How to respond to family members who disagree with weight goal
elphie754
Posts: 7,574 Member
Does anyone else have family members that don't agree with your weight goal? If so, what do you say to them/respond?
0
Replies
-
Not that BMI is the sole indicator of health, but is your weight goal within the healthy BMI range for your height?0
-
what is your height and weight?
0 -
Who gives a *kitten* what your family members think. They're not the ones stuck in YOUR body 24/7. Just tell them to pound sand...in a nice way. "Thanks, but you're opinion is not needed."0
-
tiptoethruthetulips wrote: »Not that BMI is the sole indicator of health, but is your weight goal within the healthy BMI range for your height?
This0 -
Sorry, it only posted the first paragraph for some reason and I'm on the mobile site so the edit button doesn't always work.
A little bit more detail:
When I started my journey I had about 110 lbs to lose until I was considered to be within a "normal" BMI but was/still aiming for 130lb loss to put me in the middle of a healthy BMi. To date I have lost 60 lbs, but still have 50-70 lbs to go. The other night, I had my parents over for dinner. The conversation started out well but then quickly descended into an argument. At first they were "happy and proud" I've lost so much (yay!) but then came the catalyst that started the fight- mom asked how much I've lost and "how much more do you want to lose, only a another 10-20 lbs?" I said no, another 50 would be great. I don't know if it is because they are used to seeing me so big, or I look smaller than I weigh, but my parents freaked out. "Why do you lose so much", "that will be too thin" etc. I didn't really know how to respond to them, so just said "well my MD thinks my weight goal is good" (she actually did say that) and if they don't want to be supportive, the front door is that way".
Just looking for some other ways people have explained their goal to loved ones. Everyone in my family is pretty "big" so it could just be that. I have 3 food scales (kitchen, travel and back up) and they constantly nag me about being obsessive. It's frustrating. One minute they are proud, the next they start chastising and yelling.0 -
Yes I've had this! Went to visit my mum and mentioned how much weight I had lost and my dad was like *you don't need to lose weight*
And I said we'll yes actually I do my BMI is in the overweight range. I'd like to feel hhealthy too.
His response was *what a load of crap*
This coming from a man who is very overweight, now disabled, drinks far too much cola when he is diabetic and no longer has a leg due to not looking after his health.
He is everything I DON'T want to be.0 -
tiptoethruthetulips wrote: »Not that BMI is the sole indicator of health, but is your weight goal within the healthy BMI range for your height?
Very much so. My goal is weight would have me at 20.6. I would be happy with anything between 20 and 24.9. Going for more of a range then a set number.iwillsucceed0444 wrote: »Who gives a *kitten* what your family members think. They're not the ones stuck in YOUR body 24/7. Just tell them to pound sand...in a nice way. "Thanks, but you're opinion is not needed."
Not that easy. Even when they yell I refuse to yell back. They help me with a lot, so I try my best not to be rude to them.
So sorry guys. I can totally see how my first post can sound like that lol. I'm on mobile, and when I type directly into the "start convo" box, it likes to cover what you are writing so you can see it (like it scrolls). Because of that, I thpically type things out on "notepad" and just c/p. Guess I forgot to hit "select all" lol.0 -
imabeevampire wrote: »Yes I've had this! Went to visit my mum and mentioned how much weight I had lost and my dad was like *you don't need to lose weight*
And I said we'll yes actually I do my BMI is in the overweight range. I'd like to feel hhealthy too.
His response was *what a load of crap*
This coming from a man who is very overweight, now disabled, drinks far too much cola when he is diabetic and no longer has a leg due to not looking after his health.
He is everything I DON'T want to be.
Very similar to their response. I even showed them a bmi chart and was told "hogwash, if that is true than your mother and I are overweight as well". I was nice and just said- we'll see what your doctor thinks. What I really wanted to say was- uhhhh yeah you really are.0 -
I find a good, terse, "Fark off" gets the point across without much dilly-dally.0
-
SergeantSausage wrote: »I find a good, terse, "Fark off" gets the point across without much dilly-dally.
If it were anyone else, I would, and would also use the actual profane word, but not with them.0 -
Honestly with some people it's just not worth the argument. Most people don't have the ability to look at someone who is a healthy weight (especially if they are overweight themselves) and say they weight this amount. Rather than argue with them smile, nod and don't correct their assumptions about how much you've lost, or how much more you plan to. Let your mom believe that 20 more pounds is your end goal, then just keep doing what your doing. If she comments, say those last 10 pounds are hard to get rid of.0
-
Amanda4change wrote: »Honestly with some people it's just not worth the argument. Most people don't have the ability to look at someone who is a healthy weight (especially if they are overweight themselves) and say they weight this amount. Rather than argue with them smile, nod and don't correct their assumptions about how much you've lost, or how much more you plan to. Let your mom believe that 20 more pounds is your end goal, then just keep doing what your doing. If she comments, say those last 10 pounds are hard to get rid of.
I know. Frustrating though. I have been trying to encourage them to take an interest in their own health. My dad is on board with it (he's been coming out walk/running with me when he can. My mom though has some very inaccurate and sometimes laughable ideas about losing weight. Not sure if she is actively trying, but I heard her say the other day that she was frustrated because she works out 15minutes once a week, and doesn't understand why it hasn't done anything for her (not sure what "thing" she wished to accomplish).0 -
herrspoons wrote: »It depends. Stats plz.
Already stated in terms of bmi.0 -
It depends if this is a one-off, or is it indicative of a long-term pattern of controlling and possibly abusive behaviour? If it's one-off, it's probably just parental concern and a bit of shame expressed badly, if it's a pattern...then that is another, rather complex ball game.0
-
They're probably mostly worried about the visual aspect. To them 50-60 pounds (gotta convert to kilos for a sec..aah ok) is like a small child. You could explain that it's not all going to be that literal and that it's impossible to visualise 50 pounds like that, it doesn't work that way in losing weight.
My parents are supportive, but also gawked when my mum asked me if I was nearly finished and I said I still had 40 or so pounds to go. People carry weight differently. It was clear I was overweight, but nobody would have guessed it was actually morbidly obese. I've seen pictures of people with my height and weight who looked way bigger than I did. So they'll just have to wait and see the end result and trust in your doctor!0 -
It depends if this is a one-off, or is it indicative of a long-term pattern of controlling and possibly abusive behaviour? If it's one-off, it's probably just parental concern and a bit of shame expressed badly, if it's a pattern...then that is another, rather complex ball game.
What? How is anything I write an insi action of abuse? You're going to have to spell that one out for me because I don't see it that way at all.
Was it a one time comment? Nope, and I'll likely hear it again the next time I'm with them. It's funny though because when I was overweight the nagged and said I should lose weight; I lose weight and suddenly it's too much.They're probably mostly worried about the visual aspect. To them 50-60 pounds (gotta convert to kilos for a sec..aah ok) is like a small child. You could explain that it's not all going to be that literal and that it's impossible to visualise 50 pounds like that, it doesn't work that way in losing weight.
My parents are supportive, but also gawked when my mum asked me if I was nearly finished and I said I still had 40 or so pounds to go. People carry weight differently. It was clear I was overweight, but nobody would have guessed it was actually morbidly obese. I've seen pictures of people with my height and weight who looked way bigger than I did. So they'll just have to wait and see the end result and trust in your doctor!
That sound so similar to me. While obvious I'm overweight, I guess my body just distributes it fairly well so that no one body part is out of proportion.0 -
Amanda4change wrote: »Honestly with some people it's just not worth the argument. Most people don't have the ability to look at someone who is a healthy weight (especially if they are overweight themselves) and say they weight this amount. Rather than argue with them smile, nod and don't correct their assumptions about how much you've lost, or how much more you plan to. Let your mom believe that 20 more pounds is your end goal, then just keep doing what your doing. If she comments, say those last 10 pounds are hard to get rid of.
I know. Frustrating though. I have been trying to encourage them to take an interest in their own health. My dad is on board with it (he's been coming out walk/running with me when he can. My mom though has some very inaccurate and sometimes laughable ideas about losing weight. Not sure if she is actively trying, but I heard her say the other day that she was frustrated because she works out 15minutes once a week, and doesn't understand why it hasn't done anything for her (not sure what "thing" she wished to accomplish).
If your goal is to get them on board, then of course you are opening yourself to unhelpful input from them.
Walk with your dad. Leave mom out of this completely.
And stop talking about your weight/bmi with both of them.
If you need to discuss what is going on with your weight loss, find people who are not your parents/relatives.0 -
I am currently experiencing this also, I have lost 44lbs now with another 26-33lbs to go which will take me smack bang in the middle of BMI, although if I got to a UK size 10 before that then I would stop I think as I've imagined being smaller than an 10. However my mum, who is my best friend, keeps putting an absolute downer on it, telling me never to shop in certain shops as they come up small so I have no hope to fit and looking genuinely horrified when I said ideally I am aiming for a size 10 saying that is too thin for someone of 5'6 and I should be at least a curvy size 12, I'm going to have an eating disorder etc, I'm being ridiculous with this now, should max lose another 10lbs etc. The real kicker is that she is 5'4 and has always strived for a UK 10! Doh!
I bite my tongue with her because I don't want to fall out but it has gotten me really upset at times like she doesn't believe I can do it, but I'm also more determined. I suspect she may be jealous and a little afraid of change as I am not too far off her weight and she has been yo yo dieting ever since I can remember (she is off the wagon now) so in some strange way it might make her look bad?
I don't have much advice on how to tackle things as I am keeping quiet to save an argument but just wanted to let you know you're not alone!
P.s. last time she started my step dad chimed in and told her to stop and that it was up to me what I want to do and she did stop...so I could lend you my stepdad? Haha0 -
-
I don't need my parents to co-sign my decisions. When I've made decisions they haven't supported, I haven't tried to push them for their support (my dad tried to talk me out of finishing my bachelor's degree, for goodness sake).
I don't know if you live with them or they support you financially or what, but I would try to extract myself from a situation in which I was being yelled at and did not feel as though I could push back.0 -
Amanda4change wrote: »Honestly with some people it's just not worth the argument. Most people don't have the ability to look at someone who is a healthy weight (especially if they are overweight themselves) and say they weight this amount. Rather than argue with them smile, nod and don't correct their assumptions about how much you've lost, or how much more you plan to. Let your mom believe that 20 more pounds is your end goal, then just keep doing what your doing. If she comments, say those last 10 pounds are hard to get rid of.
I know. Frustrating though. I have been trying to encourage them to take an interest in their own health. My dad is on board with it (he's been coming out walk/running with me when he can. My mom though has some very inaccurate and sometimes laughable ideas about losing weight. Not sure if she is actively trying, but I heard her say the other day that she was frustrated because she works out 15minutes once a week, and doesn't understand why it hasn't done anything for her (not sure what "thing" she wished to accomplish).
If your goal is to get them on board, then of course you are opening yourself to unhelpful input from them.
Walk with your dad. Leave mom out of this completely.
And stop talking about your weight/bmi with both of them.
If you need to discuss what is going on with your weight loss, find people who are not your parents/relatives.
It never was my goal for them to join. It just kind of happened. They were over one day and I told them I needed to go for my daily exercise, which was not meant as an invite to join but rather a subtle hint that it was time for them to leave. My dad enjoyed it, so asked me if he could tag along regularly. Against my better judgement I said sure. I don't care one way or the other, it's the nagging that pisses me off. I never talk about my weight or BMi around them. If weight comes up, it is because my mom brought it up, but I never tell them my specific numbers. Again- I am not the one who brings it up.
0 -
Just smile agree and say you will lose the amount they want you to...then lose the amount the dr and you agreed on.
When you visit+them always bring and share a treat you worked into your cal goal. This way they will stop worrying+that you arent+eating enough and this silly disagreement over a number on+a+scale+can+stop.0 -
I am currently experiencing this also, I have lost 44lbs now with another 26-33lbs to go which will take me smack bang in the middle of BMI, although if I got to a UK size 10 before that then I would stop I think as I've imagined being smaller than an 10. However my mum, who is my best friend, keeps putting an absolute downer on it, telling me never to shop in certain shops as they come up small so I have no hope to fit and looking genuinely horrified when I said ideally I am aiming for a size 10 saying that is too thin for someone of 5'6 and I should be at least a curvy size 12, I'm going to have an eating disorder etc, I'm being ridiculous with this now, should max lose another 10lbs etc. The real kicker is that she is 5'4 and has always strived for a UK 10! Doh!
I bite my tongue with her because I don't want to fall out but it has gotten me really upset at times like she doesn't believe I can do it, but I'm also more determined. I suspect she may be jealous and a little afraid of change as I am not too far off her weight and she has been yo yo dieting ever since I can remember (she is off the wagon now) so in some strange way it might make her look bad?
I don't have much advice on how to tackle things as I am keeping quiet to save an argument but just wanted to let you know you're not alone!
P.s. last time she started my step dad chimed in and told her to stop and that it was up to me what I want to do and she did stop...so I could lend you my stepdad? Haha
Sure! Send him this way. I'll even pay for shipping :-p.
My biggest peeve is if I have food in the house my mom think is unhealthy (chips, diet sodas, popcorn etc) she tries to tell me how bad they are and if I want to lose weight I can't eat those.obscuremusicreference wrote: »I don't need my parents to co-sign my decisions. When I've made decisions they haven't supported, I haven't tried to push them for their support (my dad tried to talk me out of finishing my bachelor's degree, for goodness sake).
I don't know if you live with them or they support you financially or what, but I would try to extract myself from a situation in which I was being yelled at and did not feel as though I could push back.
I don't look for their input (whether it be support or the nagging). They just chime in and feel the needs to constantly bring the conversation back to that topic.0 -
My mom gets weird about it too, she wants me to lose weight but I'd imagine she has a pretty firm thought in her head about how much it should be. More than where I am now and less than where I plan to end up if I had to guess.
My tactic since the beginning has been to be vague about it when with them. Thankfully I don't spend much time around her but when I do I make it a point to eat as "normally" as I can, when she asks if I've lost weight I hmm and say I dunno, maybe I guess so? All my clothes are stretchy and you know I don't really notice" stuff like that. Basically I just don't make a big deal out of it.
I will see them soon and mom will ask again about it and I will be like "yeah I guess I've lost some since I've seen you last but I'm not sure how much" and then we move past the subject. Or she may speculate about how much and I'll say "sure yeah that probably sounds right".
Were I you I would just agree with my parents "yeah mom I thought about it you are right, your idea sounds great" and then just do whatever I want anyway. Since I started doing this years ago we never argue. In the context of your conversation my answer would have been something like "I dunno, I haven't really thought about it too much, but that sounds good" or something like that. And that's not even much of a lie, I really do just worry about the next pound and then go from there. I don't need to worry about 50 lbs from now any more than my mom does as today I am dealing with this next pound and that's all that matters right now.
It seems silly to argue with them over a number like 50 lbs since they can't even visualize what that is even going to look like on you. It's not like they have good advice/information to offer you were they to know your full plan. I'd also stop worrying about wanting to influence their health/weight decisions and just focus on spending time with them and enjoying their company in whatever way you can and not stress them out.
And I hope I don't sound like I am being hard on you, I think your parents are in the wrong on a lot of levels, but from what you have said they sound like my mom with little to no chance of changing their way of thinking, and it's just not worth arguing with them so my suggestions deal with the only thing you can actually control or influence which is you.0 -
I have had this also, I think that this problem is that a lot of people who have little experience of weight loss have trouble conceptualizing what that amount of weight would look like when it comes off and to them it sounds like a very high number.
I have found that the easiest way to avoid the drama is just to say, 'I am not sure I am willing to stop whenever I get to a shape that looks and feels healthy on my body'0 -
Tell them it isn't up for discussion. If you've rationally made your case about it being a healthy BMI for your body, they don't have an argument to make. I'm sorry. My own mother occasionally nags me about something and I refuse to discuss it and change the subject.
You don't need to yell back, but you should feel comfortable telling them it's not on the table.0 -
aha
smile and nod
people don't get it
I was getting this comment from everyone, including my boss's boss before I even hit a BMI of 25 which was my target weight
I'm now at that weight and maintaining until I can work out where I want to go from here .. clearly I could lose more according to BMI but I'm not sure I want to yet based on how my body is looking
just smile and nod and lie .. say oh a few more pounds
because people worry0 -
Let's forget BMI for a second, if you feel like you need to loose more weight to reach your physical peak do it. My parents like mentioning my gut but don't want to see me as a size 0. my mom was a size 0 when she was my age, no diet or anything! I'm just trying to get to a normal body weight that I can be comfortable with. I've learnt to ignore them and carry on with what I'm doing
If it's not your weight it would be something else0 -
Just don't discuss it with them. Problem solved0
-
The comments on this thread make me so glad I live far away from my mother.... I can't imagine the insanity that she would bring to the table in my weight loss...0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions