Diet Soda
ilikecats01
Posts: 3 Member
I am a big diet coke fan, and drink quite a bit during the day. Sometimes I wonder if, in some weird way, it is negatively affecting my weight. Like doing something to my metabolism? Anyone have an insight or experiences in this?
0
Replies
-
no its not.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Here is some research that I came across....
"When Purdue researchers Susan Swithers, PhD, and Terry Davidson, PhD, published their first studies in rats designed to test their theory that artificial sweeteners alter the body’s ability to regulate calorie intake, they were not prepared for the press attention their research received.
In the first study, two groups of rats were fed sweet, flavored, cola-like liquids. For one group, the liquid was always sweetened with sugar so there was a consistent relationship between the sweet taste and calories. In the second group, the sugar-sweetened liquids were alternated with liquids sweetened with the artificial sweetener saccharin, so that the relationship between the sweet taste and calories was inconsistent.
After 10 days, the rats were given a sweet, high-calorie chocolate pudding. Those exposed to the caloric and non-caloric sweet beverages ate more of the pudding.
In another study, rats were fed high-calorie chocolate pudding or chocolate milk with their regular food. At the end of the month, the chocolate milk group had gained significantly more weight.
The first experiment suggested that by breaking the connection between sweet taste and calories, artificial sweeteners interfere with the body’s natural ability to judge calorie content, Swithers says. The second, that the body is less able to recognize energy delivered in liquid form.
In a later set of studies the researchers fed rats yogurt sweetened with sugar or saccharine in addition to their regular chow and found that the rats that ate the no-calorie sweetener took in more calories overall and gained more weight."
I'm drinking a diet Pepsi right now, btw.
Everything can be bad in excess, I suggest seriously cutting back on the diet soda.0 -
I think it can. I myself lost 10 lbs in about 4 weeks doing nothing different than cutting out diet soda. I had to, it was reacting to a medication i was taking. So that meant nothing with nutrasweet, splenda, sucralose, etc. No diet soda, no crystal light, none of that mio water enhancer stuff. No sugar free candy or gum. So I gave it all up. and I even ADDED 1 can of FULL sugar soda a day in place of the 3-4 cans of diet I was drinking. Lost 10lbs like I said.
I talked to my Dr. and Allergist.. neither were surprised. Your brain is getting signals of 'sweet' intake, but not the blood sugar boost that goes with it. Maybe for some people that can trigger bigger cravings, and more intake of other foods, thus an overall increase of calories.
of course, to be fair my 1 can full sugar soda slowly increased itself over time and i gained the 10lbs back. with MFP, Fit bit and back to healthier eating, which includes a continued ban on fake anything, I've lost 21-24 lbs(still fluctuating and getting back on track these past few weeks).
I'd rather drink unsweetened ice tea, and enjoy a small Jack and Coke at night than have tons of the fake chemicals all day long. Personal choice though in the long run.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
asflatasapancake wrote: »It is Friday, I suppose. That answer is no. Enjoy whatever comes next. I'd just like to add this, as it has become one of my favorite gifs lately.
Best cat gif I've seen in a long time! Will be saving that for future use.0 -
asflatasapancake wrote: »It is Friday, I suppose. That answer is no. Enjoy whatever comes next. I'd just like to add this, as it has become one of my favorite gifs lately.
Actually posts like these make me feel like I'm in Groundhog Day.
0 -
I don't drink soda, was just never a fan. Would occasionally have a carbonated beverage. What made me swear off the stuff forever was having to replace a pipe in one of the facilities I manage. The pipe ran the syrup to the carbonation line and then to the soda machine. It was a 1/2 inch think steel pipe. And the syrup ate through it. Corroded the heck out of it. It smelled so bad. So very bad. With all the facility plumbing issues I've seen over the years, I've never seen anything like that. Granted, it took years. But, ewww!!!!
0 -
Watching my diabetic father intake the amount of diet soda he does, I would wager diet soda in excess - may cause some negative effects in those with pre-existing sugar sensitivities, diabetes, or other insulin-related medical issues. (I assure you, all of those italics and bolds were necessary. If you'd been here before, you'd know.... oh - you'd know... O_o;;; )
I limit myself to one a week only because I have trouble drinking enough water if I'm filling up on soda. That's the only reason. Like everything else in the world, in moderation, it's likely perfectly harmless. If you're concerned, cut back and make it a not-so-daily habit.
0 -
asflatasapancake wrote: »It is Friday, I suppose. That answer is no. Enjoy whatever comes next. I'd just like to add this, as it has become one of my favorite gifs lately.
Slightly off topic but it's really bugging me: is that Salem from Sabrina the teenage witch?
OP- no, it has no effect on weight loss0 -
ManiacalLaugh wrote: »Watching my diabetic father intake the amount of diet soda he does, I would wager diet soda in excess - may cause some negative effects in those with pre-existing sugar sensitivities, diabetes, or other insulin-related medical issues. (I assure you, all of those italics and bolds were necessary. If you'd been here before, you'd know.... oh - you'd know... O_o;;; )
I limit myself to one a week only because I have trouble drinking enough water if I'm filling up on soda. That's the only reason. Like everything else in the world, in moderation, it's likely perfectly harmless. If you're concerned, cut back and make it a not-so-daily habit.
Agreed. Moderation, balance. Make sure you drink enough water and if the diet soda doesn't bother you physically then there's probably no problem with it.0 -
My blood is made from Diet Coke.0
-
I do the moderation thing myself. All that acid give doesn't help with heartburn or reflux issues. Carbonation is hard on tooth enamel. Taking in something sweet (fake or not) all day long....can't be a good habit.
I do drink water all day. This may be an acquired thing.....use a filter pitcher.....add a slice of lemon (mint leaves, ginger slices) whatever you can do to get used to it.
Love the kitty gif!0 -
I know I'm late to the party but I just have to add my own experience. I'm addicted to Diet Coke. I love it. Love. I started LCHF last week along with cutting back on my beloved DC. I went into ketosis (fat burning) within 24 hours and I was consistently losing weight. Yesterday I drank a 20oz bottle of DC, it was the only thing I did to stray from my diet and I gained back .7lbs and was barely in ketosis yesterday evening and this morning. Now I know it's just one time but I'm going to experiment to see if it really messes with me or not. I don't think anyone can really say, yes it does mess with your metabolism or not. It's really up to you to test it out, everyone is different and individual results will vary.0
-
I know I'm late to the party but I just have to add my own experience. I'm addicted to Diet Coke. I love it. Love. I started LCHF last week along with cutting back on my beloved DC. I went into ketosis (fat burning) within 24 hours and I was consistently losing weight. Yesterday I drank a 20oz bottle of DC, it was the only thing I did to stray from my diet and I gained back .7lbs and was barely in ketosis yesterday evening and this morning. Now I know it's just one time but I'm going to experiment to see if it really messes with me or not. I don't think anyone can really say, yes it does mess with your metabolism or not. It's really up to you to test it out, everyone is different and individual results will vary.
Weight loss isn't lineal though. Judging that a certain food impedes weight loss simply because you see a small fluctuation on the scale the next day isn't a great foundation.
Last week I had deep-fried jalapeno poppers for dinner. The next day, I hit my goal weight. Did deep fried food make me lose the last bit of weight? Of course not. Our weight loss is the function of *everything* that happens the previous day (not just food intake) and what happened on previous days as well.0 -
janejellyroll wrote: »I know I'm late to the party but I just have to add my own experience. I'm addicted to Diet Coke. I love it. Love. I started LCHF last week along with cutting back on my beloved DC. I went into ketosis (fat burning) within 24 hours and I was consistently losing weight. Yesterday I drank a 20oz bottle of DC, it was the only thing I did to stray from my diet and I gained back .7lbs and was barely in ketosis yesterday evening and this morning. Now I know it's just one time but I'm going to experiment to see if it really messes with me or not. I don't think anyone can really say, yes it does mess with your metabolism or not. It's really up to you to test it out, everyone is different and individual results will vary.
Weight loss isn't lineal though. Judging that a certain food impedes weight loss simply because you see a small fluctuation on the scale the next day isn't a great foundation.
Last week I had deep-fried jalapeno poppers for dinner. The next day, I hit my goal weight. Did deep fried food make me lose the last bit of weight? Of course not. Our weight loss is the function of *everything* that happens the previous day (not just food intake) and what happened on previous days as well.
This. If you have a sensitivity to artifical sweeteners, then maybe I could see a bottle of soda creating waterweight gain, but 20oz of diet soda, regular soda, vodka, or just about anything you can drink outside of pure olive oil, is not going to make you gain more than half a pound of fat.0 -
janejellyroll wrote: »I know I'm late to the party but I just have to add my own experience. I'm addicted to Diet Coke. I love it. Love. I started LCHF last week along with cutting back on my beloved DC. I went into ketosis (fat burning) within 24 hours and I was consistently losing weight. Yesterday I drank a 20oz bottle of DC, it was the only thing I did to stray from my diet and I gained back .7lbs and was barely in ketosis yesterday evening and this morning. Now I know it's just one time but I'm going to experiment to see if it really messes with me or not. I don't think anyone can really say, yes it does mess with your metabolism or not. It's really up to you to test it out, everyone is different and individual results will vary.
Weight loss isn't lineal though. Judging that a certain food impedes weight loss simply because you see a small fluctuation on the scale the next day isn't a great foundation.
Last week I had deep-fried jalapeno poppers for dinner. The next day, I hit my goal weight. Did deep fried food make me lose the last bit of weight? Of course not. Our weight loss is the function of *everything* that happens the previous day (not just food intake) and what happened on previous days as well.
Mmmm.... deep fried jalapeno poppers.... and I read that they even provide weight loss.
Seriously, though... I've been drinking diet soda for 2 decades while I gained and while I've been losing weight. The diet soda had nothing to do with anything except it tastes good and gives me a small caffeine boost.
Also, your body uses the water in soda whether diet or not.0 -
I'd be down for jalepeno peppers = weight loss. Mmmmmm....0
-
This seems so unlikely as to be impossible. There's no way you lost 2.5 pounds a week doing nothing different except cutting zero calorie artificial sweeteners.gaelowyn_pt_duex wrote: »I think it can. I myself lost 10 lbs in about 4 weeks doing nothing different than cutting out diet soda.
0 -
gaelowyn_pt_duex wrote: »I think it can. I myself lost 10 lbs in about 4 weeks doing nothing different than cutting out diet soda. I had to, it was reacting to a medication i was taking. So that meant nothing with nutrasweet, splenda, sucralose, etc. No diet soda, no crystal light, none of that mio water enhancer stuff. No sugar free candy or gum. So I gave it all up. and I even ADDED 1 can of FULL sugar soda a day in place of the 3-4 cans of diet I was drinking. Lost 10lbs like I said.
I talked to my Dr. and Allergist.. neither were surprised. Your brain is getting signals of 'sweet' intake, but not the blood sugar boost that goes with it. Maybe for some people that can trigger bigger cravings, and more intake of other foods, thus an overall increase of calories.
of course, to be fair my 1 can full sugar soda slowly increased itself over time and i gained the 10lbs back. with MFP, Fit bit and back to healthier eating, which includes a continued ban on fake anything, I've lost 21-24 lbs(still fluctuating and getting back on track these past few weeks).
I'd rather drink unsweetened ice tea, and enjoy a small Jack and Coke at night than have tons of the fake chemicals all day long. Personal choice though in the long run.
They basically told you that when you were drinking diet soda you were also eating more.
OP-if you find you're craving more food bc of the diet soda ( I don't think it really causes this-(FWIW)-by all means cut it out. But it certainly does not CAUSE you to gain weight, or mess with your metabolism. Personally I drink lots of coke zero and other sugar free products. They help me tremendously bc I eat within my calorie goal, and therefore lose weight.0 -
A correlation study is hardly significant, especially when animals are involved.Elle_Bronwyn15 wrote: »Here is some research that I came across....
"When Purdue researchers Susan Swithers, PhD, and Terry Davidson, PhD, published their first studies in rats designed to test their theory that artificial sweeteners alter the body’s ability to regulate calorie intake, they were not prepared for the press attention their research received.
In the first study, two groups of rats were fed sweet, flavored, cola-like liquids. For one group, the liquid was always sweetened with sugar so there was a consistent relationship between the sweet taste and calories. In the second group, the sugar-sweetened liquids were alternated with liquids sweetened with the artificial sweetener saccharin, so that the relationship between the sweet taste and calories was inconsistent.
After 10 days, the rats were given a sweet, high-calorie chocolate pudding. Those exposed to the caloric and non-caloric sweet beverages ate more of the pudding.
In another study, rats were fed high-calorie chocolate pudding or chocolate milk with their regular food. At the end of the month, the chocolate milk group had gained significantly more weight.
The first experiment suggested that by breaking the connection between sweet taste and calories, artificial sweeteners interfere with the body’s natural ability to judge calorie content, Swithers says. The second, that the body is less able to recognize energy delivered in liquid form.
In a later set of studies the researchers fed rats yogurt sweetened with sugar or saccharine in addition to their regular chow and found that the rats that ate the no-calorie sweetener took in more calories overall and gained more weight."
I'm drinking a diet Pepsi right now, btw.
Everything can be bad in excess, I suggest seriously cutting back on the diet soda.
As mentioned, dosage can be an issue, so drink in moderation.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
0 -
They took the aspartame out of the Diet Pepsi.
I don't want the caffeine addiction again. I don't need the extra sodium (although I have lowered it enough that I could probably squeeze some in.) I can drink water pretty cheaply, why pay, but...
It makes it very tempting, lol. The second I heard it was really gone, I was like, "I could drink it again!"
Must stay strong, but maybe if I go out to eat.
0 -
They took the aspartame out of the Diet Pepsi.
I don't want the caffeine addiction again. I don't need the extra sodium (although I have lowered it enough that I could probably squeeze some in.) I can drink water pretty cheaply, why pay, but...
It makes it very tempting, lol. The second I heard it was really gone, I was like, "I could drink it again!"
Must stay strong, but maybe if I go out to eat.
I don't think that has happened yet because I just got a Diet Pepsi this morning and it had aspartame. The bottle had the Pepsi Pass summer promotion, so I know it isn't old. But I think there is a plan to switch to sucralose, it just hasn't happened yet.0 -
soda, or anything carbonated,, bloats your stomach, making it bigger for a little while. diet sugar sodas and the carbonated water will most definitely make you feel more hungry. although it doesn't add any calories, the soda is actually not doing you any good. especially coke. mt dew is the worst soda ever.. the rot they both cause. I love coke and diet coke don't get me wrong, but when we are trying to lose weight, we should minimize or just eliminate the soda all together. diet sugar has been known to make people feel more hungry too. I know I drink the crystal light, or generic crystal light powder stuff to get my water in. whenever im done with a glass of that shortly there after I feel hungry.. idk do what makes you happy just do in moderation. if you drink a six pack bottle of diet coke a day, try to reduce a bottle a day. or week. each week reduce a bottle and replace it with something else. good luck. keep trying.0
-
-
This content has been removed.
-
As I'm sure has already been mentioned, unless you have a specific issue with something in diet soda, it is fine in moderation just like nearly everything else. Some people say that Aspartame causes them issues, so if that is the case, I probably wouldn't drink it, but for 99.9% of the population, diet soda is just fine and perfectly safe.0
-
I drink 16 oz of Coca-Cola Life each week as a treat. It has 60 Kcal per 8oz and uses cane sugar and stevia as the sweetener.0
-
midwesterner85 wrote: »They took the aspartame out of the Diet Pepsi.
I don't want the caffeine addiction again. I don't need the extra sodium (although I have lowered it enough that I could probably squeeze some in.) I can drink water pretty cheaply, why pay, but...
It makes it very tempting, lol. The second I heard it was really gone, I was like, "I could drink it again!"
Must stay strong, but maybe if I go out to eat.
I don't think that has happened yet because I just got a Diet Pepsi this morning and it had aspartame. The bottle had the Pepsi Pass summer promotion, so I know it isn't old. But I think there is a plan to switch to sucralose, it just hasn't happened yet.
I don't know about where you are, but it's in the stores here! 0 -
janejellyroll wrote: »Last week I had deep-fried jalapeno poppers for dinner. The next day, I hit my goal weight. Did deep fried food make me lose the last bit of weight? Of course not.
Oh lordy. That sounds so good.
Are you SURE it didn't contribute to your weight loss?
I would like to volunteer as a participant in the continued research that is surely needed to address this question.
I wish! They were delicious, well worth the pain of cleaning the deep fryer.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions