines if anything about her made you uncomfortable. That it "ruined" the rest of your workout is the only bit where you're being a bit dramatic. You could have switched machines.

She did. I think her asthma kicked in though due to the smell so she couldn't continue.

chodde

I don't think you are overreacting, because you did not tell this person where to go... However, a few possible thoughts from the other person's perspective. Ever heard the phrase "my *kitten* don't stink" it simply means if you are always around your smell, you don't realize it (or how bad it is). Not very considerate, but some people just don't have that level of self awareness.

Another thought is that possibly that is the treadmill the person runs on every day. I know in my old gym, when you found a treadmill that didn't slip or stop suddenly on you, you used it and never changed (took me 5 treadmills one day before I could effectively run my 5 miles). I don't have that problem in my new gym but then again all 25 are filled up too.

Still I hear ya, nothing worse than choking on that smell!

spicy618

Any psychologist or those who analyze people please explain why, why, why do some people do this crap? Is it a mental thing? lol!

higgins8283801

My son is an asthmatic and I know his triggers all too well. For him he would have been a wheezy mess! So I get you.

I try not to get right next to someone if I don't have to.

TR0berts

Eh, on the whole, I think you're probably not overreacting.

That said, did that person simply grab the nearest treadmill? Or, for that matter, the treadmill the furthest away, so that she got a few more steps in? Maybe, for whatever reason, she likes that particular treadmill? My point is that maybe there's a particular reason she chose that treadmill - you just happened to be next to it.

spicy618

TR0berts wrote: »

Eh, on the whole, I think you're probably not overreacting.

That said, did that person simply grab the nearest treadmill? Or, for that matter, the treadmill the furthest away, so that she got a few more steps in? Maybe, for whatever reason, she likes that particular treadmill? My point is that maybe there's a particular reason she chose that treadmill - you just happened to be next to it.

Good point. Didn't think of this.

Jennloella

britishbroccoli wrote: »

Social etiquette dictates that any time there is a multiple available situation, you do not crowd next to someone else. Same rules for restroom stalls, open sinks in the restroom, urinals, movie theater seats, seat yourself restaurants (chipotle, panera) and so forth. In my experience, people who ignore these standards are either oblivious or trying to hit on you.

Since this is merely etiquette and not a rule and any gym I know, you should have switched machines if anything about her made you uncomfortable. That it "ruined" the rest of your workout is the only bit where you're being a bit dramatic. You could have switched machines.

OP was in the zone and mentioned having to stop, move belongings, settle in and fire up a new machine would not be the same. I get it. I also get nauseated at the smell so I would have checked out too

Sylvarose

I know before our local Y got wifi available for members (so I could watch netflix while on the treadmill off my iphone) I would tend to use the same two treadmills because they were the ones located in front of the TV on the only channel I could stand watching.

TheBattleAxe

amazes me that people still smoke, surely everybody knows how bad it is for you. Don't you also think it's a bit old fashioned? Also what's the point in running to get fit and healthy whilst you're still a smoker, defies logic.
As for choosing the machine right next to you when there is plenty of others, maybe you looked like you were running a similar speed to her and she wanted a pace to follow?

astrose00

I get it but when you are in a public place you don't have a right to extra space.

I wouldn't want to be right next to someone regardless of whether they smoked but I don't have a right to tell someone they should move or to even expect them to. Just like my bus commute to work everyday. I love having the seat next to me open but can't deny the seat to anyone who wants it.

I have a home gym but also have a gym membership I haven't used in a while. I love working out at home so I don't have to worry about anyone else's germs or sweat or smells! When I did go regularly, there were definitely certain machines that were better than others. If the choice was to use a crappy machine or workout next to someone, I will choose the latter. Nothing worse than a clunky, squeaky machine when you're trying to workout.

Again, I get that you're annoyed and I would have been, too. I guess I'm a little bold because I mostly likely would have told him/her that they smelled of cigarettes, just in case they didn't realize. Call it obnoxious but I would have wanted to annoy him/her in the same way I was annoyed.

hamoncan

Can't wait until I'm old and don't care enough to not say exactly what's on my mind aloud

dbmata

Here's what you do. Next time ol' smokey hops on right next to you...

Yell out, NITRO BOOST!
Then let it rip.

She'll move.

WalkingAlong

britishbroccoli wrote: »

Social etiquette dictates that any time there is a multiple available situation, you do not crowd next to someone else. Same rules for restroom stalls, open sinks in the restroom, urinals, movie theater seats, seat yourself restaurants (chipotle, panera) and so forth. In my experience, people who ignore these standards are either oblivious or trying to hit on you.

I agree. But there are times when I think etiquette calls for NOT leaving empty seats between parties, too, though. But if the movie or ride or whatever is probably going to be half full... yeah, spread out. If it's a shuttle bus that holds 24 people and there are 30 waiting, or opening night of a movie, don't think you'll get an empty seat on either side of you, so just cozy up instead of someone having to split their party or ask you to scooch.

quiksylver296

Jennloella wrote: »

it's annoying whether they smell or not. And yes smokers reek, no matter how careful they are. I can always tell if my father in law has been in my home, I hate it and he is no longer allowed on upholstered furniture, kitchen chairs for him. I can't stand the smell.

Wow... I don't like the smell either, but I would just Febreze my chairs after. Seems really rude to your F-I-L.

ImChipper

I agree here, but also know that while smokers know they smell, they are a lot like drunk people in that they think they have a handle on it, and that it isn't as bad as other people think. My sister would often bathe in aerosol spray when she came inside from smoking, and she still stunk, but she was adamant that she didn't smell it anymore and we were overreacting.

I myself, will only go right next to someone for 3 reasons- if the other machines are full, broken, or the show I want to watch while running is only playing on that one side

(happened yesterday. They gave me a weird look, but if my phone is dead, I'm picking Friends over Dr.Phil- sorry guys on either side of me )

If I've been pushing hard, and I know I have B.O., I try to give space. We are all there for a reason, but doesn't mean I'd want to smell the funk if I didn't need to

merisaOct3

dbmata wrote: »

Here's what you do. Next time ol' smokey hops on right next to you...

Yell out, NITRO BOOST!
Then let it rip.

She'll move.

Best. Comment. Ever.

thecrushinator

OMG thank you! I am not the only one who finds this behavior bizarre and obnoxious. It is the worst i just want to vomit on people who do *kitten* like this.

bohoT

I agree that social etiquette rules against crowding another person if there are other options available. I have a big personal space bubble so my RBF usually gets the better of me and occasionally scares people away. I have noticed that sometimes when people are new to the gym they freeze up when picking a machine. Then you just have to be forgiving of newbs.

I feel your pain as someone who sensitive to smells. However, us delicate flowers do have to understand that world does not cater to our preferences. I would totally prefer that the hippy-ster who has decided we are besties would keep her patchouli stink away from me on the cardio machines. I wish people would re-rack their weights. I also wish that people would stop using “conversate” as a word. I wish no one was allowed to wear Axe body spray in public ever.

So yes, it is annoying, but, it is not something you are going to get away from in the gym.

wilsoncl6

I would only do it if that particular machine was the one I always use. I always go to the same machine at the same gym at the same time and the usuals always know, leave it open most times and don't mind if you jump in right next to them because you are always there at the same time. Otherwise, I try to give people as much space as possible because I don't want to smell them and I'm sure they don't want to smell me. Somebody should write down the unwritten rules of gym etiquette and post them up for everyone to see but I guess they wouldn't be unwritten rules then.

Lauren8239

dbmata wrote: »

Here's what you do. Next time ol' smokey hops on right next to you...

Yell out, NITRO BOOST!
Then let it rip.

She'll move.

or.........she may think it's a competition and let loose her own nitro boost lmao

glevinso

I have had to, in the past, institute a no smoking policy for anyone who will be in my house. Not even in the yard. If you smoke, not allowed in. I don't want that smell in my house and it takes forever to go away.

Smokers stink all the time whether they think they do or not.

That said, you are in a semi-public place and that is something we have to deal with in places like this. It is apparently still somewhat socially acceptable to have tobacco stink on your body, but it is not socially acceptable to smell of BO. Go figure...

jbee27

I don't know that it was rude, as I doubt it was her intention to disrupt your workout in any way. But, I do think it's annoying, and I would be similarly annoyed.

In that woman's defense, perhaps its not her that is a smoker. A few years ago, I lived in a duplex where the couple living below me smoked like chimneys. My clothes (and sometimes my hair!) ALWAYS stunk like smoke in the winter months, because it would waft up into my apartment, and no amount of fans/air freshener could stop it. I was absolutely mortified about it. Ugh. Thank goodness that was a sublet for just 6 months.