Fruits are too sugary and bad for weight loss?
glfernandes828
Posts: 101 Member
I've read a lot of articles lately that say that fruits really aren't that great of a food to eat when trying to lose weight because despite the vitamins, they are filled with sugar and if you are trying to loose weight, you should keep your fruit consumption at a minimum.
This sucks cuz I loooove all fruits so much. But since reading those articles I've chosen to only eat fruits as meal replacers or snacks in between very spread apart meals.
What are your opinions and facts you know about fruits?
This sucks cuz I loooove all fruits so much. But since reading those articles I've chosen to only eat fruits as meal replacers or snacks in between very spread apart meals.
What are your opinions and facts you know about fruits?
0
Replies
-
Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
If you have a medical or personal reason to watch your sugar intake, then you'll need to account for fruit sugars just like you account for added sugars.
Anything else is personal preference.
I lost 55 pounds while eating fruit as part of my diet. Your mileage may vary.0 -
To lose weight, eat fewer calories than you burn off. That's it.
For health reasons, people watch their sugar intake, or their salt intake, or their cholesterol intake.
If you have no health issues, then eat all the sugar you want. Within your calorie and macronutrient goals, of course.0 -
Eating too many calories is bad for weight loss. If your fruit fits in your calories and you're getting your other essential nutrients then I wouldn't worry about it.0
-
No. CICO.
Sugar doesn't make you gain weight. Too many calories does.0 -
I aim to get two servings of fruit and veggies a day. Fruit is good for you, like anything else.... An excess can be a negative.0
-
One of the biggest benefits of going low carb (ie. avoiding fruits, breads, pasta, etc) is that your body takes longer to digest fats, meaning you feel full longer, and your cravings for sugar is reduced. Sugar is an addictive substance, and when you cut sugar (natural unprocessed sugars included) for a sufficient amount of time, your cravings stop. These two components combine to mean that without thinking about it you reduce your caloric intake. I've been on a strict low carb diet for over a month, and am easily at a 1000 calorie deficit almost every day, and when I go over it's more because I'm snacking or trying to meet my macro needs than because I feel hungry. A 1000 calorie deficit translates to 2lbs lost a week according to MFP, and is as low as they recommend you can safely go. Unfortunately it is difficult to get to this point without eliminating fruit at least for a little while (aside from berried which are low enough carb to work).0
-
No. CICO.
Sugar doesn't make you gain weight. Too many calories does.
This and this
http://bretcontreras.com/sugar-the-sweet-truth/
"What about health?
There are many cultures in tropical climates thriving on diets of up to 90% carbohydrates [8-10]. And we’re not talking oatmeal and broccoli here. These cultures rely on sugary fruits. In fact, honey is the favorite food of the Hadza from Tanzania [9].
Evolution has made sure our bodies can deal with sugar, because it is found in many of the world’s most nutritious foods: fruits. Fruit is in fact one of the foods humans have consumed for the longest period of our genetic existence. It has been a staple in our diet ever since we were still monkeys living in the jungle [5, 11]. And glucose is literally in our blood."0 -
I eat several types of fruit per day. I find it keeps me full. Like others have said just make sure you are within your calories.0
-
Fruits are fine.0
-
Fruit sugar isn't bad for you. Too many calories stop weight loss.0
-
brittany_812 wrote: »One of the biggest benefits of going low carb (ie. avoiding fruits, breads, pasta, etc) is that your body takes longer to digest fats, meaning you feel full longer, and your cravings for sugar is reduced. Sugar is an addictive substance, and when you cut sugar (natural unprocessed sugars included) for a sufficient amount of time, your cravings stop. These two components combine to mean that without thinking about it you reduce your caloric intake. I've been on a strict low carb diet for over a month, and am easily at a 1000 calorie deficit almost every day, and when I go over it's more because I'm snacking or trying to meet my macro needs than because I feel hungry. A 1000 calorie deficit translates to 2lbs lost a week according to MFP, and is as low as they recommend you can safely go. Unfortunately it is difficult to get to this point without eliminating fruit at least for a little while (aside from berried which are low enough carb to work).
sugar is not addictive….
0 -
OP - calorie deficit = weight loss …not the amount of sugar you are consuming, unless of course your sugar consumption is putting you in caloric surplus...0
-
diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.
Which is why I added my second line about medical reasons to track sugar, which you declined to quote.
0 -
diannethegeek wrote: »azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.
Which is why I added my second line about medical reasons to track sugar, which you declined to quote.
Making an absolute statement and then contradicting yourself was...unclear.0 -
Government food guides encourage the consumption of fruits and vegetables. They are full of fiber and micronutrients.
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an/food-guide-aliment/choose-choix/fruit/index-eng.php0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.
Which is why I added my second line about medical reasons to track sugar, which you declined to quote.
Making an absolute statement and then contradicting yourself was...unclear.
No, she was clear and you cropped her statement to make it look like she neglected to mention medical conditions that have special considerations.0 -
Fruit is fine. It's healthy and yummy.
But, contrary to what some programs (e.g. Weight Watchers) would have you believe, fruit is not "free". It has calories. So you do have to limit how many calories you eat overall. Which means you can't eat unlimited quantities of fruit... or of anything else.
If it fits into your calorie goal? Sure, go for it. Vive la fruit.0 -
-
azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.
sorry I forgot my medical disclaimer….*rolls eyez*
and even if you have one of those conditions it is still comes down to CICO0 -
Awesome! Okay thanks y'all. I like to get as much info as I can. I already eat less calories than necessary to lose weight, just wanted to see if fruits affected it regardless.0
-
CICO- fruit is fine.0
-
I have lost almost all of my weight (3 pounds from my revised, revised goal weight) and I eat a ton of fruit! Even with fruit, there are higher calorie options and lower. I stick primarily with berries. Strawberries with milk and sugar for breakfast and bedtime, blueberries same way in season. Yummy, fills me just right, and keeps everything moving along nicely
0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.
I think you are over-estimating how many people here truly do have these issues. One person on my MFP friends list actually has PCOS, and I just checked her diary, her carb goal is 190g. She also exceeds this limit at times while being below or at her calories most of those times as well... iirc she's lost 30lbs in her time here and has a pretty reasonable calorie goal (1900).
In the end though your body doesn't defy CICO.0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »azulvioleta6 wrote: »diannethegeek wrote: »Calories are what matter for weight loss. Not sugars. Not carbs. Just calories.
Unless you have PCOS, diabetes, pre-diabetes/metabolic syndrome or another metabolic issue which makes you especially sensitive to carbs. Many of us here DO have problems with carbs and sugar. Yes, under the right circumstances, the sugar in fruit CAN stall your weight loss or make you gain weight.
While I do consume fruit, I have found that I do better if I can limit myself to 1-2 servings a day. I try to make up for that by getting 8-9 servings of lower-carb vegetables (not corn, not potatoes) each day.
Another good strategy is picking fruits that are lower on the Glycemic Index. Cherries and berries are great, bananas not so much.
Which is why I added my second line about medical reasons to track sugar, which you declined to quote.
Making an absolute statement and then contradicting yourself was...unclear.
Just read her OP. Doesn't sound contradictory in the least.
Statement 1: there is no reason to track sugar for weight loss purposes, because CICO. Makes sense.
Statement 2: However, if you have a medical disorder or another logical reason to monitor your sugar intake for health reasons, then you'd need to track fruit sugar as well. Again, makes sense. This statement does not tie into the act of losing weight.0 -
Honestly, you can get the same vitamins and minerals from vegetables that you can get from fruits. Green, leafy vegetables are higher in dietary fiber, lower in sugars and are overall better for you. Spinach especially.
If you want to consume a good fruit, go for avocados. Or if you really want a sweet dessert, go for low carb fruits such as raspberries, blackberries and strawberries.0 -
Government food guides encourage the consumption of fruits and vegetables. They are full of fiber and micronutrients.
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an/food-guide-aliment/choose-choix/fruit/index-eng.php
The government is in bed with the pharmaceudical companies. Like a big ol orgy in there.
Read on...0 -
BritDillinger wrote: »Honestly, you can get the same vitamins and minerals from vegetables that you can get from fruits. Green, leafy vegetables are higher in dietary fiber, lower in sugars and are overall better for you. Spinach especially.
If you want to consume a good fruit, go for avocados. Or if you really want a sweet dessert, go for low carb fruits such as raspberries, blackberries and strawberries.
This makes no sense.
You say to stop eating fruit because it's high in sugar, you eat Quest bars.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
RockstarWilson wrote: »Government food guides encourage the consumption of fruits and vegetables. They are full of fiber and micronutrients.
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/fn-an/food-guide-aliment/choose-choix/fruit/index-eng.php
The government is in bed with the pharmaceudical companies. Like a big ol orgy in there.
Read on...
The government suggests eating natural foods because they want you to not be healthy?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions