21 Day Sugar Detox
Dbow0207
Posts: 220 Member
Replies
-
This content has been removed.
-
While I don't mind plans that cut sweets and other added sugars for a while, to get cravings under control your list is unnecessarily restrictive, and not terribly logical imho. It's not going to be low carb (because it allows fruit, and unlimited vegetables), but then it cuts GREAT foods that aren't really sugary, or have a high glycemic impact/load, like legumes. Legumes are GREAT when you're working on your blood sugar levels and trying to master your cravings.
My point: the list doesn't make any real logical sense.
By all means, eliminate, or strictly limit foods with added sugars, and things like fruit juice, and heavily refined carbs (white breads with lots of sugar or HFCS) for a few weeks to get your cravings under control, but your list just doesn't make sense to me.
If you decide to do this kind of thing, look at a few other 2 week lists, like the South Beach phase 1 list.
1 -
Elimination diets usually have the highest failure rate (95% of people who attempt them fail) because they are a complete switch to previous behavior and strictly limits other foods that aren't bad to have (fruits here). Reduction alone just helps. Just eat more whole foods and reduce some of the processed foods.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
-
I understand the need for some people to restrict to get a handle on their sugar intake. That list is unnecessarily prohibitive on some pretty random things, though.0
-
On Day 22 you become superhuman. Your superhuman powers are taken away when you eat any of the "no" foods.
0 -
Yeah. no.0
-
So, here's my take.
I find that when I quit eating added sugars completely, it only takes me a couple of days to quit craving them completely. By about day four, a grapefruit tastes like delicious candy and I'm happy.
The minute someone offers me a cookie and I decide to eat it since I can fit it into my calorie goals? All bets are off and I start fiending for sugar again.
Unless you're never going to eat any of the foods on the forbidden list again, this isn't going to change anything for you long term.
It's way easier just to enjoy sugary foods in moderation, as it fits into your calorie and macronutrient goals.0 -
PeachyPlum wrote: »So, here's my take.
I find that when I quit eating added sugars completely, it only takes me a couple of days to quit craving them completely. By about day four, a grapefruit tastes like delicious candy and I'm happy.
The minute someone offers me a cookie and I decide to eat it since I can fit it into my calorie goals? All bets are off and I start fiending for sugar again.
Unless you're never going to eat any of the foods on the forbidden list again, this isn't going to change anything for you long term.
It's way easier just to enjoy sugary foods in moderation, as it fits into your calorie and macronutrient goals.
I agree with this. If you're not going to avoid the "forbidden" foods forever, then there's no point. But giving up added sugars (for me this is any type of cookies, cakes, candy), can help if you're craving them constantly. At least it does for me, so I chose to give up those foods entirely. And like the above poster, it really only takes me a couple of days for the cravings to disappear. But this has nothing to do with weight loss and everything to do with how I feel when I eat those foods (ie. migraines, joint pain, and even hives).
Ask yourself - what is your goal in giving up these foods? What do you think is going to happen on day 22? Are you doing this for weight loss? Or is there another reason? (ie. food allergies or something else?)
ETA: What is the problem here with dairy? And why, if butter is "forbidden" is ghee ok? Seriously... just ask yourself what here makes sense rather than following a list that has zero scientific explanation. (mini rant over)
0 -
Sugar is not a toxin and your body does not require detoxification from it. If you want to cut back on or eliminate sugar, that's great. I limit sugar too because it is concentrated, empty calories. But the whole "detox" thing is a bunch of woo.0
-
I don't see anything wrong with it. Lots of people already eat that way, myself included (however cream and cheese has stayed with me because yum) so this 21 day plan is my 520ish day plan and going strong. Half the "do not eat" list is common sense but people get scared when they think of no sugar and then make up all sorts of crap on why it's unattainable instead of actually giving it a go and realizing it's really not that hard.0
-
Looks good to me! PeachyPlum is right in that you might crave sugar like mad at first, but then you won't and whole fruits and stuff will start to taste great! It's true that our bodies need a little sugar (it's what fuels our nervous system!), but most Americans get way too much! Minimizing pastries and breads that break down into sugars when you digest them pretty much quitting sugary drinks altogether is a smart move! It's not too extreme. Your body can get the sugar it needs from fruit and nutrient-dense carbs like quinoa, couscous, and brown rice. That's not to say you can never have another brownie ever again, but a 21 Day sugar-rehab program sounds smart to me! It'll accelerate your weight loss plus....training yourself to cut down on sugar reduces your cancer risk AND the rate at which your cells age. (Sugar, although necessary in small doses, is a mutagen and does speed up mitosis.) I agree that detoxing on lemon juice and celery for life is kind of crazy, but once in a while, weaning off sugar/booze/bread can be a nice way to clean the slate physically and psychologically. Every once in a while, we just gotta hit "reset" you know?0
-
I don't see anything wrong with it. Lots of people already eat that way, myself included (however cream and cheese has stayed with me because yum) so this 21 day plan is my 520ish day plan and going strong. Half the "do not eat" list is common sense but people get scared when they think of no sugar and then make up all sorts of crap on why it's unattainable instead of actually giving it a go and realizing it's really not that hard.
So you don't eat fruit at all? Honest question.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
But that's a subjective point of view rather than an objective point of view. I view enjoyment of life around the cultural foods I eat with my family. Some have refined sugar as well as HFCS. So I have a some, but accounted for and well within control. To NOT enjoy it may make me avoid more family get togethers (which some people I know do) and to me that's sad.I don't see anything wrong with it. Lots of people already eat that way, myself included (however cream and cheese has stayed with me because yum) so this 21 day plan is my 520ish day plan and going strong. Half the "do not eat" list is common sense but people get scared when they think of no sugar and then make up all sorts of crap on why it's unattainable instead of actually giving it a go and realizing it's really not that hard.
Same with sex. To tell someone "hey no sex just give it a go" FOREVER won't fly well with many many people. Some will do just fine without it, but I'm betting it's just a minority of people.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
I eat maybe 5 raspberries if they're on sale but other than that, nope. No fruit in 17+ months. (I have no idea how to directly reply, boards confuse me)0
-
As for not enjoying stuff with family, my family as well as some friends have seen how well it's worked out for me and now eat as I do so I'm not missing out on anything. My life doesn't revolve around food.
0 -
I eat maybe 5 raspberries if they're on sale but other than that, nope. No fruit in 17+ months. (I have no idea how to directly reply, boards confuse me)
A cup of raspberries (which I just finished eating) had a nice 8 grams of fiber though, and only 64 calories! They're tasty too. Why give that up? I have PCOS and I don't have to give this stuff up.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
It's a great idea to try it out and see how you feel. It's only 21 days. You may be surprised at how great you will feel. This closely resembles how my family eats daily, except we eat dairy and allow small amounts of stevia and xylitol. I've always wanted to try to go without even those. Good luck to you !0
-
I eat zero sugar. I have to say yes, I'm pretty proud of that. I get my fibre in dark veggies.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
How is this restrictive? lol. I have a sugar addiction as bad as a heroin addiction (Doctors words) and this seems SUPER easy to do. I am so glad I seen this....I start this tomorrow. I would today but I had some Dr Pepper already lol0
-
I said dark veggies, not cans of corn. I watch my net carbs. I get more nutrients with less sugar in veggies. Sugar causes insulin spikes and cravings, so I avoid it.0
-
I don't see anything wrong with it. Lots of people already eat that way, myself included (however cream and cheese has stayed with me because yum) so this 21 day plan is my 520ish day plan and going strong. Half the "do not eat" list is common sense but people get scared when they think of no sugar and then make up all sorts of crap on why it's unattainable instead of actually giving it a go and realizing it's really not that hard.
So because you think some food is crap that means it's crap for everyone? Why does anyone have to give up that stuff?
Well, yes, most of that food IS crap. Not all, but a lot of it.0 -
JessieLMay wrote: »How is this restrictive? lol. I have a sugar addiction as bad as a heroin addiction (Doctors words) and this seems SUPER easy to do. I am so glad I seen this....I start this tomorrow. I would today but I had some Dr Pepper already lol
I see this ending well.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions